UC Collections & Services

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
HathiTrust Unless otherwise noted, these slides and their contents are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution Unported License.
Advertisements

HATHI TRUST A Shared Digital Repository Building A Future By Preserving Our Past The Preservation Infrastructure of HathiTrust Digital Library Jeremy York.
KAT HAGEDORN HATHITRUST SPECIAL PROJECTS COORDINATOR UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN LIBRARIES OCTOBER 9, 2009 Seamless Sharing: NYU, HathiTrust, ReCAP and the.
Building the Universal Library: The Promise and Challenges of HathiTrust John Wilkin 2 April 2009.
How HathiTrust Serves the UC Community Users Council May 21, 2012 Heather Christenson, California Digital Library.
HATHI TRUST A Shared Digital Repository HathiTrust, Collections, and Collaboration COLD 2011 Spring Meeting Jeremy York May 20, 2011.
KAT HAGEDORN HATHITRUST SPECIAL PROJECTS COORDINATOR UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN LIBRARIES OCTOBER 9, 2009 Seamless Sharing: NYU, HathiTrust, ReCAP and the.
National Institutes of Health U.S. Department of Health and Human Services The PEPH Resource Center: A New, More Convenient Login.
HathiTrust and the Ecology of Shared Collections Paul N. Courant 21 May 2009.
HATHITRUST A Shared Digital Repository We’re Preserving the Past, What About the Present? NISO Webinar: Ensuring the Preservation of E-Books May 23, 2012.
What’s Next for HathiTrust?. We’re Growing Up! Partnership Arizona State University Baylor University Boston University California Digital Library Columbia.
HATHITRUST A Shared Digital Repository HathiTrust current work, challenges, and opportunities for public libraries Creating a Blueprint for a National.
HATHITRUST A Shared Digital Repository HathiTrust as a Model for Preservation and Access Jeremy York Media Preservation Conference April 17, 2013.
HATHITRUST A Shared Digital Repository Bibliographic Metadata and HathiTrust ALCTS CaMMS Catalog Management Interest Group Meeting American Library Association.
HATHITRUST A Shared Digital Repository The HathiTrust Print Monograph Archive Planning Task Force Print Archive Network Forum ALA 2015 Midwinter Meeting.
HATHITRUST A Shared Digital Repository Collective Stewardship through HathiTrust Digital Library African Studies in the Digital Age November 12, 2014 Mike.
HATHITRUST A Shared Digital Repository HathiTrust METS and PREMIS October 25, 2011 Jeremy York Project Librarian, HathiTrust.
HATHITRUST A Shared Digital Repository HathiTrust on the Move A Growing Partnership Taking Stock and Looking Ahead National Library of Medecine October.
HATHITRUST A Shared Digital Repository HathiTrust: A Second Life for Library Collections Jeremy York Exploring Humanities Cyberinfrastructure April 30,
HATHITRUST A Shared Digital Repository HathiTrust: The Collection and Its Uses NEFLIN Webinar - November 7, 2013 Jeremy York, Assistant Director, HathiTrust.
HATHITRUST A Shared Digital Repository A Preservation Infrastructure Built to Last: Preservation, Community, and HathiTrust UNESCO Memory of the World.
HATHITRUST A Shared Digital Repository How Can Digital Collections Support Shared Print Initiatives? The HathiTrust Print Monograph Archive Planning Task.
HATHITRUST A Shared Digital Repository HathiTrust Overview: Partnership and Services Jeremy York Wesleyan University Web Presentation February 18, 2014.
HATHITRUST A Shared Digital Repository Why Digitize? or The Limits of Preservation 2014 TEI/DHCS Plenary Session Evanston, IL Mike Furlough Executive Director,
HATHITRUST A Shared Digital Repository Digital Humanities in HathiTrust: Research At Any Scale Jeremy York Digital Humanities and the Futures of Japanese.
1 Archiving and Preserving the Web Kristine Hanna Internet Archive April 2006.
Massively Digitizing UC Library Collections Google, Microsoft, and More Learning in Retirement Libraries – The Intersection of Tradition and Innovation.
HATHITRUST A Shared Digital Repository HathiTrust Past, Present, and Future A Brief Introduction.
Western Regional Storage Trust (WEST) Overview and Current Status Image courtesy of the Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley.
HATHITRUST A Shared Digital Repository More, Better, Together: HathiTrust Accomplishments and Aspirations The Researcher of Tomorrow Universidad Complutense.
High Water Raises All Boats Leveraging Partnerships on Campus to Build a Repository Mary Molinaro University of Kentucky Libraries.
CILogon and InCommon: Technical Update Jim Basney This material is based upon work supported by the National Science Foundation under grant numbers
HATHITRUST A Shared Digital Repository HathiTrust: Putting Research in Context HTRC UnCamp September 10, 2012 John Wilkin, Executive Director, HathiTrust.
HATHITRUST A Shared Digital Repository Collaborating Globally, Planning Locally HathiTrust and New Opportunities in Collection Management GWLA/UNM: Emerging.
1 The Partnership Challenge Higher education’s missions are realized in increasingly global, collaborative, online relationships –Higher educations’ digital.
1 The Prevention Research Centers Program: The Case for Networks Eduardo Simoes, MD, MSc, MPH Program Director Prevention Research Centers National Center.
Bioengineering Graduate Program Fischell Department of Bioengineering University of Maryland John P. Fisher, Ph.D. Professor and Associate Chair Director.
HathiTrust Digital Library. Overview ›Began in 2008 ›Large scale digital preservation repository ›Partnership of major research libraries ›Focus on both.
What is Going on with Kuali? Jennifer Foutty Executive Director, Kuali Foundation.
Looking to the East: Challenges in Connecting Asian Libraries in the World of Information Karen T. Wei University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign Hong.
From Concept to Reality: An overview of the University of Wisconsin Digital Collections Melissa Mclimans.
Using the University of Northampton Library: an ‘EWO’ guide for students based at other locations Please note: The University’s official term for arrangements.
June, 2012 Art Mandel.  Multiple acceptances to Ivy League Schools  Multiple acceptances to the “Most Competitive” colleges and universities  State.
HATHITRUST A Shared Digital Repository HathiTrust: Key Concepts and Issues in Managing the Digital Archive ICPSR Summer Workshop “Curating and Managing.
HTRC Workshop 101 THATCamp Gainesville April 24, 2014.
Breana McCracken University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign HathiTrust and Copyright Future Implications - Strong precedent for libraries to continue to.
University of California Mass Digitization Projects Update Users Council Annual Meeting May 8, 2008 Heather Christenson, Mass Digitization Project Mgr,
HATHITRUST A Shared Digital Repository HathiTrust and TRAC DigitalPreservation 2012 July 25, 2012 Jeremy York, Project Librarian, HathiTrust.
HATHITRUST A Shared Digital Repository The HathiTrust Print Monograph Archive Planning Task Force Print Archive Network Forum ALA 2015 Annual Meeting June.
HATHITRUST A Shared Digital Repository HathiTrust and the Future of Research Libraries American Antiquarian Society March 31, 2012 Jeremy York, Project.
HATHITRUST A Shared Digital Repository Your Library, Now Online! Putting HathiTrust in the Context of Traditional (and New) Library Services MCLS Webinar.
Compliance Assist Refresher Instruction Guide Adding or Editing Student Learning Outcomes.
HATHITRUST A Shared Digital Repository Institution Uses of HathiTrust Jeremy York University of Maine May 24, 2013.
Delivering Knowledge for Health Get in the Good Books: eBooks training day Thursday 22 nd March 2007 Wolfson Training Suite, Edinburgh University.
HathiTrust: Collaboration in Building the Universal Collection John Wilkin 1 October 2009.
Session Session 29-2 Updating Your Eligibility Status.
HATHITRUST A Shared Digital Repository HathiTrust Large Digital Libraries: Beyond Google Books Modern Language Association January 5, 2012 Jeremy York,
An Overview of the Platform
Collaboration: to work jointly with others towards a common goal Or the whole is greater than the sum of its parts Lisa B. German Library Faculty Organization.
Presenters:Lea Domingo, Branch Manager, Kahuku Public and School Library Sunny Pai, Digital Initiatives Librarian, Kapiolani Community College If you.
HathiTrust: A valuable and visionary Partnership.
HathiTrust--a GovDocs Repository? Brian Vetruba, Catalog Librarian/Germanic Studies Librarian Washington University in St. Louis Leveraging.
HATHITRUST A Shared Digital Repository ALA CopyTalk: CRMS The Copyright Review Management System September 1, 2016 Melissa Levine, Lead Copyright Officer,
Introducing Students to the Locker
IRBchoice Connections Call: June 10, 2016
HathiTrust Digital Library Interface and Services
HathiTrust Copyright Review
EBSCOhost Digital Archives Viewer
From Innovation to Commercialization Access to Data
Tutorial Introduction to help.ebsco.com.
Presentation transcript:

UC Collections & Services HathiTrust: UC Collections & Services UCLAS Webinar, May 12, 2015 Heather Christenson California Digital Library

Council of University Librarians’ Priority Capitalize on technological opportunities to accelerate the transition to a primarily digital environment University of California Libraries, Systemwide Plan and Priorities, FY 2013-2016 http://libraries.universityofcalifornia.edu/about/vision-and-priorities

UC Libraries’ Mass Digitized Volumes 3,492,720 UC volumes ≈ 25 million volumes ≈ 13.6% of Google Books volumes (estimated) Google Books 193,576 UC volumes ≈ 2.4 million IA-digitized volumes ≈ 8% of IA-digitized volumes (estimated) Internet Archive 3,637,905 UC volumes 13,334,601 total HT volumes ≈ 27% of HT volumes Includes locally digitized UC volumes HathiTrust

Today’s presentation What is HathiTrust? What is in HathiTrust? Overview, mission, members, UC participation What is in HathiTrust? Overall, by library, languages, dates, copyright distribution, UC collections A bit about copyright How access is determined, CRMS project, the public domain, opening up rights Services we have as a HathiTrust partner organization Preservation, single sign on, filtering to UC or campus, print disabled services, collection building and sharing, search widget, download open access books via web and mobile, advanced full text search Access points Melvyl, campus catalogs, HathiTrust Research Center, Bookworm, DPLA Service questions & communications Future HathiTrust initiatives

HathiTrust What is HathiTrust? A shared digital repository founded in October 2008. Very large scale A partnership community of over 100 research libraries. UC is a founding partner Dual focus on preservation and access Research center for computational research using text Why is it important to libraries? Continues and extends the historical role of libraries Services not driven by commercial purposes Draws upon contributions and expertise from across the partnership Standardization enables programmatic activities Scale enables savings Collaboration empowers the libraries as a whole

HathiTrust Mission To  contribute  to  research,  scholarship,  and  the  common  good by  collaboratively  collecting,  organizing,  preserving,  communicating, and  sharing  the  record  of  human  knowledge. building  comprehensive  collections  and  infrastructure   co-­owned  and  managed  by  partners.   infrastructure  for  digital  content  of  value  to  scholars  and  researchers   enabling  access  by  users  with  print  disabilities.   supporting  research  with  the  collections.   stimulating  shared  collection  storage strategies among libraries

North Carolina State University Northeastern University Northwestern University Oklahoma State University The Ohio State University The Pennsylvania State University Princeton University Purdue University Rutgers University Stanford University State University System of Florida Syracuse University Temple University Texas A&M University Texas Tech University Tufts University Universidad Complutense de Madrid University of Alabama University of Alberta University of Arizona University of British Columbia University of Calgary University of California Berkeley Davis Irvine Los Angeles Merced Riverside San Diego San Francisco Santa Barbara Santa Cruz California Digital Library The University of Chicago University of Connecticut University of Delaware University of Houston University of Illinois University of Illinois at Chicago The University of Iowa University of Kansas University of Maine University of Maryland University of Massachusetts, Amherst University of Miami University of Michigan University of Minnesota University of Missouri University of Nebraska-Lincoln University of New Mexico The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill University of Notre Dame University of Oklahoma University of Pennsylvania University of Pittsburgh University of Queensland University of Tennessee, Knoxville University of Texas University of Utah University of Vermont University of Virginia University of Washington University of Wisconsin-Madison Utah State University Vanderbilt University Virginia Tech Wake Forest University Washington University Yale University Library Allegheny College American University of Beirut Arizona State University Baylor University Boston College Boston University Brandeis University Brown University Carnegie Mellon University Case Western Reserve Colby College Columbia University Cornell University Dartmouth College Duke University Emory University Florida State University Getty Research Institute Georgetown University Georgia Tech Harvard University Library Indiana University Iowa State University Johns Hopkins University Kansas State University Lafayette College Library of Congress Massachusetts Institute of Technology McGill University` Michigan State University Montana State University Mount Holyoke College New York Public Library New York University North Carolina Central University 16 April 2015

UC Libraries’ leadership & engagement Board of Governors Laine Farley (CDL), Brian Schottlaender (UCSD) Program Steering Committee Martha Hruska (UCSD), Todd Grappone (UCLA), Ivy Anderson (CDL) Collections Committee Sharon Farb (UCLA), Ivy Anderson (CDL) Rights & Access Working Group Sharon Farb (UCLA) Government Documents Initiative Planning and Advisory Group Elizabeth Cowell (UCSC), Ivy Anderson (CDL) Print Monographs Archive Planning Task Force Erik Mitchell (UCB), Emily Stambaugh (CDL) User Support Working Group Becky Culbertson (UCSD) CRMS Project teams at UCI, UCLA, UCSF, and CDL

CDL Technical development & operations Development of standards and process to transfer digitized volumes into HathiTrust from both Google & the Internet Archive Choosing appropriate file format for balance of function and cost (TIFF G4 + JPEG 2000 mix) Ensuring data is present to support full functionality (discovery, access, preservation) Enabling download and coordinating with Google, Michigan, and other partners Specifying reporting requirements Development for access HathiTrust “Pageturner” interface Link resolver “target” Search widget Zephir HathiTrust Metadata Management System Launched Nov 2013 19.2 million item records in Zephir Clustered into 7.2 million bibliographic records There are 40 different contributor sources represented by 63 source collections 2.74 million new or updated records loaded in 2014 (first full year of production)

HathiTrust Digital Library includes Currently 13,410,840 total volumes 6,793,404 book titles 355,066 serial titles 4,693,794,000 pages 601 terabytes 159 miles 10,896 tons 5,092,457 volumes(~38% of total) in the public domain Volumes contributed from 23 partners, including UC Brings together outputs of major mass digitization initiatives

Contributions by Library April 2015 byy Library, Apr 2015 Institution Volumes University of Michigan 4,722,050 University of California 3,639,937 Harvard University 838,122 University of Wisconsin 561,534 Indiana University 529,798 Cornell University 515,753 Penn State 389,247 University of Illinois 348,946 University of Minnesota 334,249 New York Public Library 304,610 Princeton University 252,841 Universidad Complutense 117,322 Library of Congress 108,892 Keio University 90,122 University of Alberta 76,106 Ohio State 74,525 Columbia University 73,396 Northwestern University 57,000 University of Chicago 56,981 University of Virginia 51,207 16 April 2015

And here you can see the breakdown of what is in and out of copyright And here you can see the breakdown of what is in and out of copyright. What is in copyright is ‘dark’ but searchable.

UC Library Collections in HathiTrust Mass digitized via Google & the Internet Archive NRLF & SRLF: all subjects, all languages UC Berkeley: cookbooks, mathematics, selected Bancroft collections, Main library, Music Library, East Asian Library UC Davis: California documents, Main library collection, wine collections, special collections UCLA: children’s books, Italian comedies, rare business and economics texts, East Asian Library, Management, Chem / Biomed, Arts Library UC San Diego: East Asia collection, IRPS, Scripps, Music, Science/Engineering UC San Francisco: Medical library collections, special collections UC Santa Cruz: Humanities / Social Sciences Locally digitized collections from UCSF, UCSD in progress, UCLA, UCM, UCB

Local Digitization – Path to HathiTrust CDL assists UC library staff to upload locally digitized volumes and metadata to HathiTrust Path via Google CDL consults with library to correctly package images and metadata Direct path to HathiTrust CDL helps: Interpret HT requirements and documentation Test sample images and interpret results Interface with Michigan staff on image remediation and metadata issues Assists in the completing HT paperwork: DASI, Submission Inventory, missing metadata, etc. If your library would like to upload locally digitized materials to HT, please consult CDL as early in the process as possible.  

HathiTrust Rights Status – Public Domain HT automatic rights algorithm assigns “Public Domain” status to books published in the US prior to 1923 and to works published outside the US prior to 1875. These are open access to everyone. HT automatic rights algorithm assigns “Public Domain – United States” status to books published outside the US during years 1875 – 1922. These are only open to users in the United States. CRMS World reviewers are currently conducting author death date research for works published in the UK, Canada, and Australia between 1875 and 1945 (for the UK) and 1965 (for Canada and Australia). When legally appropriate, volumes are re-assigned the rights status “Public Domain” The year 1875/1945/1965 moves up an increment each January 1st

Public Domain Extension? Works published in 1923 should enter the public domain in the U.S. on January 1, 2019. Thereafter, the year should increment by one every January 1st. This is thanks to the Sonny Bono Copyright Term Extension Act of 1998. Prior to 1998, copyright in published works lasted at most 75 years, the Sonny Bono act extended all existing copyrights by 20 years. This is why works published before 1923 are in the public domain: 1922 + 75 = 1997 (the year before the new rule took effect) However, Congress could grant another copyright extension before 2019 and prevent more works from entering the public domain.

HT CRMS (Copyright Review Management System) In the past 6 years CRMS project staff have reviewed 511,520 volumes for copyright status and have been able to open 270,979 volumes (or 52.96%) to the public. CRMS U.S. (2008 - 2014) reviewed volumes published in the United States between 1923 and 1963. CRMS World (2014 – 2016) Reviewers are currently conducting author death date research for works published in the UK, Canada, and Australia between 1875 and 1945 to determine if they are in the public domain. UC staff from UC Irvine, UC Los Angeles, UC San Francisco, and CDL are currently conducting reviews CRMS projects have been funded via National Leadership Grants from IMLS (Institute of Museum and Library Sciences)

UC Rights Holders may open their publications in HathiTrust for public access http://www.hathitrust.org/permissions_agreement

Digital Preservation Long-term commitments on digital content facilitate decision-making about digitization efforts and print collections management “Use of standard and open content formats that meet community-accepted digital preservation standards, are widely supported on a number of platforms, and that we are confident can be preserved and migrated forward to new preservation formats over time” “Reliance on standards for repository design and trustworthiness such as OAIS and TRAC” http://www.hathitrust.org/preservation

HathiTrust Services for Print Disabled Quote: Brian Carver, assistant professor, School of Information, UC Berkeley

Simple log in using existing university credentials via Shibboleth Go to HathiTrust.org Click the yellow “Log in” button in the top right-hand corner Select your institution from the dropdown box Sign in via your university credentials

Limit HT Search Results to UC Volumes Only From search results page, scroll down to “Original Location” in the “Refine Results” column on the left side of the page. Click “University of California” Search results will now only include volumes from UC

Limit Search Results to Volumes Held by Your Campus Login to HathiTrust Go to Advance Full Text Search Fill in your search query and then check off the box under the “Limit to” section Click “Search”

Collection Building: from a Book Page 1. From a book page, select “Create New Collection” from the drop box on the left-hand side of the page under “Add to Collection” 2. Add a name for your collection and click to make it either private or public 3. Click “Save Changes”

Collection Building: from Search Results Enter a query for full text-search search Select at least 1 item to add to your collection by checking on a box beside each search result 3. Select “Create New Collection” from drop down list on gray bar above search results and click “Add Selected” Add a name and click to make your Collection private or public

Add Items to Your Collection You can add a volume (or volumes) to your collection in the same way you created a collection – via a book page or search results. Select your collection name from the same drop down list and the selected volume/s will be added to the selected collection.

Accessing and Sharing your collections To share your collection, go to HathiTrust.org and click “Collections” from the top navigation bar. Then click the “My Collections” tab Next, click the collection you want to share from your list of collections Your collection page will open. It has an unique URL which you can share with others. You have the ability to search only within your collection.

UCSF Collection Search Widget CDL staff created a search box for UCSF’s collection on HT 1. Enter a search term from UCSF’s Archive page and go directly to results within UCSF’s collection on HathiTrust

UCSF Collection Search Widget 2. Select a volume and go directly to the search inside the book option with your search term already entered. 3. View your search within the book results

UCSF Collection Search Widget 4. Select the page you want to see and go directly to the page which contains your search term

Download Open Access Books Make sure you are logged into HathiTrust Go to a full view book page for the book you want to download Click “Download Whole Book (PDF)

Downloading Open Access Text via Mobile Device Go to HathiTrust.org on your mobile device Log in Enter a search term and click “find” 4. Select the volume you want from the results 5. Select to go to “Full View” volume from the institution you prefer

5. Click the white arrow at the bottom of the screen to open the menu 6. Click “Get Book” icon 7. Choose to download either a PDF or EPUB 8. Wait until your PDF is finished building and click “Download”

9. Select where you’d like to save and read your volume 10. Read your book using your device from anywhere!

HathiTrust Advanced Full-Text Search

Refining Search Results

HathiTrust Links in Melvyl (via OCLC) http://www.cdlib.org/services/d2d/melvyl/Melvyl_FAQ.html#hathi1 FAQ http://www.cdlib.org/services/d2d/melvyl/Melvyl_FAQ.html#hathi1

HT Links in UC Davis Catalog

HT Links in UCSD Catalog

HathiTrust Research Center (HTRC) Bring researchers to the data Starting with public domain materials Support “non-consumptive” research Evolve around user demand Distribution of datasets http://www.hathitrust.org/datasets Access for researchers Assemble worksets Browse volume lists and algorithms, execute algorithms, view results Sandbox: can run own algorithms

Example Projects Supported by HTRC Muñoz, Trevor, University of Maryland. “Distributed Metadata Correction and Annotation.” Correction, annotation and enhancement of HT records and export as linked data Page, Kevin, Oxford University. “ElEPHãT: Early English Print in HathiTrust, a Linked Semantic Workset Prototype” Development of secondary worksets based on both HT and the Early English Books Online Text Creation Partnership (EEBO-TCP). Burton, Vernon. “The South as ‘Other,’ the Southerner as ‘Stranger.’” Explore how attitudes expressed in print about slavery, southerners, and non-southerners have changed over both time and space. Ted Underwood, Associate Professor of English at the University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign. Using public domain texts received from HathiTrust to explore changing relationships in literary genres from 1700-1899.

HathiTrust Bookworm, as alternative search interface http://bookworm.htrc.illinois.edu/

HathiTrust in DPLA Hathitrust is one of over 40 content hubs providing metadata to be searched on the Digital Public Library of America which resolve to digital objects. DPLA is a way to search HathiTrust alongside many sources of rich digital materials which include text, sound, and moving images. 1. Enter search terms

2. Refine search results to include only HT results 3. Refine results further to include only UC items in HT

2. Refine search results to include only HT results 3. Refine results further to include only UC items in HT

Service & Communications Qs What happens when I use the HathiTrust Feedback button? Some issues scale to multiple campuses, some don’t: Implementation of print disabled services Replacement copies Opening up rights Can I get a book in that I want in there? How do I correct a record?

Future HathiTrust Initiatives Shared Print Monographs Archive US Federal Government Documents Initiative Collections assessment: non-print? Metadata policy Quality characterization & improvement Methods to solicit and evaluate proposals for development      Translating HathiTrust Research Center research into operational services Continue to expand lawful uses

A NOTE OF THANKS To each and every person on every campus who has contributed to UC’s mass digitization projects! Your hard work is the foundation of this digital library.

More Information Questions? HathiTrust www.hathitrust.org About: http://www.hathitrust.org/about Resources: http://www.hathitrust.org/resources Twitter: http://twitter.com/hathitrust Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/hathitrust Monthly newsletter: http:www.hathitrust.org/updates Contact: feedback@issues.hathitrust.org Blogs: http://www.hathitrust.org/blogs HathiTrust Research Center www.hathitrust.org/htrc/ 2015 Uncamp: http://www.hathitrust.org/htrc_uncamp2015 UC Mass Digitization Projects http://www.cdlib.org/services/collections/massdig/ Contact: Heather.christenson@ucop.edu Thanks to Mike Furlough, HathiTrust Executive Director, for sharing slides, & Renata Ewing (CDL) for her assistance http://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=uc1.b4594029;view=thumb;seq=1 Questions?

Main points in Authors Guild v. HathiTrust decision Section 108 on library privileges doesn’t limit the scope of fair use. A search index and access for the print-disabled are both fair uses. Search indexing is a transformative use. The libraries aren’t making commercial uses, even though they partnered with Google to get the scans. The plaintiffs haven’t proven that HathiTrust is creating any security risks. There is no market for scanning and print-disabled access, nor is one likely to develop.