“Crazy for You” Cast Album (1992); Music & Lyrics by George & Ira Gershwin (1918-37) Now Online: –Slides from Wednesday –New Assignment Sheet If you are.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The Essential Louis Armstrong: Disc 1 (Recordings ) LUNCH 12:05 1. Allen 2. Bhimani 3. Chung 4. Massey 5. McGivern 6. Olsen 7. Retenauer.
Advertisements

“Romantic Russia”, London Symphony Orchestra (recorded 1956, 1966) Music: Mid- to Late 19 th Century UNIT II: EXTENSION BY ANALOGY (WHALING CASES)
When might conforming to custom be a bad idea? (Includes…)
Mr. Marquina Somerset Silver Palms Civics
MUSIC: Paul Winter Canyon (1985) STATUS OF GRADING: Practice Midterms: Ready for Pick-Up Next: Assignment #1 Target Date: Nov. 6.
MUSIC: MAX BRUCH Violin Concerto #1 (1868) Scottish Fantasy (1880) Royal Philharmonic Orchestra (Recording 1972) Rudolf Kempe, Conductor * Kyung Wa Chung,
Pictures at AN Exhibition Music (for Piano) by Modest Moussorsky (1874) Orchestration by Maurice Ravel (1922) Recording by Cleveland Orchestra (1979) Lorin.
Stan Getz & The Oscar Peterson Trio (Recorded 1957) Stan Getz, Tenor Sax * Oscar Peterson, Piano Herb Ellis, Guitar * Ray Brown, Bass Please Place Takings.
MUSIC: “Crazy for You” Cast Album (1992) Music & Lyrics by George & Ira Gershwin ( ) §B Lunch Wed Oct 1 Meet on 12:15 Bautz * Fierro Golden*
1 Streamlined Sales Tax Governing Board. The Marketplace Fairness Act of 2015(MFA) Grants state and local jurisdictions the right to require the collection.
MUSIC: ERIK SATIE OEUVRES POUR PIANO ( ) Aldo Ciccolini, Piano ( Recordings: Disc 2) Briefs Due Before Fall Break: KRYPTON: Albers Brief.
MUSIC: Gilbert & Sullivan PIRATES OF PENZANCE (1879) Welsh National Opera Charles Mackerras, Conductor Recording: 1993.
MY DOGS ARE FOUND MY DOGS ARE FOUND Tchaikovsky, Symphony #4 (1880) Berlin Philharmonic (von Karajan 1977) LUNCH 12:05 1. Daley 2. Fasano 3. Figueroa.
Ludwig van Beethoven Symphony #3 “Eroica” (1804) Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra Karl Bohm, Conductor Recorded 1972.
Music: The Beatles: Magical Mystery Tour (1967). Two Percolating Concerns This Class is Fine BUT : 1.Does any of this really matter? 2.I don’t know what.
ELEMENTS B POWER POINT SLIDES Class #14 (Extendo-Class) Friday, September 25, 2015.
MUSIC: THE MAMAS & THE PAPAS, 16 of Their Greatest Hits ( ) ***************************** UPCOMING LUNCHES: MEET ON 12:05 B1 TODAY Bianchi.
The Last Word: Assignment 8 for Friday; Federalist questions for Friday.
Tchaikovsky, Symphony #4 (1880) “Capriccio Italien” Berlin Philharmonic (1977) Conductor: Von Karajan.
“Romantic Russia” London Symphony Orchestra (recorded 1956, 1966) Music: Mid- to Late 19 th Century Oxygen Brief #1: Available for Pick-Up Krypton Brief.
Music: Schumann, Piano Concerto in A Minor (1949) Grieg, Piano Concerto in A Minor (1872) Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra (2004) Conductor: Sir Colin.
Applying Legal Rule /Test 1.Look for best arguments for each party –Be Cognizant of Structure of Test –Use Care w Language –Utilize Definitions 2.If significant.
The Essential Louis Armstrong: Disc 1 (Recordings ) §B Lunch Tue Sep 30 Meet at SAC Law Room after Torts Del Rivero * Forzisi Perez * Sanseverino.
MUSIC: ISAAC ALBENIZ WORKS FOR PIANO ( ) Alicia de Larrocha, Piano (Recordings1959, 1992) Dean’s Fellow Sessions This Week: Review Problem 2F (p.
MUSIC: CLAUDE DEBUSSY, Afternoon of a Faun (1894); Nocturnes (1900); The Sea (1905) ORCHESTRE de la Suisse Romande (1988/1990) conductOR: ARMIN JORDAN.
ELEMENTS B POWER POINT SLIDES Class #17 (Extendo-Class) Friday, October 2, 2015.
MUSIC: Tchaikovsky Symphony #4 (1880) Berlin Philharmonic (2003) Conductor: Von Karajan §B Lunch Wed Sep 17 Meet on 12:15 Centurion * P.Comparato.
MUSIC: “Crazy for You” Cast Album (1992); Music & Lyrics by George & Ira Gershwin ( ) If you are taking Elements exam Friday: – Look at Info Memo.
NEON & HELIUM: Put Taber & Bartlett Briefs Face Down in Box on Front Table MUSIC: Ray Charles & Friends Genius Loves Company (Duets 2004) DOG = KATIE (15)
ELEMENTS B POWER POINT SLIDES Class #15 Monday, September 28, 2015.
MUSIC: Gilbert & Sullivan PIRATES OF PENZANCE (1879) Welsh National Opera Charles Mackerras, Conductor Recording: 1993 NEXT WEEK Mon & Tues: Regular Schedule.
MUSIC: ERIK SATIE OEUVRES POUR PIANO ( ) Aldo Ciccolini, Piano ( Disc 2: Recordings ) Tue Sep 23 (Today): Office Hours Cancelled Wed Sep.
Pictures at AN Exhibition Music (for Piano) by Modest Moussorsky (1874) Orchestration by Maurice Ravel (1922) Recording by Cleveland Orchestra (1979) Lorin.
ELEMENTS B POWER POINT SLIDES Class #16 Wednesday, September 30, 2015.
Music: Beethoven, Piano Sonata #23 (Appassionata) (1805) Performer: Emil Giles, Piano (1972) LUNCH TUESDAY 1. FOXHOVEN 2. GALLO 3. KINZER 4. MELIA 5. RAINES.
Transaction Costs Can Prevent Parties from Reaching Bargains that are “Efficient” (= Would Make Everyone Better Off)
MUSIC: THERE WILL BE BLOOD Movie Soundtrack (2007) Music by Jonny Greenwood Trey’s Monday DF Sessions Moving to 9:30-10:20 am Room F200 Fajer’s.
ELEMENTS B POWER POINT SLIDES Class #23 Friday, October 23, 2015 National Boston Cream Pie Day.
Music: The Beatles, Magical Mystery Tour (1967) (on one speaker  ) Written Briefs Due: HELIUM : Monday 9/15 (Mullett) CHLORINE : Wednesday 9/17 (Manning)
ELEMENTS B POWER POINT SLIDES Class #11 Wednesday, September 16, 2015.
Unit 3 Chapter 3, Section 1 Structure and Principles Mr. Young Government.
MUSIC: Paul Winter Canyon (1985). LOGISTICS Lessons from Assignment #1 Follow Directions!!! Accuracy with Facts Accuracy with Cases Explain/Defend Conclusions.
ELEMENTS B POWER POINT SLIDES Class #18 Monday, October 12, 2015.
Music: The Beatles: Magical Mystery Tour (1967) Lunch & Office Hours Today Cancelled; I’ll lunchers about rescheduling Lunch Tomorrow 12:25.
ELEMENTS B POWER POINT SLIDES Class #13 Monday, September 21, 2015.
Class #26 Monday, November 2, 2015 National Deviled Egg Day ELEMENTS B POWER POINT SLIDES.
Music: The Mamas and the Papas: Greatest Hits ( ) Aluminum: Mullett Briefs Face Down on Table Updated Assignment Sheet Posted Radium: Manning Briefs.
MUSIC: Beethoven Symphony No. 3 (1804) Performed by Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra (1972)
Comments on Epstein “Possession as Root of Title” Nick Parker Econ 594ER October 29, 2007.
ELEMENTS B POWER POINT SLIDES Class #19 Wednesday, October 12, 2015.
The Essential Louis Armstrong: Disc 1 (Recordings ) B1 LUNCH 12:05 1.Guerrazzi 2. Mottin-Berger B2 LUNCH 12:05 1. Binko 2. Burns.
T.G.I. FRIDAY OCTOBER 9 MUSIC: Max Bruch Violin Concerto #1 (1868) Scottish Fantasy (1880) RECORDING (1972): Royal Philharmonic Orchestra Rudolf Kempe,
ELEMENTS B1 & B2 POWER POINT SLIDES Class #20 Monday, October 10, 2016 Tuesday, October 11, 2016.
ELEMENTS B1 & B2 POWER POINT SLIDES
Bell Ringer – if you were not here last class, don’t ask me questions…. RQ #7 – STUDY!
ELEMENTS B1 & B2 POWER POINT SLIDES
ELEMENTS B1 & B2 POWER POINT SLIDES
ELEMENTS B1 & B2 POWER POINT SLIDES
ELEMENTS D2 & D1 POWER POINT SLIDES
ELEMENTS D2 & D POWER POINT SLIDES
CHLORINES: Place Swift Briefs Face Down in Box on Front Table
ELEMENTS D2 & D1 POWER POINT SLIDES
ELEMENTS D2 & D1 POWER POINT SLIDES
ELEMENTS D2 & D1 POWER POINT SLIDES
ELEMENTS D2 & D1 POWER POINT SLIDES
ALUMINUM: Written Swift Brief Due Wed
ELEMENTS D2 & D1 POWER POINT SLIDES
ELEMENTS B1 & B2 POWER POINT SLIDES
Introduction to the Federal Courts
MUSIC: The Percussive Rhythm of (GEORGE HERBERT) WALKER
Presentation transcript:

“Crazy for You” Cast Album (1992); Music & Lyrics by George & Ira Gershwin ( ) Now Online: –Slides from Wednesday –New Assignment Sheet If you are taking my exam Sunday: –Look at Info Memo #3 –Office Hours 2-6 p.m. Tomorrow

UNIT II: EXTENSION BY ANALOGY § A. WHALING CASES

INTRODUCTION TO WHALING Admiralty Actions in Federal Court –Alleged torts took place on navigable waters –Fed’l gov’t has exclusive jurisdiction over maritime commerce (need for uniformity) –D.Mass. = United States District Court for the District of Massachusetts

INTRODUCTION TO WHALING Admiralty Actions in Federal Court Ships v. Boats

INTRODUCTION TO WHALING Admiralty Actions in Federal Court Ships v. Boats Okhotsk Sea –Spelled differently in different cases

INTRODUCTION TO WHALING Admiralty Actions in Federal Court Ships v. Boats Okhotsk Sea –Spelled differently in different cases –Trip from New England (Around the Horn)

INTRODUCTION TO WHALING Admiralty Actions in Federal Court Ships v. Boats Okhotsk Sea Value of Whales (Considerable): –Whale Oil (used as energy source) –Whalebone (used in corsets) –Ambergris (used in perfume) –Meat (for crew)

THE LOGIC OF ALBERS 1.DOMESTICATED OR WILD 2.ADDRESSING PRIOR AUTHORITY 3.WHAT THE CASE HOLDS 4.CRITIQUE

THE LOGIC OF ALBERS: ADDRESSING PRIOR AUTHORITY DQ52b (ZINC): Colo. Statute: The common law of England, so far as the same is applicable and of a general nature shall be the rule of decision, and shall be considered as of full force until repealed by legislative authority. What argument did D make relying on this?

THE LOGIC OF ALBERS: ADDRESSING PRIOR AUTHORITY DQ52b (ZINC): Colo. Statute: The common law of England, so far as the same is applicable and of a general nature shall be the rule of decision, and shall be considered as of full force until repealed by legislative authority. What argument did D make relying on this? Why did the court reject this argument?

THE LOGIC OF ALBERS 1.DOMESTICATED OR WILD 2.ADDRESSING PRIOR AUTHORITY 3.WHAT THE CASE HOLDS 4.CRITIQUE

THE LOGIC OF ALBERS: WHAT THE CASE HOLDS Mullett rule inapplicable because of changed circumstances (development of fox fur industry)

THE LOGIC OF ALBERS: WHAT THE CASE HOLDS Instead, court says original owner wins where … [Manning-like list but even more facts]

THE LOGIC OF ALBERS: WHAT THE CASE HOLDS Original owner wins where fox … “had been held in captivity, semi-domesticated, escaped by accident, fled against the will of his owner, and pursuit was abandoned by compulsion.” PLUS ….

THE LOGIC OF ALBERS: WHAT THE CASE HOLDS D “had, or is charged with, knowledge that: the pelt purchased was the product of a vast, legitimate, and generally known industry it had a considerable/easily ascertainable value that it bore the indicia of ownership it had been taken in an unusual way; the seller was not the owner; PLUS …

THE LOGIC OF ALBERS: WHAT THE CASE HOLDS D “had, or is charged with, knowledge that”: no right of innocent purchasers had intervened; & it was from an animal taken –in a locality where its kind ferae naturae was unknown; and –in a state where large numbers were kept in captivity.”

THE LOGIC OF ALBERS: WHAT THE CASE HOLDS CALCIUM DQ53: Factors that Albers treats as relevant that are not explicitly part of the analysis in Manning or Mullett?

THE LOGIC OF ALBERS: WHAT THE CASE HOLDS CALCIUM DQ53: Factors that Albers treats as relevant that are not explicitly part of the analysis in Manning or Mullett? Industry/Investment (focus of discussion of why Mullett inapplicable) Finder’s Knowledge (focus of penultimate paragraph: grizzly bear in NY; elephant in cornfield; seal in millpond)

THE LOGIC OF ALBERS: WHAT THE CASE HOLDS CALCIUM DQ53: To Articulate Rule in Albers, Helpful to Note Dual Focus: 1.acts of owner: investment, protection, animus rev., pursuit 2. likely knowledge of finder : nat’l liberty 3.both: taming, marking I’ll Send Requests to Some Calciums to Send Me Sample Rules

THE LOGIC OF ALBERS 1.DOMESTICATED OR WILD 2.ADDRESSING PRIOR AUTHORITY 3.WHAT THE CASE HOLDS 4.CRITIQUE

THE LOGIC OF ALBERS: CRITIQUE DQ54 (Calcium): Authority of Col. S. Ct. 1.Court here essentially: a. carved out exception to the Mullett rule b. to meet perceived policy need. 2. Alternative (as in Ontario): a. Court applies existing rule b. Legislature responds by enacting new statute modifying rule to meet policy need.

THE LOGIC OF ALBERS: CRITIQUE DQ54 (Calcium): Authority of Col. S. Ct. Pros/cons of allowing courts to alter/develop law (as in Albers) v. legislature (as in Ontario)? –Relative institutional strengths? –Democratic theory? –Certainty/notice?

THE LOGIC OF ALBERS: CRITIQUE DQ54 (Calcium): Authority of Col. S. Ct. p.42: Having then neither statute nor applicable common-law rule governing the case, we must so apply general principles in the light of custom, existing facts, and common knowledge, that justice will be done. So the courts of England and the United States have acted from time immemorial, and so the common law itself came into existence.

THE LOGIC OF ALBERS: CRITIQUE DQ55 (Calcium): Demsetz 1 st Theory Decision: Finder’s Choice: Keep found animal v. Look for original owner (OO) Old Rule: Mullett/ Blackstone Rule Externalities?

THE LOGIC OF ALBERS: CRITIQUE DQ55 (Calcium): Demsetz 1 st Theory Decision: Finder’s Choice: Keep found animal v. Look for original owner (OO) Old Rule: Mullett/ Blackstone Rule Externalities? OO Losses (Investment; Affection) Change in Circumstances?

THE LOGIC OF ALBERS: CRITIQUE DQ55 (Calcium): Demsetz 1 st Theory Decision: Finder’s Choice: Keep found animal v. Look for original owner (OO) Old Rule: Mullett/ Blackstone Rule Externalities? OO Losses (Investment; Affection) Change in Circumstances? Development of Fox Breeding Farms Increase in Externalities?

THE LOGIC OF ALBERS: CRITIQUE DQ55 (Calcium): Demsetz 1 st Theory Decision: Finder’s Choice: Keep found animal v. Look for original owner (OO) Old Rule: Mullett/ Blackstone Rule Externalities? OO Losses (Investment; Affection) Change in Circs? Fox Breeding Farms Increase in Externalities? OO losses greater; may also affect state economy Change in Rule: Albers rejects old rule.

THE LOGIC OF ALBERS: CRITIQUE DQ55 (Calcium): Demsetz 2d Theory Would Demsetz Like the Result? YES! Change in Albers creates stronger private property rights & fewer valuable escaped animals returning to commons. Seems consistent with tendency toward more private property that Demsetz sees as positive because of reduced externalities over time.

MERCURY DQ57: Factual Differences between Albers and Kesler: Why Might They Matter? Help Kesler OO or F? 1.Kesler caretakers still in pursuit when fox killed.

MERCURY DQ57: Factual Differences between Albers and Kesler: Why Might They Matter? Help Kesler OO or F? 1.Kesler caretakers still in pursuit when fox killed. 2.Fox in Kesler had escaped once before & been recaptured.

MERCURY DQ57: Factual Differences between Albers and Kesler: Why Might They Matter? Help Kesler OO or F? 1.Kesler caretakers still in pursuit when fox killed. 2.Fox in Kesler had escaped once before & been recaptured. 3.Kesler finder/defendant is not expert.

MERCURY DQ57: Factual Differences between Albers and Kesler: Why Might They Matter? Help Kesler OO or F? 1.Kesler caretakers still in pursuit when fox killed. 2.Fox in Kesler had escaped once before & been recaptured. 3.Kesler finder/defendant is not expert. 4.Kesler fox has no tattoo.

MERCURY DQ57: Factual Differences between Albers and Kesler: Why Might They Matter? Help Kesler OO or F? 1.Kesler caretakers still in pursuit when fox killed. 2.Fox in Kesler had escaped once before & been recaptured. 3.Kesler finder/defendant is not expert. 4.Kesler fox has no tattoo. 5.Kesler takes place in Idaho, not Colorado.

MERCURY DQ57: Factual Differences between Albers and Kesler: Why Might They Matter? Help Kesler OO or F? 1.Kesler caretakers still in pursuit when fox killed. 2.Fox in Kesler had escaped once before & been recaptured. 3.Kesler finder/defendant is not expert. 4.Kesler fox has no tattoo. 5.Kesler takes place in Idaho, not Colorado. 6.Other???