Sustainability Science: What it is and what it’s not J. David Tàbara, Congrés UPC Sostenible 2015 Barcelona, 10 July 2009

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Food crisis and the International Assessment of Agriculture knowledge, Science and Technology for Development (SSA) Dr Simplice Davo VODOUHE PAN International.
Advertisements

Intergovernmental Consultation on Strengthening the Scientific Base of the United Nations Environment Programme
EURADWASTE 29 March 2004 LOCAL COMMUNITIES IN NUCLEAR WASTE MANAGEMENT THE COWAM EUROPEAN PROJECT EURADWASTE, 29 March 2004.
J. David Tàbara Institute of Environmental Science and Technology Autonomous University of Barcelona Integrated Climate Governance.
Key Characteristics of Climate-Smart Conservation Dr. Leigh Welling Chief, Climate Change Response Program US National Park Service Dr. Bruce A. Stein.
Inter-discipline Integration Implications of sustained Development of Architectural Education Presented by Tsung Juang (TJ) Wang Department of Architecture.
What change should extension be enabling in the name of climate change adaptation? Dr. Lauren Rickards Research Fellow, University of Melbourne: Primary.
© UKCIP 2011 Learning and Informing Practice: The role of knowledge exchange Roger B Street Technical Director Friday, 25 th November 2011 Crew Project.
Computing Research in Latin America Jaime Puente Program Manager External Research & Programs Microsoft Research Jaime Puente Program Manager External.
POLITICS IN A CLIMATE- CHALLENGED SOCIETY Professor David Schlosberg Department of Government and International Relations.
What is Sustainable Innovation? Professor Lassi Linnanen October 20, 2011.
Joshua C. Farley University of Vermont Community Development and Applied Economics Gund Institute for Ecological Economics sustainability science.
Determining CLIMASP Competencies Jerash University Development of Interdisciplinary Program on Climate Change and Sustainability Policy- CLIMASP Development.
11 Steps Leading to Amsterdam and Beyond A much greater emphasis on frameworks for planned adaptation, and also to robust approaches to decision-making.
Lessons from Thematic Working Groups. Getting to Scale: NEEDS Capacity building at all levels – – for all Focus on the most vulnerable Conceive appropriate.
Teacher education for a sustainable future
History, Theory, and Philosophy of Science (In SMAC + RT) 7th smester -Fall 2005 Institute of Media Technology and Engineering Science Aalborg University.
Learning in the agora: the new engagement agenda in science Frans Berkhout King’s College London and Future Earth.
The SEEAW in the context of Integrated Water Resource Management Roberto Lenton Chair, Technical Committee Global Water Partnership.
Development of Interdisciplinary Program on Climate Change and Sustainability Policy- CLIMASP” CLARIFYING ETHICS AND VALUES CLIMASP Course Curriculum Development.
Urban-Nexus – Integrated Urban Management David Ludlow and Michael Buser UWE Sofia November 2011.
Aim The aim of this research is to assess and improve research impact on policy and practice of climate change governance at the regional and local level.
PUBLIC SCHOLARSHIP EXPLORED: FORMS & POSSIBILITIES Julie Plaut, ,
WP 5: Assessment of Transition Pathways to Regional Sustainability of Agriculture “to build on findings from WP3 to inform participatory identification.
The Climate Prediction Project Global Climate Information for Regional Adaptation and Decision-Making in the 21 st Century.
Global Water Partnership Meeting the WSSD action target on IWRM and water efficiency strategies: A how-to guide.
Our Common Journey: A Transition toward Sustainability Summarized by: Asa Young Me 449 Husar.
Climate Change Capacity Building, Built Environment, and Technology: Selected Issues Track 6 Contribution.
Professor Philip Lowe Newcastle University Director of UK Research Councils’ Rural Economy and Land Use Programme Researching Environment - Society Relations.
Heide Hackmann Stockholm, 31 January Introduction: process, objectives and audiences 2.Why a world social science report on global environmental.
Analysing Resilience in Social-Ecological Systems (ReSES) – a simple model of water management in a semi-arid river delta DISCUSSION References: [1] Walker.
Social science for the Integrated Assessment of environmental risks and problems. DAY 3: Managing social-ecological systems and scarce resources. Dr. J.
Chapter 6: Integrating Knowledge and Action Scott Kaminski ME / 9 / 2005.
Facilitator: Dr Alex Ryan Associate, Higher Education Academy Interdisciplinary Sustainability Education: Insights, Momentum and Futures 14 th December.
Brainstorming meeting House of Catalonia, Bruxelles 26 March 2014 Territorial Vision and Pathways 2050.
The Monitoring and Evaluation of Government-Funded Organizations in the Western Cape: Discourses of Social Development Presentation for SAMEA Conference,
HIGHER EDUCATION PARTNERSHIPS FOR THE SDGS: PROSPECTS BEYOND THE MDGS Marit Egner, EAIE Board and University of Oslo.
Visioning: Towards a new initiative on Earth system research for global sustainability research Prof. Deliang CHEN, ICSU Executive Director.
Research with CSOs for Sustainable Development : Reflecting on experience Introduction to workshop Les Levidow.
AWARE How to achieve sustainable water ecosystems management connecting research, people and policy makers in Europe Kick-off meeting Rome 4 – 5 June 2009.
Division of Technology, Industry, and Economics Economics and Trade Branch Incorporating Biodiversity into Trade-Related Integrated Assessments Presentation.
Kasper Kok Session 14.3 – Panel on: Scaling in Integrated Assessment.
A coordinated approach to water in Europe Harro Riedstra, EWP.
Steve Morgan Associate Director for Research, Training and Development Hewlett Foundation/Population Reference Bureau Conference; London
Waisea Vosa Climate Change Unit Division of Political and Treaties Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation.
Education for Sustainable Development in European Higher Education Jos H.A.N. Rikers (OUNL) Geert R. de Snoo (Leiden University) Rietje C.E. van Dam-Mieras.
Innovative and effective approaches to climate change: Experiences from the Global Climate Change Alliance Brussels 12 th -14 th September 2012 Mainstreaming.
ISSUES & CHALLENGES Adaptation, translation, and global application DiClemente, Crosby, & Kegler, 2009.
Effective Stakeholder Engagement in Resource Management Author: Dr. Jonathan Rosenberg Delivered by: Jim Powell.
Evaluation for Social Justice AMY HILGENDORF, PHD KATE WESTABY, MS VICTORIA FAUST, MPA UNIVERSITY OF WISCONSIN-MADISON American Evaluation Association.
UNGGIM – PRIVATE SECTOR NETWORK. AGENDA > OVERVIEW OF PRIVATE SECTOR >PURPOSE AND VISION OF PRIVATE SECTOR NETWORK > STRUCTURE AND TERMS OF REFERENCE.
Future Earth Research for Global Sustainability photos:
The WHY, WHAT and HOW of FECOASTS
Socio-ecological systems & SESYNC
Participatory Action-research and the use of citizen science in promoting effective climate adaptation actions Filipe Moreira Alves Centre for Climate.
Computing Research for Sustainability
Support Sustainable Research through a
Energy and Sustainability Science: What have we learned. William C
The GEO-6 Matrix Drafting Approach
Production Engineering Department
Participatory Scenario Development and Sustainable Water Policies
Background to the Regional Workshop
Launch of Towards 2020 GWP Strategy.
Governance innovation : unlocking ICT potential
Global and local: Science for policy and the role of networks
Merlijn van Rijswijk, Marcel Kleijn et al
Sustainable Development- A Context & Direction
Division for Social Impact
SusCatt Increasing productivity, resource efficiency and product quality to increase the economic competitiveness of forage and grazing based cattle.
Merlijn van Rijswijk, Marcel Kleijn et al
Presentation transcript:

Sustainability Science: What it is and what it’s not J. David Tàbara, Congrés UPC Sostenible 2015 Barcelona, 10 July

See: Clark, W. C. P. J. Crutzen, & H. J. Schellnhuber, Science for Global Sustainability: Toward a New Paradigm. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Chapter 1. Available at : mitpress.mit.edu/books/chapters/ chap1.pdf

FIRST BOOK ON SUSTAINABIILTY SCIENCE: Kasemir, B.; J. Jäger; & C. Jaeger, M. T. Gardner, M.T. (Eds) Public Participation in Sustainability Science. A handbook. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Kasemir, B.; J. Jäger; & C. Jaeger, M. T. Gardner, M.T. (Eds) Public Participation in Sustainability Science. A handbook. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Available in Catalan for educational non-commercial purposes at:

RECOMMENDED READING: Jäger, Jill The Governance of science for sustainability. In: W. Neil Adger and A. Jordan. Governing Sustainability. Cambrigde: Cambridge University Press.

Personal CO2 calculator....

The Ulysses collages INTEGRATING MULTIPLES LANGUAGES AND KNOWLEDGE REPRESENTATIONS: The future of the Metropolitan Area of Barcelona in 2050 if we continue with the same trends in the consumption of energy and resources as we have done so far…

The Matisse project: Integrated Sustainability Assessment. To explicitly address issues of transition and power in a multi-level, multi-domain, integrated and participatory manner and to explore multiple solution interdependencies.

Traditional Science versus Sustainability Science (adapted from Roger Kasperson) TRADITIONAL SCIENCE Curiosity-driven Value free Divide and conquer No direct policy user Reduce and eliminate the rest Expert / corporate dominated Profit /prestige seeking Linear evolution of knowledge Product focused (paper, patent, …) SUSTAINABILITY SCIENCE Problem-driven; problem-solving Value inclusive Integrate and be open Potential users included Systemic, complex system based Extended peer-reviewed Socially relevant Non-linear evolution of knowledge Place-based analysis Process focused, capacity building

SOME CHALLENGES FOR SUSTAINABILITY SCIENCE

Linking global social-ecological systems (SES) systems thinking and LOCAL practice. Linking global social-ecological systems (SES) systems thinking and LOCAL practice. Focus on INTERACTIONS between social- ecological systems. Focus on INTERACTIONS between social- ecological systems. Assess impacts and consequences of science and technology innovations and products in social-ecological STOCKS AND FLOWS. Assess changes in sustainability base. Assess impacts and consequences of science and technology innovations and products in social-ecological STOCKS AND FLOWS. Assess changes in sustainability base. Consider global and regional LIMITS to resource use, beyond ecoefficiency, to avoid rebound effects. Consider global and regional LIMITS to resource use, beyond ecoefficiency, to avoid rebound effects. 1. ‘THINK GLOBALLY, RESEARCH LOCALLY’

2. DEMOCRATISING ‘REAL’ SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY PRACTICES. Engaging society to support sustainability transformations. The real challenge of sustainability is one of democracy, equity and responsibility. The real challenge of sustainability is one of democracy, equity and responsibility.  Sustainability science won’t be possible unless it can contribute to the real democratisation of science and technology practices and decisions.  Contribute to a more equal access of resource use decisions and resource appropriation institutions.  It demands the engagement of many constituencies and building of new partnerships, based on new opportunities to reduce inequality, increase cooperation and improve welfare.

3. SOCIAL LEARNING: Continuous reframing of goals and means Constant questioning of the ultimate goals of science and technology, and their societal functions. Avoid the fiction of ‘science without context’. Consider the possibilities of sustainability learning in powerful institutions and organisations. Go beyond thinking science and technology in terms of problem-solutions and start framing knowledge practices as part of social-ecological systems PROCESSES AND FEEDBACKS. INTEGRATION is the main source of learning, but not only between different scientific disciplines (‘risky integration, e.g. ciber-biology) but between science and the real problems and needs.

We need to move from thinking about ‘what is the (persistent) problem’ but who is the (persistent) problem… To assign responsibilities, ownership and transformative capacities to agents in a relational way. And from not knowing the solution before knowing the problems… (e.g. mainstream economics, some technologies…). All should be placed in particular SES conditions. New integrated framings: avoid false dualisms (e.g. between nature and society) and ‘ecological exemptionalism’. 4. Help framing problems differently

GOVERNING SCIENCE TO SUPPORT SUSTAINABILITY SCIENCE The governance of science is necessary to ensure the sustainability of science. Governance entails action and engagement beyond the traditional boundaries of science. Sustainability science should help assessing not only vulnerabilities but also new opportunities for (sustainable) development. Sustainability science is not necessary a threat to mainstream science, but only to those practices of science which do actually contribute to unsustainability. Sustainability science is a necessary complement to mainstream science, because it builds on it and needs it too.

Selected references: Kates, R. W., W. C. Clark, et al ‘Sustainability Science’. Science, 292: Clark, W. C. P. J. Crutzen, & H. J. Schellnhuber, Science for Global Sustainability: Toward a New Paradigm. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Kasemir, B.; J. Jäger; & C. Jaeger, M. T. Gardner, M.T. (Eds) Public Participation in Sustainability Science. A Handbook. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Catalan translation for educational purposes only: secciogeografia/mediambient/cat/projecteMUGA/resultats/capitols/default.htm Jäger, J The Governance of science for sustainability. In: W. Neil Adger and A. Jordan. Governing Sustainability. Cambrigde: Cambridge University Press. Tàbara, J. D. and C. Pahl-Wostl Sustainability Learning in Natural Resource Use and Management. Ecology and Society, 12 (2): 3. [online] URL: Tàbara, J. D ‘Una altra ciència és possible. La sostenibilogia en la societat del desconeixement’. Revista Àmbits, Tàbara, J. D (2003). 'Participatory Sustainability Assessment using computer models'. In P. Valkering, Amelung, B., Van der Brugge, R., & J. Rotmans. More puzzle Solving For Policy. Integrated Assessment from Theory to Practice. The Netherlands: International Institute of Integrative Studies - European Forum for Integrated Environmental Assessment. Maastricht: ICIS. ttp://