Competitive tendering contracts: Why is Norway lagging behind? Presentation at THREDBO 9 Lisbon, Portugal, 6th September 2005 Trine Hagen, Institute of.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Strategies & actions for macro-regions BSR INTERREG III B WP2,Minerals and Mining subgroup Anders Jonsson County Board, Umeå Ola Torstensen, County of.
Advertisements

Global Marketing.
Sino-Danish Center, Workshop in september 2012 HRM and the quality of work life for Chinese Knowledge workers employed at Scandinavian companies settled.
LABOR RELATIONS & INDUSTRIAL DEMOCRACY
 SAP AG 2003 Market segments Business Issues and Challenges Problems and Chances to IT Spending among SMBs Contents: The SMB Market.
Rationales and Ideas behind ‘Workfare’ Reforms in Denmark, Sweden and Finland since the early 1990s Johannes Kananen Centre for Nordic Studies University.
Quality tendering and contracting service design Comparing the Dutch and Norwegian initiatives Frode Longva, and Bård Norheim Institute of Transport Economics.
Experiences with regulatory changes in the taxi industry Jon-Terje Bekken Institute of Transport Economic Norway Thredbo 9, Lisbon.
Scandinavian welfare regime in crisis
The Swedish system. Swedish passengers no longer trust the railway.
Results and lessons to be learned from the liberalisation of long distance bus and coach lines in Norway.
Multinational Organizations Management Control Systems Chapter 15 September 2014Iwan Pudjanegara SE., MM.1.
DEMOCRACY AND PRIVATE PROPERTY: GOVERNANCE OF A THREE PARTY PUBLIC PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP Sven-Olof Collin & Elin Smith.
C OOPERATION AND COMPETITION AMONG FIRMS P ROFESSOR A LESSANDRO A RRIGHETTI Baldini Lisa Ballotta Lucrezia Cenci Chiara Università degli studi di Parma.
1 Competitive long-term financing of Norwegian exports Norwegian Finance Breakfast – Dallas Federal Reserve, April 18, 2012.
VERSITET JAN MEJDING OG LOUISE RØNBERG AARHUS UNIVERSITY, DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION (DPU) AARHUS UNIVERSITET 20TH MAY 2014 UNI MATERIALS AND APPROACHES IN.
ENTERPRISE EUROPE NETWORK Business Support on Your Doorstep EUROPEAN INFORMATION AND INNIOVATION CENTER IN MACEDONIA Ass. Prof. dr Kole Vasilevski Vice-rector.
Public and private sector cooperation Observations and reflections from a Baltic Sea Region Perspective Ulf Johansson Sweco Eurofutures AB.
1.
Ministry of Transport and Road Safety. Introduction Historical Approach to Contracting with Foreign Companies Current Policy and Requirements for Foreign.
C The first public transportation project procured through Competitive Dialogue in Sweden.
Miami, 10 May Dr. Árpád Kovács Competitiveness, Sustainable Development and Sustainable Constitutional State.
Business Model for an Industrial development agency
EU-Regional Policy Structural actions 1 LESSONS FROM THE THEMATIC EVALUATION OF THE TERRITORIAL EMPLOYMENT PACTS Veronica Gaffey, DG Regional.
Language teaching and the integration of immigrants and refugees in the Nordic countries Sally Boyd Prof of general linguistics University of.
NORWEGIAN FOREIGN SERVICE Our cooperation with Norwegian business end industry to promote our economic interests abroad.
ETUI-industriAll Summer College European Works Councils and Transnational Company Agreements ETUI-industriAll Collective Bargaining & Company Policy Summer.
North-Eastern Federal University named after M.K.Ammosov.
Status of ODL in the Baltic and Nordic countries: overview of situation and visible trends of development Sirje Virkus, Estonia 18. March 2005.
Results versus resources An analysis of publicly funded research in Norway Jan Fagerberg, TIK (University of Oslo), CIRCLE (University of Lund) and SPRU.
Financing and regulating highway construction in Scandinavia – experiences and perspectives Svein Bråthen Molde University College
Energy Industry Analysis 2009 November 2010 The purpose of this analysis is to document the significance of Danish energy industries for the economy and.
Petroleum Law – Gas sales – Spring 2007 Gas sales – Competition aspects Petroleum Law - JUR /22 March Catherine Banet, Phd Research fellow.
Samordningsrådet med kunskapsplattform för smarta elnät Smart Grid and Smart Metering - Swedish Experiences Karin Widegren, Director Swedish Coordination.
Norwegian Health Informatics 1 The Electronic Medical Handbook Terje Johannessen Editor, professor in General Practice Bridging the gap between research.
Entrepreneurship Mr. Bernstein Entrepreneurship and the Economy, pp 6-9 and Basic Economic Concepts, pp September 2015.
1 Procurement procedures and the size of firms in infrastructure contracts Annual World Bank Conference on Development Economics May 2006, Tokyo.
Shipbuilding & Repair Contracts Attorney-at-Law/Partner Axel Øwre Advoco Advokatfirma DA UiO/NIFS October 20, 2010.
C.A.I 1. 2 What we are Norwegian booking and promotion agency Established ten years ago Focusing on country music Working in Scandinavia: –Norway –Sweden.
1 Current state of activities and trends in the ETD’s development in Scandinavia Eva Müller Electronic Publishing Centre Uppsala University Library.
The development of the Scandinavian police during the 19th and 20th centuries: Transference, adaptation and cooperation Björn Furuhagen Uppsala University,
Part-financed by the European Union Baltic Sea Region 2007– Profile Joint Technical Secretariat Lead Applicant Seminar, Riga, 9-11 April 2008.
International Cooperation in Cartel Investigations Regional Cooperation Hanna Witt Head of Cartel Enforcement, Swedish Competition Authority 2013 ICN Cartel.
It Takes More than a Bridge to Make a Region The Øresund Contracts as Instruments for Cross- Border R&D Cooperation Isabelle Collins and Erik Arnold AEA.
Sweden Home Why Sweden? Study options Course search Institutions Scholarships Living in Sweden Learn Swedish.
The Scandinavian Currency Union Andrew C. Hedberg.
Analysis of Bilateral Relations between Czech institutions and the institutions from donor states Martina Bečvářová BF Working Group – 9th September 2015,
Accession to the European Union Criteria acquis rationale.
Project coordinator Kaj Loman, Local Action Groups Päijänne Leader + Etpähä ry, Finland xx.xx.2012.
Danish Agricultural Advisory Service National Centre The adviser as important mediator of research and innovation in organic farming. Differences in organic.
1 Version 1.0 Digital signature. 2 About Nets Nets is a supplier of digital solutions for the identification of persons, as well as the signing and archiving.
Povl Asserhøj President, Gastra A/S GTE 2 nd Annual Conference 23 and 24 September 2004 Copenhagen.
EMTA General Meeting Prague May 2012 Round table on PSO Regulation 1370/2007 “Two years after enforcement, where are we? How efficient is the regulation?
1 CAST – Campaigns and Awareness-raising Strategies in Traffic safety: Status WP1: “Road User Model” 3rd SC-meeting Brussels– 27th February 2007 Truls.
Northern Europe “Scandanavia”
Economic Systems. I. ?s - All Economic Systems Answer What and how many goods and services should be produced? How should goods and services be produced?
11th NI&D Conference. Spring for information Reykjavik 30. May – 1. June 2001 Marianne Hummelshoj, Associate Professor, MLI.Sci. Royal School of Library.
Emission Permits Thomas Olsen, Statistics Denmark Presented by Ole Gravgård, Statistics Denmark Prepared for the 13th London Group meeting, Brussels, 29.
The oil industry and regional transformation in the North – Creating Innovation Systems in the Wake of Developing the Snøhvitfield Sveinung Eikeland,
Unit 8 Day 1 Concepts of Trade. Trade Trade – the act of buying or selling goods and services. Trade – the act of buying or selling goods and services.
NORDIC MARKET. .THE NORDIC MARKET: INSIGHTS, IMAGE & AWARENESS.
Belgrade, 27 March 2009 Professionalisation and Certification in Public Procurement in Austria Hubert Reisner 1 Workshop on Public Procurement Belgrade,
PEPPOL meeting - Sweden country presentation Irene Andersson, Swedish Agency for Administrative Development, VERVA, June 11, 2008.
Framework for Introducing OPRC Christopher R. Bennett Sr. Transport Specialist EASTE.
Posted workers and foreign companies in Danish construction
Gender equality for sustainable social and economic growth
The EU on the agenda in Norwegian municipalities and counties
Andrea Sundstrand Associate Professor
Counterfactual impact evaluations in Poland
Practice EOCT Questions
Presentation transcript:

Competitive tendering contracts: Why is Norway lagging behind? Presentation at THREDBO 9 Lisbon, Portugal, 6th September 2005 Trine Hagen, Institute of Transport Economics

2 Source: Jon-Terje Bekken, TØI, 2005

3 Local tendering in Scandinavia What characterizes cooperation between authorities and operators in public transport, in the cases where contracts are ventured into as a result of competitive tendering? How do counties and operators handle the need to adjust contracts during the contractual period? Are there differences between the Scandinavian countries?

4 Method Case studies Document studies Interviews with authorities

5 Main results (1) Norwegian contracts are less extensive than Danish and Swedish ones – Bonus – Quality – Responsibilities of the authorities: vaguely formulated, if any – Few arenas for contact and development of cooperation are defined – The right to negotiate is not formalised

6 Main results (2) Similarities in Scandinavia Negotiations do take place on a regular basis Talks/contact between operators and authorities are common What’s different in Norway? Less is regulated by contract Practice is more important in Norway

7 Conclusions (1) Norwegian tradition: talks, negotiations are informal – all based on local companies and well known counterparts In order for Norwegian public transport to work, the relationship between operators/authorities must be good When little is regulated by contract, practice becomes more important

8 Conclusions (2) The Norwegian market: Changing The need for more formalised contracts will probably rise Practice will be less important as contracts become more formalised Norway will follow the development in Denmark and Sweden