Methods for Assessing Economic, Environmental and Social Impacts of Aquaculture Technologies: Integrated Agriculture-Aquaculture in Malawi John Antle Oregon.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Coping with Extreme Climate Events Policy Implications Joyashree Roy Professor of Economics Coordinator-Global Change Programme-JU Jadavpur University,
Advertisements

Regional Impact Assessment AgMIP SSA Kickoff Workshop John Antle AgMIP Regional Econ Team Leader 1 Accra, Ghana Sept
Econometric-Process Simulation Models for Semi-Subsistence Agricultural Systems: Application of the NUTMON Data for Machakos.
Agricultural Carbon Sequestration and Poverty John M. Antle Dept of Ag Econ & Econ, Montana State U.
NIORO case study Amy Faye ISRA-BAME. Objectives Climate change impact assessment Objectives : Assess the distributional impact of climate change in the.
Minimum-Data Analysis of Technology Adoption and Impact Assessment for Agriculture-Aquaculture Systems John Antle Oregon State University Roberto Valdivia.
Economic Potential for Soil Carbon Sequestration in the Nioro Region of Senegal’s Peanut Basin by John Antle, Bocar Diagana, Jetse Stoorvogel and Kara.
Diet Matters: Approaches and Indicators to Assess Agriculture's Role in Nutrition Diego Rose, Brian Luckett, and Adrienne Mundorf School of Public Health.
Development or Environment? Tradeoff Analysis Framework Jetse Stoorvogel, John Antle, Andre de Jager, Alejandra Mora Valleja, Gerdien Meijerink.
Income Inequality in the United States,
East Africa Tradeoff Analysis Workshop. Workshop goals and strategy Strategy Monday Introduction to TOA approach Tuesday AM Conceptual framework Tuesday.
National Workshop on Water Resources and Livelihoods in the Dry Areas Considering Climate Uncertainty Hammamet, Tunisia, September 2014 ECONOMIC.
Diversification of economic portfolios to deal with climate variability: Case study of livelihoods strategies in two Andean communities Carolina Barreda.
What is the TOA-MD Model? Basic Concepts and an Example John Antle Roberto Valdivia Agricultural and Resource Economics Oregon State University
Technology Impact Assessment John M. Antle Professor of Ag Econ & Econ Montana State University Roberto Valdivia Research Associate in Ag Econ & Econ Montana.
Jetse Stoorvogel, Lieven Claessens, John Antle Philip Thornton, Mario Herrero A novel methodology for ex ante assessment of climate change adaptation strategies.
Local Agricultural Supply Chain Improvement Lindsey Arita, Joseph Lee, Julia Mahon, Jay Raghavan Advisor: Dr. Eric Bruun ESE Senior Design Demo.
Modeling and Forecasting Climate Change, Biophysical Impacts, and Ecological and Economic Implications: Discussion John Antle Agricultural and Resource.
What is the TOA-MD Model? Basic Concepts and an Example John Antle Oregon State University Roberto Valdivia Montana State University
1 Tradeoff analysis and NUTMON: Linking models for policy analysis A.P Mora-Vallejo, J.J. Stoorvogel, J. Antle, A. de Jager, C. Crissman.
New Methods to Assess Climate Change Impacts and Adaptation for Poor Agricultural Households John M. Antle Roberto Valdivia Agricultural and Resource Economics.
Squeezing more out of existing data sources: Small Area Estimation of Welfare Indicators Berk Özler The World Bank Development Research Group, Poverty.
UGANDA NATIONAL PANEL SURVEY PROGRAM DECEMBER 2013 By James Muwonge, Uganda Bureau of Statistics Uganda Bureau of Statistics.
Wye City Group Meeting on Rural Development and Agricultural Household Income Measuring under-nourishment : comparative analysis between parametric and.
Feed the Future Innovation Lab for Small-Scale Irrigation Alan Duncan Ethiopia Partner meeting, Mar From Plan to Action Field Studies and Ex Ante.
Integrated household based agricultural survey methodology applied in Ethiopia, new developments and comments on the Integrated survey frame work.
1. Project Title Name of Investigator(s) & Institutions.
Copyright © 2013, 2009, and 2007, Pearson Education, Inc. Chapter 12 Analyzing the Association Between Quantitative Variables: Regression Analysis Section.
Klaas Stijnen New Zealand Society of Actuaries Conference 2010 Unemployment models The probability of unemployment © 2010 Deloitte Actuarial Services.
PREPARATION, ORGANISATION AND CONDUCTING OF THE POST- ENUMERATION SURVEY IN THE STATE STATISTICAL OFFICE OF THE REPUBLIC OF MACEDONIA Skopje, May 2008.
Copyright 2010, The World Bank Group. All Rights Reserved. Importance and Uses of Agricultural Statistics Section A 1.
Tradeoff Analysis: From Science to Policy John M. Antle Department of Ag Econ & Econ Montana State University.
Stakeholder-driven, multi-sectoral climate adaptation in small urban areas ASP Colloquium - 6 th August 2014, Boulder Amanda Edelman, Pardee RAND Graduate.
Mali Work Packages. Crop Fields Gardens Livestock People Trees Farm 1 Farm 2 Farm 3 Fallow Pasture/forest Market Water sources Policy Landscape/Watershed.
16th ICABR Conference - 128th EAAE Seminar
Access to Electricity, Food Security and Poverty Reduction in Rural South-western Nigeria Awotide, B.A., T.T. Awoyemi, and A.O. Obayelu A paper prepared.
 Lecture #9.  The course assumes little prior applied knowledge in the area of finance.  References  Kristina (2010) ‘Investment Analysis and Portfolio.
A New Trans-Disciplinary Approach to Regional Integrated Assessment of Climate Impact and Adaptation in Agricultural Systems John Antle & Roberto Valdivia.
Moving Along the Impact Pathway: The Case of IAA in Bangladesh John Antle & Roberto Valdivia Oregon State University Charles Crissman & Khondker Murshed-e-Jahan.
The impact of low quality fertilizer on wealth effect Ling Yee Khor, Manfred Zeller University of Hohenheim, Stuttgart, Germany 17 th ICABR Conference.
CROP MODEL I: Overview and possible applications Becky Chaplin-Kramer NatCap Olympics
1 Ratio estimation under SRS Assume Absence of nonsampling error SRS of size n from a pop of size N Ratio estimation is alternative to under SRS, uses.
1 Improving Statistics for Food Security, Sustainable Agriculture and Rural Development – Action Plan for Africa THE RESEARCH COMPONENT OF THE IMPLEMENTATION.
Agro-industry investments, smallholders and workers: evidences on household income effects from Tanzania Raoul Herrmann 1, 2, Khamaldin Mutabazi 3, Ulrike.
Decision Support for Biosecurity: Valuation of Biodiversity Brian Bell.
Near East Regional Workshop - Linking Population and Housing Censuses with Agricultural Censuses. Amman, Jordan, June 2012 Tabulations and Analysis.
Tradeoff Analysis and Minimum-Data Modeling John Antle Jetse Stoorvogel Workshop on Adaptation to Climate Change, Nairobi September
Climate and the risk of pests and disease Primary research activities in this area: 1.Participatory evaluations of risk for potato tuber moth and Andean.
Agricultural and environmental indicators and models por Rubén De la Sierra Rosario Peyrot.
Uganda Bureau of Statistics ¤ Plot 9 Colville Street, Kampala Uganda ¤ Website: Tel: +256(0) ¤ 1 Analysis.
Targeting of Public Spending Menno Pradhan Senior Poverty Economist The World Bank office, Jakarta.
Integrating Ecosystem Services and Biodiversity Conservation Dick Cameron Senior Conservation Planner The Nature Conservancy, California Program 1.
FAO of the United Nations, Rome, Italy
Phase 2 Research Questions Theme 1: Nutrition, food safety and value addition 1)Which combinations of technology packages can reduce household vulnerability.
Tradeoff Analysis System: Policy Decision Support for Agriculture ?
CORRELATION-REGULATION ANALYSIS Томский политехнический университет.
Ibrahima Hathie Initiative Prospective Agricole et Rurale (IPAR) & AgMIP CIWARA CO-PI Dakar - June 1, 2016 A New Trans-Disciplinary Approach to Regional.
Climate Smart Agricultural Development in the Goulburn Broken A regional climate change adaptation partnership project.
Chapter 1: Roles and Opportunities for Information Technology in Meeting Sustainability Challenges Helynranta Viola Parkkila Vilma
Climate Smart Agricultural Development in the Goulburn Broken
Revenue, Cost and Profitability of Grape Production in the U. S
NAGARKOT… Reward for the early birds.
Predicted Adoption rate (%) Discussion, conclusions & implications
Model Summary Fred Lauer
Linking Population and Housing Censuses with Agricultural Censuses
Climate Smart Agricultural Development in the Goulburn Broken
Poverty Maps for Sri Lanka
1st Joint Workshop Pesticides Statistics
Forestry and Agriculture GHG Modeling Forum October 9th, 2002
Emulators of Irrigated Crop Yields Provide an Efficient Approach for Understanding Multisectoral Water-Energy-Land Dynamics Objective: Develop statistical.
Presentation transcript:

Methods for Assessing Economic, Environmental and Social Impacts of Aquaculture Technologies: Integrated Agriculture-Aquaculture in Malawi John Antle Oregon State University Roberto Valdivia Montana State University tradeoffs.oregonstate.edu 9AFAF Conference Shanghai April

What is the TOA-MD Model? The TOA-MD Model is a unique simulation tool for multi- dimensional impact assessment that uses a statistical description of a heterogeneous farm population to simulate the adoption and impacts of a new technology or a change in environmental conditions. TOA-MD is designed to simulate what would be observed if it were possible to conduct a controlled experiment to measure the effects of farms adopting a new production technology In fact it is never possible to carry out such ideal experiments, so TOA-MD is designed to utilize the available data to attain the best possible approximation, given the available time and other resources available to conduct the analysis. Additionally, TOA-MD is designed to facilitate analysis of the inevitable uncertainties associated with impact assessment.

There are two components in the TOA analysis: First, the model simulates the proportion of farms that would adopt the new system Second, based on the adoption rate of the new system, the TOA-MD model simulates selected economic, environmental and social impact indicators for adopters, non-adopters and the entire population.

TOA-MD approach: modeling systems used by heterogeneous populations Systems are being used in heterogeneous populations A system is defined in terms of household, crop, livestock and aquaculture sub-systems

(ω)(ω) 0 Map of a heterogeneous region Opportunity cost, system choice and adoption Opportunity cost  = v 1 – v 2 follows distribution  (  ) System 1:  > 0 (non-adopters) System 2:  < 0 (adopters)  opportunity cost

Outcome distributions are associated with system choice –Farms select themselves into “non-adopter” and “adopter” sub- populations, generating corresponding outcome distributions for these sub-populations Impact indicators are based on system choice and outcome distributions –TOA-MD produces mean indicators and threshold-based indicators Analysis shows that impacts depend on the correlations between adoption (opportunity cost) and outcomes –Many impact assessments ignore correlations Adoption, Outcome Distributions and Impact Indicators

Adoption and outcome distributions Entire Population with adoption: 55% >  r(1,a)% non- adopters System 1: 20% >  System 1 before adoption: 25% > threshold  System 2: 90% >   Outcome z  (z|1) r(2,a)% adopters  (z|1,a)  (z|2,a)  (z|a)

Components of TOA-MD Analysis System characterization Adoption rate Population (Strata) Impact indicator design Opportunity cost distributionOutcome distributions Indicators and Tradeoffs Design Data Simulation

The Malawi Case Study: Integrated Agriculture-Aquaculture Based on Dey et al (2010) Agricultural Economics: economic analysis of IAA stratified survey of farms, without and with IAA estimate adoption model but cannot predict adoption rate… Design of TOA-MD analysis population: farm households in southern Malawi where aquaculture is feasible strata: 5 southern districts systems: Subsistence crops Crops + aquaculture, low or high integration Subsistence crops Aquaculture Irrigated vegetables

Adoption Rate and Opportunity Cost of Adopting IAA in Southern Malawi – Predicted Adoption Rate is Point Where Curves Cross the Horizontal Axis

Poverty Rate and Adoption Rate of IAA, Southern Malawi

Mean Monthly Protein Consumption and Adoption of IAA, Southern Malawi

Relationship between adoption and Protein Consumption, Non-adopters and Adopters of IAA, Mulanje Dist., Malawi Non-adopter sub-population and entire population are equal at 0% adoption Adopter sub-population and entire population are equal at 100% adoption Slope of relationship between indicator and adoption rate has same sign as the correlation between opp cost and the outcome variable (negative in this case)

Relationship between adoption and Mean Returns per Farm, Non- Adopters and Adopters of IAA, Mulanje District, Malawi Economic outcomes that are positively related to net returns have a maximum in the entire population at the predicted adoption rate (41% in this example)

Summary: Impacts of IAA Adoption on Farm Population and IAA Adopters

Conclusions TOA-MD is a unique simulation tool for multi-dimensional impact assessment of agriculture and aquaculture systems The Malawi case study illustrates how it can be used with available data to simulate: the adoption rate of a new technology the economic, environmental or social impacts of the new technology The model can also be used for analysis of ecosystem services, and impacts of climate change and other environmental change Training in use of the model, and the model software are available from the TOA Team.

More info is available at :