Sustainable energy supply in Germany – scenario analysis with different CO 2 certificate prices Markus Blesl, Uwe Remme, Ulrich Fahl 24.06.2003 International.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Model Comparison: Top-Down vs. Bottom-Up Models

Advertisements

© OECD/IEA 2010 Data Compilation Issues for Electricity and Heat Energy Statistics Workshop Beijing, China, Sept Pierre Boileau International Energy.

Rainer Friedrich, Sandra Torras Ortiz, Ganlin Huang Institute for Energy Economics and the rational Use of Energy – University Stuttgart, Germany Jouni.

Lignite Project By Ramic, Haris. GLOBAL OUTLOOK FOR ENERGY World energy consumption is projected to increase at about 1.8%/year between 2000 and 2030(driven.

University College London Complex Built Environment Systems Bartlett School of Graduate Studies 1 Using ESDS data for Energy and Environment Modelling.

Planning and Partnership Panel – 9 March 2007 John Rumble Sustainability Team Leader Forward Planning Climate Change in Hertfordshire.

FOREST FUEL - RENEWABLE ENERGY. Renewable energy Today, renewable energy is an important part of the Swedish energy budget. With its share in the energy.

The contribution of electro-technologies to energy efficiency Paul Baudry, Marie-Ann Evans UIE (International Union for Electricity applications) Conference.

Future role of renewable energy in Germany against the background of climate change mitigation and liberalisation Dipl.-Ing. Uwe Remme Institute of Energy.

Global and Regional Emissions and Mitigation Policies (with Application of ERB model for India) P.R. Shukla.

European Electricity Market between Liberalisation and Climate Protection Dr. Markus Blesl, Dipl.-Ing. Uwe Remme, Dr. Ulrich Fahl International.

Why should renewable energy not be subsidised?. Sustainable Energy Usage By the end of the lesson you will; 1) Be able to describe the key features of.

11 Energy in Denmark Observed energy consumption and adjusted gross energy consumption.

UK POLICIES AND MEASURES SIAN PRIEST DEPARTMENT FOR ENVIRONMENT, FOOD AND RURAL AFFAIRS.

1 Brendan Devlin Adviser, Markets and Infrastructure Directorate B, DG ENER European Commission.

INTERNATIONAL ENERGY AGENCY AGENCE INTERNATIONALE DE L’ENERGIE 1 Dr. Robert K. Dixon Head, Energy Technology Policy Division International Energy Agency.

The National Danish Energy Policy focus on waste and biomass Anders H Kristensen Danish Energy Agency.

Japan Energy Update Kae Takase Senior Economist Governance Design Laboratory.

Status: Karsten Brinkmann PowerMex-CHP_CO2 bensheim engineers CHP – one Possibility to reduce CO 2 Karsten Brinkmann Promotion for CHP Berlin.

The National Danish Energy Policy focus on waste and biomass Anders H Kristensen Danish Energy Agency.

World Energy Outlook Strategic Challenges Hideshi Emoto Senior Energy Analyst International Energy Agency.

WIND ENERGY Is there a Latvian Master Plan? CHRISTIAN KJÆR Chief Executive Officer European Wind Energy Association SSE Riga, 4 December 2008 © EWEA/L.

Owen WILSON Environment and Sustainable Development Committee, EURELECTRIC POWER CHOICES EURELECTRIC Study on low-CO2 Europe by 2050 POWER CHOICES EURELECTRIC.

National Seminar Role of DER in the EU and Current Status in the Baltic States 6 March 2007 Current Status of Energy Policy on Development of Distributed.

© Prof. Dr. Georg Erdmann 1 Electricity Systems with High Renewable Energy Shares Prof. Dr. Georg Erdmann TU Berlin; Chair Energy Systems Member of the.

Jan MELICHAR Charles University Environment Center NEEDS Forum 3 - Cairo January 28, 2008 The external costs calculation in CEEC countries focusing on.

CEEH Workshop Roskilde, February 6, 2008 The Pan European NEEDS-TIMES model SIXTH FRAMEWORK PROGRAMME [6.1] [ Sustainable Energy Systems] Markus Blesl.

APERC Workshop, Bali 16 November, 2009 Norihiro Okumura Asia Pacific Energy Research Centre APEC ENERGY DEMAND & SUPPLY OUTLOOK 4 th Edition ～ Case of.

1 5.2 Low-energy strategies for the European Union Katharina Koch Manuela Steiner Barbara Unterrainer.

TA Project: “Improving Emissions Control” Session 2 Scenarios for Emissions Management Dr Russell C Frost Project Team Leader.

1 Macroeconomic Impacts of EU Climate Policy in AIECE November 5, 2008 Olavi Rantala - Paavo Suni The Research Institute of the Finnish Economy.

Energy Information Administration Official Energy Statistics from the U.S. Government Annual Energy Outlook 2008 Energy Information Administration December.

Swedish Energy Policy. Relative Energy Supply coal hydro wood oil nuclear new RES.

Estonian energy scenarios 2030, 2050 Mikael Togeby Anders Larsen.

Energy in Germany. All that needs energy. Traffic, heating, or eletricity almost everything needs energy. We produce most of our electricity with.

Updates on the RFE Energy Sector and the RFE LEAP model, and Implications of a Regional Alternative Path for the Russian Far East Victor Kalashnikov Economic.

The Dutch energy accounts Sjoerd Schenau Statistics Netherlands.

REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA MINISTRY OF THE ENVIRONMENT AND SPATIAL PLANNING Directorate for European Affairs and Investments Department for Energy Efficiency.

Anni Podimata MEP Member, Committee on Industry, Research and Energy 8th Inter-Parliamentary Meeting on Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency Budapest,

European Commission DG TREN / C: Conventional Energy Greenhouse gas mitigation and energy policy, a European perspective Presentation by Cristóbal.

Earth’s Changing Environment Lecture 15 Energy Conservation.

Efficiency in industry through electro-technologies Paul Baudry, EDF / R&D The future of Energy in Enlarged Europe, Warsaw 7-8th october 2004.

CAPACITY DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP ON FOSSIL FUEL AND RENEWABLE ENERGY (FFRE) FOR INDIAN OCEAN AND AFRICAN SIDS Organized by United Nations Office for Sustainable.

Energy Sector in Estonia Ando Leppiman Energy Department, Head of fuel and energy market division.

Sustainable Energy Systems The EU “WETO” World Energy, Technology and climate policy Outlook 2030 Domenico Rossetti di Valdalbero European Commission,

Carbon Emissions and the Need for Improved Energy Efficiency.

11 Energy in Denmark Observed energy consumption and adjusted gross energy consumption.

Workshop on Energy-related National and EU-Wide Projections of Greenhouse Gas Emissions 27 to 28 februari 2002 Emissions of CO 2 from the energy sector.

INTERNATIONAL ENERGY AGENCY AGENCE INTERNATIONALE DE L’ENERGIE What is the Cost of Not Having Nuclear Power or Carbon Capture and Storage While Still Stabilizing.

Workshop on Facilitation of climate policy in CEE and Turkey for the post 2012 period BudapestMarch , Workshop on Facilitation of climate policy.

New Energy Externalities Development for Sustainability Final Conference "External costs of energy technologies" Markus Blesl, IER, Germany RS “Modelling.

CAFE Baseline dissemination workshop 27/09/2004 Dr. Leonidas Mantzos E3M-LAB/ICCS NTUA contact: Energy projections as input to the.

CES KULeuven The Pan EU NEEDS TIMES model: main results of scenario analysis The Pan EU NEEDS TIMES model: main results of scenario analysis SIXTH FRAMEWORK.

Public Name: François Bruggemans Dept: New Business - Heating Carbon footprint of heating systems Lowering GHG emissions by the use of heat pumps.

Energy Information Administration 25th Anniversary of the 1973 Oil Embargo 25th Anniversary of the 1973 Oil Embargo Energy Trends Since the First Major.

London 2062 Symposium London’s Energy Future Peter North 19 th March 2012.

© OECD/IEA Do we have the technology to secure energy supply and CO 2 neutrality? Insights from Energy Technology Perspectives 2010 Copenhagen,

1 Glen Sweetnam Energy Information Administration Houston, Texas November 16, 2007 Outlook for North American Natural Gas Demand.

1 Perspectives of CCS power plants in Europe under different climate policy regimes Tom Kober, Markus Blesl Institute of Energy Economics and the Rational.

THE FUTURE OF NUCLEAR POWER IN EUROPE THE BULGARIAN CONTEXT Milko Kovachev Chairman Bulgarian WEC Committee.

1 Co-benefits of CO 2 Reduction in a Developing Country: Case of Thailand Ram M. Shrestha and Shreekar Pradhan Asian Institute of Technology Thailand INTERNATIONAL.

World Energy and Environmental Outlook to 2030

Energy Year 2016 Electricity

Prof. Dr. V. Zebergs, Prof. Dr. N Zeltins

CENERG 3rd TEMATIC WORKSHOP

Markus Blesl, Tom Kober IER; University of Stuttgart

Energy in Denmark 2014 Danish Energy Agency.

Energy Efficiency and Renewables role in the future energy needs

The Global Energy Outlook

Comparison of the Swedish NC3 and CAFE baseline projections

Presentation transcript:

Sustainable energy supply in Germany – scenario analysis with different CO 2 certificate prices Markus Blesl, Uwe Remme, Ulrich Fahl International Energy Workshop, Laxenburg

Comparison of CO2-reduction cost for different technologies in Germany

Cost balance Emissions balance Net production- value Process energy space heating Area Person Light Communication Force Personal- kilometres Tonne- kilometres Demand Coal refining Refinery Power plant and Grid CHP and District Heat Gas pipelines Industry Commercial Domestic Transport End energy Primary Energy Inland production Import Demand values Energy carrier prices, Resources availability price capacities Energy flow Emission cost

TIMES-D2 Two regional model (West + East Germany) Approx. 135 conversion technologies per region Approx. 85 transport technologies per region Approx. 120 residential technologies per region Approx. 90 commercial technologies per region Approx. 90 industrial technologies per region Time horizon , 5 year periods Six time segments per year 17 sectors per region

Socio-economic assumptions for the Scenarios Population Inhabitant in Mio.82,2 82,180,877,9 Gross domestic production GDP per head (Euro) Changes p.a.2005/ / / / /2030 GDP (Mrd. Euro)1,9% 1,7%1,3%1,0% GDP per capita (Euro) 1,9% 1,8%1,7% Living space Detached house (Mio m²) Multiple house (Mio m²) Sum Living space per capita (m²)40,242,845,551,354,3 Traffic Personnel traffic, Mrd Pkm968, ,71138,21139,1 Goods traffic, Mrd tkm483,1544,3607,4732,4839,2 Energy prices (Euro/GJ) Crude oil 2,813,183,564,315,06 Gas2,152,502,843,524,20 Hard Coal1,361,401,431,591,76

Policy Measures Phase-out of nuclear energy Use of domestic hard coal will decline (1120 PJ in 2000 => 200 PJ in 2030) Use of domestic lignite Subsidies for renewable energy sources and CHP Efficiency improvement programme for buildings Self commitment of German car industry to reduce specific fuel consumption Starting from year 2007 stronger legislative measures concerning maximum SO 2 and NOx emissions for conversion technologies exist

Scenario definition Reference case (REF) Scenarios with different CO2 certificate prices between 5 and 50 Euro per t CO 2 in 2010, after 2010 increasing 4 % per year  Certificate prices for the total energy system (CT)  Certificate prices only for the electricity production (CE) ( CT30 Certificate price for the total energy system of 30 Euro /t CO 2 ) 4% CT100,0010,0012,1714,8018,0121,91 CT300,0030,0036,5044,4154,0365,73

Energy related greenhouse gas emissions in Germany in Mio. t CO 2 * % -35 % -40 % -50 %

66 Energy related greenhouse gas emissions by sectors in Germany

Net electricity generation by energy carrier in Germany in TWh

Net electricity generation by renewable sources in Germany in TWh

Final energy consumption by sector in Germany in EJ

Primary energy consumption by energy carrier in Germany in EJ

Greenhouse gas intensity of the energy consumption in t CO 2 * per GJ

Energy related greenhouse gas emissions reduction depending on the certificate price in Germany

NO x -Emissions by sector for the different scenarios Gothenburg Protocol of convention on transboundary long range air pollution

SO x -Emissions by sector for the different scenarios Gothenburg Protocol of convention on transboundary long range air pollution National emission ceilings directive proposed commission

Considered monetary values for the external costs For fossil conversion technologies and transport For special conversion technologies

Comparison between the average of the discounted CO 2 reduction cost with and without taking the external cost into account (ex post)

Conclusions Germany can achieve the Kyoto targets with given CO 2 certificate prices for the whole energy system of 10 €/t CO 2. Germany has also with certificate prices lower than 30 €/t CO 2 costs problems to achieve the national emission targets for air pollutants from the European commission. CO 2 certificates should be applied to the entire energy system to avoid leakage effects. CO 2 certificates can be used to realise hidden benefits and to realise a sustainable energy supply system in Germany.