1 Job Search Models. 2 In economics we have a general rule of behavior that says engage in an activity up to the point where the marginal benefit is equal.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Aggregate Supply The AS is the part of our national economy model where the production side is studied.
Advertisements

Compensating Wage Differentials
1 Impact of Change in Income Here we want to consider the change consumers will make if they experience a change in income.
Unions 1. 2 Let’s begin by looking at some of the history of unions in the United States. Note that a yellow-dog contract are contracts between workers.
Utility Theory.
Market Impact of Payroll Tax At the bottom of page 157 the author starts with the sentence, “This result illustrates a principle that is worth remembering:
Labor Demand in the market in the short run.
Changes in income After we build our initial model of labor/leisure choice we add ideas about how a person might react to change.
Long Run Demand for Labor
Facilities and Aggregate Planning. A digression I am not an advocate of gambling, but use an example here that you might draw on later. Say I have a coin.
Chapter 7 Introduction to Linear Programming. Linear? To get a feel for what linear means let’s think about a simple example. You have $10 to spend and.
Other Inventory Models 1. Continuous Review or Q System 2 The EOQ model is based on several assumptions, one being that there is a constant demand. This.
1 One Tailed Tests Here we study the hypothesis test for the mean of a population when the alternative hypothesis is an inequality.
1 Normal Probability Distributions. 2 Review relative frequency histogram 1/10 2/10 4/10 2/10 1/10 Values of a variable, say test scores In.
1 The International Trade and Capital Flows Chapter 23.
1 Utility Theory. 2 Option 1: bet that pays $5,000,000 if a coin flipped comes up tails you get $0 if the coin comes up heads. Option 2: get $2,000,000.
Labor Supply and Elasticity
1 Monopsony Monopsony is a situation where there is one buyer – you have seen Monopoly, a case of one seller. Here we want to explore the impact on the.
Monopsony Monopsony is a situation where there is one buyer – you have seen Monopoly, a case of one seller. Here we want to explore the impact on the.
Human Capital.
1 Production and Costs in the Long Run. 2 The long run u The long run is the time frame longer or just as long as it takes to alter the plant. u Thus.
Labor Union Ideas 1. Intro You and I have seen that firms that want to hire labor take a good look at the marginal revenue product of labor and consider.
Chapter 1 Supply, Demand and Equilibrium
1 The Normal Probability Distribution. 2 Review relative frequency histogram 1/10 2/10 4/10 2/10 1/10 Values of a variable, say test scores
1 Labor Market Equilibrium. 2 Overview In this section we want to explore what happens in a competitive labor market. Plus we will look at an application.
1 Production and Supply. 2 When trying to understand the supply decisions of firms, the concept called opportunity cost is important. Here I reproduce.
1 Understanding more about Consumers. 2 Recall the law of demand was a statement that the price of a product and the quantity demanded of the product.
Labor Demand. Overview In the next few chapters we will consider the demand for resources. Just as a coin has two sides, when viewing a firm we could.
1 Competitive Industry in the Short Run. 2 operating rule case 1 $/unit Q or units MC AC AVCb c The firm is a price taker - say it takes P If firm operatesif.
1 Basic Macroeconomic Relationships. 2 Overview Here we study some basic economic relationships that we think hold in a general way in the economy. Here.
An Inference Procedure
Macroeconomics Chapter 91 Capital Utilization and Unemployment C h a p t e r 9.
1 Labor Demand and Supply. 2 Overview u In the previous few chapters we have focused on the output decision for firms. Now we want to focus on the input.
1 Supply and Demand. 2 In economics we use a model of supply and demand in an attempt to understand market outcomes for a good or service. Of particular.
1 Perfect Competition in the Short Run. 2 Perfect competition Firms in the real world make either one product or make more than one product. They also.
The Basics of Regression continued
1 Human Capital. 2 In economics we talk about the 4 basic resource groups Land, Labor, Capital (things made to make other things), and Entrepreneurship.
1 Production and Costs in the Long Run. 2 The long run u The long run is the time frame longer or just as long as it takes to alter the plant. u Thus.
Team Cost, Profit and Winning Here we start with definitions and then look at idea of how a sports owner might run the team. 1.
Production In this section we want to explore ideas about production of output from using inputs. We will do so in both a short run context and in a long.
1 Monopsony Monopsony is a situation where there is one buyer – you have seen Monopoly, a case of one seller. Here we want to explore the impact on the.
The Normal Distribution
1 Labor Supply and Demand In this section we study the general overall condition in labor markets.
1 Labor Markets. 2 Review and overview In this section we want to look at various environments in which suppliers and demanders of labor interact. When.
1 T-test for the Mean of a Population: Unknown population standard deviation Here we will focus on two methods of hypothesis testing: the critical value.
Labor Market Equilibrium
1 The Behavior of Consumers Here we study an elementary view of the economic approach to how consumers go about spending their money.
1 Models of Effort. 2 The Principal-Agent Problem Human Resource Management is a separate field of study today. But, we in economics have a take on the.
1 Profit The word profit in economics really means economic profit. Let’s see what this means.
1 The Sample Mean rule Recall we learned a variable could have a normal distribution? This was useful because then we could say approximately.
1 Human Capital 2. 2 Example based on last section: Assume for a person there is just two years after high school. The individual could work in both years.
1 Work-Life Incentive Schemes Models in this area look at the whole working career of an individual and try to make pay over the career keep the individual.
1 The Behavior of Consumers Here we study an elementary view of the economic approach to how consumers go about spending their money – you could say this.
1 Money Market. 2 In these notes that follow we will refer to short term interest rates. An important short term rate is the FED FUNDS rate. This is the.
Chapter 8 Cost McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2008 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Cost. Overview In this section we want to translate the production data into cost data. In other words, we will want to understand how the cost of producing.
1 Confidence Interval for Population Mean The case when the population standard deviation is unknown (the more common case).
An Inference Procedure
Economic Applications of Functions and Derivatives
Copyright © 2009 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. McGraw-Hill/Irwin Chapter 4 How Businesses Work.
Chapter 4 How Businesses Work McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2012 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.
1 More Monopsony. 2 On the next slide I have reproduced something from a previous section. Note the marginal labor cost is greater than the wage at each.
Introduction to Data Analysis Probability Distributions.
Chapter 6: Probability Distributions
Section 8.1 Estimating  When  is Known In this section, we develop techniques for estimating the population mean μ using sample data. We assume that.
Next page Chapter 5: The Demand for Labor. Jump to first page 1. Derived Demand for Labor.
1 Compensating Wage Differentials. 2 We know different people get paid different wages. In this section we focus on the differences in the JOBS that lead.
Chap 5-1 Discrete and Continuous Probability Distributions.
Chapter 5 The Demand for Labor McGraw-Hill/Irwin
Understanding Supply What is the law of supply?
Presentation transcript:

1 Job Search Models

2 In economics we have a general rule of behavior that says engage in an activity up to the point where the marginal benefit is equal to the marginal cost. When you first saw this rule it was probably related to how much output a firm should make. Here we want to look at a variant of the rule that guides folks in understanding how many firms they should search in an attempt to land a job. The Fixed Sample Search Model. COST – It is assumed that the cost to a job searcher of each firm searched is a constant amount c. The total cost of searching n firms is cn and the marginal cost of searching another firm is c. Let’s look at the marginal cost in a graph on the next screen.

3 Number of firms searched $ Marginal expected cost = mec =c (the constant) What does it cost you to check out a firm for a job? You have to research the company and maybe drive there. Maybe you even send a resume. It is assumed the cost is the same for each firm searched.

4 BENEFITS To explore the benefits of the job search we will look at an example. Say there are two types of companies out there. Half have starting pay of 20,000 and half have starting pay of 30,000. The job applicant does not know what type of firm each firm is until the potential worker has checked out the company. The expected (yearly) wage from searching only one firm is.5(20,000) +.5(30,000) = 25,000. By the way, the expected wage is the probability that each type of firm would be found times its pay and add the multiplications across all firms. The expected wage from searching only two firms is.25(20,000) +.75(30,000) = 27,500. Let’s think about how we obtained this amount. On the next slide we start with the possible wage offers the worker could get when two firms are searched.

5 (20,000 20,000) (20,000 30,000) (30,000 20,000) (30,000 30,000) If a person checks two firms, and if they pick the job that pays more between the two, then only 25% of the time will they get a 20,000 job. 75% of time they would get a 30,000 job. Next I have a table where we list the expected wage for various numbers of firms searched.

6 Firms searchedprob. Of prob. Of expected wage meb 20k offer 30k offer 1 ½ ½ ½(20k) +1/2(30k) = 25,000 xxx 2 ¼ ¾ 1/4(20k) +3/4(30k) = 27,500 2, /8 7/8 1/8(20k) +7/8(30k) = 28,750 1, /16 15/16 1/16(20k) +15/16(30k) = 29, The last column, meb, or marginal expected benefit, is the additional wage the person can expected if they expanded their job search by 1 additional firm. As you can see the amount is not the same for each firm added to the search. Note, I said the cost of search per firm searched was a constant. In that sense it is known with certainty, but I mentioned the marginal expected cost because on the benefit side we have uncertainty. Let’s graph both the mec and meb on the next slide.

7 Number of firms searched $ mec n* is the optimal number of firms searched because after that point the expected benefits of additional search are outweighed by the cost of the search. meb n*

8 What happens to the optimal number of jobs searched if the cost of job search rises? Well, in the graph the mec would rise and thus the curves would cross at a lower point – search less firms. This makes sense because if the cost of additional search rises then you would expect fewer of the searches to have high enough additional benefits to overcome the cost. Some dude named Stigler – a university of Chicago chap, dead now a few years – showed if wage offers follow a normal distribution with mean offer wmean, and standard deviation sigma, then the meb =.24(sigma)/n raised to the power On the next slide let’s see a graph when sigma = 1 and the cost of searching a firm is a little over 7 cents.

9

10 Here I show that if the standard deviation of the distribution is larger the marginal expected benefit curve shifts right and the optimal number of firms search would rise. The basic logic behind this result is that when the standard deviation rises the probability of getting a high paying job rises. When you look back at our table the expected wage is sensitive to the probability of a high paying job. If the probability goes up then the meb will go up as well.

11 Some have criticized the fixed search model as unrealistic. Their logic is that although there is a distribution of wages, some will get a high wage relatively early in the search and thus stop way short of searching n* firms. The criticism suggests that the search should really stop after a certain wage has been offered. We turn to this idea next. Sequential Search Model We are going to look at an example here to motivate our discussion. Say you have 10 weeks in your summer vacation and you will go to a resort area to get a job. The time line below shows your ten weeks. If you take a job at time zero you will work the whole ten weeks. If you wait and not take a job until time 1 you will only have 9 weeks left to work, and so on

12 In our example say you will get one job a week and if you reject it you will have to wait a week for another offer. Say there are four types of jobs. The difference is that the pay per week over your room and board will be either 100, 120, 130, or 140 and the probability of getting any type of job is ¼. Before you take a job at time zero, let’s think about the expected value of continuing the job search until time period 1 (the beginning of the second week). Job typeincome over the 9 weeks 100 job job job job1260 The expected value of continuing the job search is ¼(900) + ¼(1080) + ¼(1170) + ¼(1260) =

13 The $ is called the reservation wage at time zero by the authors. This wage makes you indifferent between accepting a job at time zero and continuing the search into the next period. On a weekly basis the reservation wage is So, the only offer that should be rejected at time zero is the offer of 100. Ways the reservation wage - wr -can change 1) If there are out-of-pocket costs when not working then wr would be lower. In our example, if room and board is $100 per week then you would subtract the 100 from the ) Sources of nonlabor income like unemployment benefits increase wr. Say your parents pay your room and board the first week and give you 20. wr = ) wr changes if the payment distribution changes – we need to see the changes before more can be said about the impact. 4) wr changes if the probability distribution changes - wr rises if the distrubution becomes more disperse – similar to the Stigler story. 5) Wr is lower the longer you are unemployed. Consider waiting until time 2 to take a job The expected wage is then 980.

14 Because of the criticism of the fixed sample search model we said the focus should be on the wages offered and not the number of firms searched. In our graph we will switch from the number of firms searched on the horizontal axis to the value of the reservation wage. Our behavioral rule is still the same – continue to search until the mec = meb, but the connecting point is the reservation wage not the number of firms searched. More formal model Assume Searchers are unemployed No unemployment bennies or welfare Looking for a lifetime job Each period one firm is searched at a constant cost c Same wage offer distribution and cost occurs each period

15 Digress: the uniform distribution The uniform distribution is one where the probability of any set interval within the distribution is the same no matter where the interval is placed. As an example, say the arrival time of a plane from Chicago is uniform over the time period 1 hour after take-off to 1 hour and 30 minutes after take-off. The probability of landing between 1 hour and 5 minutes to 1 hour ten minutes after take-off would be the same as from 1 hour ten minutes to 1 hour 15 minutes after take-off = 1/6. minutes density 1/30 Probabilities are areas here. 5 minute intervals have an area = 1/6

16 Say wage offers are uniformly distributed over the range 0 to $1. In the graph below I have put in a value for wr arbitrarily, but we use it as a reference point. The probability a wage is above wr is 1-wr. The average wage above wr is (1+wr)/2, so the marginal expected benefit is (1-wr)(1+wr)/2 = ((1-wr)^2)/2. dollars 0 1 density 1 wr wr 1-wr

17 So in our example, if meb = ((1-wr)^2)/2 and if we have mec = c, then the point of equality is the wr where ((1-wr)^2)/2 = c, so wr* = 1-sqrt(2c). Remember this is just for the uniform distribution. We switch to the graph for the more general setting. $ wr c ((1-wr)^2)/2 wr*

18 Impact on the optimal reservation wage to changes in the world 1) Higher search cost – means wr* would be lower because the mec shifts up. 2) Bringing in nonlabor income and unemployment bennies here is like a lowering of the search cost – wr* rises. 3) If a wider distrubution of wage offers occurs then the probability of getting a high paying job rises and meb shifts right – so wr* rises. Implications for unemployment Some unemployment may be voluntary and may be good in the sense that the job ultimately taken has higher marginal product – meaning more output results.