WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Cold Event in the South Atlantic Bight during Summer 2003: Observations and Model Simulations Alfredo Aretxabaleta Applied Ocean Physics & Engineering WHOI J. Nelson, J. Blanton (SkIO) B. Blanton, H. Seim, F. Werner, J. Bane (UNC-CH) E. Chassignet (FSU) R. Weisberg (USF)
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Baroclinic process: associated with density structure (density and pressure surfaces intersect) Barotropic response is “simpler” e.g.: tides, direct wind forcing Difficult both to measure and to model Examples: fronts, plumes, internal waves Implications: mixing, circulation, biological processes Baroclinic processes
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Introduction Observations Model simulations Implications Conclusions Outline
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 South Atlantic Bight (SAB) Region Bane et al., 2001
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Summer 2003 beach report Shivering in the Surf Atlantic's Sudden Temperature Dive A Midsummer Mystery for Scientists By John F. Kelly Washington Post, Thursday, August 7, 2003
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Anomalous hydrographic and atmospheric conditions A. Aretxabaleta, J. Nelson, J. Blanton, H. Seim, F. Werner, J. Bane, R. Weisberg Published JGR, 2006
WHOI, 20-Dec observations Cross-shelf hydrographic transects Wind observations Bottom temperature NOS coastal water level
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Surface Temperature Anomaly NDBC (NOAA)
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 R2 Bottom Temperature Year 2003 Temperature ( o C) 6 o C temperature anomaly
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 SST anomaly July 2003 MODIS, NASA Earth Observatory
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 SAB processes Inner-shelf: coast-20m isobath Mid-shelf: 20-40m isobaths Outer-shelf: 40-75m isobath
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Wind temporal variability 2003 Upwelling favorable wind stronger than in previous years Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Wind Persistence Direction (degrees) July 2003 July previous years ( ) 2003 wind persistently in upwelling favorable direction (red line)
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 River Discharge Higher than average river discharge during the study period (USGS)
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Cruise tracks R/V Savannah Most of the cruise observations in inner and mid-shelf
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Temperature transects Cold water intrusion increases with time
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Salinity transects Strong salinity gradients during spring Very homogeneous conditions during the summer
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Density transects Level of stratification increases as season progresses
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 May Salinity Large surface pool of fresher water Strong salinity stratification 07-May-2003 observed salinity May climatological salinity
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 June Temperature By June Transformed into thermal stratification June climatological temperature 25-Jun-2003 observed temperature
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 August Temperature August climatological temperature 27-Aug-2003 observed temperature By August Strong stratification with water 8°C colder!!
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 T-S characteristics
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Salinity Temperature ( o C) T-S characteristics MAY Surface water greatly influenced by river discharge
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Salinity Temperature ( o C) T-S characteristics JUNE “Deep” related to Gulf Stream water “Surface” still influenced by fresh water
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Salinity Temperature ( o C) T-S characteristics AUGUST Closely linked to Gulf Stream water
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Origin of upwelled water where α is the thermal expansion, β is the saline contraction, T GS is the Gulf Stream temperature and T j is the observed temperature
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 ~10-15 cm lower than climatology During Jul + Aug Virginia Key Cape Hatteras Water Level anomaly (2003 – climatology)
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Virginia Key Cape Hatteras Water Level anomaly (2003 – climatology)
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Enhanced Ekman Transport Relationship between Ekman velocity and stratification (Niiler and Krauss, 1977; Ralph and Niiler, 1999) Therefore, in shallow areas (not fully developed Ekman layer) the total Ekman transport is constraint to a shallower layer, resulting in increased Ekman velocities.
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Anomalous upwelling favorable winds Increased river discharge produced stronger stratification Salinity and thermal stratification enhanced upwelling process The cold water upwelled onto the shelf and the Gulf Stream water had similar characteristics No single mechanism explains the cold anomaly Conclusions from observations
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Model Simulations and Implications A. Aretxabaleta, B. Blanton, H. Seim, F. Werner, J. Nelson, E. Chassignet Submitted JGR
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 GOALS Relative importance of different forcings Anomalous wind River discharge and increased stratification Gulf Stream intrusion Comparison with observations Estimate volume of anomalous water on the shelf Possible biological implications Summer 2003 cold event model study
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Model QUODDY Nonlinear prognostic, finite element model (Lynch & Werner, 1991) Uses higher order advection scheme (Kliem, 2004)
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Model Procedure HYCOM/ CLIM Post-processing Comparison with obs. River discharge USGS EDAS
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Model forcings Generated by Brian Blanton Initial and open-ocean boundary conditions: HYCOM 1/16 North Atlantic analysis climatological temperature and salinity ( Blanton et al., 2003 ) Tidal boundary conditions: ADCIRC tidal database ( Blanton et al., 2004 ) Atmospheric forcing: atmospheric model (EDAS)
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 HYCOM mass fields Generated by Brian Blanton
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 UNC-SAB model nested regional-scale QUODDY (right). Within the 1/12 deg operational HYCOM-GODAE model (left). SAB Nested Regional Model
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Heat flux Atmospheric forcing: EDAS model
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 HYCOM as IC and BC estimator HYCOM (NRL) QUODDY Resolution~1/12 deg O(10 km)50 m to 5 km Bathymetry ETOPO5 + local improvements NGDC Coastal Relief Model Coastal Wall~10-m isobath 0-m contour line in NGDC CRM RiversNONE in SAB7 TidesNONETides (Blanton et al, 2004.)
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Surface Salinity Inclusion of River Discharge
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Summer 2003 hindcast model results Temperature ( o C) 2003 Surface Gray’s Reef Gray’s Reef Year 2003 RMS difference 1.81 o C
WHOI, 20-Dec Bottom R2 R2 Temperature ( o C) Summer 2003 hindcast model results RMS diff o C
WHOI, 20-Dec Bottom CAP3 CAP3 Temperature ( o C) Summer 2003 hindcast model results
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Model results Heat flux errors affect the surface temperature field and the total stratification
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Model results Inclusion of river discharge provides approx. to salinity field
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Model results (river effect) Effect of river discharge (river -no river simulations) ~0.5 o C in subsurface
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Model results Effect of atmospheric forcing (2003 simulation minus simulation with 2002 wind) 1-2 o C in subsurface
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Skill assessment Model skill definition Hetland & Signell (2005) where d i are available observations, m i are model results and c i are climatological values
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Bottom Temperature Animation Temperature ( o C) Bottom Temperature < 23 o C
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Remote upwelling dynamics
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Across isobath flow Influx to outer-shelf along shelf- break in central and southern areas Influx to mid- shelf in southern areas and near-bottom in central areas
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Vertically-averaged temperature anomaly Influx of anomalously cold water (2 o C colder than normal) along shelf- break in central and southern areas
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Volume of anomalous water Volume (km 3 ) Percentage of shelf volume 16-May Jun Jun Jul Jul Aug Aug Sep Sep
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Implications Bottom nitrate estimate from temperature Large pool of extra nitrate in mid-shelf
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Model provides realistic description of event Anomalous wind stress conditions Main driver (inner- and mid-shelf) High river discharge Effect on stratification Controlled inner-shelf structure Strong stratification Enhanced upwelling process Gulf Stream Source of cold water Anomalous cold water >50% shelf Biological implications (to be determined) Event Conclusions
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Improve atmospheric forcing Improve initial conditions More elaborate nesting between basin-scale (HYCOM) and shelf-scale Evaluation of nitrate fluxes Next steps
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Acknowledgments Funding SEACOOS (ONR) SABLAM (NOPP) Institutions UNC-CH Skidaway Institute of Oceanography Dartmouth College People Dennis McGillicuddy, Keston Smith, J.L. Pelegri, Rick Luettich
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Inner-shelf coast-20m isobath Tides, Winds, Rivers Mid-shelf 20m-50m isobaths Winds, Tides, Q-Flux Outer-shelf 50m-Shelfbreak W.B.C. Influences Currently, neither basin-scale nor regional-scale models can include all relevant scales/physics for shelf prediction We augment basin-scale HYCOM TS initializations and estimates of TS and sea level along a limited-area domain open boundary, with locally enhanced resolution, physics, and forcing, through nesting procedures.
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 Summer 2003 hindcast model results Gray’s Reef RMS difference 1.81 o C
WHOI, 20-Dec-2006 R2 Summer 2003 hindcast model results RMS diff o C
WHOI, 20-Dec Bottom CAP3 CAP3 Temperature ( o C) Summer 2003 hindcast model results