NEW MADRID: A dying fault? GPS seismology geology Heat flow Recent data, taken together, suggest that the New Madrid seismic zone may be shutting down.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
(Introduction to) Earthquake Energy Balance
Advertisements

PLATE TECTONICS AS CONVECTION Plate tectonics is surface manifestation of convection cells in earth’s mantle. Ridges (spreading centers) mark upwelling,
Triggering of New Madrid Seismicity by Late Pleistocene Erosion Eric Calais & Andy Freed Purdue University Roy Van Arsdale, University of Memphis Seth.
Continental Drift.
TECTONIC PLATES. Tectonic plates are large areas of the Earth's crust that move slowly on the upper part of the mantle, often colliding and moving.
TECTONIC PLATES sublayers.
Dr. Benedikt Halldorsson
Geology of the Lithosphere 2. Evidence for the Structure of the Crust & Upper Mantle What is the lithosphere and what is the structure of the lithosphere?
Strength of the lithosphere: Constraints imposed by laboratory experiments David Kohlstedt Brian Evans Stephen Mackwell.
Numerical simulation of seismic cycles at a subduction zone with a laboratory-derived friction law Naoyuki Kato (1), Kazuro Hirahara (2), and Mikio Iizuka.
Since New Madrid's not moving... A complex system view of midcontinental seismicity and hazards Seth Stein Northwestern Eric Calais Purdue Qingsong Li.
NEW MADRID: A dying fault? GPS seismology geology Heat flow Recent data, taken together, suggest that the New Madrid seismic zone may be shutting down.
8/23/2011 Washington Post Mineral, VA, earthquake illustrates seismicity of a passive-aggressive margin Seth Stein 1, Frank Pazzaglia 2, Emily Wolin 1,
Using Geodetic Rates in Seismic Hazard Mapping March 30, Geodetic and Geologic slip rate estimates for earthquake hazard assessment in Southern California.
8: EARTHQUAKE SOURCE PARAMETERS
1 2 Outlines Earthquakes in the Manhattan area “Big” ones Small ones Earthquakes and earthquake hazard Causes of earthquakes Why Manhattan had earthquakes.
You must unlearn what you have learned. Alan Kafka 8. Faults switching on and off.
CONTRASTING SEISMIC RATES BETWEEN THE NEW MADRID AND WABASH VALLEY SEISMIC ZONES: STRESS TRANSFER OR AFTERSHOCKS? Miguel Merino, Seth Stein & Emile Okal.
Migrating earthquakes and faults switching on and off: a new view of intracontinental earthquakes Seth Stein Northwestern University Mian Liu University.
Time-dependent seismic hazard maps for the New Madrid seismic zone and Charleston, South Carolina areas James Hebden Seth Stein Department of Earth and.
TOPIC 2: How does the challenge of predicting hazards differ between earthquakes - at plate boundaries -In plate boundary zones -within plates?
Why North China is seismically active while South China remains largely aseismic? Youqing Yang & Mian Liu, Dept. of geol. University of Missouri-Columbia.
April Exploring a collaboration between Caltech and the Singaporean government Forecasting giant earthquakes of the Sumatran subduction zone and.
7. What’s going on at New Madrid? What’s under the Reelfoot rift? How can earthquakes happen there? Why do earthquakes happen there? DD 11.1.
UseIT Tutorial # 3 Earthquakes in the Southern California Fault System Tom Jordan June 16, 2011.
2007 NSTA: St. Louis, Missouri Earthquake Prediction and Forecasting: A Case Study of the San Andreas and New Madrid Faults Sponsored by: IRIS (Incorporated.
CHAPTER 12: EARTHQUAKES.
The Theory of Plate Tectonics
The Dynamic Earth Earth is composed of layers. The three main layers are the crust, mantle, and core. Earth’s outer layer has moved. At one time, the continents.
Earth Science: Plate Tectonics
Global Plate Tectonics n Plate Tectonics = Sea Floor Spreading + Continental drift n These two concepts came from separate sets of observations n The Plate.
The Hunting of the SNARF Giovanni F. Sella Seth Stein Northwestern University Timothy H. Dixon University of Miami "What's the good of Mercator's North.
Earthquakes (Chapter 13). Lecture Outline What is an earthquake? Seismic waves Epicenter location Earthquake magnitude Tectonic setting Hazards.
Searching for Long Duration Aftershocks in Continental Interiors Miguel Merino, Seth Stein Northwestern University.
Intraplate Seismicity Finite element modeling. Introduction Spatial patterns (Fig. 1) –Randomly scattered (Australia) –Isolated “seismic zones” (CEUS)
In the past ~15 years we’ve learned a lot and have new questions: Paleoseismology shows that continental intraplate seismicity often migrates, is episodic,
Cause of Earthquakes What is an Earthquake?
NE Caribbean and Hispaniola = major plate boundary, 2 cm/yr relative motion Strike-slip + convergence partitioned between 3 major fault systems Apparent.
Earthquake hazard isn’t a physical thing we measure. It's something mapmakers define and then use computer programs to predict. To decide how much to believe.
Fig Earthquakes and Earthquake Hazards. 3 Seismic waves allow us to look inside the Earth.
How Faulting Keeps Crust Strong? J. Townend & M.D. Zoback, 2000 Geology.
Attempting to Reconcile Holocene And Long-Term Seismicity Rates in the New Madrid Seismic Zone Mark Zoback – Stanford University NASA World Wind looking.
Time-variable Deformation in the New Madrid Seismic Zone (why there, why now?) Eric Calais, Andy Freed, Purdue University Seth Stein, Northwestern University.
Karen Felzer & Emily Brodsky Testing Stress Shadows.
Chapter 3 Plate Tectonics.
17.1 Structure of Earth VOCABULARY crust mantle lithosphere
Of EgyptSeismicity BadawyAhmed National Research Institute of Astronomy and Geophysics, Cairo, EGYPTHelwan Abstract. Spatial distribution of earthquake.
The influence of the geometry of the San Andreas fault system on earthquakes in California Qingsong Li and Mian Liu Geological Sciences, 101 Geol. Bldg.,
Clustering and Scattering of Intraplate Earthquakes in the NMSZ and Other Regions: Preliminary Results From Geodynamic Modeling Qingsong Li Lunar and Planetary.
GEOLOGY ASSIGNMENT BY DANNY HAMPTON. Subduction Subduction in the geological manner is the process that takes place as the boundaries of the Tectonic.
TECTONIC PLATES. UNDERSTANDING QUESTIONS 1. What are tectonic plates? 2. How many principal tectonic plates exist? 3. Which tectonic plates is Colombia.
A GPS-based view of New Madrid earthquake hazard Seth Stein, Northwestern University Uncertainties permit wide range (3X) of hazard models, some higher.
Earthquakes occur along faults. (Page 45)
Earthquakes and crustal Deformation - Objectives of class- Introduce a variety of techniques to describe ‘quantitatively’ deformation of the lithosphere.
Migrating earthquakes and faults switching on and off: a new view of intracontinental earthquakes Seth Stein Northwestern University Mian Liu University.
EART 118 Seismotectonics MWF D250 9:30-10:40 am; Th D250 2:00-4:00 pm Prof.: Thorne Lay, C382 E&MS, Office Hours 11:00-12:00 MWF TA: Lingling Ye, Office.
9. As hazardous as California? USGS/FEMA: Buildings should be built to same standards How can we evaluate this argument? Frankel et al., 1996.
You must unlearn what you have learned. Alan Kafka 8. Faults switching on and off.
Plate Tectonics Sections 17.3 and 17.4
Continental drift and plate tectonics. Continental Drift Modern scientists consider the age of the Earth to be around 4.54 billion years Over that time.
°PINTO -\ Limitations of a Young Science The centennial of the 1906 San Francisco earthquake is a natu-ral rime to reflect on the past, present, and future.
Seth Stein Northwestern University Timothy Dixon University of Miami
Earth’s Interior =mOSpRzW2i_4.
BREVIA Time-Variable Deformation in the New Madrid Seismic Zone Eric Calais 1 and Seth Stein 2 velocities relative to the rigid interior ofNorth Amer-
Comparison of Seismicity Rates in the New Madrid and Wabash Valley Seismic Zones Miguel Merino, ' Seth Stein, ' Mian Liu, 2 and Emile A. Okal ' The Wabash.
The Charlevoix Seismic Zone
RECENT SEISMIC MONITORING RESULTS FROM THE CENTRAL
Section 3: Plate Boundaries
The Dynamic Earth 17 Earth is composed of layers.
Seismic Waves Seismology
Presentation transcript:

NEW MADRID: A dying fault? GPS seismology geology Heat flow Recent data, taken together, suggest that the New Madrid seismic zone may be shutting down after the recent cluster of large earthquakes in the past ~1000 years. If so, it will be a very long time until the large earthquakes of recur. ?? 9k7k6k4k12k3k1kToday Portageville CycleReelfoot CycleNew Madrid Cycle Slip Cluster Slip Cluster Slip Cluster Quiescent Holocene Punctuated Slip New Madrid earthquake history inferred from Mississippi river channels Holbrook et al., 2006

GPS measurements show that the ground is barely moving or isn’t moving, so little or no strain is building up for a future earthquake The small earthquakes we see today look like aftershocks of the large earthquakes The New Madrid zone doesn’t look thermally or mechanically different from many other structures in the central U.S. Geological data show that the New Madrid zone goes through pulses of activity The simplest explanation is that the present pulse is ending A DYING FAULT? In the past 15 years we’ve learned:

GPS SITES SHOW LITTLE OR NO MOTION Motions with respect to the rigid North American plate are small, < 2 mm/yr, and generally within their error ellipses. The data do not require motion, and restrict any motion to being very slow. Thus a very long time would be needed to store up the slip needed for a future large earthquake For steady motion, M 7 is at least hundreds of years away. M 8 would thousands. Stein 2007

NEW MADRID SEISMICITY: AFTERSHOCKS? Ongoing seismicity looks like aftershocks of , as suggested by the fact that the rate & size are decreasing. Moreover, the largest are at the ends of the presumed ruptures Looks like a dying fault? Stein & Newman, 1994

Dieterich (1994) model relates ratio of aftershock length to main shock recurrence t a / t r  1/stressing rate For low intraplate stressing rate, could have 200 year aftershocks for 500 yr recurrence Hence large style events may not recur here for a very long time, but could migrate elsewhere. INTERPLATE EARTHQUAKES ROCK MECHANICS CONSISTENT WITH LONG INTRAPLATE AFTERSHOCK SEQUENCES Stein & Newman, 1994

?? 9k7k6k4k12k3k1kToday Portageville CycleReelfoot CycleNew Madrid Cycle Slip Cluster Slip Cluster Slip Cluster Quiescent Holocene Punctuated Slip New Madrid earthquake history inferred from Mississippi river channels Holbrook et al., 2006 GEOLOGY IMPLIES NEW MADRID EARTHQUAKES ARE EPISODIC & CLUSTERED The absence of significant fault topography, and other geological data, imply that the recent pulse of activity is only a few thousand years old. This is consistent with results from other continental interiors showing episodic & clustered earthquakes

o Historical o Instrumental NEW MADRID SEISMICITY: EPISODIC & MIGRATING? Why are NMSZ earthquakes concentrated on the Reelfoot Rift, when the continent contains many fossil structures that seem equally likely candidates for concentrated seismicity? Liu & Zoback (1997) suggest the NMSZ is hotter and thus weaker than surrounding regions, so the weak lower crust and mantle concentrate stress and seismicity here in the upper crust. Alternatively, if the NMSZ is not significantly hotter and weaker than its surroundings, seismicity is likely to be episodic and migrate among many similar fossil weak zones. M. Liu

NMSZ NOT HOT & WEAK Liu & Zoback (1997) argue that NMSZ heat flow is ~ 15 mW/m 2 higher than the surrounding area, so crust and upper mantle are significantly hotter and thus weaker than surroundings. Reanalysis finds the anomaly is either zero or much smaller (3+/-23 mW/m 2 ), so the NMSZ and CEUS have essentially the same temperature & strength. Hence there is no tendency for upper crustal stresses to concentrate in the NMSZ. Liu & Zoback, 1997 McKenna et al., 2007

GPS, seismological, geologic, & geothermal data are consistent with the NMSZ shutting down after the recent cluster of large events The longer geodetic data show essentially no motion, the more likely it seems that the fault is shutting down Seismicity may migrate to somewhere else Hazard from style large events may be small for thousands of years In this case, the seismic hazard from large style events should be viewed as lower and diffuse rather than high and concentrated near the rupture.