Chapter 14 Alternative Assets Portfolio Construction, Management, & Protection, 5e, Robert A. Strong Copyright ©2009 by South-Western, a division of Thomson Business & Economics. All rights reserved.
JPMorgan Asst Management “It is unusual that something as boring as infrastructure—pipelines, toll roads, electricity transmission lines, and airports—becomes the hot new thing but here it is." Mark Weisdorf, CFA Managing Director JPMorgan Asst Management
Introduction Rapid recent growth in importance Five Category Groups Pensions and endowments allocation growth: 5 percent in 2000 10 percent in 2008 Five Category Groups Infrastructure Private Equity Hedge Funds Commodities Specialized Real Estate
Infrastructure Investments Prominent alternative asset $3.0 trillion in 2006 Typically started under government authority and later sold to private investors Eliminates managerial burden Raises cash for other societal needs “brownfield projects” Sometimes businesses provide originates services that are typically offered by government “greenfield projects” e.g., high-speed toll road to Washington D.C.’s airport Considered to be more risky
Popular Types of Infrastructure Approximately $3 trillion in 2006, including: Toll roads & bridges Airports and airport trolley systems Railway and ferry systems Sporting arenas Shipping ports Electricity transmission Water distribution networks
International Aspect of Infrastructure Investment Infrastructure investments: Are also called public/private partnerships Are necessary and facilitate economic development Are found across the globe Canada: $C66 India: $150 billion Europe: €600 billion
Infrastructure Investment Characteristics Long-life Cash flows generally stable and inflation linked Significant barriers to entry by competitors Provides essential community service Few substitutes for service Typically are highly levered Highly illiquid
Infrastructure Investment Options Direct investment Requires enormous capital reserves Listed funds Most popular investment method by individuals Unlisted funds Offered through investment banks Most popular investment methods by pension funds and institutional investors
Advantages of Infrastructure Investment Annual cash flow stream Periodic increases to keep up with inflation Private management may provide efficiencies unavailable to government Low correlation with other assets Too new for many long-term studies Australian equities and infrastructure: 0.32 Zero correlation between non-Australian equities and Australian infrastructure
Hedge Funds No single definition Common characteristics Low-correlation focused investment funds Relatively few investors Substantial minimal initial investment Investors are limited partners Hedge fund is general partner The unlimited liability of general partner is used to justify management fees and large proportion of profits Consistency of return is typical investment objective
Hedge Fund Demographics Total number of funds is unknown Only hedge funds with $30 million in assets or over 15 investors must register with SEC Hedge funds publicize success, biasing perceptions in favor of hedge fund investment Alfred Jones started first hedge fund in 1949 - used short positions to offset risk of equity positions In 2008: $2 trillion dollars invested 44% held by individuals
Hedge Fund Classifications Nondirectional/Directional Strategy Anticipated changes in the underlying market does not impact choices in nondirectional strategies Arbitrage/Relative Value strategy Assumes the “mispriced” securities will move towards their normal relationship Merger arbitrage may result in selling shares of acquiring firm and buying those of acquired firm Convertible arbitrage may result in selling shares and buy convertibles bonds to earn interest income “may” because one has to consider current price and perceived value of both positions
130/130 Strategy A long/short strategy Buying undervalued stocks and selling overvalued stocks Within a given portfolio, sell short the 30% considered to be overvalued and invest the proceeds in the 30% considered to be undervalued. For every $1 originally invested, there now is another $0.60 worth of positions taken The proportions could be any number greater than 100 110/110 or 120/120, but not 120/110
Hedge Fund-of-Funds Portfolio of hedge funds Lower initial investment than individual funds Higher management fees Pay fees to fund managers and Fund-of-fund managers
Commodities Now a widely-used investment class Primary advantage: Low correlation with equity investments Over 1994-2008 period, the correlation with the Wilshire 5000 Index has been between 0.02 and 0.10, depending on index Primary disadvantage: Returns typically do not outpace inflation May outpace inflation during short periods In 2008: Oil and wheat hit record high prices
Commodities (cont’d) Some institutional investors use futures markets Seek price gain, not the commodity itself Others invest in farmland, almond groves, and vineyards where assets will be produced “Price bubbles” Farmland, ethanol, and all commodities
Private Equity Acquisition of a significant portion of a company, develop the company’s value, and sell it to the investment community There always is a clear exit strategy consisting of receiving cash Unlike the entrepreneur, and private equity investor has a target selling date Both are willing to put forth the time and effort needed to influence corporate decisions
Private Equity Investments in 2006 Private Equity Portfolio Allocation Expect a Significant Increase in Allocation over 2007-2009 period Corporate Funds 4.4% 36% Endowment Funds 8.4% 61%
Forms of Private Equity Venture Capital New companies or new ideas High revenue growth, limited net income Corporate Finance/Buyout Established firm investment Help them take advantage of competitive advantage Mezzanine Financing Provision of second-mortgage financing May convert to equity Distressed Firm Financing Cash infusion when firm is unable to make debt payments
J Curve Pattern of returns from private equity investment to cash event Typically lose money in first four or five years Eventually, return turns positive, resulting in annual returns in the 25 percent range Over 1992-2007 period, the U.S. venture capital market earned a 19.65 percent annualized rate of return The S&P 500 earned 11.19% over the same period Given the risks, it is wise to own a “portfolio” of private equity investments!
Opportunistic Real Estate High-risk, developed property investment Generally have a specific purpose Examples include golf courses, churches, bowling alley, hotels, student housing projects, single-family homes Opportunistic real estate opportunities may arise from: Severe regional economic conditions (bankruptcy of city’s primary employer) Natural disasters (Hurricane Katrina) Systematic problems (Subprime mortgage problems) Opportunistic real estate investors focus more on price appreciation Income streams are smaller, more volatile, and inconsistent Traditional real estate investors are more concerned with current income Less than 1 percent of public institutional investment assets