Ethnography & Photography: issues in theorizing photography Zoe Leonard as a case study SM4134 Visual Ethngoraphy & Creative Intervention Dr. Linda C.H.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Literary Response – Sec. 5 Guiding Question Childrens Rights: Attainable Goal or Wishful Thinking?
Advertisements

Definition: The arrangement of elements within a frame
Bell's Theory of Art Bell’s requirements for constructing a Theory of Art The ability to think clearly. The possession of an artistic sensibility. (the.
Team Task Choose 1 Progression to READ: Number and Operations--Fractions Ratios and Proportional Relationships Develop “Content” Knowledge.
Macro Photography Close-up Macro photography is the art of taking close-up pictures that reveal details which can’t be seen with the naked eye. For example,
Interaktionsdesign Session 3 Etnografisk tilgang til kontekst.
Ethnographic Research
Film Art and Culture 2009 Culture and Identity 28 February 2009.
Defining and controlling the space of the frame Aspect ratio Masking Camera placement Focus Perspective Mobile framing.
Foundations This chapter lays down the fundamental ideas and choices on which our approach is based. First, it identifies the needs of architects in the.
 Derives from Greek words meaning Love of Wisdom.
Pengukuran Opini Publik. Survey Research Survey research is a technique that well designed for assessing the prevalence and distribution of attitudes,
Chapter 17 Ethnographic Research Gay, Mills, and Airasian
Introduction to Art Part One: What is Art? Part Two: Art Criticism and Aesthetic Judgment Part Three: Aesthetic Theories.
On Roles of Models in Information Systems (Arne Sølvberg) Gustavo Carvalho 26 de Agosto de 2010.
Disciplines of the Humanities Arts Disciplines Visual art- drawing, painting, printmaking, sculpture, photography Performing art- music, theatre, dance,
An Introduction to Visual Analysis Katy Gregg & Desiree Paulin Seponski QUAL 8420 March 26, 2009.
Qualitative Research.
Shot Types …common types of shots, framing and picture composition.
Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment
University of Durham D Dr Robert Coe University of Durham School of Education Tel: (+44 / 0) Fax: (+44 / 0)
Evidence Based Practice (EBP) For Physical Therapists.
Mr. Green ANALYZING ART.  Responding to, interpreting meaning, and making critical judgments about specific works of art  Art critics help viewers perceive,
Subjectivity, Positionality, and Reflexivity Just a few thoughts. We need to keep coming back to this.
CHAPTER 1 Aesthetic Experience Where does art come from? -Unique to humans -Urge to create: 1. meaning and form 2. structure in our world so it reflects.
© Jody Walker, Eva R. Brumberger. Background Report: Visual Rhetoric Document design. Visual Rhetoric.
LOGIC AND ONTOLOGY Both logic and ontology are important areas of philosophy covering large, diverse, and active research projects. These two areas overlap.
Photography Composition. What is Composition? The arrangement of visual elements within the frame of a photograph.
Photography The Basics. Snapshots vs. Photographs Snapshot Memories What the subject is Point and click Photographs Artistic interpretation of a thing.
INTRODUCTION: REVIEW. What is Art?  Form of expression with aesthetic  Organize perception  A work of art is the visual expression of an idea or experience.
WHAT IS THE NATURE OF SCIENCE?. SCIENTIFIC WORLD VIEW 1.The Universe Is Understandable. 2.The Universe Is a Vast Single System In Which the Basic Rules.
Media Literacy. Purpose To gain an understanding for the role that media plays in our lives To be able to analyze various forms of media text To make.
Module 4 Review The Elements of Composition. Important Definitions What is focus? What is focus? –When an image is clear –Press the shutter release halfway.
In Written Texts and Screens.  Make a list of dominant images in the novel  Categorize the images into binary opposites.
Qualitative Research EDUC 7741/Paris/Terry.
INFO 414 Information Behavior Theoretical foundations, frameworks and paradigms.
Ch 10 Methodology.
Design Basics. Introduction to Design de-sign 1. To prepare the preliminary sketch or the plans for (a work to be executed) esp. to plan the form and.
Research for Nurses: Methods and Interpretation Chapter 1 What is research? What is nursing research? What are the goals of Nursing research?
Social Research and the Internet Welcome to the Second Part of this Course! My name is Maria Bakardjieva.
Lecture №1 Role of science in modern society. Role of science in modern society.
Constructivism: The Social Construction of International Politics POL 3080 Approaches to IR.
Discuss how researchers analyze data obtained in observational research.
What is Postmodernism? A complicated term A set of ideas emerged as an area of academic study since the mid-1980s It is hard to define it is a concept.
ABRA Week 3 research design, methods… SS. Research Design and Method.
PHOTOJOURNALISM Letizia Battaglia “Franco Zecchin” 1987 Steve McCurry “Afghan Girl” 1984.
Is a Picture Worth a Thousand Words? Engaging with Visual Culture.
Grounded theory, discourse analysis and hermeneutics Part Two – Discourse Analysis ERPM001 Interpretive Methodologies Dr Alexandra Allan.
Composition & Elements of Art and Principles of Design A artists toolbox.
Environment Photography. Introduction The topic I have decided to do is Environment. I have chosen this topic because I find it would be an interesting.
Creative Photography 2013 Artist Statements. For me, the creation of art is a process of capturing the passion and inspiration of my life. Photographs.
Visual Adjectives for Movies. Set up each shot to create emphasis on something in the frame. Use these to create mood, feeling, convey an idea, highlight.
Theoretical Framework Do you have a theoretical framework to guide your research?
WHAT IS THE NATURE OF SCIENCE?
Placement of the subject - Composition
EDUCATIONAL & CURRICULUM Philosophy
Photography for Charcoal Portrait Reference
Composition & Elements of Art and Principles of Design
Ambiguities & epistemology (ways to know and produce knowledge): documentary as organized ethnographic texts SM6324 Dr. Linda C.H. LAI.
Miss Scherger Visual Communication Design Horsham College
© LOUIS COHEN, LAWRENCE MANION AND KEITH MORRISON
Understanding Early Photography II
The Aesthetic Experience
RESEARCH BASICS What is research?.
Creating-1: Generate and conceptualize artistic ideas and work.
Data Collection technologies
What is qualitative research?
Wrt 105: practices of academic writing
Assessment Objectives...
Presentation transcript:

Ethnography & Photography: issues in theorizing photography Zoe Leonard as a case study SM4134 Visual Ethngoraphy & Creative Intervention Dr. Linda C.H. Lai February 2009

Ethnography: field visits, before and after 1)Initial frame 2)Collecting data* 3)Coding 4)Frame 5)Interpretation: text – subtext the interpretive circles

Three widespread views in the discussion of photography 1)The photographic process is, in some sense, automatic. Mechanical, mind-independent, agent-less, natural, causal, physical… 2)The resultant images are, in some sense, realistic. Authentic, faithful, objective, truthful, accurate… 3) The realism of photographs, in some sense, depends on the automatism of the photographic process. Diarmuid Costello and Dawn M. Phillips, “Automatism, Causality and Realism: Foundational Problems in the Philosophy of Photography,” in Philosophy Compass

What are existing theories of photography mainly about? (1)Epistemic Vs Aesthetic debates Epistemology concerns how knowledge is produced. The epistemic issues of photography often raise questions about what kinds of truth a photograph produce… Aesthetic issues concern the perceptual and formal aspects of photography. The epistemic and the aesthetic cannot be separated. In the case of photography, they always work together, whether in the case of the researcher, or the user.

What are existing theories of photography mainly about? (2) Medium-specific approach  Essentialist view of photography: focusing on the photographic medium alone “A medium-specific approach assumes that the material means of production supply the necessary and sufficient conditions that are definitive of photographs.” (p. 3) Vs theories of photography that supposes some conception of their object. Usage / Wittgenstein…there is no particular essential features common to all photographs… “Photograph is a family resemblance concept.”

Family resemblance? Photography is a human activity by which the making of the photograph facilitates the recall / retrieval / re-association / connection… of/with what already exists for a particular purpose.

Using photography in qualitative research The use of still photographs as a methodological tool The use of still photographs as a means of presenting social research. The use of photography as a research method. **This requires a theory of how pictures get used by both picture makers and viewers.” // data, data-generators, treatment of how viewers, informants or researchers treat and understand photographic images. Dona Schwartz, “Visual Ethnography: using photography in qualitative research,” Qualitative Sociology, 12(2), Summer 1989.

(Unique properties of) photographic articulation Interpretation and use Ambiguities of photographic imagery Dona Schwartz

Photography as a social transaction A photograph as art [photographer-artist] [photographer is “source.”] A photograph as a precise machine-made record of a subject [accuracy] [subject of photograph is source] PROBLEM WITH THE ABOVE DISTINCTION: 1. “Photographic meaning is conceptualized as being contained within the image itself.”

PROBLEM WITH THE ABOVE DISTINCTION: art Vs record “Photographic meaning is conceptualized as being contained within the image itself.” i.e. The photograph is a “receptacle” (artist, subject) that generates different possible meanings 2.Spectator is missing in the process of constructing photographic meaning Consider, for example, Roland Barthes’ idea of “punctum” and “studium” (See his work “Camera Lucida: Reflections on Photography.”) “studium” = the cultural, linguistic and political interpretation of a photo “punctum” = personally touching details grounded in relationship 3. Usage

An artist’s ethnography via photography: Zoe Leonard “I see, I photograph.” “I am showing you what I have seen and photographed, and not what I have invented.” “That is how it is.” Documentary mode of photography…?

Can a photograph be an objective document? From a visual ethnographer’s POV… the intention of making objective document is an observable trait i.e. a documentary mode is an observable fact, an observable intention We can look at a photograph’s framing and other observable facts of production. i.e. the documentary intention of a work is the subtext of a photograph.

However, one must not turn “perceivable intention” into an absolute rule.

The photographer-researcher is interpreting… The meaning of a photograph has to be understood in terms of focus and context. The usual visual grammar of photography has to be reconsidered… Does a wide shot necessarily contain more details than a tight shot? -A wide shot may not mean an emphasis on background environment. (For example, a photograph with a wide shot of a highway may well be calling attention to an empty highway as a focus.) -A tight shot (a close-up) of an object does not necessarily mean a focus on the object itself; it could be calling attention to the fine texture.

Zoe Leonard, the ethnographer This emphasizes ethnography as a path of discovery… + an artistic practice that highlights discovery over pure assertion of the artist’s belief “Zoe Leonard follows the traces and scars of the world in order to understand the structures of the world, to comprehend the essence of past and present, space and time, existential and social relativity.”

What to do with a photograph…the interpretive circles 5 Ws (basic observable content) Composition and facts of production (aesthetic side) Composition and facts of production (interpretive side) Use (usage) – audience, maker The optical unconscious ***change of frames