Forward Jet Production at HERA, Patrick Ryan, Univ. of Wisconsin EPS2005, July 21, 2005 - 1 Patrick Ryan University of Wisconsin On Behalf of the H1 and.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Low x meeting, Sinai Alice Valkárová on behalf of H1 collaboration LOW x meeting 2005, Sinaia H1 measurements of the structure of diffraction.
Advertisements

Interjet Energy Flow. Patrick Ryan, Univ. of Wisconsin Collaboration Meeting, June 6, Patrick Ryan University of Wisconsin Claire Gwenlan Oxford.
ISDM 2005, Kromeriz Kamil Sedlak, Jets in photoproduction at HERA 1 Jets in Photoproduction & at low Q 2 at HERA On behalf of the H1 and ZEUS Collaborations.
1 Pierre Marage Univ. Libre de Bruxelles On behalf of the H1 and ZEUS collaborations Diffraction at HERA CIPANP 2006 Puerto-Rico 29/5-4/6/2006.
QCD Studies at HERA Ian C. Brock Bonn University representing the ZEUS and H1 Collaborations.
Karlheinz Meier - Kirchhof-Institut für Physik - Heidelberg University - Vth Workshop on Small-x and Diffractive Physics - Fermilab - September 2002 Odderon.
25 th of October 2007Meeting on Diffraction and Forward Physics at HERA and the LHC, Antwerpen 1 Factorization breaking in diffraction at HERA? Alice Valkárová.
Interjet Energy Flow at ZEUS. Patrick Ryan. Univ. of Wisconsin DPF, Aug. 27, Patrick Ryan University of Wisconsin Aug. 27, 2004 Interjet Energy.
Ursula Bassler, LPNHE-Paris, RUN II MC workshop 1 Monte Carlo Tuning: The HERA Experience Monte Carlo Models for DIS events Description of inclusive hadronic.
Erik MaddoxBEACH 2004, Chicago1 Heavy flavour production at HERA Outline: Introduction Charm production Beauty production Conclusions Erik Maddox (NIKHEF/UvA)
M.KapishinDiffraction using Proton Spectrometers at HERA 1 Results on Diffraction using Proton Spectrometers at HERA Low-x Meeting: Paphos, Cyprus, June.
1 Methods of Experimental Particle Physics Alexei Safonov Lecture #14.
Inclusive Jets in ep Interactions at HERA, Mónica V á zquez Acosta (UAM) HEP 2003 Europhysics Conference in Aachen, July 19, Mónica Luisa Vázquez.
PIC 2001 Michael Strauss The University of Oklahoma Recent Results on Jet Physics and  s XXI Physics in Collision Conference Seoul, Korea June 28, 2001.
Luca Stanco - PadovaQCD at HERA, LISHEP pQCD  JETS Luca Stanco – INFN Padova LISHEP 2006 Workshop Rio de Janeiro, April 3-7, 2006 on behalf of.
Experimental Tests of the BFKL Mechanism Zarah Casilum State University of New York at Stony Brook for the D0 Collaboration 1997 Joint April APS/AAPT Meeting.
T. Schörner-Sadenius: Jets at HERA JETS IN ep AND γp INTERACTIONS AT HERA Thomas Schörner-Sadenius Hamburg University Photon 2005, Warsaw.
Working Group C: Hadronic Final States David Milstead The University of Liverpool Review of Experiments 27 experiment and 11 theory contributions.
1 Jets in diffraction and factorization at HERA Alice Valkárová Charles University, Prague On behalf of H1 and ZEUS collaborations.
Mean Charged Multiplicity in DIS, Michele Rosin U. WisconsinZEUS Monday Meeting, Apr. 18th Preliminary Request: Mean Charged Multiplicity in DIS.
16/04/2004 DIS2004 WGD1 Jet cross sections in D * photoproduction at ZEUS Takanori Kohno (University of Oxford) on behalf of the ZEUS Collaboration XII.
V. Chiochia DIS 2003 Workshop Production of beauty quarks in deep inelastic scattering at HERA XI International Workshop on Deep Inelastic Scattering St.
T. Schörner-Sadenius: Jets at HERA JETS IN ep AND γp INTERACTIONS AT HERA Thomas Schörner-Sadenius Hamburg University Photon 2005, Warsaw.
NEW RESULTS FROM JET PHYSICS AT HERA Thomas Schörner-Sadenius Hamburg University 2 nd HERA-LHC Workshop June 2006.
DIJET (and inclusive-jet) CROSS SECTIONS IN DIS AT HERA T. Schörner-Sadenius (for the ZEUS collaboration) Hamburg University DIS 06, April 2006 Tsukuba,
LISHEP Rio de Janeiro1 Factorization in diffraction Alice Valkárová Charles University, Prague On behalf of H1 and ZEUS collaborations.
7 th April 2003PHOTON 2003, Frascati1 Photon structure as revealed in ep collisions Alice Valkárová Institute of Particle and Nuclear Physics Charles University.
Inclusive Diffraction at HERA Marcella Capua – INFN and Calabria University Small X and Diffraction FNAL Chicago (USA) 17 – 20 September 2003 on behalf.
QCD Dynamics in low-x DIS T. Danielson, U. WisconsinRencontres de Moriond, March 22, Results from ZEUS and H1 Tom Danielson University of Wisconsin.
DIS Conference, Madison WI, 28 th April 2005Jeff Standage, York University Theoretical Motivations DIS Cross Sections and pQCD The Breit Frame Physics.
B. Naroska Un. Hamburg Beauty at HERA HEP05 Lisbon 21/07/ Beauty Production at HERA HEP05 International Europhysics Conference on High Energy Physics.
Hard QCD and heavy flavour production at HERA (on behalf of H1 and ZEUS) A. Rostovtsev Charm production Multijet production Running α s and quark masses.
Hadron Structure 2009 Factorisation in diffraction Alice Valkárová Charles University, Prague Representing H1 and ZEUS experiments Hadron structure.
Event Shapes, Alexander Savin University of WisconsinDIS 2006, April 21, Event Shapes in NC DIS at ZEUS Alexander A. Savin University of Wisconsin.
Isabell-A. Melzer-Pellmann Photon 2005, Diffractive interactions in ep collisions Diffractive interactions in ep collisions Isabell-Alissandra.
1 Diffractive dijets at HERA Alice Valkárová Charles University, Prague Representing H1 and ZEUS experiments.
Jets and α S in DIS Maxime GOUZEVITCH Laboratoire Leprince-Ringuet Ecole Polytechnique – CNRS/IN2P3, France On behalf of the collaboration On behalf of.
DIJET (and inclusive-jet) CROSS SECTIONS IN DIS AT HERA T. Schörner-Sadenius (for the ZEUS collaboration) Hamburg University DIS 06, April 2006 Tsukuba,
Recent multiplicity studies at ZEUS, Michele Rosin U. WisconsinHadron Structure 2004, Sept. 1st University of Wisconsin, Madison on behalf of the.
K 0 S and  production at ZEUS, A. Savin, University of Wisconsin DIS 2006, April 22, K 0 S and  production at ZEUS Alexander A. Savin University.
Measurement of inclusive jet and dijet production in pp collisions at √s = 7 TeV using the ATLAS detector Seminar talk by Eduardo Garcia-Valdecasas Tenreiro.
Isabell-A. Melzer-Pellmann DIS 2007 Charm production in diffractive DIS and PHP at ZEUS Charm production in diffractive DIS and PHP at ZEUS Isabell-Alissandra.
1 Heavy Flavour Content of the Proton Motivation Experimental Techniques charm and beauty cross sections in DIS for the H1 & ZEUS Collaborations Paul Thompson.
Charged Particle Multiplicity, Michele Rosin U. WisconsinQCD Meeting May 13, M. Rosin, D. Kçira, and A. Savin University of Wisconsin L. Shcheglova.
1 Forward Jet/  0 Production in DIS at HERA On behalf of the H1 and ZEUS Collaborations ICHEP August 2004, Beijing Didar Dobur, University of Freiburg.
A. Bertolin on behalf of the H1 and ZEUS collaborations Charm (and beauty) production in DIS at HERA (Sezione di Padova) Outline: HERA, H1 and ZEUS heavy.
Mean Charged Multiplicity in DIS, Michele Rosin U. WisconsinZEUS Collaboration Meeting, Oct. 21st Analysis Update: Mean Charged Multiplicity in.
Costas Foudas, Imperial College, Jet Production at High Transverse Energies at HERA Underline: Costas Foudas Imperial College
Modern Approach to Monte Carlo’s (L1) The role of resolution in Monte Carlo’s (L1) Leading order Monte Carlo’s (L1) Next-to-Leading order Monte Carlo’s.
Luca Stanco - PadovaLow-x at HERA, Small-x Low-x AND Low Q 2 Luca Stanco – INFN Padova Small-x and Diffraction 2007 Workshop FermiLab, March 28-30,
1 Proton Structure Functions and HERA QCD Fit HERA+Experiments F 2 Charged Current+xF 3 HERA QCD Fit for the H1 and ZEUS Collaborations Andrew Mehta (Liverpool.
Inclusive jet photoproduction at HERA B.Andrieu (LPNHE, Paris) On behalf of the collaboration Outline: Introduction & motivation QCD calculations and Monte.
Event Shapes in NC DIS at ZEUS
Small-x Physics and Diffraction: HERA Results
Charged Particle Multiplicity in DIS
Charged Particle Multiplicity in DIS
Open Heavy Flavour Production at HERA
Color Glass Condensate : Theory and Phenomenology
Diffraction in ep collisions
DIS 2004 XII International Workshop
Analysis Update: Mean Charged Multiplicity in DIS
Inclusive Jet Cross Section Measurement at CDF
Di-jet production in gg collisions in OPAL
Parton Dynamics at Low Bjorken x in Deep Inelastic Scattering at HERA
K0S and L production at ZEUS
Preliminary Request: Mean Charged Multiplicity in DIS
Heavy Flavour Content of the Proton
Diffractive PDF fits and factorisation tests at HERA
Outline of the talk: ● Introduction ● QCD models
Fc2 measurements at HERA New trends in HERA Physics, Ringberg 2008
Presentation transcript:

Forward Jet Production at HERA, Patrick Ryan, Univ. of Wisconsin EPS2005, July 21, Patrick Ryan University of Wisconsin On Behalf of the H1 and ZEUS Collaborations Forward Jet Production at HERA HEP2005 Europhysics Conference Lisbon, Portugal

Forward Jet Production at HERA, Patrick Ryan, Univ. of Wisconsin EPS2005, July 21, Parton Evolution Equations Perturbative expansion of evolution equations ~  mn A mn ln(Q 2 ) m ln(1/x) n Cannot be explicitly calculated to all orders Equations to calculate QCD evolution DGLAP - Resum in ln(Q 2 ):  (  s ln Q 2 ) n BFKL - Resum in ln(1/x):  (  s ln 1/x) n CCFM - Resum in ln(Q 2 ) and ln (1/x) Regions of validity DGLAP - Large Q 2, x not small BFKL - Small x, Q 2 not too large CCFM - Valid in large x range

Forward Jet Production at HERA, Patrick Ryan, Univ. of Wisconsin EPS2005, July 21, Parton Evolution Equations Gluon Ladder DGLAP Strongly ordered in trans momentum: k T,1 << k T,2 << … << k T,n << Q 2 Ordered in x: x 1 > x 2 > … > x n > x BFKL: Strongly ordered in x: x 1 >> x 2 >> … >> x n >> x No k T ordering  Eta democracy Predicts additional hadrons from high p T forward partons Experiments: Try to distinguish between evolution equations DGLAPBFKL Strong k T ordering Strong x ordering x ordering No k T ordering Highest k T Lowest x Lowest k T Highest x Lowest x Highest x

Forward Jet Production at HERA, Patrick Ryan, Univ. of Wisconsin EPS2005, July 21, Investigate New Parton Dynamics DGLAP Evolution expected to describe most of HERA kinematic range Find region where DGLAP not guaranteed to be valid Search for signs of BFKL dynamics Suppress events strongly ordered in virtuality Require Jet p T 2 ~ Q 2 Require large E Jet /E Proton Forward Jet (close to Proton) BFKL predicts larger fraction of small x events will contain high E T events than DGLAP Can also tag forward Particles P

Forward Jet Production at HERA, Patrick Ryan, Univ. of Wisconsin EPS2005, July 21, Monte Carlo and Calculations Monte Carlo LEPTO Parton shower: k T ordered (MEPS) – Uses DGLAP RAPGAP Parton shower: k T ordered (MEPS) – Uses DGLAP Direct  interactions similar to LEPTO Includes resolved  interactions ARIADNE Parton shower: Color Dipole Model (CDM) – BFKL like CASCADE Based on CCFM Set1: k  cut = 1.33 GeV Set2: k  cut = 1.88 GeV and non-singular terms in spliting function included All models use Lung String Model for Hadronization NLO QCD Calculations DISENT Fixed order  s 2

Forward Jet Production at HERA, Patrick Ryan, Univ. of Wisconsin EPS2005, July 21, Forward Jet Production at HERA H1 Collaboration Inclusive Forward Jet Production DISENT NLO Calculations and RAPGAP (DGLAP) with only direct  below data Disagreement at low x RAPGAP resolved  model improves agreement Still disagreement at low x  Hint of BFKL dynamics? ARIANDE (“BFKL-like”) MC and RAPGAP Direct + Resolved (DGLAP) slightly below forward jet data CASCADE (CCFM) MC gives poor description of forward jet data Data vs. NLOData vs. MC

Forward Jet Production at HERA, Patrick Ryan, Univ. of Wisconsin EPS2005, July 21, Forward Jet Production at HERA ZEUS Collaboration BFKL Phase Space (O  s 2  ) ARIADNE (“BFKL”) describes forward jet data, LEPTO (DGLAP) does not NLO gives better description of forward jet data than in inclusive region Disagreement still present at low x Disagreement between LO and NLO  large corrections from higher order terms BFKL Forward Phase Space ARIADNE (“BFKL”) describes forward jet data, LEPTO (DGLAP) does not NLO slightly lower than forward jet data Disagreement between LO and NLO much bigger than in BFKL Phase Space Need for higher order calculations BFKL Phase Space cos(  had ) < 0 0 <  Jet < < E T 2 /Q 2 < 2 BFKL “Forward” Phase Space cos(  had ) < 0 0 <  Jet < < E T 2 /Q 2 < 2 2 <  Jet < 3 LEPTO ARIADNE LO: O(  s 1 ) NLO: O(  s 2 ) LEPTO NLO: O(  s 2 ) ARIADNE LO: O(  s 1 )

Forward Jet Production at HERA, Patrick Ryan, Univ. of Wisconsin EPS2005, July 21, Very Forward Jets at HERA Data vs. MC (ZEUS) Very Forward  region 2  Jet < 3.5 Previous H1:  Jet < 2.7 Previous ZEUS:  Jet < 3.0 ARIADNE describes forward jet data LEPTO does not describe data Large disagreement at low Q 2, x CASCADE Set 1 Does not describe data CASCADE Set 2 Good description of Q 2 and E T Jet Reasonable description of x and  Data vs. MC

Forward Jet Production at HERA, Patrick Ryan, Univ. of Wisconsin EPS2005, July 21, Very Forward Jets at HERA Data vs. NLO (ZEUS) Very Forward  Region 2  Jet < 3.5 DISENT NLO Describes forward jets data within theoretical uncertainties Large variation with renormalization scale Suggests need for higher order calculations Data vs. NLO

Forward Jet Production at HERA, Patrick Ryan, Univ. of Wisconsin EPS2005, July 21, Forward Jet with Central Dijets H1 Collaboration 2 High-E T central jets in addition to forward jet Jets ordered in  :  fwd-Jet >  Jet2 >  Jet1 >  electron  separation Between central jets:  1 =  Jet2 –  Jet1 Between hadronic system & forward jet:  2 =  fwd-Jet –  Jet2 Suppress strong k T ordering by demanding same p T cut for 3 Jets Selects “BFKL region”  1 < 1 Maximize BFKL phase space  1 >1 Separation btw central & forward jets smaller  resolved photon region  1 < 1  1 > 1

Forward Jet Production at HERA, Patrick Ryan, Univ. of Wisconsin EPS2005, July 21, Forward Jet with Central Dijets Data vs. Models (H1)  2 Cross Section RAPGAP Direct + Resolved (DGLAP) Below data for All  1 and  1 < 1 Agrees with data only in highest bin of  1 > 1 LEPTO (BFKL-like) Better agreement for  1 1 CASCADE (CCFM) Set 1 does not describe data in any region Set 2 Describes data for  1 1

Forward Jet Production at HERA, Patrick Ryan, Univ. of Wisconsin EPS2005, July 21, Forward  0 Production at HERA p T Distributions (H1) Measure  0 instead of Jets No ambiguities from Jet algorithm Larger uncertainities from hadronization BFKL Region: Particle p T 2 ~ Q 2 Cross Section p T  Data falls steeply as p T  increases RAPGAP Dir+Res describes  0 data RAPGAP Dir only below  0 data ARIADNE describes  0 data CASCADE Good description at higher Q 2 Poor description at lower Q 2 p T  Cross Section

Forward Jet Production at HERA, Patrick Ryan, Univ. of Wisconsin EPS2005, July 21, Forward  0 Production at HERA x Distributions (H1) x Cross Section RAPGAP Direct + Resolved describe  0 data well RAPGAP Direct only below  0 data CASCADE describes  0 data only at high x and Q 2 Discrepancies at low x not covered by Forward Jet measurement x Cross Section with p T  > 3.5 GeV Cross Sections 2-4 times lower NLO calculation describes data x Cross Section with p T  > 2.5 GeV x Cross Section with p T  > 3.5 GeV

Forward Jet Production at HERA, Patrick Ryan, Univ. of Wisconsin EPS2005, July 21, Forward Jet Summary BFKL Region Selected Forward Jets with Jet p T 2 ~ Q 2 Forward  0 with Particle p T 2 ~ Q 2 Forward Jet + central dijets with  separations Summary of Agreement between Data and Predictions MC which describe data ARIADNE (BFKL-like) RAPGAP (DGLAP) Direct + Resolved (except fwd+dijet) MC which do not describe data LEPTO (DGLAP) RAPGAP (DGLAP) Direct only CASCADE (CCFM) NLO gives good description of data Higher order calculations needed to improve agreement Conclusions DGLAP works everywhere except forward + central dijets Can improve MC agreement with data with any or all of Direct and resolved contributions of DGLAP MC BFKL-like MC NLO