Time travel van inwagen’s response. the altered past paradox 1. If time travel is possible, then one can change the past. 2. One cannot change the past.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Physical and Chemical Changes
Advertisements

Time Travel Branching Time Lines. Back to the Future External time is objective or real time. Personal time is time measured on your wristwatch. A time-traveler.
the self-visitation paradox
what is science OBSERVATION
the double-occupancy paradox
DO CRY OVER SPILT MILK: POSSIBLY YOU CAN CHANGE THE PAST Peter B. M. Vranas Iowa State University Central APA, 28 April 2005.
Time travel the grandfather paradox ii. lewis’s puzzle A. Tim can kill Grandfather. B. Tim cannot kill Grandfather.
ON CHANGE Zeno. The Dichotomy Zeno’s arguments about motion which provide trouble for those who try to resolve them are four in number. The first.
Does Time Really Pass? Simon Prosser University of St Andrews University of Durham Institute of Advanced Study Public lecture, 20 th November 2012.
Obtain Data from Other Sources Data you need to include in an Access database often already exists in another file: in another Access database, in a table.
© Michael Lacewing Omnipotence and other puzzles Michael Lacewing co.uk.
Time tense. a-properties and b-properties A properties: putative temporal properties like pastness, presentness, futurity, being one day future, etc.
Time travel the grandfather paradox i. the grandfather paradox 1. If time travel is possible, then one can commit grampatricide before one’s father is.
Time travel the bootstrapping paradox ii. The diary paradox 1. The diary has exactly n entries in it when it is handed to Jane in Jane writes.
Personal Immortality: Arguments 1. Socrates/Descartes: unlike the body, the soul is simple, immaterial, & does not come apart Objection: death is not dissolution.
Time travel vranas on changing the past. the altered past paradox 1. If time travel is possible, then one can change the past. 2. One cannot change the.
Time McTaggart’s Argument. Time W hat, then, is time? I know well enough what it is, provided that nobody asks me; but if I am asked what it is and try.
Freedom and Determinism Hard Determinism. Review The Freedom Principle: Some actions are free. The Control Principle: An action is free only if it’s up.
EXAMPLE 5 Solve a multi-step problem LIBRARY
3 Variables in an Experiment. Independent Variable There are three kinds of variables that you must account for in an experiment. The independent variable.
LECTURE 26 NEW VERSIONS OF DESCARTES’ ARGUMENT AND THE LEIBNIZIAN ARGUMENT G.E. MOORE’S OBSERVATION.
1 2.5:Reason Using Properties from Algebra Goal:Use algebraic properties in logical arguments.
Sections Logarithmic Functions (5.3) What is a logarithm??? LOGS ARE POWERS!!!! A logarithm or “ log ” of a number of a certain base is the exponent.
God and Omniscience Dr Steve Makin Department of Philosophy University of Sheffield 1.
You have the right to learn and study in a quiet, productive environment. Your have the responsibility to work independently or in cooperation.
What is science? an introduction to life science.
Traveling Seeds!. Parts of the Seed Seed Coat Cotyledon Embryo.
Time Travel The Causal Paradox. The Altered Past Paradox 1)If time travel were possible, it would be possible to change the past. 2)It’s not possible.
OBJECTIONS Hard Determinism. Determinism The Universality of Causation: Everything that happens has a cause (which precedes it in time). The Sufficiency.
Observation and Inference
LECTURE 19 THE COSMOLOGICAL ARGUMENT CONTINUED. THE QUANTUM MECHANICAL OBJECTION DEPENDS UPON A PARTICULAR INTERPRETATION WE MIGHT REASONABLY SUSPEND.
Time Travel and Paradoxes An Introduction to Time Travel and Temporal Anomolies in Time Travel Movies.
History: “What is it?” and “Why does it matter?”.
Understanding Observations
Observations. Observations are taken in science so that someone reading your experiment can see what you experienced. Observations can include measurements,
LECTURE 21 WHAT RATIONAL BEINGS ARE THERE?. VAN INWAGEN’S CHARACTERIZATION OF “RATIONAL” HE AVOIDS THE USE OF THE WORD “INTELLIGENT” IN FAVOR OF “RATIONAL”.
Free Will and Determinism Chapter Three Think pp
Time and Travel. Seventh objection.-A thing can move back and forth in space, though it cannot do so in time.
Time Travel and its Paradoxes. As for traveling into the future, suppose the traveler to journey at some rate such as one year per hour, i.e., he.
Tuesday 9/22 Day 2 Science Starters Sheet 1. Please have these Items on your desk. Agenda 2- Fill out your Agenda. Science starter: Physical property:
DoING Science: Science Process Skills Science is a process through which we learn about the world. We not only learn about science, we actually DO Science!
网上报账系统包括以下业务: 日常报销 差旅费报销 借款业务 1. 填写报销内容 2. 选择支付方式 (或冲销借款) 3. 提交预约单 4. 打印预约单并同分类粘 贴好的发票一起送至财务 处 预约报销步骤: 网上报账系统 薪酬发放管理系统 财务查询系统 1.
Physical Properties of Matter Grade 7.
Lecture 11 Persistence: arguments for perdurance
How are living and nonliving things alike and different?
Omnipotence and other puzzles
Important Terms ATOM - Smallest unit of an element that keeps its chemical properties ELEMENT – Unique substance with the same number of protons in every.
The Science of Observation Vocabulary
What is Physical Science?
The Altered Past Paradox
What is Physical Science?
Making Inferences from Observations
Which do you think would have the greater mass and greater volume? Why? 1 kg of rock 1 kg of feathers.
Qualitative vs. Quantitative
Qualitative Observation
Is the concept of substance innate?
7.9 Comb Basis Set Transform comb-to-comb transform
Do Now: What is the difference between an observation and an inference?
Logarithmic and Exponential Equations
Unit: Science & Technology
This is… 2 DOUBLES 4→10 EARLY NUMBER SENSE.
№96 сонли умумий ўрта мактабининг ўқитувчиси Эшанкулова феруза
Bell Work What happens when people are hypnotized?
The following information is NOT from an academic source!
BASIC SCIENCE PROCESS SKILLS
Traveling Seeds!.
THE PROMISE THE LAW & GALATIANS 3: THE PROMISE THE LAW & GALATIANS 3:15-25.
This is… 7 DOUBLES 12→20 EARLY NUMBER SENSE.
Scientific Method Chapter 1.5.
Time Metaphysics 2019.
Presentation transcript:

time travel van inwagen’s response

the altered past paradox 1. If time travel is possible, then one can change the past. 2. One cannot change the past. 3. [So] Time travel is not possible.

the anti-change argument 1. For any x, if it is possible for x to change (in the qualitative sense), it is possible for x to have different properties at different times. 2. It is not possible for the past to have different properties at different times. 3. [So] It is not possible for the past to change.

the anti-growth argument 1. For any x, if it is possible for x to grow, it is possible for x to be different sizes at different times. 2. It is not possible for time (i.e., the temporal manifold) to have different sizes at different times. 3. [So] It is not possible for time to grow.