Congestion Pricing: Competitive Locational Prices of Power Stoft (2002)

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Perfect Competition 12.
Advertisements

Chapter Twenty-Five Monopoly Behavior. How Should a Monopoly Price? u So far a monopoly has been thought of as a firm which has to sell its product at.
Pure Competition in the Long Run
Competitive Markets Chapter 8.
Copyright 2003 PJM 1 PJM’s Annual FTR Auction.
Consumer Sovereignty The interaction of supply and demand in the market mechanism.
Equilibrium, Profits, and Adjustment in a Competitive Market Chapter 8 J. F. O’Connor.
The Competitive Effects of Ownership of Financial Transmission Rights in a Deregulated Electricity Industry Manho Joung and Ross Baldick Electrical and.
Copyright © 2004 South-Western Welfare Economics Welfare economics is the study of how the allocation of resources affects economic well-being. Buyers.
Ramping and CMSC (Congestion Management Settlement Credit) payments.
Chapter 23: Competitive Markets Copyright © 2013 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. McGraw-Hill/Irwin 13e.
Fundamentals of Markets © 2011 D. Kirschen and the University of Washington 1.
Copyright©2004 South-Western 17 Monopolistic Competition.
General Equilibrium and Efficiency. General Equilibrium Analysis is the study of the simultaneous determination of prices and quantities in all relevant.
FRST 318 / 537C March 3 rd Lab Midterm Review. Question 1 Governments in North America announce that wood is a preferred building material because it.
14 Perfect Competition CHAPTER Notes and teaching tips: 4, 7, 8, 9, 25, 26, 27, and 28. To view a full-screen figure during a class, click the red “expand”
Principles of Microeconomics & Principles of Macroeconomics: Ch.7 First Canadian Edition Overview u Welfare Economics u Consumer Surplus u Producer Surplus.
ECO 435 Locational Transmission Pricing Stoft Chapter 5.
1 A PART OF THE INVISIBLE HAND Do you see it?. 2 There is a story in economics that competitive market outcomes are efficient. Efficiency means two things.
© 2007 Thomson South-Western. WHAT IS A COMPETITIVE MARKET? A competitive market has many buyers and sellers trading identical products so that each buyer.
Chapter 10: Perfect competition
3 SUPPLY AND DEMAND II: MARKETS AND WELFARE. Copyright © 2004 South-Western 7 Consumers, Producers, and the Efficiency of Markets.
Consumers, Producers, and the Efficiency of Markets Outline:  Positive economics: Allocation of scarce resources using forces of demand and supply  Normative.
Copyright © 2004 South-Western 7 Consumers, Producers, and the Efficiency of Markets.
© 2007 Thomson South-Western. Consumers, Producers and the Efficiency of Markets Revisiting the Market Equilibrium –Do the equilibrium price and quantity.
Monopolistic Competition, Price Discrimination
Types of Market Structure
Effects of the Transmission Network on Electricity Markets © 2011 D. Kirschen and the University of Washington 1.
Market Equilibrium in Perfect Competition What do buyers and sellers get out of the market? And Why do economists think this is efficient?
Elasticity of Demand and Supply
Harcourt Brace & Company Chapter 7 Consumers, Producers and the Efficiency of Markets.
Market Structure In economics, market structure (also known as market form) describes the state of a market with respect to competition. The major market.
Chapter 7 Profit Maximization and Competitive Market.
Demand, Supply, & Market Equilibrium Chapter 3. Demand A schedule or curve that shows the various amounts of a product that consumers are willing and.
3 SUPPLY AND DEMAND II: MARKETS AND WELFARE. Copyright © 2004 South-Western 7 Consumers, Producers, and the Efficiency of Markets.
Principles of Micro Chapter 7: “Consumers, Producers, and the Efficiency of Markets” by Tanya Molodtsova, Fall 2005.
© 2015 Pearson Canada Inc. Chapter 4 Slide 1 Primary Deck.
Are Monopolies Desirable?
Unit II: The Nature and Function of Product Markets
Monopolistic Competition
Copyright © 2004 South-Western CHAPTER 17 MONOPOLISTIC COMPETITION.
Economics Online study for Lesson #6 “Prices as Signals”
Bulk Power Transmission System
How Markets Work Demand. Introduction Economics is about choices that people make to face scarcity and how those choices are affected by incentives. Prices.
© 2010 W. W. Norton & Company, Inc. 25 Monopoly Behavior.
Copyright©2004 South-Western Firms in Competitive Markets.
Perfect Competition1 PERFECT COMPETITION ECO 2023 Principles of Microeconomics Dr. McCaleb.
Monopolistic Competition Chapter 17 Copyright © 2004 by South-Western,a division of Thomson Learning.
Harcourt, Inc. items and derived items copyright © 2001 by Harcourt, Inc. Revisiting the Market Equilibrium Do the equilibrium price and quantity maximize.
Copyright © 2004 South-Western Welfare Economics Welfare economics is the study of how the allocation of resources affects economic well-being. Buyers.
Decision-making and Demand and Supply Analysis. Thinking Economically: Marginal Analysis Optimization Assumption: an assumption that suggests that the.
DAM Overview: Processes & Tools in the DAM Shams Siddiqi, Ph.D. Crescent Power, Inc. (512) April 2, 2008.
The benchmark of perfect competition Defining perfect competition Modelling market interactions Welfare and efficiency.
CHAPTER 18 EXTENSIONS TO SUPPLY AND DEMAND By Lauren O’Brien, Peter Cervantes, Erik Borders.
The Market Economy. Learning Objectives Define Economics and Economic system Define equilibrium price and equilibrium quantity Explain why the price of.
Economics 2010 Lecture 9 Markets and efficiency. Competition and Efficiency  The Key Question  Allocative Efficiency  The Invisible Hand  Obstacles.
Perfect Competition CHAPTER 11 C H A P T E R C H E C K L I S T When you have completed your study of this chapter, you will be able to 1 Explain a perfectly.
Perfect Competition. Objectives After studying this chapter, you will able to  Define perfect competition  Explain how price and output are determined.
Firms in Markets.
Firms in Perfectly Competitive Markets. A. Many buyers and sellers B. The goods are the same C. Buyers and sellers have a negligible impact on the market.
© 2010 Pearson Education Canada Perfect Competition ECON103 Microeconomics Cheryl Fu.
Market Equilibrium Week 3.  At the market equilibrium price: ◦ Quantity demanded by consumers = quantity supplied by firms/producers/sellers ◦ Without.
Copyright © 2004 South-Western Welfare Economics Welfare economics is the study of how the allocation of resources affects economic well-being. Buyers.
Price Discrimination 1. Defined: Sellers engage in price discrimination when they charge different prices to different consumers for the same good, because.
Chapter 25 Monopoly Behavior. How Should a Monopoly Price? So far a monopoly has been thought of as a firm which has to sell its product at the same price.
© 2007 Thomson South-Western
15 Monopoly.
Lecture 2 Supply and demand
Chapter 10: Perfect competition
Presentation transcript:

Congestion Pricing: Competitive Locational Prices of Power Stoft (2002)

Congestion Pricing Summary 5-3: If there are binding physical transmission limits between locations, a competitive bilateral market with physical transmission rights will trade power at different prices in different locations. – Called competitive locational prices of power (CLPs) 5-4: Central computation finds the optimal dispatch then computes prices from the marginal benefits of a free megawatt at each location. Bilateral traders never consider the optimal dispatch but look only for profitable trades. These two different processes lead to the same quantities being traded and to the same prices because perfectly competitive bilateral trade is efficient.

Congestion Pricing Is Competitive Pricing Transmission lines have capacity limits which must be enforced in order to protect the lines and the stability of the system. When traders would like to use more capacity than is safely available, transmission is a scarce resource. The slides that immediately follow will analyze a single transmission line whose transmission rights are allocated by a competitive market. – Provide a useful benchmark to compare the price outcomes of proposed market architectures to. – Provide an example of bilateral trading – often considered the opposite of centralized nodal pricing. However, both systems aim for the same set of prices.

Competitive Market Structure Two trading locations – Bus 1 – rural area – 100 MW of power needed – Bus 2 – city (the load center) – 800 MW of power needed Connecting transmission line can handle 500 MW. Thus, only 500 MW of transmission rights are issued. – The rights confer on their owner the right to transmit power from Bus 1 to Bus 2 – Initial owner of rights is unimportant – Rights need to be tradeable – Owner of rights cannot exercise market power

Bus 2 – needs 800 MW of power Bus 2 has 500 MW of generation and the 500 MW transmission line connecting it to Bus 1 (where generation capabilities are > 500 MW) Large number of small generators are located at each bus Cost of generation – Bus 2 – starts at $40/MWh and increases at the rate of $2/MWh for each additional 100 MW of output (summarized supply curve: 40 + Q/50 ) – Bus 1 – start at $20/MWh and $2/MWh for each additional 100 MW (supply curve: 20 + Q/50 )

The Price of Transmission Rights Traded separately from energy Either buyer or seller must own a transmission right in the amount of power sold Competitive pressures in the bilateral market will drive the price of transmission rights to the energy price difference between Bus 1 and Bus 2 – i.e. P AB = P B - P A

Congestion Defined In a competitive market, the path from A to B is congested if the price of transmission rights from A to B is positive. This is equivalent to the price of power at B being greater than the price of power at A. If a line would be overused if its limit were not enforced, it is congested.

The Price of Power Both the rural area (Bus 1) and city (Bus 2) customers would buy their power at Bus 1 if there were no transmission limits. Thus, the line is congested. Only 500 MW can be transported from Bus 1 to 2. To meet Bus 2’s total demand of 800 MW, 300 MW will be generated locally. Price of power obtained from supply curves: Price of power at Bus 1: ( /50) = $46 MWh Price of power at Bus 2: ( /50) = $32 MWh

Price of Transmission Remember: P AB = P B – P A $14 = (46-32)

Benefits of Competitive Locational Prices Normal competitive prices – Have standard properties promised by economics for competitive prices Suppliers will minimize cost of production Prices equal marginal values to consumers (i.e. consumers only use an additional megawatt of power when they value it more than its cost of production)

Centralized Computation of CLPs When CLPs are calculated by a central authority, such as an ISO Provided generators and customers tell ISO their true supply and demand curves, the ISO will find the same CLPs that a bilateral market would

Central Computation Details No transmission rights, only an energy market Each generator and every load customer submits a bid to the ISO which specifies the location that they will provide or take power. – Generators typically bid a supply curve, that is they are willing to provide larger quantities at progressively higher prices – Load customers bid similar demand curves The ISO maximizes total surplus and sets price equal to marginal surplus at every location, essentially clearing the market.

Centralized Computation Example

Bilateral Pricing Compared to Centralized Pricing Centralized computation tries to minimize total cost of production. Bilateral traders try to maximize own profits If no profitable bilateral trades can be found then centralized pricing has returned the bilateral outcome

Trades from Centralized Example Trade #MWFromToSale PriceTRs 1150AB$45100 MW 2300AA$ BB$ A & BC$400

Problems/Solutions Centralized computation is accused of calculating too many prices – Either a bilateral or centralized market can be set up to find fewer but less accurate prices – Increases “gaming opportunities” If there are small enough competitors (low market power), both a bilateral market and centralized computation will be competitive – Whether either is more susceptible to market power remains an open question