Climate Change and Extreme Wave Heights in the North Atlantic Peter Challenor, Werenfrid Wimmer and Ian Ashton Southampton Oceanography Centre.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Introduction to modelling extremes
Advertisements

Introduction to modelling extremes Marian Scott (with thanks to Clive Anderson, Trevor Hoey) NERC August 2009.
Analyzing Data (C2-5 BVD) C2-4: Categorical and Quantitative Data.
Contingency Tables Chapters Seven, Sixteen, and Eighteen Chapter Seven –Definition of Contingency Tables –Basic Statistics –SPSS program (Crosstabulation)
PRESENTS: FORECASTING FOR OPERATIONS AND DESIGN February 16 th 2011 – Aberdeen.
Welcome to the World of Investigative Tasks
Analysis of Extremes in Climate Science Francis Zwiers Climate Research Division, Environment Canada. Photo: F. Zwiers.
Quantile Estimation for Heavy-Tailed Data 23/03/2000 J. Beirlant G. Matthys
Introduction to Hypothesis Testing
Extremes ● An extreme value is an unusually large – or small – magnitude. ● Extreme value analysis (EVA) has as objective to quantify the stochastic behavior.
P-Values for Hypothesis Testing About  With  Known.
Statistics and Probability Theory Prof. Dr. Michael Havbro Faber
Spatial-Temporal Modelling of Extreme Rainfall
Chi-square notes. What is a Chi-test used for? Pronounced like kite, not like cheese! This test is used to check if the difference between expected and.
Sequence comparison: Significance of similarity scores Genome 559: Introduction to Statistical and Computational Genomics Prof. James H. Thomas.
Stress testing and Extreme Value Theory By A V Vedpuriswar September 12, 2009.
Psy B07 Chapter 1Slide 1 ANALYSIS OF VARIANCE. Psy B07 Chapter 1Slide 2 t-test refresher  In chapter 7 we talked about analyses that could be conducted.
Review of Statistical Inference Prepared by Vera Tabakova, East Carolina University ECON 4550 Econometrics Memorial University of Newfoundland.
Common Probability Distributions in Finance. The Normal Distribution The normal distribution is a continuous, bell-shaped distribution that is completely.
STATISTIC & INFORMATION THEORY (CSNB134) MODULE 2 NUMERICAL DATA REPRESENTATION.
© Copyright McGraw-Hill CHAPTER 6 The Normal Distribution.
Significance Tests …and their significance. Significance Tests Remember how a sampling distribution of means is created? Take a sample of size 500 from.
Introduction to Statistics Steven A. Jones Biomedical Engineering Louisiana Tech University (Created for our NSF-funded Research Experiences in Micro/Nano.
Bayesian Spatial Modeling of Extreme Precipitation Return Levels Daniel COOLEY, Douglas NYCHKA, and Philippe NAVEAU (2007, JASA)
Extreme Value Analysis What is extreme value analysis?  Different statistical distributions that are used to more accurately describe the extremes of.
BPS - 3rd Ed. Chapter 211 Inference for Regression.
Inference for Linear Regression Conditions for Regression Inference: Suppose we have n observations on an explanatory variable x and a response variable.
CE 3354 ENGINEERING HYDROLOGY Lecture 6: Probability Estimation Modeling.
February 3, 2010 Extreme offshore wave statistics in the North Sea.
Climate Change: A National and Marine Perspective David Woolf National Oceanography Centre, Southampton.
When σ is Unknown The One – Sample Interval For a Population Mean Target Goal: I can construct and interpret a CI for a population mean when σ is unknown.
Maximum Likelihood Estimator of Proportion Let {s 1,s 2,…,s n } be a set of independent outcomes from a Bernoulli experiment with unknown probability.
Recent Advances in Climate Extremes Science AVOID 2 FCO-Roshydromet workshop, Moscow, 19 th March 2015 Simon Brown, Met Office Hadley Centre.
Some advanced methods in extreme value analysis Peter Guttorp NR and UW.
PCB 3043L - General Ecology Data Analysis. OUTLINE Organizing an ecological study Basic sampling terminology Statistical analysis of data –Why use statistics?
Sullivan – Fundamentals of Statistics – 2 nd Edition – Chapter 3 Section 2 – Slide 1 of 27 Chapter 3 Section 2 Measures of Dispersion.
STATSPUNE 1 Are our dams over-designed? S.A.ParanjpeA.P.Gore.
Extreme Value Techniques Paul Gates - Lane Clark & Peacock James Orr - TSUNAMI GIRO Conference, 15 October 1999.
Extreme values and risk Adam Butler Biomathematics & Statistics Scotland CCTC meeting, September 2007.
Extreme Value Theory: Part II Sample (N=1000) from a Normal Distribution N(0,1) and fitted curve.
For information contact H. C. Koons 30 October Preliminary Analysis of ABFM Data WSR 11 x 11-km Average Harry Koons 30 October.
Copyright © 2011 Pearson Education, Inc. Describing Numerical Data Chapter 4.
Extreme Value Prediction in Sloshing Response Analysis
PCB 3043L - General Ecology Data Analysis.
Identification of Extreme Climate by Extreme Value Theory Approach
Spatial oceanographic extremes Adam Butler (Lancaster University), talk at RSC2003 Coworkers: Janet Heffernan, Jonathan Tawn, Roger Flather Data supplied.
Inferential Statistics Introduction. If both variables are categorical, build tables... Convention: Each value of the independent (causal) variable has.
New approaches in extreme-value modeling A.Zempléni, A. Beke, V. Csiszár (Eötvös Loránd University, Budapest) Flood Risk Workshop,
Probability distributions
Extreme Value Analysis
A bin-free Extended Maximum Likelihood Fit + Feldman-Cousins error analysis Peter Litchfield  A bin free Extended Maximum Likelihood method of fitting.
Chris Ferro Climate Analysis Group Department of Meteorology University of Reading Extremes in a Varied Climate 1.Significance of distributional changes.
1 Chapter 8 Interval Estimation. 2 Chapter Outline  Population Mean: Known  Population Mean: Unknown  Population Proportion.
Climate change, hydrodynamical models & extreme sea levels Adam Butler Janet Heffernan Jonathan Tawn Lancaster University Department of Mathematics &
CHAPTER 11 Mean and Standard Deviation. BOX AND WHISKER PLOTS  Worksheet on Interpreting and making a box and whisker plot in the calculator.
BPS - 5th Ed. Chapter 231 Inference for Regression.
A major Hungarian project for flood risk assessment A.Zempléni (Eötvös Loránd University, Budapest, visiting the TU Munich as a DAAD grantee) Technical.
Application of Extreme Value Theory (EVT) in River Morphology
CHAPTER 12 More About Regression
Ch8.4 P-Values The P-value is the smallest level of significance at which H0 would be rejected when a specified test procedure is used on a given data.
Extreme Value Prediction in Sloshing Response Analysis
PCB 3043L - General Ecology Data Analysis.
CHAPTER 12 More About Regression
CHAPTER 12 More About Regression
A Switching Observer for Human Perceptual Estimation
100-year waves, teleconnections and climate variation
CHAPTER 12 More About Regression
CHAPTER – 1.2 UNCERTAINTIES IN MEASUREMENTS.
Sampling Distributions
CHAPTER – 1.2 UNCERTAINTIES IN MEASUREMENTS.
Presentation transcript:

Climate Change and Extreme Wave Heights in the North Atlantic Peter Challenor, Werenfrid Wimmer and Ian Ashton Southampton Oceanography Centre

Outline Why are we interested in extremes? Extreme value theory Extremes and altimeter data Climate change and extremes Where next?

Extreme waves Extreme waves cause damage to ships and offshore structures For design purposes engineers and naval architects need to know how high ‘rare’ waves are.

Return Values Rather than use probability to describe extreme waves the convention is to use return values The n-year return value is that value that is exceeded on average at least once in n years. If we have m observations per year the n year return value corresponds to a probability of exceedence of 1-1/(m.n)

How to calculate a return value? (Theory of extremes) 1.Fit a distribution to the data 2.Use maxima - the statistics of extremes 3.Peaks over threshold methods

Fitting a distribution to all the data 1.Fit a statistical distribution to all the data (or the upper tail) 2.Extrapolate that distribution into the tails Problem: what distribution to use?

An Example Different different distributions give very different answers.

The Statistics of Extremes Statistical theory says that the largest value in a large sample tends asymptotically to one distribution - the generalised extreme value distribution (GEV) 1.Take the largest value per year 2.Fit a GEV distribution Problem: we need many years data and we only use one point per year/interval!

Peaks over Thresholds (POT) A similar result says that the upper tails of distributions also tend to a limiting distribution - the Generalised Pareto Distribution (GPD) 1.Set a high threshold 2.Fit a GPD to the exceedences about that threshold Problems: How high should the threshold be; independence of points above the threshold

1.Choose a high threshold (u) 2.Take all exceedences above that threshold 3.Fit a GPD distribution

Data TOPEX and ERS-1/2 data from from the SOC GAPS database (Also processed data from the TUD RADS database - similar results - not presented here)

POT for altimeter data Altimeter data do not record the biggest exceedences at a point But the distribution of any exceedence = probability of the largest The temporal sampling is poor Undersampling will lead to an underestimate of the extremes by about 10-15% (Robinson and Tawn)

Altimeter Processing For each 2° square in the North Atlantic take each altimeter pass across the square. Replace each pass by its median (declustering)

Setting the Threshold With in situ data we set the threshold by hand - start high and lower the threshold until nothing changes We cannot do that so we set the threshold to the 90th quantile i.e 10% of the data are exceedences

An Example Fit

50-year Return Value

Non-stationarity So far we have assumed that the wave climate is stationary i.e. that the statistics of exceedences are the same throughout the year This is not true - storms are bigger in the winter

Variable Threshold Use a different threshold value every month We can check whether this more complex model is ‘better’ (likelihood ratio test) It is significantly better everywhere

The North Atlantic Oscillation We know that the NAO affects mean wave height Does it also affect the extremes?

Adding monthly values of the NAO to the scale parameter does little to improve the fit. If we add an interaction term - a different response to the NAO each month we get better results These plots show a low (left) and high (right) NAO January H 50

Further Work We have found an NAO response,but it is noisy. –Perhaps we need to use the winter or annual NAO –Or vary the scale parameter –Or we may need more data Spatial models for extremes