Universe is Made up of normal matter Choice A (Theorists) Universe is Flat Inflation is correct Hubble Constant less than 60 Choice B (Observers) Universe.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The Calán/Tololo Supernova Survey
Advertisements

What Figure of Merit Should We Use to Evaluate Dark Energy Projects? Yun Wang Yun Wang STScI Dark Energy Symposium STScI Dark Energy Symposium May 6, 2008.
SDSS-II SN survey: Constraining Dark Energy with intermediate- redshift probes Hubert Lampeitl University Portsmouth, ICG In collaboration with: H.J. Seo,
Observational Cosmology - a laboratory for fundamental physics MPI-K, Heidelberg Marek Kowalski.
Non-linear matter power spectrum to 1% accuracy between dynamical dark energy models Matt Francis University of Sydney Geraint Lewis (University of Sydney)
Observational Cosmology - a unique laboratory for fundamental physics Marek Kowalski Physikalisches Institut Universität Bonn.
Marek Kowalski Moriond Cosmology The “Union” Supernova Ia Compilation and new Cosmological Constraints Marek Kowalski Humboldt Universität.
PRESENTATION TOPIC  DARK MATTER &DARK ENERGY.  We know about only normal matter which is only 5% of the composition of universe and the rest is  DARK.
Lecture 2: Observational constraints on dark energy Shinji Tsujikawa (Tokyo University of Science)
PRE-SUSY Karlsruhe July 2007 Rocky Kolb The University of Chicago Cosmology 101 Rocky I : The Universe Observed Rocky II :Dark Matter Rocky III :Dark Energy.
Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.
THE GAMMA-RAY BURST HUBBLE DIAGRAM TO z=6.6 Brad Schaefer Louisiana State University HUBBLE DIAGRAMS  PLOT DISTANCE vs. REDSHIFT  SHAPE OF PLOT  EXPANSION.
1 L. Perivolaropoulos Department of Physics University of Ioannina Open page
Lecture 1: Basics of dark energy Shinji Tsujikawa (Tokyo University of Science) ``Welcome to the dark side of the world.”
B12 Next Generation Supernova Surveys Marek Kowalski 1 and Bruno Leibundgut 2 1 Physikalisches Institut, Universität Bonn 2 European Southern Observatory.
Marek Kowalski PTF, Szczecin Exploding Stars, Cosmic Acceleration and Dark Energy Supernova 1994D Marek Kowalski Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin.
1 SDSS-II Supernova Survey Josh Frieman Leopoldina Dark Energy Conference October 8, 2008 See also: poster by Hubert Lampeitl, talk by Bob Nichol.
COMING HOME Michael S. Turner Kavli Institute for Cosmological Physics The University of Chicago.
Dark Energy Bengt Gustafsson: Current problems in Astrophysics Lecture 3 Ångström Laboratory, Spring 2010.
The Research School of Astronomy and Astrophysics Mount Stromlo Observatory.
A Step towards Precise Cosmology from Type Ia Supernovae Wang Xiaofeng Tsinghua University IHEP, Beijing, 23/04, 2006.
Query on Cosmic Dark Energy by Error Analyses of Type Ia Supernova Qiu-he Peng (Depart. of Astronomy, Nanjing University)
Dark energy I : Observational constraints Shinji Tsujikawa (Tokyo University of Science)
Recent results on supernova cosmology Bruno Leibundgut.
Supernova Legacy Survey Mark Sullivan University of Oxford
Adam G. Riess Johns Hopkins University and Space Telescope Science Institute The History of Cosmic Expansion from Supernovae Near and Far.
Dark Energy and Supernovae Wendy Freedman Carnegie Observatories, Pasadena CA Beyond Einstein, SLAC, May 13, 2004.
Supernova cosmology: legacy and future Bruno Leibundgut ESO.
Our Evolving Universe1 Vital Statistics of the Universe Today… l l Observational evidence for the Big Bang l l Vital statistics of the Universe   Hubble’s.
ASIAANTUPHYS CosPA Seminar May 28, Supernovae and Acceleration of the Universe A journal club K. Y. Lo.
Supernova cosmology The quest to measure the equation of state of dark energy Bruno Leibundgut European Southern Observatory.
Dark Energy Expanding Universe Accelerating Universe Dark Energy Scott Dodelson March 7, 2004.
Dark Matter and Dark Energy components chapter 7 Lecture 4.
Precise Cosmology from SNe Ia Wang Xiao-feng Physics Department and Tsinghua Center for Astrophysics, Tsinghua University 2005, 9, 22, Sino-French Dark.
Expansion history of the Universe as seen by supernovae Bruno Leibundgut European Southern Observatory.
A. Ealet, S. Escoffier, D. Fouchez, F. Henry-Couannier, S. Kermiche, C. Tao, A. Tilquin September 2012.
Using Baryon Acoustic Oscillations to test Dark Energy Will Percival The University of Portsmouth (including work as part of 2dFGRS and SDSS collaborations)
Type Ia Supernovae and the Acceleration of the Universe: Results from the ESSENCE Supernova Survey Kevin Krisciunas, 5 April 2008.
SNAP Calibration Program Steps to Spectrophotometric Calibration The SNAP (Supernova / Acceleration Probe) mission’s primary science.
BAOs SDSS, DES, WFMOS teams (Bob Nichol, ICG Portsmouth)
Cosmic Inhomogeneities and Accelerating Expansion Ho Le Tuan Anh National University of Singapore PAQFT Nov 2008.
The Carnegie Supernova Project Wendy Freedman Carnegie Observatories Cosmology 2007 San Servolo, Italy August 30, 2007.
Extending the cosmic ladder to z~7 and beyond: using SNIa to calibrate GRB standard candels Speaker: Speaker: Shuang-Nan Zhang Collaborators: Nan Liang,
Astro-2: History of the Universe Lecture 10; May
Latest Results from LSS & BAO Observations Will Percival University of Portsmouth StSci Spring Symposium: A Decade of Dark Energy, May 7 th 2008.
PHY306 1 Modern cosmology 2: More about Λ Distances at z ~1 Type Ia supernovae SNe Ia and cosmology Results from the Supernova Cosmology Project, the High.
Searching High-z Supernovae with HSC and WFMOS
NGC4603 Cepheids in NGC4603 Planetary Nebula Luminosity Function Number.
Dynamical & Resolution Trajectories for Inflation then & now Dick Bond Inflation Now 1+w(a)=  f(a/a  eq ) to 3 (1+q)/2 ~ 1 good e-fold. Only ~2 parameters.
Jochen Weller XLI Recontres de Moriond March, 18-25, 2006 Constraining Inverse Curvature Gravity with Supernovae O. Mena, J. Santiago and JW PRL, 96, ,
Observational evidence for Dark Energy
Cosmology with Supernovae Bruno Leibundgut European Southern Observatory.
Dark Energy Phenomenology: Quintessence Potential Reconstruction Je-An Gu 顧哲安 National Center for Theoretical Sciences NTHU Collaborators.
Dark Energy Phenomenology: Quintessence Potential Reconstruction Je-An Gu 顧哲安 National Center for Theoretical Sciences CYCU Collaborators.
Two useful methods for the supernova cosmologist: (1) Including CMB constraints by using the CMB shift parameters (2) A model-independent photometric redshift.
PHY306 1 Modern cosmology 2: Type Ia supernovae and Λ Distances at z ~1 Type Ia supernovae SNe Ia and cosmology Results from the Supernova Cosmology Project,
A New Route to the Hubble Constant (and Dark Energy) from HST Adam Riess (JHU, STScI) SHOES Collaboration.
Probing Dark Energy with Cosmological Observations Fan, Zuhui ( 范祖辉 ) Dept. of Astronomy Peking University.
R. PainEDEN, Dec Reynald Pain LPNHE, Univ. Paris, France Probing Dark Energy with Supernovae.
CTIO Camera Mtg - Dec ‘03 Studies of Dark Energy with Galaxy Clusters Joe Mohr Department of Astronomy Department of Physics University of Illinois.
Lecture 23: The Acceleration of the Universe Astronomy 1143 – Spring 2014.
The Nature of Dark Energy David Weinberg Ohio State University Based in part on Kujat, Linn, Scherrer, & Weinberg 2002, ApJ, 572, 1.
Dark Energy Phenomenology  a new parametrization  Je-An Gu 顧哲安 臺灣大學梁次震宇宙學與粒子天文物理學研究中心 Leung Center for Cosmology and Particle Astrophysics (LeCosPA),
Supernova Legacy Survey (SNLS) Goal: Characterize the Dark Energy equation of state “w” parameter A component of the CFHT Legacy Survey.
Constraining Dark Energy with Double Source Plane Strong Lenses Thomas Collett With: Matt Auger, Vasily Belokurov, Phil Marshall and Alex Hall ArXiv:
Probing the Coupling between Dark Components of the Universe
Recent status of dark energy and beyond
Cosmology with Supernovae
Cosmological Expansion and Dark Energy
Measurements of Cosmological Parameters
Presentation transcript:

Universe is Made up of normal matter Choice A (Theorists) Universe is Flat Inflation is correct Hubble Constant less than 60 Choice B (Observers) Universe is Open Inflation is wrong Hubble Constant less than 80 Choice C (people with few friends) Universe is Flat Universe is dominated by Cosmological Constant

Zwicky’s SN Search from 1930s-1960s giving Kowal’s Hubble Diagram in 1968 Ib/Ic SN Contamination realised in 1984/5 1st distant SN discovered in 1988 by a Danish team (z=0.3) 7 SNe discovered in 1994 by Perlmutter et al. at z = 0.4 Calan/Tololo Survey of 29 Nearby SNe Ia completed in 1994 High-Z SN Ia History

Potential Pitfalls to High-Z SNe Ia Distances Extinction –Are the Extinction Properties of High-Z and low-Z SNe the same? Evolution –Are the SNe Seen today the same as the SNe of yesterday? Selection Effects? –Are the corrections larger than the measurement? K-corrections –How accurately can we transform to the restframe? Gravitational Lensing –Does Weak Lensing significantly bias the measurement?

z Distance N brightness Selection Effects/Malmquist Bias

Selection Effects Monte Carlo Simulation 0% 40% 80% Amount Brighter than mean

Monte Carlo Simulations Play through complicated scenarios on a computer. Do many trials to lower you uncertainty Easy way to learn simulate very complicated situations Example : Craps –Rules. On first roll of two dice, 7,11 you win…2,3,12 you lose. Otherwise, you need to match your first roll before rolling another 7 (or you lose). What are your odds?

Craps – simulation…3 different goes…

Precision Monte Carlo simulations are just like an experiment… Precision increases as the sqrt(measurements). You will have a problem in the second round where you need to do a Monte Carlo Calculation.

K-Corrections As the light of an object become redshifted, we see it at different wavelengths B band (440nm) Z=0 Z=0.5 R band (650nm)

Photometry and K-corrections definition of absolute mag definition of distance modulus Flux of redshifted source definition of mag

K-Corrections Kim et al e.g SN Ia at z=0.5 has R=22.2 and K-Corr (R->B) =–0.75 and M B =-19.5 its (m-M) = = 42.45

Bruno Leibundgut John Tonry Nick Suntzeff Saurabh Jha Chris Smith Peter Garnavich Pete Challis Adam Riess Alejandro Clocchiatti Alex Filippenko Jason Spyromilio Chris Stubbs Bob Kirshner Mark Phillips Mario Hamuy Jose Maza Bob Schommer Ron Gilliland Brian Schmidt Tom Matheson Gajus Miknaitis Brian Barris Stephen Holland Weidong Li

4 April SN 28 April

So What is the Dark Energy? One possibility is that the Universe is permeated by an energy density, constant in time and uniform in space. Such a “cosmological constant” (Lambda: Λ ) was originally postulated by Einstein, but later rejected when the expansion of the Universe was first detected. General arguments from the scale of particle interactions, however, suggest that if Λ is not zero, it should be very large, larger by more than than what is measured. If dark energy is due to a cosmological constant, its ratio of pressure to energy density (its equation of state) is w = P/ ρ = −1 at all times.

Why Now?

So What is the Dark Energy? Another possibility is that the dark energy is some kind of dynamical fluid, not previously known to physics, but similar to what caused inflation. In this case the equation of state of the fluid would likely not be constant, but would vary with time. Different theories of dynamical dark energy are distinguished through their differing predictions for the evolution of the equation of state. Unfortunately none of these theories has any particularly sound basis, and most spend much of their time looking like a Cosmological Constant.

So What is the Dark Energy? An alternative explanation of the accelerating expansion of the Universe is that general relativity or the standard cosmological model is incorrect. Whether general relativity is incorrect or the Universe is filled with an unanticipated form of energy, exploration of the acceleration of the Universe’s expansion might profoundly change our understanding of the composition and nature of the Universe.

Stolen from Karl Glazebrook

Current Results on w Supernova measurements of DL from z=0 to z=1.5 (Nearby, SCP, High-Z, CFHTLS, Essence, Higher-Z) BAO (+CMB constraint of acoustic scale at z=1089) measurement of 4% by SDSS at  M measurement of 0.27± 0.03 via 2dF+SDSS WMAP + LSS combined constraints

Hubble has found 50 new Supernovae Half beyond the reach of the ground

Higher-Z (Riess et al. ApJ in Press)

SNLS Austier et al. BAO Eisenstein et al.

Austier et al. CFHT Legacy Survey – assumes Flat Universe And uses CMB + BAO measurement. w=-1+/-0.1

Essence Michael Wood-Vasey et al. ApJ Submitted

w=-1.05±.13 (0.13 mag sys)

SNLS+Essence using MLCS2k2 w=1.07 ±.0.09

Dark Energy looks like  As near as we can tell the Universe is expanding just as a Cosmological Constant would predict. (based on luminosity distance between z=0 to z=1.5 from SN Ia - and Angular-size distance (modified) between z=0.35 and z=1089) and power spectrum info from LSS+CMB.