What are the main criticisms economists make of EU biofuels policy? Kevin Lynch Economics of Food Markets Tuesday, 16 th January 2008 Trinity College,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 Drivers for biofuel Energy security – Diversification Self-sufficiency Climate change Agriculture and rural development Support for domestic farmers.
Advertisements

Session 1. Gather practical experience gained with the cultivation of traditional bioenergy crops in the Mediterranean with respect to their environmental.
Land use for bioenergy production – assessing the production potentials and the assumptions of EU bioenergy policy Trends and Future of Sustainable Development.
Protectionism and Free Trade
Arno Becker Institute for Food and Resource Economics (ILR), University of Bonn ImpactsMarket development Policy measures Policy objectives Leading to.
The impact of the rebound effect of first generation biofuel use in the EU on greenhouse gas emissions 17 th ICABR Conference, 19 June 2013 Edward Smeets,
Lecture Debate on free trade
The Choice for Agriculture A vision on the future of Dutch agriculture Gerrit Meester Ministry of Agriculture, Nature and Food Quality Utrecht, 24 February.
Critical Issues Forum Ross Harding Savannah October 14 th 2008.
Renewable Energy Directive Øyvind Vessia Policy Officer European Commission, DG Energy – Renewables and CCS Policy.
EU Biofuel Policy and Development Christopher Stevens Presentation to International Consulting Economists’ Association, 12 February 2008.
Biofuels ECON 373 March 26, Reference Bruce Gardner and Wallace Tyner. “Explorations in Biofuels Economics, Policy and History: Introduction to.
Session 1. Gather practical experience gained with the cultivation of traditional bioenergy crops in the Mediterranean with respect to their environmental.
ENFA Model ENFA Kick-off Meeting Hamburg, 10 May 2005.
Bio-Fuels Project & Industry Introduction Dr. Dawne Martin College of Business July 25, 2012.
International Trade “The Basics”.
Carbon Taxes, Climate Change, and Sustainable Development Tariq Banuri Stockholm Environment Institute June 2008.
1 Sustainable Agriculture strategy Zurich 8 th June 2011 Neil la Croix Director of Supply Chains.
RURAL FUTURES: ALTERNATIVE ECONOMIES Dr Jane Adams.
International Trade. Why do countries trade? Wider consumer choice and lower prices due to increased competition Firms have access to larger markets,
Common Agricultural Policy - FoEE FoEE meeting Monor May 2009 o Europe is a big player o CAP is at the heart of EU food system o What is FoEE going to.
Heat and Energy Saving 02 March 2009 John Russell
Liberalization of Trade in Biofuels: Implications for GHG Emissions and Social Welfare Xiaoguang Chen Madhu Khanna Hayri Önal University of Illinois at.
US and Global Energy Prospects, Biofuels, and Future Policy Alternatives Wally Tyner.
US Forest Service GHG and Energy Modeling Climate and Energy Policy: The Role of Forests Rob Doudrick US Forest Service Research and Development.
Lecture 2 – Global Trends in Agriculture EconS350 Fall Semester, 2010.
Global Inflation and Policy Responses Romuald Semblat International Monetary Fund June 2008.
Anni Podimata MEP Member, Committee on Industry, Research and Energy 8th Inter-Parliamentary Meeting on Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency Budapest,
The Science and Economics of Climate Change Based on presentations by John Houghton of IPCC, Earthguage, the Met. Office and the Stern Review.
The Food Crisis and the Region: Evidence and challenges Enrique Aldaz-Carroll “World Bank-CSO East Asia Pacific Regional Workshop” Jakarta, June 18, 2008.
Market/Non-market Instruments; and ODA Side event on The Second Quito Dialogue on Scaling up Finance for Biodiversity at CBD/COP 12, 6th October, Pyeongchang,
Supply (The Business Point of View) Another Key Economic Concept.
The Common Agricultural Policy - the UK View Claire Wilding British Embassy Paris.
PRINCIPLES OF MACROECONOMICS LECTURE 11 ECONOMICS OF PROTECTIONISM.
Industry Outlook November Manufacturing Matters in Canada  A $620 billion industry  12% of GDP (18% in 2004)  1.7.
Fair Play in Food & Farming: Linking Sustainability Trends Presentation to Food and Fairness Inquiry Second hearing - ‘Fair Play’: Inequalities of opportunity.
Chapter 17.  Resource Distribution and Specialization  Natural Resources  Capital and Labor  Unequal Resource Distribution  Specialization and Trade.
Dutch Reference Outlook Energy and Greenhouse Gases Remko Ybema, ECN Policy Studies Workshop on Energy-related National and EU-Wide Projections.
International Trade Created by: Ms. Daniel. We talk about trade in terms of trade between nations, but the actual trade is between individuals and businesses.
Biofuel Policy: Livestock Emissions Emission reduction (mmtce) Biofuel carbon price (Euro/tce) Total Livestock.
Energy Information for a Sustainable Energy System – IFEG 24 May 2007 Catherine Mitchell Warwick Business School
International Consultation on Pro-Poor Jatropha Development IFAD Rome April 2008 Richard Burge Kimberley Burge Ltd and Commissioner for Rural Communities.
Economics Journal Global Economics Week of Nov
Protectionism A2 Economics Unit 4. Aims and Objectives Aim: Understand protectionism Objectives: Define protectionism Explain methods of protectionism.
The Brazilian Ethanol Program Lessons Learned and Perspectives Presentation to: Latin America 2007 Texas A&M University Renato T Bertani Thompson & Knight.
What Is International Trade?  International trade is the exchange of goods and services between countries.  This type of trade gives rise to a world.
European Commission Enterprise and Industry 1 The High Level Group on the Competitiveness of the European Chemicals Industry European Social Dialogue in.
Application: International Trade
Biofuels – Campaign context Big Ask has been all about a strong Climate Change Bill. Now it’s time to start looking at solutions as well as some of the.
Energy security issues and policy implications: Topics within the scope of the study Geopolitical considerations of energy supply/delivery/use – Implications.
 Meat  Population  Grain  Money  Water  Ethanol  Air  Temperature  Climate  Drought  Oil.
National and regional policies that limit the development and implementation of new, innovative technologies and further exacerbate the energy-water nexus.
Protectionism 4.1 Globalisation.
The Economics of Energy, The Environment, and Global Climate Change
Comparative Advantage and International Trade
Why do China buy 80% of luxury goods abroad?
Types of Economies.
CEESA WP4: Market Development and Public Regulation
International Trade.
The EU’s CAP and the likely impact of a Doha Agreement
Outline Energy demand and prices Reserves and new sources of energy supply.
Trade Overview.
HW 1 Questions and Answers.
International Trade.
Big Oil, Big Prices FTE.
Jason Bordoff, Policy Director Hamilton Project, Brookings Institution
The Low Carbon Fuel Standard
Nürnberg, 21 February 2008 | Othmar Schwank
® ® Climate Change Action Policy
Presentation transcript:

What are the main criticisms economists make of EU biofuels policy? Kevin Lynch Economics of Food Markets Tuesday, 16 th January 2008 Trinity College, Dublin

Motivations for Policies 1. Climate Change 2. Energy Security: unstable or unfavourable regimes, rising prices, peak oil 3. Rural development

Incorrect tools Demand side measures A Carbon Tax? Climate Change – reduces carbon directly Security conservation Budgetary pressures of subsidies Uncertainity Command and control if inefficient and proposes a solution rather than identifies a problem

General Equilibrium Approach Life cycles Complex interactions with food and energy markets Technically complex – factor markets Opportunity cost with food

Trade policy Protectionism flourishing Simulations show a strong link between trade and development of bio-fuels Favouring home grown solutions – a new CAP? Infant Industry argument Time scale Feasibility