Contrasting Tropical Rainfall Regimes Using TRMM and Ground-Based Polarimetric Radar by S. A. Rutledge, R. Cifelli, T. Lang and S. W. Nesbitt EGU 2009.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
POLARIMETRIC RADAR IMPROVEMENTS
Advertisements

Characteristics of Convection in an African Easterly Wave Observed During NAMMA Robert Cifelli, Timothy Lang, Steven A. Rutledge Colorado State University.
Cloud Radar in Space: CloudSat While TRMM has been a successful precipitation radar, its dBZ minimum detectable signal does not allow views of light.
Contrasting Tropical Rainfall Regimes Using TRMM and Ground-Based Polarimetric Radar Steven A. Rutledge, Robert Cifelli, Timothy J. Lang Colorado State.
Poster template by ResearchPosters.co.za Effect of Topography in Satellite Rainfall Estimation Errors: Observational Evidence across Contrasting Elevation.
A Microwave Retrieval Algorithm of Above-Cloud Electric Fields Michael J. Peterson The University of Utah Chuntao Liu Texas A & M University – Corpus Christi.
21 September th Southwest Hydrometeorology Symposium, Tucson, AZ Future QPE: Dual-Pol and Gap-Filler Radars Kevin Scharfenberg University of Oklahoma/CIMMS.
TRMM Tropical Rainfall Measurement (Mission). Why TRMM? n Tropical Rainfall Measuring Mission (TRMM) is a joint US-Japan study initiated in 1997 to study.
MICROWAVE RAINFALL RETRIEVALS AND VALIDATIONS R.M. GAIROLA, S. POHREL & A.K. VARMA OSD/MOG SAC/ISRO AHMEDABAD.
By: Jeana Mascio. The Point Want to be more accurate with estimating rainfall amounts from Z/R relationships.
Towards improved QPE with a local area X-band radar in the framework of COPS F. Tridon, J. Van Baelen and Y. Pointin Laboratoire de Météorologie Physique,
Precipitation Over Continental Africa and the East Atlantic: Connections with Synoptic Disturbances Matthew A. Janiga November 8, 2011.
Deanna Hence, Stacy Brodzik and Robert Houze University of Washington Introduction Methodology TCSP Storms RAINEX Storms Combined TCSP + RAINEX Storms.
Radar-Observed Characteristics of the Diurnal Cycle of Precipitation during NAME 2004 Timothy Lang, Steve Nesbitt, Rob Cifelli, and Steve Rutledge Colorado.
Continuing research on radar-observed precipitation systems during NAME 2004 Timothy J. Lang, Stephen W. Nesbitt, Steven A. Rutledge, Robert Cifelli, David.
Elevation-dependent Trends in Precipitation during NAME Angela K. Rowe, Steven A. Rutledge, and Timothy J. Lang Colorado State University, Fort Collins,
Hydrometeors Injected into the Large-scale Environment by Tropical Cloud Systems Robert A. Houze & Courtney Schumacher Co-PIs ARM Science Team Meeting,
Schumacher and Houze (2006) This Lecture: Review of Schumacher and Houze, 2006: Stratiform precipitation over sub- Saharan Africa and the Tropical.
Cirrus Production by Tropical Mesoscale Convective Systems Jasmine Cetrone and Robert Houze 8 February 2008.
Cirrus Production by Tropical Mesoscale Convective Systems Jasmine Cetrone and Robert Houze University of Washington Motivation Atmospheric heating by.
WHAT IS Z?  Radar reflectivity (dBZ)  Microwave energy reflects off objects (e.g. hydrometeors) and the return is reflectivity WHAT IS R?  Rainfall.
Contrasting Tropical Rainfall Regimes Using TRMM and Ground-Based Polarimetric Radar Steven A. Rutledge, Robert Cifelli, Timothy J. Lang Colorado State.
TRMM Observations of Convection over the Himalayan Region R. A. Houze and D. C. Wilton University of Washington Presented 1 February 2005 at the International.
Regional-scale analysis of convective systems in the 2006 West African Monsoon season Nick Guy Steven Rutledge, Rob Cifelli, and Timothy Lang Colorado.
Spaceborne Weather Radar
Using NPOL (the NASA S-band polarimetric radar), and a network of 2D video disdrometers for external radar calibration and rain rate estimation, and to.
Combining GOES-R and GPM to improve GOES-R rainrate product Nai-Yu Wang, University of Maryland, CICS Kaushik Gopalan, ISRO, India* Rachel Albrecht, INPE,
Radar Derived Precipitation Physics: Implications for GPM S. Rutledge 1, D. Wolff 2, B. Dolan 1, P. Kennedy 1, W. Petersen 2, P. Hein 1 and V. Chandrasekar.
Drop size distribution from WXT weather transmitter? Heikki Pohjola, Application specialist Thanks to Elena.
Satellite Radar Studies of Extreme Convective Storms ? ? New Fellows Presentation, AGU, San Francisco, 5 December 2012 Robert A. Houze, Jr. University.
CARPE-DIEM 13/6/02, slide 1German Aerospace Center Microwaves and Radar Institute CARPE-DIEM Besprechung Helsinki, June 2004 Ewan.
RA-228 AND RA-226 FROFILES FROM THE NORTHERN SOUTH CHINA SEA Hsiu-Chuan Lin, Yu-Chia Chung and Chi-Ju Lin Institute of Marine Geology and Chemistry, National.
Case Study Example 29 August 2008 From the Cloud Radar Perspective 1)Low-level mixed- phase stratocumulus (ice falling from liquid cloud layer) 2)Brief.
Microphysical Considerations in Remote Sensing of Precipitation Daniel Rosenfeld, Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Israel and Vincenzo Levizzani, ISAC-CNR,
S-Pol NAME Radar Network NAME radar network will allow characterization of gulf surge precipitation along coast and over Gulf of California Selected sectors.
The Role of Polarimetric Radar for Validating Cloud Models Robert Cifelli 1, Timothy Lang 1, Stephen Nesbitt 1, S.A. Rutledge 1 S. Lang 2, and W.K. Tao.
SPATIO-TEMPORAL STATIONARITY OF THE MEAN RAINFALL Armand NZEUKOU University of Dschang Cameroon & Henri SAUVAGEOT University of Toulouse III France.
Use of Profilers in TRMM Ground Validation Kenneth Gage 1, and Christopher Williams 1,2 1 NOAA Aeronomy Laboratory, Tropical Dynamics and Climate Group.
The climate and climate variability of the wind power resource in the Great Lakes region of the United States Sharon Zhong 1 *, Xiuping Li 1, Xindi Bian.
Climatology Precipitation 3B42 climatological precipitation is presented for July-September (peak monsoon period) in Fig. 2a, along with the 2006 season.
RAdio Detection And Ranging. Was originally for military use 1.Sent out electromagnetic radiation (Active) 2.Bounced off an object and returned to a listening.
Relationships between Lightning and Radar Parameters in the Mid-Atlantic Region Scott D. Rudlosky Cooperative Institute of Climate and Satellites University.
Polarimetric radar analysis of convection in northwestern Mexico Timothy J. Lang, Angela Rowe, Steve Rutledge, Rob Cifelli Steve Nesbitt.
EumetCal Examples.
1 Airborne Measurements of Ocean Backscatter Work In Progress by D. Esteban, Z. Jelenak, T. Mavor, P. Chang, NOAA/NESDIS/ORA D. Esteban, Z. Jelenak, T.
Evaluation of Passive Microwave Rainfall Estimates Using TRMM PR and Ground Measurements as References Xin Lin and Arthur Y. Hou NASA Goddard Space Flight.
2nd International GPM GV Workshop Taipei, Taiwan, September 27-29, 2005 Characteristics of Convective Systems Observed During TRMM-LBA Rob Cifelli, Steve.
Joanna Futyan and Tony DelGenio GIST 25, Exeter, 24 th October 2006 The Evolution of Convective Systems over Africa and the Tropical Atlantic.
A Global Rainfall Validation Strategy Wesley Berg, Christian Kummerow, and Tristan L’Ecuyer Colorado State University.
- 200 hPa geopotential heights in the GDAS analysis are lower than in CDAS between 20 o N to the South Pole hPa geopotential heights are consistently.
Dual-pol obs in NW Environment B. Dolan and S. Rutledge OLYMPEX planning meeting Seattle, 22 January 2015.
An Overview of Satellite Rainfall Estimation for Flash Flood Monitoring Timothy Love NOAA Climate Prediction Center with USAID- FEWS-NET, MFEWS, AFN Presented.
JAPAN’s GV Strategy and Plans for GPM
Kinematic, Microphysical, and Precipitation Characteristics of MCSs in TRMM-LBA Robert Cifelli, Walter Petersen, Lawrence Carey, and Steven A. Rutledge.
G O D D A R D S P A C E F L I G H T C E N T E R TRMM Tropical Rainfall Measuring Mission 2nd GPM GV Workshop TRMM Ground Validation Some Lessons and Results.
- 200 hPa geopotential heights in the GDAS analysis are lower than in CDAS over most of the planet except the North American continent, particularly from.
Observations of Specific Differential Phase, KDP Chris Collier Acknowledgements: Lindsay Bennett, Alan Blyth and David Dufton.
Passive Microwave Remote Sensing
Statistical Analysis of S-Pol Polarimetric Radar Data from NAME 2004 Timothy J. Lang, Robert Cifelli, Steven A. Rutledge, Angela Rowe, and Lee Nelson Colorado.
HSAF Soil Moisture Training
Radar/Surface Quantitative Precipitation Estimation
The Variable Structure of Convection at Low Latitudes
Polarimetric radar analysis of convection in the complex topography
Matt Lebsock Chris Kummerow Graeme Stephens Tristan L’Ecuyer
OLYMPEx Precipitation
Polarimetric radar analysis of convection in northwestern Mexico
TOWARDS HIGH-RESOLUTION GLOBAL SATELLITE PRECIPITATION ESTIMATION
Validation of Satellite Precipitation Estimates using High-Resolution Surface Rainfall Observations in West Africa Paul A. Kucera and Andrew J. Newman.
Jennifer C. DeHart, Robert A. Houze, Jr. and Deanna A. Hence
D. C. Stolz, S. A. Rutledge, J. R. Pierce, S. C. van den Heever 2017
Presentation transcript:

Contrasting Tropical Rainfall Regimes Using TRMM and Ground-Based Polarimetric Radar by S. A. Rutledge, R. Cifelli, T. Lang and S. W. Nesbitt EGU 2009 Session AS1.3

The TRMM satellite has provided unprecedented data for over 10 years. TRMM precipitation products have advanced our understanding of tropical precipitation considerably. We used ground-based polarimetric radar data from two field campaigns, TRMM-LBA (1999) and NAME (North American Monsoon Experiment; 2004), to characterize the physical nature of precipitation in these regions (tropical Brazil and Mexico). We focus on comparing rain rate and reflectivity distributions between the TRMM PR and the ground based radar data. TRMM LBA NAME

East-West Regimes found in TRMM-LBA. East regime associated with high CAPE, vigorous convection and frequent lightning. West regime associated with lower CAPE, weaker convection and lower flash rates. January-February 1999.

Strong topographical influence on precipitation intensity and structure. For both NAME and LBA, observations suggest equilibrium DSD indicated by near constant D 0 values at high rain rates/reflectivities.

Mean TRMM reflectivity values are lower compared to S-pol below 7-8 km. Above this level TRMM PR is higher mainly due to 17 dB cut off for the PR. Are the reflectivity differences below 7-8 km a result of attenuation correction issues for the PR (wet ice, Mie effects), sampling issues (many more PR profiles compared to ground based profiles), or other factors? S-pol resolution has been degraded

For NAME, PR reflectivities are again less than those for S-pol in a vertical profile sense. Near surface values are in better agreement with S-pol. In a mean profile sense, and statistically, the PR reflectivities are lower compared to ground based observations for both locales. PR profile remains below S-pol profile. Stronger convection in NAME.

TRMM PR does not see the high rain rates observed in the S-pol spectrum TRMM PR places more rain volume at lower rain rates compared to the ground based radar. Turn now to examination of rain rates between PR and S-pol for TRMM-LBA

NAME shows similar behavior, especially over water and the coastal plains. At higher elevations, TRMM PR and S-pol rain rate spectrum is in better agreement. This may be due to reduced S-pol resolution (compared to PR) at long ranges required to sample storms over the higher terrain. Over waterCoastal plain m> 1500 m And the same analysis for NAME

For NAME, TRMM PR places more rain volume at lower rain rates compared to the ground based radar. Consistent with finding for TRMM-LBA % differences in rain volume seen for this particular comparison.

Z-R plot for LBA Solid--S-pol Dash--PR Above 10 mm/h, PR reflectivity corresponds to lower rain rate compared to same reflectivity for S-pol.

Over water Over coastal plains Z-R relationships in fair agreement over water. Z-R relationships in lesser agreement over adjacent coastal plains and higher topographical elevations (not shown). NAME For a given Z, TRMM Z-R produces less rain compared to S–pol for R > 10 mm/h

Summary To the extent that the differences in the PR and ground based data records don’t matter….. TRMM PR reflectivities reduced over land compared to ground based observations in two field projects. Does this reflect issues with attenuation correction over land? TRMM generated rain rates are lower than ground based radar estimates for a given reflectivity. Single polarization, radar-based rain estimates such as those from the PR are not capable of capturing the full physics of the DSD. So even if the Z’s were to match…. Evidence for equilibrium DSD being achieved in these tropical rain regimes; drop break up produces smaller drops. This process complicates Z based rain estimation. Appeal next to Darwin dataset that is much longer than field campaign data Acknowledge long term support from NASA TRMM and PMM programs

DSD differences can be seen in distribution of A coefficient in Z = AR b DSD Attenuation correction Rain estimation