Center for Stellar and Planetary Astrophysics Monash University Summary prepared by John Lattanzio, Dec 2003 Abundances in NGC6752.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
AGB stars in Galactic Globular Clusters – Are They Chemically Distinct to Their Fellow RGB and HB Stars? M5: SDSS Simon Campbell.
Advertisements

Carbon Enhanced Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ( SDSS ) T. Sivarani, Young Sun Lee, B. Marsteller & T. C. Beers Michigan State University & Joint.
Li Abundance of TO stars in globular clusters Zhixia Shen Luca Pasquini.
Improving mass and age estimates of unresolved stellar clusters Margaret Hanson & Bogdan Popescu Department of Physics.
Lithium abundance in the globular cluster M4: from the Turn-Off up to the RGB Bump Collaborators: M. Salaris (University of Liverpool, UK) L. Lovisi, F.R.
S-Process in C-Rich EMPS: predictions versus observations Sara Bisterzo (1) Roberto Gallino (1) Oscar Straniero (2) I. I. Ivans (3, 4) and Wako Aoki, Sean.
GEOL3045: Planetary Geology Lysa Chizmadia 11 Jan 2007 The Big Bang & Nucleosynthesis Lysa Chizmadia 11 Jan 2007 The Big Bang & Nucleosynthesis.
ASTRONOMICAL APPLICATIONS OF NEW LINE LISTS FOR CN, C 2 AND THEIR ISOTOPOLOGUES P. F. Bernath Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, Old Dominion University,
Helium-enhancements in globular cluster stars from AGB pollution Amanda Karakas 1, Yeshe Fenner 2, Alison Sills 1, Simon Campbell 3 & John Lattanzio 3.
Post Main Sequence Evolution PHYS390 (Astrophysics) Professor Lee Carkner Lecture 15.
Stellar Structure Section 6: Introduction to Stellar Evolution Lecture 16 – Evolution of core after S-C instability Formation of red giant Evolution up.
Center for Stellar and Planetary Astrophysics Monash University Summary prepared by John Lattanzio Abundances in M71.
S-Process in low metallicity Pb stars: comparison between new theoretical results and spectroscopic observations Sara Bisterzo (1) Roberto Gallino (1),
Astronomy 1 – Fall 2014 Lecture 12; November 18, 2014.
Kinematics of Globular Clusters in Giant Elliptical Galaxies Hong Soo Park 1, Myung Gyoon Lee 1, Ho Seong Hwang 2, Nobuo Arimoto 3, Naoyuki Tamura 4, Masato.
15. Make the following conversions: 5.4 m = ? km 0.87 kg = ? mg 2.04 cL = ? mL 16. What are 3 pieces of evidence to support the Big Bang theory? 17. How.
Ages and Age Spreads in The Orion Nebula Cluster Rob Jeffries: Keele University, UK Absolute Ages The HR diagram of the ONC Evidence for luminosity and.
How Old is the Universe? Here are some of the methods,
NGC 2419 – the most bizarre Galactic globular cluster Judith Cohen (Caltech) & Evan Kirby (UC Irvine/Caltech) Conference: Small Stellar Systems, Tuscany,
Non-LTE in Stars The Sun Early-type stars Other spectral types.
Presolar grains and AGB stars Maria Lugaro Sterrenkundig Instituut University of Utrecht.
Stellar AGB evolution and its impact on galaxy spectrophotometric properties at low and high redshift: an updated view Alberto Buzzoni INAF – Oss. Astronomico.
Definitions  Sun: Star at the center of our solar system. Also another name for any star.  Luminosity: measures how bright a star would be in relation.
Lecture 2: Formation of the chemical elements Bengt Gustafsson: Current problems in Astrophysics Ångström Laboratory, Spring 2010.
'Sculptor'-ing the Galaxy? Doug Geisler, Universidad de Concepción Verne Smith, UTEP George Wallerstein, U Washington Guillermo Gonzalez, ISU Corinne Charbonnel,
Eugenio Carretta INAF- Osservatorio Astronomico di Padova L’anticorrelazione Na-O: sonda per la formazione e la prima evoluzione degli ammassi globulari?
SPETTROSCOPIA DI STELLE CALDE DI RAMO ORIZZONTALE IN AMMASSI GLOBULARI COFIN 2001 – Bologna, 12 giugno 2003.
Observational evidence of multiple Stellar Populations in Galactic Globular Clusters Giampaolo Piotto Dipartimento di Astronomia Universita’ di Padova.
Prelim Review.
1 The structure and evolution of stars Lecture 10: The evolution of 1M  mass stars.
Multiple stellar populations and the horizontal branch of globular clusters Raffaele Gratton INAF – Osservatorio Astronomico di Padova.
3D Numerical Simulations of Thermohaline Mixing in Low-Mass Red Giants Pavel Denisenkov, UVic.
Chemical Composition of Planet-Host Stars Wonseok Kang Kyung Hee University Sang-Gak Lee Seoul National University.
Advanced Burning Building the Heavy Elements. Advanced Burning 2  Advanced burning can be (is) very inhomogeneous  The process is very important to.
Comprehensive Stellar Population Models and the Disentanglement of Age and Metallicity Effects Guy Worthey 1994, ApJS, 95, 107.
Observational evidence of multiple stellar populations in star clusters Giampaolo Piotto Dipartimento di Astronomia Universita’ di Padova Collaborators:
AIMS OF G ALACTIC C HEMICAL E VOLUTION STUDIES To check / constrain our understanding of stellar nucleosynthesis (i.e. stellar yields), either statistically.
Lesson 13 Nuclear Astrophysics. Elemental and Isotopic Abundances.
Yields from single AGB stars Amanda Karakas Research School of Astronomy & Astrophysics Mt Stromlo Observatory.
Quiz #6 Most stars form in the spiral arms of galaxies Stars form in clusters, with all types of stars forming. O,B,A,F,G,K,M Spiral arms barely move,
A note on: Group Behavior Open Clusters: contain a few hundred to a few thousands of stars. Lie in the plane of the Milky Way Galaxy. A few parsecs in.
New and Odds on Globular Cluster Stellar Populations: an Observational Point of View (The Snapshot Database) G.Piotto, I. King, S. Djorgovski and G. Bono,
Multiple Stellar Populations: the evolutionary framework Santi Cassisi INAF - Astronomical Observatory of Teramo - Italy.
The Star Formation Histories of Red Sequence Galaxies Mike Hudson U. Waterloo / IAP Steve Allanson (Waterloo) Allanson, MH et al 09, ApJ 702, 1275 Russell.
Dept. of Astronmy Comparison with Theoretical CM diagram Galactic Astronomy #6.1.3 Jae Gyu Byeon.
Goal: To understand voids Objectives: 1)To examine the Size and distribution of voids 2)To understand the Properties of voids 3)To learn about the Formation.
Lecture 18 Stellar populations. Stellar clusters Open clusters: contain stars loose structure Globular clusters: million stars centrally.
Globular Clusters. A globular cluster is an almost spherical conglomeration of 100,000 to 1,000,000 stars of different masses that have practically.
M5 = NGC 5904 ( nearest “intermediate-metallicity” globular cluster accessible from a northern hemisphere site ) Harris (2003, Feb version) 7.5kpc from.
Why do globular clusters have more than one main sequence? Ref: Gratton et al. 2012, A&ARv, 20, 50.
June 5, 2006 AAS/Calgary Stellar Populations: Old Stars in the Nearest E Galaxy From Field Stars to Globular Clusters.
Galactic Evolution Workshop NAOJ Sachie Arao, Yuhri Ishimaru (ICU) Shinya Wanajo(Riken) Nucleosynthesis of Elements heavier than Fe through.
52 0 Congresso SAIT - Teramo 2008 The Globular Clusters of the Large Magellanic Cloud : chemical abundances and ages Alessio Mucciarelli Università di.
Light Elements (Li and Be) in Globular Clusters L. Pasquini, ESO  Li in Turn-Off (or close to TO)  Li in evolved stars  A new result..  Be in TO stars.
Stellar Spectroscopy and Elemental Abundances Definitions Solar Abundances Relative Abundances Origin of Elements 1.
Center for Stellar and Planetary Astrophysics Monash University Summary prepared by John Lattanzio, Oct 2003 Abundances in M92.
Multiple populations in globular clusters: a clue to second parameter problem? R. Gratton INAF-Osservatorio Astronomico di Padova, Italy World of Clusters,
How do stars produce energy? Nuclear reactions. Project due Friday! Remaining assignments Labs during last week.
Globular Clusters Globular clusters are clusters of stars which contain stars of various stages in their evolution. An H-R diagram for a globular cluster.
Thermohaline Mixing in Low and Intermediate Metallicity Globular Clusters George Angelou The Globular Cluster-Galaxy Connection II. ● Prof John Lattanzio.
Spectroscopy and the evolution of hot subdwarf stars
Multiple stellar populations in Globular Clusters - A progress report
Chemical enrichment mechanisms in Omega Centauri:
B. Barbuy IAG - Universidade de São Paulo
Peculiar Massive Globular Clusters in the Milky Way
Joleen Carlberg July 12, 2017 Abstract:
Nucleosynthesis and stellar lifecycles
Nucleosynthesis in Early Massive Stars: Origin of Heavy Elements
The structure and evolution of stars
Evidences of Multiple Populations in GCs
Presentation transcript:

Center for Stellar and Planetary Astrophysics Monash University Summary prepared by John Lattanzio, Dec 2003 Abundances in NGC6752

NGC6752: Everything you need to know!?

NGC6752: Back to Basics [Fe/H] = -1.5 Age = Old… 13 Gyr or “more” Distance = 13,000 ly Log (M/M 0 ) = 5.1 (DaCosta’s thesis, 1977) m-M = C = 2.50, core collapsed

NGC6752: HRD etc V (HB) = 13.5 – 18 with a big gap! V (TO) = 17 V (RGB tip) = 11 HB is very blue, with a gap… Also a gap on Sub Giant Branch…

Gaps on the sub-giant branch

NGC6752: the start Da Costa and Cottrell ) 2 stars…on had CN up and one had CN down Bell and Dickens ) 4 stars 2) C down and N “probably” up

NGC6752: Norris et al Red Giants CN bimodal

NGC6752: Norris et al 1981 Also found Al up a bit AGB stars interesting.., 1) No AGB stars with enhanced N 2) AGB stars are all low (normal?) C

NGC6752: Norris et al 1981 “model” All gas forms with same [Fe/H] Half has normal CN, half has higher CN and hence higher Y by ~0.05 Thus two groups of stars 1) C and N normal, Y=0.25 2) C down, N up, Y=0.30 This gives two populations on HB! Given Z=0.001 and age = 13Gyr 1) M TO (Y=0.25) = 0.81M 0 2) M TO (Y=0.30) = 0.74M 0 Core mass same, so lower M = lower M env So lower mass is BLUER and leaves HB SOONER, not making it to the AGB So AGB has the CN normal stars

Cottrell & Da Costa 1981 CN strong stars have 1) Na up by ~ 0.25 dex 2) Al up by ~ 0.2 dex Mg, Si, Ca, Fe, Ba are the same in all stars

Smith and Norris 1982 Tried to estimate the amount of N needed to match the observations Hard to get C down and N up by enough! They used old (Renzini and Voli 1981) yields. Do it more better??? Yeshe?

HB stars and their abunds Heber et al ) He = 0.2% to 3% (by number) 2) That is a factor of FIFTEEN! Glaspey et al ) Fe in blue HB stars ~ 50 x Fe in RGB stars 2) Believed due to gravitational settling and high UV flux levitating light elements

Suntzeff and Smith red giants C12/C13 ~ 3-5 (ie CN equilibrium) No dependence of C12/C13 on CN!?

Suntzeff and Smith red giants Variation of C12 with B-V? The high C12 seem to disappear There are low C12 at all temperatures…

Smith and Norris 1993 AGB CN problem…. CN bands are weaker in AGB stars This is due to lower T and larger g BUT: there is still a smaller spread in CN in the AGB stars than the RGB stars Seen in other GC as well M4 and M5: AGB stars are CN-strong NGC6752: AGB stars are CN weak

INTERMISSION

Story So Far Note: nothing as a function of L! Except C in Suntzeff and Smith But NGC6752 is bright/nearby So everyone went to look at the TO… This they now do…© Python (Monty)

Gratton et al 2001 Many TO and early RGB stars Look at O, Na, Mg and Al

Gratton et al 2001 O-Na correlation exists at the TO And at the bottom of RBG

Gratton et al 2001 Mg-Al correlation clear in subgiants Less clear at the TO They say that this is due to using different Al lines for the warmer TO stars The AL correlates with Na (not shown) for TO stars

Grundahl et al red giants Many below RGB bump Usual correlations seen

Grundahl et al 2002 Li disappears once you get to the bump!

Yong et al bright RGB stars Look at Mg24:Mg25:Mg26 Solar value is 80:10:10 Mg24 made in supernova

Yong et al 2003 Mg24 down as Al up Mg25 same for all Al Mg26 up as Al up Does not fit Mg-Al cycle  (maybe at very high T?)

Yong et al 2003 No dependence of these on evolutionary state (thank God!)

Yong et al 2003 Highest Mg26 (dotted circles) has: 1) Lowest O 2) Highest Na 3) Highest Al

James et al 2003 (astro-ph) 9 TO stars and 9 SGB stars Sr, Y, Ba, Eu: little or no variation 1) [Sr/Fe] = ) [Y/Fe] = ) [Ba/Fe] = ) [Eu/Fe] = 0.41 This gives [Ba/Eu] = Pure r-process is –0.7 so there has been s-process active!

Fenner et al 2004 (MNRAS) Initial burst of Z=0 stars Bimodal mass distribution Resulting yields used to mix to observed [Fe/H] Resulting mixture evolved along AGB by Simon

Fenner et al O-Na and MG-Al correlations not reproduced Red = individual stars from Simon Blackline = evolution of ISM in NGC6752 Blue and Green = data… Mg24 fits data!!!

Fenner et al No correlations with Mg isotopes match the observations either!

Fenner et al CN anti-correlation? Not really…. Blue crosses are averages of the CN weak and CN strong groups

Fenner et al Total C+N+O Not very constant!

Summary Not much evidence for deep mixing on GB via the C and N variations Very little data showing L variation… CN bimodal O-Na and Mg-Al anti-correlations seen at all L Mg isotopes hard to understand: 1) Rich in high mass isotopes 2) But how to keep Mg25 constant? AGB models really don’t fit!

References Norris et al, 1981, ApJ, 244, 205 Cottrell & DaCosta, 1981, ApJ, 245, L79 Smith & Norris, 1982, ApJ, 254, 594 Heber et al, 1986, A&A, 162, 171 Suntzeff & Smith, 1991, ApJ, 381, 160 Smith & Norris, 1993, ApJ, 105, 173 Gratton et al, 2001, A&A, 369, 87 Grundahl et al, 2002, A&A, 385, L14 Yong et al, 2003, A&A, 402, 985 Fenner et al, 2004, MNRAS, submitted