MODELS’ COMPARISON Denmark England and Wales Belarus First experience COST Action G9, WG 2 meeting Marina Vaskovich Székesfehérvár, Hungary, September 2-3, 2004

How to compare subdivision procedure? By actors involved? By actors involved? By activities performed? By activities performed? By identifying decision-making body? By identifying decision-making body? By clarifying role of surveyor? By clarifying role of surveyor? COST Action G9, WG 2 meeting Székesfehérvár, Hungary, September 2-3, 2004

To compare by actors Which actors involved Which actors involved Active/passive actors Active/passive actors Who takes legal decision (e.g. surveyor, municipality, etc.) Who takes legal decision (e.g. surveyor, municipality, etc.) … COST Action G9, WG 2 meeting Székesfehérvár, Hungary, September 2-3, 2004

To compare by activities Which activities performed by each actor Which activities performed by each actor Queue of activities (e.g., measurement before/after legal decision, etc.) Queue of activities (e.g., measurement before/after legal decision, etc.) … COST Action G9, WG 2 meeting (who does what?) Székesfehérvár, Hungary, September 2-3, 2004

Subdivision: Denmark Activities Initiation Initiation Investigation Investigation Check/Measurement Check/Measurement Case preparation Case preparation Application to M, OA Application to M, OA Case approval Case approval Application for R Application for R Case check Case check Ownership registration Ownership registration Information updating Information updating Actors Owner Licensed surveyor Municipality Licensed surveyor Cadastral authority Land Registry, M Council COST Action G9, WG 2 meeting Székesfehérvár, Hungary, September 2-3, 2004

Subdivision: E&W Activities Initiation Initiation Investigation Investigation Consultation? Consultation? Case preparation Case preparation Application for R Application for R Case check Case check Ownership registration Ownership registration Actors Owner Solicitor Municipality Solicitor HM Land Registry COST Action G9, WG 2 meeting Székesfehérvár, Hungary, September 2-3, 2004

Subdivision: activities Denmark Initiation Initiation Investigation Investigation Check/Measurement Check/Measurement Case preparation Case preparation Case approval Case approval Application for R Application for R Case check Case check Ownership registration Ownership registration Information updating Information updating E&W Initiation Investigation Consultation Case preparation Application for R Case check Ownership registration COST Action G9, WG 2 Székesfehérvár, Hungary, September 2-3, 2004

Subdivision: conclusions Denmark Informal initiation Informal initiation Measurement before legal survey and approvals Measurement before legal survey and approvals Approval from municipality is needed Approval from municipality is needed Mortgage is not considered Mortgage is not considered E&W Informal initiation Office work No measurement Mortgage is considered COST Action G9, WG 2 meeting Székesfehérvár, Hungary, September 2-3, 2004

Subdivision: actors Denmark Owner Owner Licensed surveyor Licensed surveyor Cadastral authority (KMS) Cadastral authority (KMS) Land Registry Land Registry Municipality Municipality Relevant authorities Relevant authorities (which ones?) E&W Owner Solicitor Municipality HM Land Registry COST Action G9, WG 2 meeting Székesfehérvár, Hungary, September 2-3, 2004

Privatization: Belarus Activities Initiation Initiation Decision Decision Investigation/check Investigation/check Decision Decision Case preparation Case preparation Case approval Case approval Decision Decision Measurement Measurement Application for R Application for R Case check Case check Ownership registration Ownership registration Actors Applicant Municipality Surveyor Municipality Surveyor Municipality Surveyor Applicant/new owner Cad and Reg authority Municipality COST Action G9, WG 2 meeting

Legal decision by Cadastral authority (KMS) - Denmark Cadastral authority (KMS) - Denmark Solicitor - E&W Solicitor - E&W Municipality - Belarus Municipality - Belarus COST Action G9, WG 2 meeting Székesfehérvár, Hungary, September 2-3, 2004

Surveyor’s responsibilities in subdivision procedure COST Action G9, WG 2 meeting Székesfehérvár, Hungary, September 2-3, 2004 Denmark: private licensed surveyors; legally and technically responsible for whole process Denmark: private licensed surveyors; legally and technically responsible for whole process E&W: not involved E&W: not involved Belarus: preparatory work, measurement Belarus: preparatory work, measurement

Comparison: conclusions COST Action G9, WG 2 meeting Székesfehérvár, Hungary, September 2-3, 2004 Identification of actors Identification of actors Key activities for each procedure/country Key activities for each procedure/country Output of activities (e.g., report, permission, etc.) Output of activities (e.g., report, permission, etc.) Registration Registration Different kind of diagrams Different kind of diagrams …