The Federal Budget and Tax Policy Lecture by Robert M. Coen Emeritus Professor of Economics Northwestern University September 29, 2009
Federal Receipts and Expenditures (Billions of dollars) QuarterReceiptsExpendituresSurplus 2000Q1 2, , Q2 2, , ,294.9 Change , ,500.1
Estimated Federal Budget Surplus for (Billions of dollars per year) Jan est.+846 Early 2000s downturn-291 Bush policies-673 (tax cuts, Iraq, drug ins.) Current recession-479 Bailouts-185 Continuing policies (e.g., war, AMT adj.)-232 Obama stimulus-145 Other Obama programs -56 Current estimate -1,215 Source: David Leonhardt, New York Times, June 10, 2009
CBO: Baseline Federal Budget Projection Total deficit $3,988 $7,137 ($ billions) Deficit/GDP (Percent) Debt/GDP (Percent)
Total Public Debt as Percent of GDP, 2008 France 68 Germany 64 Japan 173 Sweden 37 UK 52 US 61 Source: CIA World Fact Book
CBO: Baseline Federal Expenditures Projection Change in annual expenditures, 2009 to 2019 (billions of dollars) Total+1,294 Mandatory +506 Discretionary +243 Interest +545 Social security +418 Medicare +444 Medicaid +174
CBO: Effects of Alternative Policies on Deficit (Billions of dollars) Baseline deficit $3,988 $7,137 30,000 troop reduction by ,074 Freeze discretionary spending Extend expiring tax cuts +1,640 +4,090 Index AMT for inflation
What Is Sound Budget Policy? False analogies to private debt Balance the budget? Balance current budget, borrow for capital expenditures? Balance the budget over business cycle? Keep debt/GDP ratio at “safe” level? Functional finance?
Key Comparative Ratios 2006 TaxesIncome taxConsumption to GDP to total tax* to GDP France Germany Japan Sweden UK US * Excluding property and social insurance taxes Source: OECD
How We Could Impair the Economic Well-being of Future Generations Bequeathing less capital Bequeathing a less educated, less healthy workforce Bequeathing less scientific, engineering, and managerial knowledge Bequeathing fewer natural resources Accumulating foreign debt to finance current consumption or unprofitable investment