Bill Pugh NSF (Jan - Jun 2011) Univ. Of Maryland Google NSF Broader Impact.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
NSF CAREER Young Faculty Perspective Steve McIntosh Department of Chemical Engineering.
Advertisements

Building a Strategic Management System Office for Student Affairs, Twin Cities Campus Ground Level Work Metrics Initiatives Managing Change Change Management.
High Level Comments Strengths  Pre-proposal – concise, compelling  Topic is timely  Major Activities are organized well and engages team effectively.
1 Performance Assessment An NSF Perspective MJ Suiter Budget, Finance and Awards NSF.
The Industry-University Cooperative Research Program ( IUCRP ) University of California 1996 – 2010 Lovell Jarvis University of California, Davis.
What is the NSF CAREER Program? NSF website:
Broader Impacts: Meaningful Links between Research and Societal Benefits October 23, 2014 Martin Storksdieck I Center for Research on Lifelong STEM Learning.
Session 5 Intellectual Merit and Broader Significance FISH 521.
Agenda What is Geek the Library? The Research The Pilot The Latest The Campaign The Keys to Success The Return on Investment.
NSF Proposal and Merit Review Process. Outline Proposal review process –Submission –Administrative Review –Merit Review –Decisions.
Merit Review and Proposal Preparation Mark Courtney Division of Environmental Biology
NSF Merit Review and Proposal Preparation Mark Courtney, Ph.D Adjunct, Department of Biology New Mexico State University 24 September 2008.
Facilitators: Janet Lange and Bob Munn
Armed Forces Community Covenant (AFCC) grant scheme The context The Armed Forces Community makes up approximately 10 % of the total population of Hampshire.
1 “Broader Impacts”: NSF Changes & SE Researcher Strategies Margaret Burnett, Lori Clarke, Sebastian Elbaum, Bill Pugh Oregon State Univ., Univ. Mass Amherst,
1 Strategic Planning: An Update March 13, Outline What we have done so far? Where do we stand now? Next steps?
Strategic Plan for CIS Department. Vision Have an international reputation, apart from the main campus, for innovative research and excellent educational.
1 CCLI Proposal Writing Strategies Tim Fossum Program Director Division of Undergraduate Education National Science Foundation Vermont.
National Science Foundation: Transforming Undergraduate Education in Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (TUES)
CAREER WORKSHOP APRIL 9, 2014 Required Elements of the Proposal Beth Hodges Director, Office of Proposal Development FLORIDA STATE UNIVERSITY.
Proposal Strengths and Weakness as Identified by Reviewers Russ Pimmel & Sheryl Sorby FIE Conference Oct 13, 2007.
Top Ten Ways To Write a Good Proposal… That Won’t Get Funded.
Navigating Research Funding Cynthia Sagers Office of the Vice Provost for Research and Economic Development UA.
BIRDS Jeannette M. Wing Assistant Director for Computer and Information Science and Engineering National Science Foundation June 22, 2010.
Funding Opportunities for Chemists at the National Science Foundation Division of Undergraduate Education Pamela Brown, NSF Program Director Division of.
Ingredients of Good Proposals Before you apply for funding … write the call: – Volunteer for funding workshops & white papers – Participate in forward-looking.
The University of Arkansas GK-12 KIDS (K-12, I, Do, Science) Program Changing Graduate Training to Include a Responsibility for K-12 Science and Math Education.
 NSF Merit Review Criteria Intellectual Merit Broader Impacts  Additional Considerations Integration of Research & Education Integrating Diversity into.
INTERNET2 COLLABORATIVE INNOVATION PROGRAM DEVELOPMENT Florence D. Hudson Senior Vice President and Chief Innovation.
Search Engine Optimization  The Two Key SEO Principles  SEO in Ten Steps Ivan Surjanovic, Copyright 2014 by iPower.
Service-Learning and Grant Writing Workshop Tennessee Technological University February 23, 2010 Presented by: Shelley Brown Department of Sociology and.
E-MENTORING: New Skills and Competencies for New Jobs e-MENTORING: New Skills and Competencies for New Jobs No LLP LT-KA3-KA3MP European.
On Preparing Proposals: Comments from Both Inside and Outside NSF Xiaodong Zhang The Ohio State University.
Writing More Effective NSF Proposals Jeanne R. Small Oklahoma City, Oklahoma March 2, 2006 Division of Undergraduate Education (DUE) National Science Foundation.
Tips for NSF GRF Applicants Matt Williams Barry M. Goldwater Scholar ( ) NSF Graduate Research Fellow ( ) October 13, 2010.
A 40 Year Perspective Dr. Frank Scioli NSF-Retired.
NSF GRFP Workshop Sept 16, 2016 Dr. Julia Fulghum
Managing Opportunities Lori A. Clarke Department of Computer Science University of Massachusetts, Amherst.
The shift to programs in the LAC region. What is a program? A program is a coherent set of initiatives by CARE and our allies that involves a long-term.
Funding your Dreams Cathy Manduca Director, Science Education Resource Center Iowa State University, 2005.
NSF IGERT proposals Yang Zhao Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering Wayne State University.
 NSF Merit Review Criteria Intellectual Merit Broader Impacts  Additional Considerations Integration of Research & Education Broadening Participation.
Congress created the NSF in 1950 as an independent federal agency. Budget ~$7.0 billion (2012) Funding for basic research.
Secure and Trustworthy Cyberspace (SaTC) “Top 10” Tips for SaTC Proposals One program director’s observations Sol Greenspan.
Session B – Broader Impacts: What’s the big idea? J. Britt HolbrookSharon Franks Center for the Study of InterdisciplinarityResearch Proposal Development.
NSF Programs for Faculty Scripps Research Institute April 30, 2009 George Kenyon NSF Division of Chemistry
CAREER WORKSHOP APRIL 6, 2015 Required Elements of the NSF Proposal Beth Hodges Director, Office of Proposal Development FLORIDA STATE UNIVERSITY.
Next Meeting Open to all PIs, current and past from CPATH Open to all PIs, current and past from CPATH NSF should provide travel funds for PIs of expired.
How to Plan a Successful Academic Year with Your Chapter: Keeping the End in Mind JODI BROOKINS-FISHER, PHD, MCHES ESG PRESIDENT HOLLY TURNER MOSES, PHD,
Funding Caroline Wardle Senior Science Advisor, CISE Directorate National Science Foundation
Parts of an NSF full grant proposal
The Review Process o What happens to your proposal o Two Review Criteria.
Student Affairs Assessment Council: Articulating our purpose “Position description” for membership Charge update Wednesday, August 21, 2013.
1Mobile Computing Systems © 2001 Carnegie Mellon University Writing a Successful NSF Proposal November 4, 2003 Website: nsf.gov.
1 “Raise the Civic Canopy” 3 rd Annual “Raise the Civic Canopy” Event February 15, 2007 Belmar Center, Lakewood, CO.
NSF policies and requirements for Implementation of the America COMPETES Act. America COMPETES Act contains a number of new requirements for all those.
1 Presentation to IEEE Education Activities Board: IEEE-USA/EAB Cooperative Endeavors Presented to EAB June 21, 2008 John W. Meredith, PE IEEE-USA 2007.
2015/2016 PSIEE Seed Grant Information Session October 21, 2015.
March 12, SIGCSE Report FOCE Summit Panel 1 Getting to a Future of Computing Education Summit Joseph Urban Texas Tech University.
Course, Curriculum, and Laboratory Improvement (CCLI) Transforming Undergraduate Education in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics PROGRAM.
How to Obtain National Science Foundation Fellowships and Awards: The Basics Facilitator: Jeff Ryan Ph.D. A workshop providing information on the process.
IFIP TC5 Working Group 5.4 Computer Aided Innovation Objectives: The Working Group will: – Identify the different existing approaches – Share opinions,
Enrique E. AlvarezICACIT - WHIE for A’s Engineers for the Americas E for A’s.
NSF RCR Training Requirement New NSF requirement for Responsible Conduct of Research in effect as of January 4, 2010 Mandates RCR training for students.
Major Research Instrumentation- COV Discussion of the Issues and Recommendations with SMART October 18, 2005.
External Research Funding in Academia Ron Rardin Professor of Industrial Engineering.
Understanding NSF Broader Impact Criterion
Strategic Planning PPT
NATIONAL PARTICIPATORY BUDGET
Writing More Effective NSF Proposals
Presentation transcript:

Bill Pugh NSF (Jan - Jun 2011) Univ. Of Maryland Google NSF Broader Impact

Nothing official Nothing has been decided or announced about how NSF will implement provisions of the America Competes Act I don't speak for NSF Lots of people have used this as an opportunity to encourage and discuss broader impact and outreach, and advocate for their vision of broader impact Broader impact and outreach is a good thing

Broader Impact at NSF current status Proposals are evaluated in terms of intellectual merit and broader impact Proposals with weak intellectually merit, as evaluated by panel, don't get funded Proposals get returned without review if they don't explicitly mention broader impact Broader impact can make a difference in ranking competitive proposals near the funding cutoff

How much of a difference? Fund rate is perhaps 20-25% In panel with 30 proposals, might fund 6-8 proposals Might be 1-3 proposals nearly tied for intellectual merit Strong broader impact might move you to the top of that group

Broader Impact via research Almost anyone publishing at ICSE can claim to have broader impact via their research (1) Increased economic competitiveness of the United States (8) Increased national security Can improve impact by plans to make artifacts produced via research publicly available software, data sets Also helpful to discuss measures to ensure real world relevance

Outreach broader impact Lots of ways to have broader impact via outreach of many kinds Many people assume that new NSF rules will allow for broader impact sidecars

Broader impact side cars Broader impact effort not connected to proposal research Doesn't need to be original or innovative; being successful is also important Can be participation in existing departmental or campus program Can allocate funds for outreach activities and/or evaluation

Broader impact side cars I expect that if new rules allow for BI sidecars, most proposals in software engineering won't have them But some PI's are very enthusiastic and motivated to do outreach activities This will provide them with opportunities put that energy and ideas into their NSF proposals and be rewarded for it

Volunteer to serve on an NSF panel Program managers are always gets looking for people to serve on panels Particularly need help identifying nand faculty and postdocs Great way to serve the community, learn how the process works, and perhaps influence the work that gets funded For software engineering, contact Sol Greenspan I'll be gone by the end of June