Dyadic designs to model relations in social interaction data Todd D. Little Yale University.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Questions From Yesterday
Advertisements

University of Connecticut
Dyadic Analysis: Using HLM
Seven Deadly Sins of Dyadic Data Analysis David A. Kenny February 14, 2013.
By Zach Andersen Jon Durrant Jayson Talakai
Linear Equations Review. Find the slope and y intercept: y + x = -1.
Statistical Analysis Overview I Session 2 Peg Burchinal Frank Porter Graham Child Development Institute, University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill.
Social Relations Model: Estimation Indistinguishable Dyads David A. Kenny.
1 Multilevel Mediation Overview -Mediation -Multilevel data as a nuisance and an opportunity -Mediation in Multilevel Models -
APIM with Distinguishable Dyads: SEM Estimation
Jeff Beard Lisa Helma David Parrish Start Presentation.
Graphs in HLM. Model setup, Run the analysis before graphing Sector = 0 public school Sector = 1 private school.
Psychology 202b Advanced Psychological Statistics, II February 1, 2011.
Longitudinal Experiments Larry V. Hedges Northwestern University Prepared for the IES Summer Research Training Institute July 28, 2010.
Clustered or Multilevel Data
Correlation “A statistician is someone who loves to work with numbers but doesn't have the personality to be an accountant.”
C ENTERING IN HLM. W HY CENTERING ? In OLS regression, we mostly focus on the slope but not intercept. Therefore, raw data (natural X metric) is perfectly.
APIM with Between- and Within Dyads Outcomes David A. Kenny December 11, 2014.
Analysis of Covariance Goals: 1)Reduce error variance. 2)Remove sources of bias from experiment. 3)Obtain adjusted estimates of population means.
Measurement and Modeling of Change: Just some of the issues Todd D. Little Yale University (for now…) Auburn University, May 8, 2001.
Correlation 1. Correlation - degree to which variables are associated or covary. (Changes in the value of one tends to be associated with changes in the.
Multiple Regression Research Methods and Statistics.
Chapter 7 Correlational Research Gay, Mills, and Airasian
Introduction to Statistics for the Social Sciences SBS200, COMM200, GEOG200, PA200, POL200, or SOC200 Lecture Section 001, Spring 2015 Room 150 Harvill.
Examples from Singer’s Using SAS Proc Mixed to Fit Multilevel Models… “ To use the paper effectively, … in particular the reader must understand: The difference.
Relationships Among Variables
1 Multilevel Models in Survey Error Estimation Joop Hox Utrecht University mlsurvey.
Analysis of Clustered and Longitudinal Data
Introduction to Multilevel Modeling Using SPSS
Multilevel Modeling: Other Topics
3. Multiple Regression Analysis: Estimation -Although bivariate linear regressions are sometimes useful, they are often unrealistic -SLR.4, that all factors.
An Introduction to HLM and SEM
Regression with 2 IVs Generalization of Regression from 1 to 2 Independent Variables.
Multilevel Modeling 1.Overview 2.Application #1: Growth Modeling Break 3.Application # 2: Individuals Nested Within Groups 4.Questions?
Advanced Business Research Method Intructor : Prof. Feng-Hui Huang Agung D. Buchdadi DA21G201.
Hierarchical Linear Modeling (HLM): A Conceptual Introduction Jessaca Spybrook Educational Leadership, Research, and Technology.
Introduction Multilevel Analysis
Business Statistics: A First Course, 5e © 2009 Prentice-Hall, Inc. Chap 12-1 Correlation and Regression.
One-with-Many Design: Estimation David A. Kenny June 22, 2013.
One-with-Many Design: Introduction David A. Kenny June 11, 2013.
Introduction to Multilevel Modeling Stephen R. Porter Associate Professor Dept. of Educational Leadership and Policy Studies Iowa State University Lagomarcino.
MBP1010H – Lecture 4: March 26, Multiple regression 2.Survival analysis Reading: Introduction to the Practice of Statistics: Chapters 2, 10 and 11.
Chapter 16 Data Analysis: Testing for Associations.
HLM Models. General Analysis Strategy Baseline Model - No Predictors Model 1- Level 1 Predictors Model 2 – Level 2 Predictors of Group Mean Model 3 –
Multilevel Modeling: Other Topics David A. Kenny January 7, 2014.
Analysis of Covariance (ANCOVA)
Mixed Effects Models Rebecca Atkins and Rachel Smith March 30, 2015.
Data Analysis in Practice- Based Research Stephen Zyzanski, PhD Department of Family Medicine Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine October.
Correlation and Regression: The Need to Knows Correlation is a statistical technique: tells you if scores on variable X are related to scores on variable.
Stuff I Have Done and Am Doing Now David A. Kenny.
FIXED AND RANDOM EFFECTS IN HLM. Fixed effects produce constant impact on DV. Random effects produce variable impact on DV. F IXED VS RANDOM EFFECTS.
MULTILEVEL MODELING Multilevel: what does it mean? Consider the following graph: LIKINGLIKING AGGRESSION LO HI.
Intro to Psychology Statistics Supplement. Descriptive Statistics: used to describe different aspects of numerical data; used only to describe the sample.
Analysis of Experiments
Definitions in Dyadic Data Analysis David A. Kenny February 18, 2013.
Jessaca Spybrook Western Michigan University Multi-level Modeling (MLM) Refresher.
Unit 3 Section : Regression  Regression – statistical method used to describe the nature of the relationship between variables.  Positive.
ANCOVA.
Actor-Partner Interdependence Model or APIM. APIM A model that simultaneously estimates actor and partner effects on an outcome variable The actor and.
Week of March 23 Partial correlations Semipartial correlations
Using Multilevel Modeling in Institutional Research
Multilevel modelling: general ideas and uses
Linear Mixed Models in JMP Pro
APIM with Indistinguishable Dyads: SEM Estimation
G Lecture 6 Multilevel Notation; Level 1 and Level 2 Equations
Mediation MODERATION THREE WAYS OF DOING ANALYSIS Kun
Defining, Measuring, and Dealing with Nonindependence
A New Approach to the Study of Teams: The GAPIM
Social Relations Model: Estimation of Relationship Effects
Presentation transcript:

Dyadic designs to model relations in social interaction data Todd D. Little Yale University

Outline Why have such a symposium Dyadic Designs and Analyses Thoughts on Future Directions

Some Bad Methods Dyad-level Setups (Ignore individuals) Target-Partner Setups Arbitrary assignment of target vs partner Loss of power Often underestimates relations Ignores dyadic impact Target with multiple-Partner Take average of partners to reduce dyad- level influences Doesn't really do it Ignores dyadic impact

Intraclass Setups Represents target with partner & partner with target in same data structure Exchangeable case (target/partner arbitrary) Distinguishable case (something systematic) Keeps dyadic influence Contains dependencies Requires adjustments for accurate statistical inferences (see e.g., Gonzalez & Griffin)

Between-Friend Correlations

Canonical Correlations Child- Rated Parent- Rated Teacher- Rated Grade

Social Relations Model (Kenny et al.) X ijk = m k + a i + b j + g ij + e ijk Where X ijk is the actor i's behavior with partner j at occasion k m k is a grand mean or intercept a i is variance unique to the actor i b j is variance unique to the partner j g ij is variance unique to the ij-dyad e ijk is error variance Round-Robin designs: (n * (n-1) / 2) Sample from all possible interactions Block designs: p persons interact with q persons Checker-board: multiple p's and q's of 2 or more

Development Gender Persistence Tenure Relative Ability to Compete Onlooking Directives Imitation From Hawley & Little, 1999 SEM of a Block Design

Multilevel Approaches Distinguish HLM (a specific program) from hierarchical linear modeling, the technique –A generic term for a type of analysis Probably best to discuss MRC(M) Modeling –Multilevel Random Coefficient Modeling Different program implementations –HLM, MLn, SAS, BMDP, LISREL, and others

"Once you know that hierarchies exist, you see them everywhere." "Once you know that hierarchies exist, you see them everywhere." -Kreft and de Leeuw ( 1998 )

Logic of MRCM Coefficients describing level 1 phenomena are estimated within each level 2 unit (e.g., individual- level effects) –Intercepts—means –Slopes—covariance/regression coefficients Level 1 coefficients are also analyzed at level 2 (e.g., dyad-level effects) –Intercepts: mean effect of dyad –Slopes: effects of dyad-level predictors

Negative Individual, Positive Group

Positive Individual, Negative Group

No Individual, Positive Group

No Group, Mixed Individual

A Contrived Example Y ij = Friendship Closeness ratings of each individual i within each dyad j. Level 1 Measures: Age & Social Skill of the individual participants Level 2 Measures: Length of Friendship & Gender Composition of Friendship

The Equations y ij =  0j +  1j Age +  2j SocSkill +  3j Age*Skill + r ij The Level 1 Equation:  0j =  00 +  01 (Time) +  02 (Gnd) +  03 (Time*Gnd) + u 0j  1j =  10 +  11 (Time) +  12 (Gnd) +  13 (Time*Gnd) + u 1j  2j =  20 +  21 (Time) +  22 (Gnd) +  23 (Time*Gnd) + u 2j  3j =  30 +  31 (Time) +  32 (Gnd) +  33 (Time*Gnd) + u 3j The Level 2 Equations:

Future Directions OLS vs. ML estimator and bias Individual-oriented data vs. dyad-oriented data Thoughts on Future Directions

Level 1 Equations: Meaning of Intercepts Y = Friendship Closeness Ratings –i individuals –across j dyads –r ij individual level error Intercept (Dyad-mean Closeness) –Y ij =  0j + r ij

Level 2 Equations: Meaning of Intercepts Do Dyad Means Differ? Mean Closeness across Dyads –  0j =  00 + u 0j Mean Closeness and dyad-level variables (time together and gender composition) –  0j =  00 +  01 (TIME) +  02 (Gen) + u 0j

Level 1 Equations: Meaning of Slope E.g., Relationship between Closeness and Social Skill within each dyad –Y ij =  0j +  2j (SocSkil) + r ij Intercept for each dyad:  0j Social Skill slope for each dyad:  2j

Level 2 Equations: Meaning of Slopes Mean Social Skill-Closeness relationship across all dyads –   j =  10 + u 1j Does SocSkill-Closeness relationship vary as a function of how long the dyad has been together? –  1j =  10 +  11 (TIME) + u 1j