Presenter Disclosures (1)The following personal financial relationships with commercial interests relevant to this presentation existed during the past 12 months: Iwalani Else “No relationships to disclose”
Native Hawaiian Adolescents and Suicide by ‘Iwalani Else, Ph.D. Pūlama I Ke Ola (Life is Precious) Approaching 2010 – Addressing Hawai‘i’s Health Disparities May 22, 2008 Department of Psychiatry John A. Burns School of Medicine University of Hawai‘i at Mānoa
Suicide in the United States – A Public Health Issue per 100,000 ( ) 3 times higher than homicide Twice as high as deaths from HIV/AIDS Males higher completion rates than females (4:1) Females higher rates of attempts than males (3:1) (CDC, 2007 and NIMH, 2003 & 2004)
Suicide in the United States – A Public Health Issue Ninety percent (90%) of people who die by suicide have a diagnosable mental illness and/or substance abuse disorder. 1 The annual cost of untreated mental illness is $100 billion. 2 Rates are affected by the data Quality/accuracy Coding/definitions 1 National Center for Health Statistics, Bazelon Center for Mental Health Law, 1999
Youth Suicide in the United States Suicide is the fastest growing cause of death among U.S. youth in the past 60 years Youth suicide rates tripled from From Rates among year olds increased by 14% Rates among year olds increased by 100% (U.S. Public Health Service, 1999)
Suicide in Hawai‘i Suicide is the single leading cause of injury death in Hawai‘i lives to suicide each year (about one every 3 days) per 100,000 for Hawai‘i State Department of Health 2 CDC WISQARS
Causes of fatal injuries among Hawaii residents, (Galanis, 2006 – Department of Health)
Injury Pyramid for Suicide and Attempts in Hawai‘i Deaths (128/yr.) Hospitalizations ~870 (7:1 ratio to deaths) Ambulance calls ~500 (?) (~4:1 ratio to deaths) Emergency department visits ~560 (~5:1 ratio to deaths) (Hawai‘i State Department of Health) Non-fatal attempts/ self-inflicted injuries
Suicide Numbers and Rates (per 100,000) by County in Hawai‘i Suicide Numbers and Rates (per 100,000) by County in Hawai‘i (Galanis, 2006 – Department. of Health, revised to annual rates)
Negative Life Events in Autopsy Records
Native Hawaiians Native Hawaiians (Kanaka Maoli) 60% live in the state of Hawai‘i Make up 20% of the state’s population Ethnically diverse Two-thirds (~67%) of Native Hawaiians claimed more than one race/ethnic group Compared with 38% of Whites and 32% of Japanese
Native Hawaiians Source: PASE REPORT, 03-04:12. Policy Analysis & System Evaluation Kamehameha Schools. Koren Ishibashi, December 2003.
Native Suicide: A Multi-factorial Event -Edn,-Econ,-Rec Family Disruption Domestic Violence Family Disruption Domestic Violence Impulsiveness Negative Boarding School Hopelessness Historical Trauma Family History Suicidal Behavior Suicidal Behavior Cultural Distress Psychiatric Illness & Stigma Psychodynamics/ Psychological Vulnerability Psychodynamics/ Psychological Vulnerability Substance Use/Abuse Suicide (Douglas Jacobs, 2003 and R. Dale Walker, 2003)
History of Cultural Loss Loss of land The Great Mahele Plantation economy Loss of life By 1893, 90% of the native population had died from introduced, communicable diseases Loss of self-determination Overthrow of the monarchy 1898 – Formal annexation to the United States Statehood
History of Cultural Loss, cont’d Loss of language Hawaiian language has an oral tradition Missionaries, 1820s Hawaiian was banned as a language between 1896 and 1986 In public and private schools In the early 1900’s, children were severely punished for speaking Hawaiian
(Galanis, 2006 – Department. of Health, revised to annual rates) Annual Unadjusted Rates (per 100,000) of Suicides among Hawaii Residents by Ethnicity, Groups with the same letters have statistically comparable rate estimates (p>.05) Annual U.S. Rate
Annual Suicide Rates (per 100,000) among Hawai‘i Residents by Age Group & Ethnicity, (Galanis, 2006 – Dept. of Health, revised to annual rates)
Suicides & Attempts in Hawai‘i Suicides (fatal) Males at risk (77% of victims) Youth have lowest risk, elderly highest Most commonly hangings (45%) Firearms 2nd (23%) Decreasing trends (males only) Higher risk on Neighbor Islands Why? (from autopsy records): mental illness, negative events, substance use, previous attempts Attempts (non-fatal) Females predominate (60%) Youth have highest risk, elderly lowest Predominantly (68%) poisonings from drugs/medicinal substances Trends? (lack of injury coding) NI vs Oahu? (lack of injury coding) Why? (other studies)
Suicide Attempt* in Hawai‘i Youth (39 states reporting) (Youth Risk Behavior Surveillance System [YRBSS], 2005 ) 2nd highest percent of youth (nearly 20%) who reported that they “seriously considered attempting suicide” Highest percent of youth (17%) who reported “making a suicide plan” 2nd highest percent of youth (13%) who reported “attempted suicide” 4th highest (4%) who reported “suicide attempt treated by a doctor or nurse” *In the past 12 months
Trends in self-reported suicide risk factor prevalence among high school students, Hawaii vs. U.S.,
National Center on Indigenous Hawaiian Behavioral Health Reflects over 20 years of research on Native Hawaiians in the Department of Psychiatry, JABSOM, UH Mānoa Two epidemiologic studies Native Hawaiian Mental Health Research Development Program (NIMH-R25) Pacific Peoples’ Mental Health Research Support Program (NIMH-R25)
Attempted suicide, Native Hawaiians 12.9% Risks/Predictors Depression Substance use Lower education of main wage earner Higher Hawaiian cultural affiliation Non-Hawaiians 9.6% Risks/Predictors Depression Substance use Aggression Yuen, et al Cultural identification and attempted suicide in Native Hawaiians. Journal of American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 39 :
Attempted suicide, Native Hawaiians (n=700) 9.2% Females – 12%, depression, aggression, substance use, low family support, Hawaiian culture 47% drank alcohol 27% smoked pot 14% smoked cigarettes Males – 5%, depression, anxiety, aggression, cigarettes, low family support, Hawaiian culture 20% smoked cigarettes (Else, Andrade & Nahulu, 2007) Non-Hawaiians (n=472) 6.4% Females – 9%, depression, aggression, substance use, low family support 52% drank alcohol 39% smoked pot 17% smoked cigarettes Males – 5%, lifestyles, language 43% smoked pot
Lifetime Suicide Attempts, Resilience and protective factors Talking with mothers and fathers, family cohesion and organization, parental bonding, and family support Risk factors Sexual activity, having sex with both males and females, family conflict, and witnessing or hearing family violence Family conflict: 7.4 times more likely to have made a suicide attempt in the past year Sexual activity: 6.9 times more likely to have made a suicide attempt during the past year. (Else, Andrade & Nahulu, 2007)
Intervention Points Suicide Mental illness, depression, ideation and previous attempts, negative life events (relationship ending, serious illness), alcohol and drug use. Attempted suicide (youth) Anxiety, depression, substance use, family conflict, sexual activity Promote family cohesion, bonding and support
Resources National Suicide Prevention Lifeline TALK (8255) ACCESS Line: Crisis line (808) Neighbor Islands – Department of Health, Injury Prevention and Control Program – Art Tani, Hawai‘i State Suicide Prevention Coordinator (808) ASIST (Applied Suicide Intervention Skills Training)
Acknowledgments Department of Psychiatry – National Center on Indigenous Hawaiian Behavioral Health Department of Health, Injury Prevention & Control Dan Galanis, Ph.D., State Epidemiologist Art Tani, Suicide Prevention Coordinator Suicide Steering Committee & Task Force National Center on Minority Health and Health Disparities Conference planners