Radical Cystectomy As Early Primary Therapy for T1G3 Bladder Cancer Karim Touijer and Bernard H. Bochner. Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center
T1G3 Bladder Cancer “THE FACTS” Is a potentially lethal tumorIs a potentially lethal tumor This is NOT a superficial tumorThis is NOT a superficial tumor Understaging occurs frequentlyUnderstaging occurs frequently High recurrence rate and progression despite intravesical therapyHigh recurrence rate and progression despite intravesical therapy Poor markers available to accurately identify high risk lesionsPoor markers available to accurately identify high risk lesions Can be effectively CURED by early definitive surgery (radical cystectomy)Can be effectively CURED by early definitive surgery (radical cystectomy)
BLADDER CANCER: TWO PATHWAYS OF PROGRESSION NORMAL UROTHELIUM Ta 9qDel RAS T1T2-4 N+/M+ 9pDel (INK4A) (Presti et al, Ca Res 91; Cordon-Cardo et al, JNCI 92; Dalbagni et al, Lancet 93; Sarkis et al, JNCI 93; Cairns et al, Science 94; Orlow et al, JNCI 95; Li et al, Am J Path 96; Rabbani et al, JNCI 99; McShane et al, Ca Res 2000; Hernando et al, Int J Ca 2001; Sanchez et al, Ca Res, 2002; Veltman et al Ca Res, 2003 ) Tis T1T2-4 N+/M+ TP53 RB 5qDel, 3pDel 10qDel, 11pDel, 18qDel 14qDel
T1G3 Bladder Cancer Can we accurately detect this disease? Are we at risk for understaging?
T1G3 And TIS Bladder Cancer Clinical Understaging Author P stage > T1 Amling (Duke), % Soloway (Florida) % (60% for Tis) Stein (USC) % % have positive nodes at cystectomy
Risk Of Understaging Is Influenced By Presence Of Muscle In TUR Specimen Dutta, J Urol 166:490, 2001 N=78 Herr, HW J Urol 162:74, 1999 A second TURBT required to identify extent of disease.
T1G3 Bladder Cancer Outcome Of Understaged Patients Disease Specific Outcomes Freeman et al, Cancer, patients (71% with T1 tumors) 53% failed intravesical therapy Understaged lesions do significantly worse Understaged lesions WILL NOT respond to bladder sparing approaches
Repeat TURBT May Help Reduce Understaging Dalbagni et al, UROLOGY 2002
T1G3 Bladder Cancer Natural History Recurrence and Progression Risk Recurrence RiskRecurrence Risk –Following TURBT, 69-80% risk of recurrence –Intravesical immunotherapy can delay recurrence and progression, but long-term will not alter natural history Progression RiskProgression Risk –33-50% will progress to muscle invasion
Can BCG Impact Ultimate Cancer- Specific Survival
BCG Can Delay Recurrence But May Not Impact Ultimate Cancer- specific Survival Recurrence-free survivalCancer-specific survival Orsola et al Eur Urol 48:231, 2005
T1G3 Bladder Cancer Long-term Results With BCG Cookson, J Urol 158:62, 1997 Pansodoro, Urology 59:227, 2002 Shahin, J Urol 169:96, 2003 Study # pts Med. F/u ProgressionCystectomy DOD DOD Cookson yrs 53% 53% 36% 36% 34% 34% Pansodoro yrs 15% 15% 8.6% 8.6% 6% 6% Shahin yrs 30 % 30 % 29% 29% 23% 23%
T1G3 Bladder Cancer Long-Term Outcome Conservative BCG and Progression of Disease patients with high risk non-muscle invasive disease (36 patients T1) patients with high risk non-muscle invasive disease (36 patients T1) Randomized to TURBT +/- BCGRandomized to TURBT +/- BCG Followed q3-6 months for 3 years then annuallyFollowed q3-6 months for 3 years then annually Evaluated progression and disease specific survivalEvaluated progression and disease specific survival
T1G3 Bladder Cancer Long-Term Outcome Conservative BCG and Progression of Disease
T1G3 Bladder Cancer Long-Term Outcome Conservative Disease Specific Survival Cookson J Urol 158:62, 1997 People not treated by cystectomy continue to die of bladder cancer!
T1G3 Bladder Cancer Long-Term Outcome Conservative Disease Specific Outcomes
T1 Bladder Cancer Characteristics Associated with Recurrence and Progression PathologicPathologic –High grade, multifocality, associated CIS, prostatic urethral involvement, size, sessile growth pattern, (Others unreliable and controversial: aneuplody, p53 alteration, lymphovascular invasion) ClinicalClinical –Failure of intravesical therapy (80% with disease at 3 months progress), endoscopically uncontrollable disease, disease within diverticuli MAJORITY