Dynamic Order Submission Strategies with Competition between a Dealer Market and a Crossing Network Discussion Frontiers of Finance, Bonaire 2005 Jennifer.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Brief on STP – ECN and GMI Currenex. Platforms: GMI ICTS FX Platform GMI MT4 Platform.

Advertisements

Stock Markets FNCE 4070 – Financial Markets and Institutions.

Security Markets

Chapter 5 Market Structures. Trading sessions Trades take place during trading sessions. Continuous market sessions Call market sessions.

Government Debt Management Unit Primary Market – Auctions of Tradable Government Bonds (Draft for comments)

Competition on the Nasdaq and the Impact of Recent Market Reforms James P. Weston.

CHAPTER 8 FINANCIAL STATEMENT ANALYSIS: APPLICATIONS Presenter’s name Presenter’s title dd Month yyyy.

Chapter 16 Value Traders. Value traders supply liquidity Uninformed traders cause prices to deviate from fundamental values Dealers mistakenly respond.

Transactions Costs.

Lecture 7 Understanding and Measuring Transaction Costs.

©Schwartz, Sipress, Weber Fall 2008 Slide 1 Topic 9.

Dynamic Order Submission Strategies with Competition between a Dealer Market and a Crossing Network Hans Degryse, University of Leuven and CentER Mark.

1 Today Financing decisions Financing patterns and stock market reaction Payout policy Reading Brealey and Myers, Chapter 16, 17.

Real-Time Analysis for High-Frequency Trading Your Data Needs to Be Faster, Not Just Bigger © 2015 Lee A Cole.

International Finance

Information Disclosure and Market Quality: The Effect of SEC Rule 605 on Trading Costs Xin Zhao and Kee H. Chung.

Harold Demsetz The Quarterly Journal of Economics 1968.

P.V. VISWANATH FOR A FIRST COURSE IN INVESTMENTS.

Investing in your future. What is INVESTORS OF TOMORROW? Investors of Tomorrow strives for excellence in fulfilling the mandate of providing financial.

1 Caput Financial Markets Frank de Jong Universiteit van Amsterdam September 2001.

FIN303 Vicentiu Covrig 1 Financial Markets and Institutions (chapter 5)

Key Terms from the World of Finance. Key Terms AMEX – Stands for American Stock Exchange. Located in New York City, this stock exchange sells memberships,

Security Markets Objectives Primary market Secondary Market.

Frontiers of Finance Conference January 2005 Unallocated Shelf Registration: Why Doesn’t Everybody Use it? Jennifer E. Bethel Babson College Laurie Krigman.

Equities Rob Graffeo Dec 14, What is a stock?

Contemporary Investments: Chapter 5 Chapter 5 ORGANIZATION OF THE FINANCIAL MARKETS What are the different types of financial markets? How do the primary.

1 Robert Engle UCSD and NYU July WHAT IS LIQUIDITY? n A market with low “transaction costs” including execution price, uncertainty and speed n.

Chapter 9 Section 9.3 – Buying and Selling Stock.

© 2009 McGraw-Hill Ryerson Limited 6-1 Chapter 6 The Stock Market The primary and secondary stock markets The primary and secondary stock markets The New.

Financial Services 2015 – Speculation on the Future of the Business Stanford-Tsukuba/WCQF Workshop March 9, 2007 Howard Bomze, DSc.

3-1 Chapter 3 Financial Intermediaries. 3-2 Deficit Sectors Financial Intermediaries Claims Surplus Sectors $ Claims $$

Impact of the introduction of the risk management products Dr. San-Lin Chung Department of Finance National Taiwan University.

ONLINE TRADING & MARKET LIQUIDITY ASEA/CASE Conference September

Stocks, Bonds, and Futures Why Buy Stock? Gain a Profit Limit the Risk on their investment Become a part of a corporation Profit Potential Capital gain-

Chapter 12: Market Microstructure and Strategies

Introduction to Stocks Basics of Investing I Spring 2014 Accounting 101` K. Robinson.

The Stock Market Understand the risks Describe how stocks are traded

Ch 8. Stocks and Their Valuation. Goals To understand characteristics of common and preferred stocks To understand stock valuations.

The impact of Electronic Communications Networks (ECNs) on NYSE

©Copyright 2003, The Nasdaq Stock Market, Inc. All rights reserved. Changes in Market Structure: Approaches to Securities Trading 15 April 2003 Alfred.

Market Structure, Fragmentation, and Market Quality Paul Bennett Li Wei New York Stock Exchange December, 2005.

Danny Burton Head of Dealing. 2 Threadneedle – Global Presence Source: Threadneedle as at August 2009 Offices Swindon Brisbane Hong Kong Singapore London.

SOA based Business Solutions Krishna Prasad Sunil Kumar K.V.

We Save US Jobs Together We Achieve Everything. We Save US Jobs Through Crowd Sourcing Together We Achieve Everything Each American has unique attributes.

Chapter 12 Jones, Investments: Analysis and Management

©R. Schwartz Equity Markets: Trading and Structure Slide 1 Bob Schwartz Zicklin School of Business Baruch College, CUNY.

Lecture 3 Secondary Equity Markets - I. Trading motives Is it a zero-sum game? Building portfolio for a long run. Trading on information. Short-term speculation.

Five Year Futures Contract Overview First-in-first-out (FIFO) vs. Pro Rata Algorithm Pros and Cons of Each Methodology.

Chapter 11 Financial Markets. Investment Investment is the act of redirecting resources from being consumed today so that they may create benefits in.

(Econ 512): Economics of Financial Markets Chapter Two: Asset Market Microstructure Dr. Reyadh Faras Econ 512 Dr. Reyadh Faras.

© Copyright IBM Corporation 2003 China Sharpening the Vision Tobin Alexander - Vice President IBM Global Automotive, Asia-Pacific Operations.

IS 356 IT for Financial Services Alternative Trading Systems (ATS) and Electronic Communications Networks (ECN)

Chapter 8– Bond Valuation and Structure of Interest RatesCopyright 2008 John Wiley & Sons 1 MT480 Unit 4 Chapters 8 and 9.

Chapter 14 Investing in Stocks. Common Stock  Issued to finance their business start-up costs and help pay for expansion and their ongoing business activities.

What is a Stock? BCHS Investment Club. Stock Represents a share of ownership in a publicly held company (privately held companies do not issue stock).

©R. Schwartz Equity Markets: Trading and Structure Slide 1 Topic 7.

P604, Pay debts 2. Raise money  Ex. To expand business.

Make a list of 5 products that you think are great and will be money makers for the company that produces them. Try to guess what company makes the product.

Make a list of 5 products that you think are great and will be money makers for the company that produces them. Try to guess what company makes the product.

FOURTH MARKETS Crystal Cady BA543 Spring Brief Introduction to ECN’s  Off-exchange trading in the market  Computerized system that allows traders.

Chapter 15 – Secondary Markets Trading of Financial Assets after Initial Sale Property Rights (Claims to Real Assets) bought and sold without money going.

Modelitec TM Experiment Results 5/7/2005 – 4/3/2006.

Corporate Finance MLI28C060 Lecture 4 Thursday 15 October 2015.

04/12/01 GS: Equity Module, Session 6 Copyright Marshall, Tucker & Associates, LLC Goldman Sachs & Co. Controllers Training Equity Markets Module.

1.  Brokerage Costs Most explicit, but by far the smallest component  Bid-Ask Spread  Price Impact The change in price an investor can create through.

The Piggy Bank Our goal is to show a consistent profit and sustainable growth by offering our community quality products and services.

IS 356 IT for Financial Services

1. Introduction to financial markets

Chapter 16 Distribution Policy

Goldman Sachs & Co. Controllers Training Equity Markets Module - Session 6 Comparison of Equity Markets -- NYSE, NASDAQ, ECNs Alan L. Tucker, Ph.D.

Presentation transcript:

Dynamic Order Submission Strategies with Competition between a Dealer Market and a Crossing Network Discussion Frontiers of Finance, Bonaire 2005 Jennifer E. Bethel Babson College

2 Intuition of model: What services do active and passive equity managers demand? Active  Quick execution  Guaranteed execution Quantitative/Passive  Low commissions  Little price impact

3 Intuition of Model DMs offer immediacy and guarantee of trade to informed traders CNs offer low cost trade to less informed traders  Lower commissions  Lower probability of trading with informed trader

4 Implications CN & DM cater to different types of traders.  Impatient traders prefer DMs.  Patient traders prefer CNs. The introduction of a CN increases overall order flow by attracting traders who would otherwise not submit trades. CNs divert trades from DMs. Opaqueness/transparency matters.

5 Posit: Quantitative/passive money managers Anonymous Confidential $0.02/share commission Midpoint pricing  save ½ the spread No unfavorable price impact from trading in open market 1 match/day around 11:30 Match took place within 10 minutes 600,000 shares matched/day in 1989; 4 million shares matched/day in 1992 (2 crosses/day: 11:30 and 1:30) 150 users

6 Posit: 2004 Active/quantitative/passive money managers Anonymous Confidential ≤ $0.02/share commission Midpoint pricing  save ½ the spread No unfavorable price impact from trading in open market 12 matches/day  Within trading hours 9:45, 10:00, 10:15, 10:30, 11:00, 11:30, 12:00, 1:00, 2:00, 3:00, 3:30 Match takes place within 1 minute after above times Mid-point of bid/ask spread  After trading hours 4:45 Closing price 22.6 million shares matched/day Average execution size: 5,800 shares 550 users

7 Posit

8 In comparison … NASDAQ  Average monthly trade volume: 27.8 million  Average monthly share volume: billion NYSE  Average monthly shares: 30,352.2 million  Average monthly value: $ billion  Average execution size: 460 shares

9 Question: When is a CN a CN? What is the objective of a particular CN? To achieve various objectives, which attributes are necessary?  Anonymous  Confidential - How transparent should the market be?  How many crosses/day?  How much possible delay?  How should shares in the match be rationed? LIFO? FIFO? Pro rata?  What are the ratios of patient/impatient traders under different scenarios?