Missing Photons that Count: Galaxy Evolution via Absorbing Gas (and a little bit of fundamental physics to boot) Chris Churchill (Penn State)

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Neutral Gas Reservoirs from z=0 to z ~ 5 Neutral Gas Reservoirs from z=0 to z ~ 5 Art Wolfe Marc Rafelski: UCSD Marcel Neeleman: UCSD Michele Fumagali:
Advertisements

Hot Gas in Damped Lyman- Systems Hidden Baryons & Metals in Galactic Halos at z=2-4 Andrew Fox (ESO-Chile) with P. Petitjean, C. Ledoux, R. Srianand, J.
Tom Theuns Institute for Computational Cosmology, Durham, UK Department of Physics, Antwerp, Belgium Munich 2005 Reionization And the thermal history of.
Metals at Highish Redshift And Large Scale Structures From DLAs to Underdense Regions Patrick Petitjean Institut d’Astrophysique de Paris B. Aracil R.
Probing the End of Reionization with High-redshift Quasars Xiaohui Fan University of Arizona Mar 18, 2005, Shanghai Collaborators: Becker, Gunn, Lupton,
Motivation 40 orbits of UDF observations with the ACS grism Spectra for every source in the field. Good S/N continuum detections to I(AB) ~ 27; about 30%
Elements of observational cosmology Integalactic medium:  in clusters  between clusters.
The Highest-Redshift Quasars and the End of Cosmic Dark Ages Xiaohui Fan Collaborators: Strauss,Schneider,Richards, Hennawi,Gunn,Becker,White,Rix,Pentericci,
End of Cosmic Dark Ages: Observational Probes of Reionization History Xiaohui Fan University of Arizona New Views Conference, Dec 12, 2005 Collaborators:
ESO Recent Results on Reionization Chris Carilli (NRAO) LANL Cosmology School, July 2011 Review: constraints on IGM during reionization  CMB large scale.
Cosmological Reionization Nick Gnedin. Co-starring Gayler Harford Katharina Kohler Peter Shaver Mike Shull Massimo Ricotti.
Probing the Universe with QSO Absorption Lines David Turnshek University of Pittsburgh.
NEUTRAL HYDROGEN Frank Briggs RSAA and ATNF z = 8 z = 0.
The Science of JWST Caleb Wheeler. Table of Contents First Paper Second Paper Nervous standing after I finish early and everyone is too bored to formulate.
Cosmological Evolution of the Fine Structure Constant Chris Churchill (Penn State)  = e 2 /hc  = (  z -  0 )/  0 In collaboration with: J. Webb,
C. Churchill (NMSU) D. Ceverino (NMSU) A. Klypin (NMSU) C. Steidel (Caltech) M. Murphy (Swinburne) N. Vogt (NMSU) Glenn G. Kacprzak (NMSU / Swinburne)
Mg II & C IV Absorption Kinematics vs. Stellar Kinematics in Galaxies Chris Churchill (Penn State) J. Charlton J. Ding J. Masiero D. Schneider M. Dickinson.
Rand (2000) NGC 5775 Hα map. D = 24.8 Mpc It is an interacting galaxy.
Galactic Gas Kinematics and High Velocity Clouds at z~1 Chris Churchill (Penn State) Mg II 2796,2803 absorption from galaxies and ??? in quasar spectra.
How to Measure Evolution in the Fundamental Constants of Physics with Large Telescopes Chris Churchill (Penn State) …and sneak in astronomical observations.
“Damped Lyman Alpha Systems” by Wolfe, Arthur M., Gawiser, E. and Prochaska, Jason X. Jean P. Walker Rutgers University Galaxy Formation Seminar.
Simona Gallerani Constraining cosmic reionization models with QSOs, GRBs and LAEs observational data In collaboration with: A. Ferrara, X. Fan, T. Choudhury,
Evolution of the IGM/Galaxy Halo Interface to z=2 Chris Churchill (New Mexico State University) Wal Sargent (Caltech) Michael Rauch (Carnegie)
Cosmological Evolution of the Fine Structure Constant Chris Churchill (Penn State)  = e 2 /hc  = (  z -  0 )/  0 In collaboration with: J. Webb,
Quasar Absorption Lines Tracing Cosmic Structure Growth & Galaxy Evolution Over Cosmic Time.
The metallicity of the intergalactic medium and its evolution Anthony Aguirre UCSC.
Galaxy Properties and the Kinematics of Gaseous Halos Chris Churchill (NMSU) Glenn Kacprzak (NMSU) Chuck Steidel (Caltech) also see: Poster (G.
IAP XVII1 Millions of Tiny, Weak Mg II Absorbers: What are They? Chris Churchill (Penn State) Jane Rigby (Steward); Jane Charlton (PSU) Churchill, Rigby,
A hot topic: the 21cm line I Benedetta Ciardi MPA.
Andrew Fox (ESO-Chile) Jacqueline Bergeron & Patrick Petitjean (IAP-Paris)
Galaxy Formation and Evolution Chris Brook Modulo 15 Room 509
Non-LTE in Stars The Sun Early-type stars Other spectral types.
1 Probing the high redshift (2-3) IGM through OVI absorption Sowgat Muzahid (IUCAA, INDIA) Supervisor : R. Srianand (IUCAA, INDIA) Collaborator : P. Petitjean.
The Evolution of Quasars and Massive Black Holes “Quasar Hosts and the Black Hole-Spheroid Connection”: Dunlop 2004 “The Evolution of Quasars”: Osmer 2004.
Sources of Reionization Jordi Miralda Escudé Institut de Ciències de l’Espai (IEEC-CSIC, ICREA), Barcelona. Beijing,
10/14/08 Claus Leitherer: UV Spectra of Galaxies 1 Massive Stars in the UV Spectra of Galaxies Claus Leitherer (STScI)
Nick Gnedin (Once More About Reionization)
Andrea Ferrara SISSA/International School for Advanced Studies, Trieste Cosmic Dawn and IGM Reionization.
Missing Photons that Count: Galaxy Evolution via Absorbing Gas (and a little bit of fundamental physics to boot) Chris Churchill (Penn State)
Galaxies and Other Gaseous Structures Through Quasar Absorption Lines Jane Charlton Penn State Collaborators: Chris Churchill (NMSU), Jie Ding (NYU),
Texas Symposium, MelbourneDecember 14th 2006 Theoretical Properties of Ly  Cooling Radiation’ Mark Dijkstra (CfA) Collaborators: Z. Haiman, M.Spaans &
The Detectability of Lyα Emission from Galaxies during the Epoch of Reionization Dijkstra, Mesinger, Wyithe. JC Alex Fry.
In this toy scenario, metal enriched clouds entrained in galactic winds gives rise to absorption lines in quasar spectra, as illustrated in the above panels.
Collaborators Blair Savage, Bart Wakker (UW-Madison) Blair Savage, Bart Wakker (UW-Madison) Ken Sembach (STScI) Ken Sembach (STScI) Todd Tripp (UMass)
The Distributions of Baryons in the Universe and the Warm Hot Intergalactic Medium Baryonic budget at z=0 Overall thermal timeline of baryons from z=1000.
Complete Ionisation of the Neutral Gas in the Hosts of High Redshift AGN As Traced Through HI and MgII Absorption.
UNM 29-Oct04 Galaxy-Halo Gas Kinematic Connection at 0.3 < z < 1 Collaborators: Chris Churchill (NMSU) Chuck Steidel (Caltech) Alice Shapley (Princeton)
Weipeng Lin (The Partner Group of MPA, SHAO) Collaborators Gerhard Börner (MPA) Houjun Mo (UMASS & MPA) Quasar Absorption line systems: Inside and around.
Simulations of Lyα emission: fluorescence, cooling, galaxies Jordi Miralda Escudé ICREA University of Barcelona, Catalonia Berkeley, Collaborators:
Lyman- Emission from The Intergalactic Medium
How to Measure Evolution in Fundamental Constants of Physics Using Large Telescopes Chris Churchill (Penn State) Evolution in the Fine Structure Constant.
Why do we need a VLST for studying QSO absorption lines? So that we can go deeper…
X-shooter spectroscopy of the GRB090926A afterglow Valerio D’Elia (ASDC/INAF-OAR) & The X-shooter GRB collaboration April, 22nd Kyoto - Japan.
Lecture 8 Optical depth.
Missing Photons that Count: Galaxy Evolution via Absorbing Gas (and a little bit of fundamental physics to boot) Chris Churchill (Penn State)
Star Formation in Damped Lyman alpha Systems Art Wolfe Collaborators: J.X. Prochaska, J. C. Howk, E.Gawiser, and K. Nagamine.
Probing quasar outflows with intrinsic narrow absorption lines 1/15 The Central Engine of AGN in Xi’an (Oct. 17, 2006) T. Misawa, M. Eracleous, J. C. Charlton.
Big Bang f(HI) ~ 0 f(HI) ~ 1 f(HI) ~ History of Baryons (mostly hydrogen) Redshift Recombination Reionization z = 1000 (0.4Myr) z = 0 (13.6Gyr) z.
KASI Galaxy Evolution Journal Club A Massive Protocluster of Galaxies at a Redshift of z ~ P. L. Capak et al. 2011, Nature, in press (arXive: )
The distant Universe and something about gravitational waves.
Cosmic Dust Enrichment and Dust Properties Investigated by ALMA Hiroyuki Hirashita ( 平下 博之 ) (ASIAA, Taiwan)
FUSE and HST Observations of Helium II Absorption in the IGM: Implications for Seeing HI Re-ionization Gerard Kriss STScI.
Proximity Effect Around High-redshift Galaxies
Lecture 6 Summary and Perspectives
Martin Haehnelt, Matteo Viel, Volker Springel
Jill Bechtold (University of Arizona)
The Stellar Population of Metal−Poor Galaxies at z~1
Probing Reionization with Lyman Alpha Emitters Pratika Dayal
High Resolution Spectroscopy of the IGM: How High
Author: Ting-Wen Lan and Houjun Mo.(2018)
Presentation transcript:

Missing Photons that Count: Galaxy Evolution via Absorbing Gas (and a little bit of fundamental physics to boot) Chris Churchill (Penn State)

To Earth CIV SiIVCIISiII Ly  em Ly  forest Lyman limit NV em SiIV em CIV em Ly  em Ly  SiII quasar Quasars: physics laboratories in the early universe Ly 

Damped Lyman-  Absorbers (DLAs): N(HI) > 2 x cm -2 Lyman Limit Systems (LLSs): N(HI) > 2 x cm -2 Lyman-  Forest N(HI) < 6 x cm -2 Categories by Neutral Hydrogen Compact Star forming objects Galaxy centers Metal lines, low ionization dominate Proto-galaxy structures Galaxy outskirts (extended halos, disks) Metal lines, low, intermediate, and high ionization Cosmic Web Sheets and Filaments Metal lines, weak to non-existent

“The Lyman Alpha Forest” Piercing the Cosmic Web Tracing Structure Growth Constraining Ionization Evolution Ly  forest N(HI) < cm -2

Great Insights are gained from simulations of structure growth, but these simulations are starved for hard data to constrain the physics… Note structure growth is rapid at for z>5 (a short cosmological time frame), and then evolution is slower, especially from z<1 (majority of time)… (courtesy M. Haehnelt)

The Power of Simply Counting Lines The redshift path density, dN/dz, places constraints on simulations of structure growth as a function of redshift… (Dave’ etal 1999)

The Power of Simply Counting Lines The redshift path density, dN/dz, places constraints on simulations of structure growth as a function of redshift… (Dave’ etal 1999)

The Power of Simply Counting Lines The redshift path density, dN/dz, places constraints on simulations of structure growth as a function of redshift… (Dave’ etal 1999)

The Power of Simply Counting Lines The redshift path density, dN/dz, places constraints on simulations of structure growth as a function of redshift… (Dave’ etal 1999) or

The Power of Simply Counting Lines (Dave’ etal 1999) (Weymann’ etal 1999)

“C IV Systems” Proto-galactic clumps Tracing Pre-galactic Structure Growth Constraining Kinematic/Dynamic Evolution Metal Lines N(HI) ~ 2 x cm -2

Efforts have been made to include ionization feedback, both in terms of spectral energy distributions, photon transport, and mechanical stirring of the gas… QSO Absorption Lines: Anatonomy of a Simulation (courtesy M. Steinmetz)

Technology and innovation is quickly outpacing observational data… QSO Absorption Lines: Anatonomy of a Simulation (courtesy M. Steinmetz) Ly-  C IV Velocity

The Power of Simply Counting Lines Mg II shows no evolution (co-moving), but nothing in known above z=2.2 Lyman Limit systems (LLS) show no evolution, measured from continuum “break” at 916 A in the rest frame, N(HI)> cm -2 C IV systems evolve rapidly! They increase with cosmic time until z=1.5 and then show no evolution Structure, Ionization, or Chemical Evolution? Evolution measures product of: number size ionization fraction Is this an increase in number, in ionization level, or in the chemical abundance of carbon? We need low ionization data. Mg II.

Motivations and Astrophysical Context Mg II arises in environments ranging over five decades of N(H I) Damped Lyman-  Absorbers (DLAs): N(HI) > 2 x cm -2 Lyman Limit Systems (LLSs): N(HI) > 2 x cm -2 sub-LLSs: (low redshift forest!) N(HI) < 6 x cm -2 eg. Biosse’ etal (1998); Rao & Turnshek (2000); Churchill etal (2000b) eg. Steidel & Sargent (1992); Churchill etal (2000a) eg. Churchill & Le Brun (1998); Churchill etal (1999); Rigby etal (2001) Mg II selection probes a wide range of astrophysical sites where star formation has enriched gas; these sites can be traced from redshift 0 to 5 Mg II  -process ion – Type II SNe – enrichment from first stars (<1 Myr) Fe II iron-group ion – Type Ia SNe – late stellar evolution (>few Gyr)

Present Day Coverage and Astrophysical Context

Simple Kinematic Models of Absorbing Gas from Galaxies Absorption kinematics is symmetric about the galaxy’s systemic velocity Absorption kinematics is offset in the direction of stellar rotation compared to the galaxy’s systemic velocity Halo/infall + Rotating/disk produces both signatures in single profile (Charlton & Churchill 1998)

Mg II 2796 Absorption Profiles from HIRES/Keck Galaxy redshifts can be matched to the absorbers… (Churchill 2001)

Mg II 2796 Absorption Profiles from HIRES/Keck (Churchill & Vogt 2001)

Mg II 2796 Absorption Profiles from HIRES/Keck Each Mg II system has several Fe II transitions and Mg I (neutral) The clouds are modeled using Voigt profile decomposition… Obtain number of clouds, temperatures, column densities, ionization conditions (from modeling)…

Build the Database and the Simulations will Follow Ultimately, the simulations need to be driven by the data… as we have seen the great successes in this arena for the Lya forest to z=5, and are seeing the new successes for metal enriched diffuse objects to z=5…. We will begin to see the successes of galaxy evolution in more detail, including structure evolution, kinematics, metallicity, and ionization. The data are lacking. Wholesale inventory of Mg II absorbers is the best approach. (courtesy M. Haehnelt)

Q Q Q (Steidel etal 2002)

Kinematics: Stellar, Mg II 2796, and C IV 1548, 1551 Mg II traces stellar kinematics yet is difficult to explain as extended disk rotation (at 72 kpc impact parameter!). C IV traces Mg II kinematics but has strongest component at galaxy’s systemic velocity, as highlighted in What physical entity is giving rise to this C IV component? (Churchill 2003; Churchill etal, in prep)

Population of Weak Systems: Where do they arise? 1.Their equivalent width distribution follows a power law down to 0.02 A 2.Arise in optically thin H I (Ly  clouds) 25%-100% of all Lya clouds with column densities <N(HI)< cm -2 3.Constrained to not have supersolar metallicity, almost all have z>0.1 solar 4.Many are iron rich, suggesting later stages of star formation 5.90% cannot be associated with galaxies (within 70 kpc) (Churchill etal 1999; Rigby etal 2002)

Equivalent Width Distribution Differential Number Density Distribution Redshift Path Density Using HIRES/Keck, we discovered that the EW distribution followed a power law, with no observable cut off down to W=0.02 A. - these are high metallicity “forest” clouds. 5 papers over 10 years predicted that none of these “weak” systems existed! They outnumber galaxies by 1:10 6. As the lower EW cutoff of the sample, W min, is increased, the number of systems per unit redshift decreases… (As W min increases, the mean redshift increases – ) differential redshift evolution Comoving redshift path density is consistent with no structure/ionization evolution for W min =0.02 A (red) and W min =0.3 A (blue). dN/dz ~ n  (1+z) .

Evolution of Strongest Systems As W min increased – evolution is stronger dN/dz = N 0 (1+z)  What is the nature of the evolution??? Is it related to high velocity clouds, presence of supperbubbles, or superwinds??? REDSHIFTREDSHIFT Scenario of kinematic evolution of gas…

Present Day Coverage and Astrophysical Context The epochs of greatest evolution are un-probed… (Based upon Pei etal 1999)

 (stars)  (gas)  (baryons)  (gas flow)  (IGM metals) No coverage for Mg II for z>2.2 No high resolution coverage for Mg II for z>1.4 Mg II provides metalicity for high-z forest in lower ionization gas- heretofore un-probed Constraints on Global Galaxy Evolution Models (Pei etal 1999)

Some Future Plans High Resolution optical spectra of QSOs to get Mg II kinematics to cover 1.4<z<2.2 High Resolution HST ultraviolet spectra of higher ionization gas Low Resolution infrared spectra of QSOs to get Mg II statistics for 2.2<z<4.0 Moderated Resolution HST ultraviolet spectra of higher ionization gas High Resolution infrared spectra of QSOs to get Mg II kinematics for 2.2<z<4.0 Leading international collaboration: Keck, Subaru, VLT, HET, BLT Student opportunities include observing, echelle data reduction, data analysis --- VP decomposition, statistics, distribution function (DF) evolution Collaborating with N. Kobayashi: Subaru, VLT Student opportunities include observing, UV and IR data reduction, data analysis --- visibility function, sample completeness, statistics, DF evolution This is 5-10 years future:VLT, BLT

“And now… for something completely different.”

Evidence For Cosmological Evolution of the Fine Structure Constant?  = (  z -  0 )/  0  = e 2 /hc

Relativistic shift of the central line in the multiplet Procedure 1. Compare heavy (Z~30) and light (Z<10) atoms, OR 2. Compare s p and d p transitions in heavy atoms. Shifts can be of opposite sign. Illustrative formula: E z=0 is the laboratory frequency. 2 nd term is non-zero only if  has changed. q is derived from relativistic many-body calculations. K is the spin-orbit splitting parameter. Numerical examples: Z=26 (s p) FeII 2383A:   = (2) x Z=12 (s p) MgII 2796A:   = (2) + 120x Z=24 (d p) CrII 2066A:   = (2) x where x =  z  0  MgII “anchor”

 /  = -5×10 -5 High-z Low-z

Uncorrected: Quoted Results