Alan M. Garber, M.D., Ph.D. Center for Primary Care and Outcomes Research Center for Health Policy Stanford University VA Palo Alto Health Care System.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

System Wide Strategies: Controlling Costs Illinois Health Forum Chicago, Illinois December 7, 2005 Enrique Martinez-Vidal Deputy Director RWJFs State Coverage.

Advertisements

Health Care Spending Growth

THE COMMONWEALTH FUND You Cant Have One Without the Other: Bending the Healthcare Cost Curve & Financing Health Reform Rachel Nuzum Senior Policy Director,

THE COMMONWEALTH FUND Making Care More Efficient: Promising Innovations and Policy Options Karen Davis President The Commonwealth Fund Bipartisan Health.

Exhibit 1. National Health Expenditures per Capita, 1980–2007

THE COMMONWEALTH FUND 1 Bending the Curve: Options for Achieving Savings and Improving Value in Health Spending Cathy Schoen Senior Vice President The.

THE COMMONWEALTH FUND 1 We Can’t Continue on Our Current Path: Growth in the Uninsured Data: K. Davis, Changing Course: Trends in Health Insurance Coverage.

 The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act : How will ACA Impact Small Business? Sponsors: St. Tammany Democratic Parish Executive Committee (DPEC)

International Variations in Health Care Expenditure Todd Gilmer, PhD Professor of Health Policy and Economics Department of Family and Preventive Medicine.

Healthcare Reforms That Might Work Sam Clovis, Jr. Doctor of Public Administration Morningside College.

59%23% 4% Figure 1. Distribution of Health Insurance Coverage, New York State, 2004– million people Note: Data include all persons below age 65.

MEDICARE: PAST, PRESENT AND FUTURE James G. Anderson, Ph.D. Department of Sociology & Anthropology.

Value Based Insurance Design Michael Chernew Feb 22, 2008 Portions of this research were funded by Pfizer and GSK.

Health Care Reform 2009 – implications for you and your patients December 1, 2009.

Economic Challenges and New Medical Technologies Laurence Baker, Ph.D. Stanford University School of Medicine

Affordability: The New Imperative Northeastern University Open Classroom October 27, 2010 Andrew Dreyfus President & CEO Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts.

Medicare spending is 14% of the federal budget Total Federal Spending in 2013: $3.5 Trillion MEDICARE Medicaid Net interest Social Security Defense Nondefense.

The Benefits of Risk Factor Prevention in Americans Aged 51 Years and Older Dana P. Goldman, Federico Girosi et al. American Journal of Public Health November.

Trends In Health Care Industry KNH 413. Difficult questions What is health insurance? What is health care versus health insurance? Is one or both a right.

A Presentation of the Colorado Health Institute 303 E. 17 th Avenue, Suite 930 Denver, Colorado (Twitter)

Health Reform: Guaranteeing Medicare’s future while protecting older adults and people with disabilities.

Exhibit 2. Medicare Enrollment, 1970–2080 Enrollment in millions Source: Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, 2013 Annual Report of the Boards of.

Colorado Department of Health Care Policy and FinancingColorado Department of Health Care Policy and Financing Colorado Department of Health Care Policy.

Health Care Reform Quynh Smith. Sources of Inefficiency in the Health Care Delivery System   We spend a substantial amount on high cost, low-value treatments.

THE COMMONWEALTH FUND Exhibit ES-1. Community-Based Strategy for Improving Care of High-Cost Patients Community governance High-cost patients with multiple.

Health Care Reform Cost Savings Julie Sonier Director, Health Economics Program Minnesota Department of Health SCI Summer Meeting July 31, 2008.

Congressional Budget Office Presentation for the Bipartisan Policy Center Health Care: Capturing the Opportunity in the Nation's Core Fiscal Challenge.

Figure ES-1. Key Differences Between the Presidential Candidates’ Health Reform Plans McCainObama Aims to Cover EveryoneNot a GoalGoal Rules for Individual.

AAMC Contact: Jane Eilbacher Health Care Affairs National Health Expenditures 2009.

Comparison of Major Health Care Reform Proposals BushKerry Aims to Cover All Americans X Tax Credits for Premiums XX Automatic Enrollment/ Individual Mandate.

Health Care Reform in America Facing Up:. President Obama and Healthcare Reform “Health care reform is no longer just a moral imperative, it’s a fiscal.

Exhibit ES-1. Synergistic Strategy: Potential Cumulative Savings Compared with Current Baseline Projection, 2013–2023 Total NHE Federal government State.

Click to jump back to the Trivia machine Helpful trivia for the Do-It-Yourself health planner Increase your knowledge and plan a healthy life with healthy.

Exhibit 1. “Medicare Extra” Benefits vs. Current Medicare Benefits Current Medicare benefits*“Medicare Extra” Deductible Hospital: $1024/benefit period.

Value Based Insurance Design Michael Chernew Oct 10, 2008 Portions of this research were funded by Pfizer and GSK.

Congressional Budget Office Presentation to The Alliance for Health Reform Health Costs and Health Information Technology Peter Orszag Director June 20,

November 04, 2008 The Price of Medical Technology: The Industry Perspective David H. Nexon Senior Executive Vice President.

The Four Pillars of Retirement Security Social Security Pensions & Savings Earnings Health Insurance.

THE COMMONWEALTH FUND THE COMMONWEALTH FUND Reforming Provider Payment: Essential Building Block for Health Reform Stuart Guterman Assistant Vice President.

1 Comparative Effectiveness Research: Key Issues and Controversies Consumer-Purchaser Disclosure Project Discussion Forum May 5, 2009 Steven D. Pearson,

1 Private Health Insurance in the OECD The OECD Health Project Francesca Colombo, OECD Gastain, 7 October 2004

Source: Patrick Conway; Office of Information Products and Data Analytics, Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. Exhibit 1. All-Cause, 30-Day Hospital.

The future of Medicare fee-for- service Mark E. Miller, Ph.D. Executive Director Medicare Payment Advisory Commission October 16, 2006.

HEALTH REFORM IN THE 2004 ELECTION Candidates’ Health Policy Agendas Moderator : Jeanne Lambrew, George Washington University AcademyHealth National Health.

The Building Blocks of Health Reform: Achieving Universal Coverage and Health System Savings Cathy Schoen Senior Vice President, The Commonwealth Fund.

Health Care Reform in America. The Stats 47 million people in the US do not have health insurance 792,000 people in CO do not have insurance – 1/5 of.

1 Medicare Advantage: Choices Jeanne Lambrew, PhD Associate Professor, George Washington University / LBJ School Senior Fellow, Center for American Progress.

What Should Be Done About Medicare? Part I Ideas Changing the World John C. Goodman National Center for Policy Analysis.

THE HEALTHCARE ENVIRONMENT MERGERS AND CONSOLIDATION William S. Custer, Ph.D. April14, 2016.

Justine Strand de Oliveira, DrPH, PA-C. Objective: Describe the major features of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) that will impact.

Health Reform’s Cost Impact Can More be Done to Bend the Cost Curve?

Date of download: 7/9/2016 From: Achieving a High-Performance Health Care System with Universal Access: What the United States Can Learn from Other Countries.

Path to a High Performance U. S

State Innovation Models Initiative: Round One Awards

Health Care Reform in America

Relative Contributions of Different Types of Health Services to Total Growth in National Health Expenditures, NOTE: Percentages may not.

Relative Contributions of Different Types of Health Services to Total Growth in National Health Expenditures, NOTE: Percentages may not total.

Using an Episode-based payment model to improve oncology care

Net Impact of Insurance Exchange Options on Federal Budget and National Health Expenditures, 2010–2020 Option 1 Public Plan at Medicare Rates Option.

NHE in trillions 6.7% annual growth $5.2 $4.6 $ % annual growth

NHE Total Expenditures: $2,700.7 billion

Policy Options and Distribution of 10-Year Impact

Policies to Improve Care and Reduce Medicare Cost Growth

System Improvement Provisions of the Affordable Care Act

Projected Savings and Effectiveness of System Reform Provisions in House and Senate Reform Bills 2010–2019 (in billions) CBO Estimate of Budget Savings,

Path Estimate CBO Estimate OMB Estimate

Path Estimate CBO Estimate OMB Estimate

Major Sources of Savings Compared with Projected Spending, Net Cumulative Reduction of National Health Expenditures, 2010–2020 Dollars in billions Public.

Major Sources of Savings Compared with Projected Spending, Net Cumulative Reduction of National Health Expenditures, 2010–2020 Affordable Coverage for.

Net savings in $ billions 2013– –2023 Total 2013–2023

Presentation transcript:

Alan M. Garber, M.D., Ph.D. Center for Primary Care and Outcomes Research Center for Health Policy Stanford University VA Palo Alto Health Care System PCOR/CHP 10 th Anniversary Celebration September 16, 2008 CENTER FOR HEALTH POLICY CENTER FOR PRIMARY CARE AND OUTCOMES RESEARCH

CENTER FOR HEALTH POLICY CENTER FOR PRIMARY CARE AND OUTCOMES RESEARCH

Alan M. Garber, M.D., Ph.D. Center for Primary Care and Outcomes Research Center for Health Policy Stanford University VA Palo Alto Health Care System PCOR/CHP 10 th Anniversary Celebration September 16, 2008

Alan M. Garber, M.D., Ph.D. Center for Primary Care and Outcomes Research Center for Health Policy Stanford University VA Palo Alto Health Care System PCOR/CHP 10 th Anniversary Celebration September 16, 2008

Alan M. Garber, M.D., Ph.D. Center for Primary Care and Outcomes Research Center for Health Policy Stanford University VA Palo Alto Health Care System PCOR/CHP 10 th Anniversary Celebration September 16, 2008

Alan M. Garber, M.D., Ph.D. Center for Primary Care and Outcomes Research Center for Health Policy Stanford University VA Palo Alto Health Care System PCOR/CHP 10 th Anniversary Celebration September 16, 2008

Should we be concerned about rising health expenditures? It’s about value

Should we be concerned about rising health expenditures? According to economists,  Increased longevity since 1970 worth $95 trillion (3x health spending)  Improvements in health and physical function highly cost-effective

Decade1 yearCost Per Life-Year Gained* $36, $14, $62, $75,656 Sources: * Cutler, Rosen, and Vijan, 2006 Medical Progress: Cost Per Life Year Gained for a 45-Year-Old

Decade Undiscounted Life- Years* Discounted Life- Years** $36,086$166, $14,581$64, $62,234$158, $75,656$246,906 Sources: * Cutler, Rosen, and Vijan, 2006; ** Additional calculations by Allison Rosen Cost Per Life Year Gained for a 45-Year-Old: Undiscounted and Discounted Life-Years

Citizens of other nations are also living longer

U.S. may not be getting as much value for health care dollar as other nations

It’s also about the money

Medicare sources of non-interest income and expenditures as a percentage of Gross Domestic Product Source: Office of the Actuary, CMS; 2008 Medicare Trustees Report

Medicare sources of non-interest income and expenditures as a percentage of Gross Domestic Product Source: Office of the Actuary, CMS; 2008 Medicare Trustees Report Unfunded liability $7600 per working age adult* *In constant 2008 dollars

Why we spend more: the usual suspects

High prices High Prices

High prices High Prices

Misaligned incentives

Cutting costs

Cutting costs with little political pain

Promote electronic health records $77 billion annual savings (Obama advisers) $88 billion 10-year savings (Lewin group)

Reduce administrative costs $ 43 billion annual savings (Obama advisers)

Prevention and disease management: $81 billion annually (Obama health advisers); more than $493 billion over 10 years (Lewin Group)

Additional opportunities for savings INITIATIVE 10-YEAR SAVINGS “Comparative effectiveness” (Center for Medical Effectiveness) Align payment incentives Improved health insurance markets Limit health insurance tax exclusion $368 billion* $457 billion ???? *Lewin Associates calculations, in Bending the Curve, Commonwealth Fund Commission on a High Performance Health System, Dec. 2007

From Bending the Curve, Commonwealth Fund Commission on a High Performance Health System, Dec. 2007

Cost control efforts must cut growth rate to have lasting effects The key to sustained savings: better incentives based on better information

Medical interventions will need to be judged by the value they provide

COX-2 Inhibitors vs NSAIDS Change in costs Gain in health benefit (QALYs) Comparator: Naproxen $12k $6k $0 Source: Spiegel et al., The Cost-Effectiveness of Cyclooxygenase-2 Selective Inhibitors in the Management of Chronic Arthritis, Ann Intern Med. 2003;138: $100k per QALY

COX-2 Inhibitors vs NSAIDS Change in costs Gain in health benefit (QALYs) Comparator: Naproxen Assumption: Excludes effects on heart Change in cost: $11,600 Change in benefit: 0.04 QALYs Incremental CER: $290,000/QALY $12k $6k $0 Source: Spiegel et al., The Cost-Effectiveness of Cyclooxygenase-2 Selective Inhibitors in the Management of Chronic Arthritis, Ann Intern Med. 2003;138: $100k per QALY Basecase

COX-2 Inhibitors vs NSAIDS Change in costs Gain in health benefit (QALYs) Comparator: Naproxen Assumption: INCLUDES effects on heart Change in cost: $11,600 Change in benefit: 0.03 QALYs Incremental CER: $395,000/QALY $12k $6k $0 Source: Spiegel et al., The Cost-Effectiveness of Cyclooxygenase-2 Selective Inhibitors in the Management of Chronic Arthritis, Ann Intern Med. 2003;138: $100k per QALY Basecasew/ heart

COX-2 Inhibitors vs NSAIDS Change in costs Gain in health benefit (QALYs) Comparator: Naproxen Assumption: High-risk patients Change in cost: $4,720 Change in benefit: 0.08 QALYs Incremental CER: $56,000/QALY $12k $6k $0 Source: Spiegel et al., The Cost-Effectiveness of Cyclooxygenase-2 Selective Inhibitors in the Management of Chronic Arthritis, Ann Intern Med. 2003;138: $100k per QALY Basecasew/ heart High risk

Moving to a cost-effectiveness criterion shifts both expenditures and outcomes

Reducing expenditure growth in 2 steps

1. Better financing and payment Payment incentives for more effective and efficient care -will almost certainly require major IT investments -remove barriers to more effective payment mechanisms

2. Better information Produce comparative effectiveness and cost- effectiveness information

3. Better financing Modify tax exclusion for health insurance and health care More efficient markets for health insurance Better information about health plans

Value-enhancing innovation will be rewarded