Ibrahim Hoteit KAUST, CSIM, May 2010 Should we be using Data Assimilation to Combine Seismic Imaging and Reservoir Modeling? Earth Sciences and Engineering.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Filtering for High Dimension Spatial Systems Jonathan Briggs Department of Statistics University of Auckland.
Advertisements

Data-Assimilation Research Centre
Introduction to Data Assimilation NCEO Data-assimilation training days 5-7 July 2010 Peter Jan van Leeuwen Data Assimilation Research Center (DARC) University.
Introduction to Data Assimilation Peter Jan van Leeuwen IMAU.
Dusanka Zupanski CIRA/Colorado State University Fort Collins, Colorado Model Error and Parameter Estimation Joint NCAR/MMM CSU/CIRA Data Assimilation Workshop.
1B.17 ASSESSING THE IMPACT OF OBSERVATIONS AND MODEL ERRORS IN THE ENSEMBLE DATA ASSIMILATION FRAMEWORK D. Zupanski 1, A. Y. Hou 2, S. Zhang 2, M. Zupanski.
The Inverse Regional Ocean Modeling System:
Initialization Issues of Coupled Ocean-atmosphere Prediction System Climate and Environment System Research Center Seoul National University, Korea In-Sik.
Effects of model error on ensemble forecast using the EnKF Hiroshi Koyama 1 and Masahiro Watanabe 2 1 : Center for Climate System Research, University.
Kalman’s Beautiful Filter (an introduction) George Kantor presented to Sensor Based Planning Lab Carnegie Mellon University December 8, 2000.
Advanced data assimilation methods- EKF and EnKF Hong Li and Eugenia Kalnay University of Maryland July 2006.
Estimation and the Kalman Filter David Johnson. The Mean of a Discrete Distribution “I have more legs than average”
Maximum Liklihood Ensemble Filter (MLEF) Dusanka Zupanski, Kevin Robert Gurney, Scott Denning, Milia Zupanski, Ravi Lokupitiya June, 2005 TransCom Meeting,
A comparison of hybrid ensemble transform Kalman filter(ETKF)-3DVAR and ensemble square root filter (EnSRF) analysis schemes Xuguang Wang NOAA/ESRL/PSD,
Platzhalter für Bild, Bild auf Titelfolie hinter das Logo einsetzen Oliver Pajonk, Bojana Rosic, Alexander Litvinenko, Hermann G. Matthies ISUME 2011,
Classification: Internal Status: Draft Using the EnKF for combined state and parameter estimation Geir Evensen.
Kalman filtering techniques for parameter estimation Jared Barber Department of Mathematics, University of Pittsburgh Work with Ivan Yotov and Mark Tronzo.
Ensemble Data Assimilation and Uncertainty Quantification Jeffrey Anderson, Alicia Karspeck, Tim Hoar, Nancy Collins, Kevin Raeder, Steve Yeager National.
The Inverse Regional Ocean Modeling System: Development and Application to Data Assimilation of Coastal Mesoscale Eddies. Di Lorenzo, E., Moore, A., H.
EnKF Overview and Theory
Computer vision: models, learning and inference Chapter 19 Temporal models.
Nonlinear Data Assimilation and Particle Filters
Computing a posteriori covariance in variational DA I.Gejadze, F.-X. Le Dimet, V.Shutyaev.
1 ESTIMATING THE STATE OF LARGE SPATIOTEMPORALLY CHAOTIC SYSTEMS: WEATHER FORECASTING, ETC. Edward Ott University of Maryland Main Reference: E. OTT, B.
CSDA Conference, Limassol, 2005 University of Medicine and Pharmacy “Gr. T. Popa” Iasi Department of Mathematics and Informatics Gabriel Dimitriu University.
Federal Department of Home Affairs FDHA Federal Office of Meteorology and Climatology MeteoSwiss High-resolution data assimilation in COSMO: Status and.
Jamal Saboune - CRV10 Tutorial Day 1 Bayesian state estimation and application to tracking Jamal Saboune VIVA Lab - SITE - University.
Assimilation of HF Radar Data into Coastal Wave Models NERC-funded PhD work also supervised by Clive W Anderson (University of Sheffield) Judith Wolf (Proudman.
Dusanka Zupanski And Scott Denning Colorado State University Fort Collins, CO CMDL Workshop on Modeling and Data Analysis of Atmospheric CO.
Human-Computer Interaction Kalman Filter Hanyang University Jong-Il Park.
2004 SIAM Annual Meeting Minisymposium on Data Assimilation and Predictability for Atmospheric and Oceanographic Modeling July 15, 2004, Portland, Oregon.
Applications of optimal control and EnKF to Flow Simulation and Modeling Florida State University, February, 2005, Tallahassee, Florida The Maximum.
MODEL ERROR ESTIMATION EMPLOYING DATA ASSIMILATION METHODOLOGIES Dusanka Zupanski Cooperative Institute for Research in the Atmosphere Colorado State University.
The I nverse R egional O cean M odeling S ystem Development and Application to Variational Data Assimilation of Coastal Mesoscale Eddies. Di Lorenzo, E.
Research Vignette: The TransCom3 Time-Dependent Global CO 2 Flux Inversion … and More David F. Baker NCAR 12 July 2007 David F. Baker NCAR 12 July 2007.
INVERSE MODELING OF ATMOSPHERIC COMPOSITION DATA Daniel J. Jacob See my web site under “educational materials” for lectures on inverse modeling atmospheric.
Outline 4D Data Assimilation Examples in Oceanography
Data assimilation and forecasting the weather (!) Eugenia Kalnay and many friends University of Maryland.
Adaptive Hybrid EnKF-OI for State- Parameters Estimation in Contaminant Transport Models Mohamad E. Gharamti, Johan Valstar, Ibrahim Hoteit European Geoscience.
MPO 674 Lecture 28 4/23/15. The course on one slide 1. Intro: numerical models, ensembles, the science of prediction 2. Lorenz 1963,
An Introduction to Kalman Filtering by Arthur Pece
Local Predictability of the Performance of an Ensemble Forecast System Liz Satterfield and Istvan Szunyogh Texas A&M University, College Station, TX Third.
Parameter estimation of forest carbon dynamics using Kalman Filter methods –Preliminary results Chao Gao, 1 Han Wang, 2 S Lakshmivarahan, 3 Ensheng Weng,
Prepared by Dusanka Zupanski and …… Maximum Likelihood Ensemble Filter: application to carbon problems.
Tracking with dynamics
Cameron Rowe.  Introduction  Purpose  Implementation  Simple Example Problem  Extended Kalman Filters  Conclusion  Real World Examples.
The I nverse R egional O cean M odeling S ystem Development and Application to Variational Data Assimilation of Coastal Mesoscale Eddies. Di Lorenzo, E.
A Random Subgrouping Scheme for Ensemble Kalman Filters Yun Liu Dept. of Atmospheric and Oceanic Science, University of Maryland Atmospheric and oceanic.
Geogg124: Data assimilation P. Lewis. What is Data Assimilation? Optimal merging of models and data Models Expression of current understanding about process.
Pg 1 SAMSI UQ Workshop; Sep Ensemble Data Assimilation and Uncertainty Quantification Jeff Anderson National Center for Atmospheric Research.
Ensemble forecasting/data assimilation and model error estimation algorithm Prepared by Dusanka Zupanski and Milija Zupanski CIRA/CSU Denning group meeting.
Future Directions in Ensemble DA for Hurricane Prediction Applications Jeff Anderson: NCAR Ryan Torn: SUNY Albany Thanks to Chris Snyder, Pavel Sakov The.
École Doctorale des Sciences de l'Environnement d’ Î le-de-France Année Modélisation Numérique de l’Écoulement Atmosphérique et Assimilation.
École Doctorale des Sciences de l'Environnement d’Île-de-France Année Universitaire Modélisation Numérique de l’Écoulement Atmosphérique et Assimilation.
École Doctorale des Sciences de l'Environnement d’ Î le-de-France Année Modélisation Numérique de l’Écoulement Atmosphérique et Assimilation.
Demonstration and Comparison of Sequential Approaches for Altimeter Data Assimilation in HYCOM A. Srinivasan, E. P. Chassignet, O. M. Smedstad, C. Thacker,
The Ensemble Kalman filter
Kalman Filter and Data Streaming Presented By :- Ankur Jain Department of Computer Science 7/21/03.
Hybrid Data Assimilation
H.L. Tanaka and K. Kondo University of Tsukuba
Data Assimilation Theory CTCD Data Assimilation Workshop Nov 2005
Gleb Panteleev (IARC) Max Yaremchuk, (NRL), Dmitri Nechaev (USM)
Kalman’s Beautiful Filter (an introduction)
Jincong He, Louis Durlofsky, Pallav Sarma (Chevron ETC)
Ensemble variance loss in transport models:
New Approaches to Data Assimilation
8th EnKF Workshop Discussion.
2. University of Northern British Columbia, Prince George, Canada
Kalman Filtering COS 323.
Sarah Dance DARC/University of Reading
Presentation transcript:

Ibrahim Hoteit KAUST, CSIM, May 2010 Should we be using Data Assimilation to Combine Seismic Imaging and Reservoir Modeling? Earth Sciences and Engineering Applied Math and Computational Sciences

1

2

3 Publisher: VDM Verlag Date: September 11, 2009

 What is Data Assimilation?  Methods of Data Assimilation Least-Squares & Bayesian methods  Ensemble Kalman Filtering An Example (ocean - but related - application …)  Discussion Outline 4

 Estimate the 4D state of a dynamical system: Atmosphere, Ocean, Hydrology, Reservoir, …  Sources of Information o Observations … but too sparse and noisy o Numerical models … but imperfect What is Data Assimilation? 5  Data Assimilation o Combines model and observations to make the best possible estimate of the state of a dynamical system o It is an inverse problem … with model dynamics as (weak or strong) constraint

6 6 Time Context in Reservoir-Seismic Poroelasticity model 4D Seismic Reservoir model

7 Formulation of the Assimilation Problem  A dynamical model and an observation model o state, transition operator o data, observational operator o & represent model and obs. errors  Two Schools: Least-Squares (Deterministic) & Bayesian Theory (Stochastic)

Least-Squares Formulation 8  Adjust a set of “control variables” to the fit model trajectory to available data over a given period of time: o control vector (any model parameter) o Optimization constrained by model dynamics o Run adjoint backward to compute gradients o Non-convex optimization!

9 9 Recursive Bayesian Formulation  Determine the pdf of the state given all observations up to the estimation time o Forecast step: Integrate analysis pdf with the model o Correction step: Update forecast pdf with the new obs

10 Least-Squares vs. Bayesian  Same solution when the system is linear and perfect  Geosciences applications: ‒ Nonlinear and imperfect system ‒ Huge dimension (~ 10 8 ) and costly models  Different solutions!  Which one is more appropriate? Least-Squares Requires adjoint models Non-conv opti when nonlinear Not suitable for forecasting Bayesian Only forward models Better with nonlinear systems Estimates of uncertainties

A Demonstration: Bayesian Assimilation with a Real Problem 11  Funded by BP, in collaboration with Anderson (NCAR) & Heimbach (MIT)  1/10 o ocean model of GOM state dimension ~  Datasets: Satellite SSH and SST  Weekly forecasts of the GOM circulation  Predicting the evolution of loop current in the Gulf of Mexico (GOM)

Ocean GCM Models 12

13 Bayesian Solution - Kalman Filtering  State pdf is Gaussian for linear models with Gaussian noise  Need to determine mean and covariance of the pdf only  In this case, the Kalman filter recursively provides the BLUE estimate of the state given previous observations  Two steps: — Forecast step to propagate estimate and uncertainties — Analysis step to correct forecast with the new observation

14 Analysis Forecast Model ModelObservation  Nonlinear model ?  Dimension of the state ~ ? Kalman Filter Algorithm

Ensemble Kalman Filtering (EnKF) 15  Monte-Carlo Approach: Represents uncertainties by an ensemble of vectors  Update the ensemble instead of : ‒ Solves storage problem ‒ Reduces computational burden to reasonable level ‒ Suitable for nonlinear systems  Combines nonlinear forecast step of the Particle filter and linear analysis step of the Kalman filter (Hoteit et al., MWR ) …

16 Model Forecast Time Analysis data+ KF EnKF Algorithms Analysis Ensemble Forecast Ensemble New Analysis Ensemble

Weekly SSH Estimates ensemble members Satellite SSHForecastAnalysis

EnKFs – Pros 18  Reasonable cost and flexible  Only forward models are required  Ability to integrate multivariate/multisources data models  Propagate information to non-observed variables  Propagate uncertainties in time …. Still have room for improvements

Working on (Frontiers of DA) 19  Generalize EnKFs to nonlinear observations Hoteit et al. (MWR, ) & Luo et al. (Physica-D, 2010)  State-parameter estimation - Dual theory Hoteit et al. (MWR, submitted )  Nonlinear smoothers to assimilate future data  Account for model errors (problem dependent!)

Discussion 20  Bayesian assimilation methods were proven efficient to constrain large dimensional nonlinear models with measurements  A framework to integrate different/multi observation models  A framework to deal with different uncertainties  Should we be using data assimilation in seismic imaging and reservoir modeling? If we want to use 4D seismic data to constrain the reservoir state, the answer is definitely yes!

21 THANK YOU Int. collaborators: D.-T. Pham (CNRS, France) B. Cornuelle (Scripps, USA) G. Triantafyllou & G. Korres (HCMR-Greece) J. Anderson (NCAR, USA) and P. Heimbach (MIT, USA) C. Dawson & C. Jackson (UT-Austin, USA) A. Kohl (University of Hamburg, Germany) Other group members – Bayesian Assimilation: X. Luo (Postdoc, PhD University of Oxford, UK) U. Altaf (Postdoc, PhD Delft University of Technology, Netherlands) W. Wang (PhD student jointly with Prof. Sun, KAUST)

22 Low-Rank Deficiency of EnKFs  Difficulties: o Underestimated error covariance matrices o Not enough degrees of freedom to fit the data  Amplification by an ‘inflation’ factor:  Localization: o of the observations impact (distance-dependent analysis) o of the covariance matrix (using a Schur product) o of the analysis subspace

What’s Next …  Define a theoretical framework for ensemble Kalman filters and generalize their analysis step to nonlinear systems  State-Parameter estimation  Dual Kalman filtering for assimilation into coupled models  Dynamical consistency of EnKF analysis  Nonlinear smoothers 23