ECLIPSING BINARIES IN OPEN CLUSTERS John Southworth Jens Viggo Clausen Niels Bohr Institute Københavns Universitet.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Outline of Ch 11b: The H-R Diagram
Advertisements

An Abundance Spread in the Bootes I Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxy? John E. Norris The Australian National University Gerard Gilmore University of Cambridge R.F.G.
Small is Beautiful: Cataclysmic Variables from the SDSS John Southworth Boris Gänsicke Tom Marsh + many others.
Improving mass and age estimates of unresolved stellar clusters Margaret Hanson & Bogdan Popescu Department of Physics.
ECLIPSING BINARIES IN OPEN CLUSTERS John Southworth Dr Pierre Maxted Dr Barry Smalley Astrophysics Group Keele University.
SLEUTHING MASS OUTFLOW FROM EVOLVED STARS Optical/IR Spectroscopy from the MMT, KECK II, and Magellan Andrea Dupree (SAO/CfA) Sz. Meszaros (SAO), Jay Strader.
SOLUTION 1: ECLIPSING BINARIES IN OPEN CLUSTERS The study of eclipsing binaries in open clusters allows strong constraints to be placed on theoretical.
HIGH-PRECISION PHOTOMETRY OF ECLIPSING BINARY STARS John Southworth + Hans Bruntt + Pierre Maxted + many others.
ECLIPSING BINARIES IN OPEN CLUSTERS John Southworth Dr Pierre Maxted Dr Barry Smalley Astrophysics Group Keele University.
HD REVISITED John Southworth Dr Pierre Maxted Dr Barry Smalley Astrophysics Group Keele University.
Stars science questions Origin of the Elements Mass Loss, Enrichment High Mass Stars Binary Stars.
VLT spectroscopy of SDSS cataclysmic variables John Southworth Boris Gänsicke Tom Marsh.
The Eclipsing Triple System U Ophiuchi Revisited – poster 094 Symposium 240 BINARY STARS AS CRITICAL TOOLS AND TESTS IN CONTEMPORARY ASTROPHYSICS Luiz.
Do NOT open CLEA until all the black boxes have finished loading.
Intensity and Distance Intensity depends on luminosity and distance Inverse-square law discovered by Newton Magnitude system used in astronomy.
The Family of Stars Chapter 8:. Organizing the Family of Stars: The Hertzsprung-Russell Diagram We know: Stars have different temperatures, different.
WIRE SATELLITE PHOTOMETRY OF ECLIPSING BINARY STARS John Southworth H Bruntt D L Buzasi.
„We are not talking about cosmology...“ (A. Sozzetti)
The Nature of the Stars Chapter 19. Parallax.
Chapter 11 Surveying The Stars Surveying The Stars.
Low-mass binaries from CoRoT: stringent tests for stellar models Abstract: Analyses of double-lined eclipsing binary systems provide masses and radii of.
CHARA Collaboration Year-Five Science Review. The Separated Fringe Packet Survey Chris Farrington CHARA / Mt. Wilson March 2009 Collaborators: T.A ten.
NGC 2506 – a try for a spectroscopic study Ekaterina Atanasova Petr Kabath Christine Oppegaard Mª Carmen Sánchez Gil Tutor: Frédéric Royer 2nd NEON Archive.
Measuring Radii and Temperatures of Stars Definitions (again…) Direct measurement of radii – Speckle – Interferometry – Occultations – Eclipsing binaries.
Measuring the Stars How big are stars? How far away are they?
Young active star research with SONG and mini-SONG Huijuan Wang National Astronomical Observatories Chinese Academy of Charleston.
1 II-6 Stellar Mass and Binary Stars (Main Ref.: Lecture notes; FK Sec.4 - 4, 6, 7; 17-9, 10, and 11, Box 4-2, 4-4) II-6a. Introduction If the star is.
Binary Stars. Double Stars/Binary Stars Binary Star Double Star Earth.
BINARIES Read Your Textbook: Foundations of Astronomy
Physical properties. Review Question What are the three ways we have of determining a stars temperature?
Dirk Terrell Southwest Research Institute Dirk Terrell Southwest Research Institute Eclipsing Binary.
Binary and variable stars. Students learn to: describe binary stars in terms of means of detection: visual,eclipsing, spectroscopic and astrometric.
Stellar Mass A star’s position on the main sequence is determined by mass. Mass and composition are set at a star’s birth.
Comprehensive Stellar Population Models and the Disentanglement of Age and Metallicity Effects Guy Worthey 1994, ApJS, 95, 107.
Chapter 15 – Measuring Pressure (con’t) Temperature spans a factor of 10 or so from M to O stars Pressure/luminosity spans six orders of magnitude from.
Data Reduction with NIRI Knut Olsen and Andrew Stephens Gemini Data Workshop Tucson, AZ July 21, 2010 Knut Olsen and Andrew Stephens Gemini Data Workshop.
The Giant Branches – Leiden 14/05/09 The Initial-Final Mass Relation Aldo Serenelli – MPA Salaris, Serenelli, Weiss & Miller Bertolami (2009)
1 Stellar Properties Basic Data Mass and Radius Spectral Classification Photometric Systems.
CHARA Collaboration Year-Five Science Review Dynamite Diameters Tabetha Boyajian GSU/CHARA Presented by Hal McAlister.
Star Properties (Chapter 8). Student Learning Objectives Classify stars Explain how star properties are related.
Measuring Radii and Temperatures of Stars Definitions (again…) Direct measurement of radii – Speckle – Interferometry – Occultations – Eclipsing binaries.
Stars.
Lecture 18 Stellar populations. Stellar clusters Open clusters: contain stars loose structure Globular clusters: million stars centrally.
Binary stars and clusters Chapter 11. Review Properties of stars –apparent brightness (apparent magnitude) measure energy/area/second –luminosity (absolute.
Chapter 13: Star Clusters Open cluster globular cluster Stars (almost) always form in clusters The stars all formed at the same time They are all at the.
Hunting down the subdwarf populations Peter Nemeth Roy Østensen and Joris Vos KU Leuven, Belgium; In collaboration with Stephane Vennes and Adela Kawka.
Announcements Project Medley Outlines due in 2 weeks! – Start thinking about how you want to do your project! If you did not sign up for a project yet,
Measuring the Stars What properties of stars might you want to determine?
A105 Stars and Galaxies  Homework due today  Remote observing this weekend Today’s APODAPOD.
ASTR112 The Galaxy Lecture 4 Prof. John Hearnshaw 7. Globular clusters 8. Galactic rotation 8.1 From halo stars 8.2 From disk stars – Oort’s constant,
Universe Tenth Edition Chapter 17 The Nature of the Stars Roger Freedman Robert Geller William Kaufmann III.
Observational Windows on the Dynamics of Open Clusters Robert D. Mathieu University of Wisconsin - Madison.
Lab 8 – The Distance to the Pleiades. Open or Galactic Cluster.
BATC Multi-color Photometry of Open Cluster M48 Zhenyu Wu 8.11, 2005, Weifang.
1 Stellar structure and evolution Dr. Philippe Stee Observatoire de la Côte d’Azur – CNRS Slides mainly from S. Smartt.
Parallax Luminosity and mass functions - a few basic facts Kinematics of the solar neighborhood Asymmetric drift Thin disk, thick disk Open and globular.
HD and its super-Earth Valerie Van Grootel (University of Liege, Belgium) M. Gillon (U. Liege), D. Valencia (U. Toronto), N. Madhusudhan (U. Cambridge),
PI Total time #CoIs, team John Pritchard 107h (ELT 42m) 5-10 people who will reduce and analyse spectra and do NLTE atmospheric and radial velocity curve.
8/18/2010 Claus Leitherer: Young Stellar Populations 1 Young Stellar Populations in the Ultraviolet Claus Leitherer (STScI)
FOUR NEW ECLIPSING CATACLYSMIC VARIABLES FROM THE SDSS John Southworth and Boris Gänsicke Department of Physics, University of Warwick, UK
Binarity as the tool for determining physical properties and evolutionary aspects of A-stars Mutlu Yıldız Ege University, Dept. of Astronomy and Space.
From last class Proper motion: movement of stars in the sky. Typical 0.1”/yr. Barnard's star 10”/yr. Distance is hard to measure. Parallaxes only work.
An Abundance Spread in the Bootes I Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxy? John E. Norris The Australian National University Gerard Gilmore University of Cambridge R.F.G.
Measuring the Stars How big are stars? How far away? How luminous?
MPIA Student Workshop, Dorio, 2007
Chapter 12 Surveying The Stars.
Lab 9 – Ages and Distances to Clusters
Chapter 10 Star Cluster.
Galactic and Extragalatic Astronomy AA 472/672
Binary stars and clusters
Presentation transcript:

ECLIPSING BINARIES IN OPEN CLUSTERS John Southworth Jens Viggo Clausen Niels Bohr Institute Københavns Universitet

Eclipsing binaries in open clusters Get absolute dimensions of the two EB stars –Spectroscopic radial velocities give accurate masses –Light curve analysis gives accurate radii –T eff and luminosity from spectral analysis or calibrations Get metallicity and age from cluster membership –Theoretical stellar models must simultaneously match cluster and EB

Eclipsing binaries in open clusters Get absolute dimensions of the two EB stars –Spectroscopic radial velocities give accurate masses –Light curve analysis gives accurate radii –T eff and luminosity from spectral analysis or calibrations Get metallicity and age from cluster membership –Theoretical stellar models must simultaneously match cluster and EB Example: NGC 869 –V615 Per (B7V + B9V) V618 Per (A3V + A5V) –Metal abundance: Z = 0.01 Southworth et al, 2004, MNRAS, 349, 547

EBs in open clusters - distance Eclipsing binaries are excellent distance indicators –Can use bolometric corrections to get M V from luminosity –Or you can use surface brightness calibrations to get distance to EB:

EBs in open clusters - distance Eclipsing binaries are excellent distance indicators –Can use bolometric corrections to get M V from luminosity –Or you can use surface brightness calibrations to get distance to EB: Southworth et al, 2005, A&A, 429, 645 (based on data from Munari et al 2004) Example: Pleiades HD (A0 + Am) –K-band surface brightness relations –Distance = 139 ± 4 pc

GV Car in NGC 3532 NGC 3532 –522 ± 15 pc 300 Myr old GV Carinae –Period: 4.2 days A0 + A8 metallic-lined stars –Eccentric orbit Apsidal motion

GV Car photometry Complete light curves in Strömgren uvby –Radii and orbital inclination derived using EBOP –Monte Carlo simulations used to find uncertainties

GV Car photometry Complete light curves in Strömgren uvby –Radii and orbital inclination derived using EBOP –Monte Carlo simulations used to find uncertainties b light curve y light curve

GV Car spectroscopy 20 FEROS échelle spectra –Radial velocities found using cross-correlation –Masses found by fitting radial velocities with SBOP

GV Car absolute dimensions M A = ± M  M B = ± M  R A = ± R  R B = ± R  Compare to Cambridge (1998) theoretical models –Age: 360 ± 15 Myr –Metal abundance: Z = 0.01

but... the light curve has changed between the 1980s and 2001

DW Car in Collinder 228 Collinder 228 –Distance: 1.9 ± 0.2 kpc –Age: 8 Myr DW Car –Period: 1.33 days –B1 V + B1 V ZAMS stars / dss

DW Car photometry Complete light curves in the Strömgren uvby system –Light curves solved with Wilson-Devinney (2003) code –Uncertainties will be from Monte Carlo simulations

DW Car spectroscopy 30 FEROS spectra: contain only 12 identifiable lines –Radial velocities from cross-correlation: okay –Radial velocities from fitting Gaussians: good –Spectral disentangling: χ 2 surface a nightmare

DW Car absolute dimensions Cambridge (1998) models: –Several possible fits: –Z = 0.03 and ZAMS –Z = 0.02 and 2 Myr M A = ± 0.21 M  M B = ± 0.20 M  R A = 4.52 ± 0.04 R  R B = 4.39 ± 0.04 R 

Conclusions Eclipsing binaries in clusters –Get masses, radii, luminosities and distance of two stars –Cluster membership gives age and metallicity (sometimes...) –Challenge theoretical models convective core overshooting, opacities, mixing length, etc. We haven’t quite got there yet –Need to study populous clusters –Globular clusters are good targets, e.g., OGLE-GC17 in ω Cen

Conclusions Eclipsing binaries in clusters –Get masses, radii, luminosities and distance of two stars –Cluster membership gives age and metallicity (sometimes...) –Challenge theoretical models convective core overshooting, opacities, mixing length, etc. We haven’t quite got there yet –Need to study populous clusters –Globular clusters are good targets, e.g., OGLE-GC17 in ω Cen

NV CMa in NGC 2243 NV CMa was discovered by Kałużny et al (1996) –NGC 2243 is an old, metal-poor, open cluster –NV CMa is at MS turn-off of NGC 2243 Being studied by Frank Grundahl et al –17 VLT / UVES spectra –Good V and I light curves –Radial velocity and abundance study of cluster

John Southworth