Charmonia production at the SPS energies Marie-Pierre COMETS IPN Orsay, FRANCE SQM2006, UCLA, Los Angeles, USA, March 26-31, 2006.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Initial and final state effects in charmonium production at RHIC and LHC. A.B.Kaidalov ITEP, Moscow Based on papers with L.Bravina, K.Tywoniuk, E.Zabrodin.
Advertisements

Shadowing and cold nuclear matter effects on quarkonium production
Upsilon: the new golden probe? Elena G. Ferreiro Universidade de Santiago de Compostela, Spain Workshop Trento, February 2013 E. G. Ferreiro.
Upsilon Production in Heavy Ions with STAR and CMS
Bielefeld, sept 05F. Fleuret - LLR 1 Heavy ions at RHIC The J/  adventure J/  simultaneously discovered in november 1974 Ting et al. at the Brookhaven.
Quarkonia Production in p+p, d+Au and A+A from PHENIX Melynda Brooks Los Alamos National Laboratory For the PHENIX Collaboration Melynda Brooks, LANL,
Analysis of transverse momentum dependence of J/ψ in Heavy-Ion Collisions Xingbo Zhao with R. Rapp Cyclotron Institute + Physics Department Texas A&M University.
Heavy Flavors at FAIR Elena Bratkovskaya , WE-Heraeus-Seminar „Characterization of the Quark Gluon Plasma with Heavy Quarks‘‘, Bad Honnef (Germany)
J/Ψ Suppression in QGP Outline:
J/  and  ’ Production in p+p, d+Au and A+A from PHENIX Melynda Brooks Los Alamos National Laboratory For the PHENIX Collaboration Melynda Brooks, LANL,
Helen Caines Yale University SQM – L.A.– March 2006 Using strange hadron yields as probes of dense matter. Outline Can we use thermal models to describe.
A d+Au data-driven prediction of cold nuclear matter (CNM) effects on J/ψ production in Au+Au collisions at RHIC Raphaël Granier de Cassagnac LLR – École.
Charmonium Production in Heavy-Ion Collisions Loïc Grandchamp Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory Texas A&M, Dec. 10 th 2004 w/ R. Rapp.
Cold nuclear matter effects on dilepton and photon production Zhong-Bo Kang Los Alamos National Laboratory Thermal Radiation Workshop RBRC, Brookhaven.
J/  production in In-In collisions at SPS energies Philippe Pillot — IPN Lyon for the NA60 Collaboration work 2005 June 16–20   Outline: Reminder.
Open charm and charmonium production in p-A collisions at the CERN SPS E. Scomparin (INFN – Torino, Italy), NA60 collaboration Introduction Charmonium.
J/  measurement in d-Au interactions at s NN = 200 GeV David Silvermyr, LANL Physics Motivation - J/  production, gluon shadowing. Run-3 d-Au (2003)
Measurements of  Production and Nuclear Modification Factor at STAR Anthony Kesich University of California, Davis STAR Collaboration.
Quarkonia from SPS to RHIC Raphaël Granier de Cassagnac LLR – École polytechnique / IN2P3 Early Time Dynamics in Heavy Ion Collisions Montréal, 2007, July.
Quarkonium suppression at the SPS International Workshop on Heavy Quarkonium, DESY, Oct Carlos Lourenço or Are the SPS J/  and  ’ suppression patterns.
А.Б.Курепин – ИЯИ РАН, Москва Столкновение релятивистских тяжелых ядер и загадка чармония VI Марковские чтения 15 Мая 2008 г. ОИЯИ, Дубна.
N. Topilskaya, A.Kurepin – INR, Moscow Transverse momentum dependence of charmonium production in heavy ion collisions. 3rd INT. WORKSHOP ON HIGH-PT PHYSICS.
SPS charm(onium) and bottom(onium) measurements E. Scomparin INFN Torino (Italy) Introduction Past heavy quark and quarkonium measurements: NA38/NA50 (Helios-3)
J/  production in p+p and 200 GeV as seen by the PHENIX experiment at RHIC Raphaël Granier de Cassagnac LLR – Ecole polytechnique Topics in Heavy-Ions.
R CP Measurement with Hadron Decay Muons in Au+Au Collisions at √s NN =200 GeV WooJin Park Korea University For the PHENIX Collaboration.
Kwangbok Lee, LANL for the PHENIX collaboration DIS 2011, Newport News, VA Heavy vector meson results at PHENIX 1.
☍ Studying bottmonium in hot/cold QGP medium. ☍ Triggering on ϒ production in STAR ☍ Baseline measurement: ϒ cross section in pp collisions. ☍ ϒ and CNM.
Quarkonia Production in Cold and Hot Matters Raphaël Granier de Cassagnac LLR – École polytechnique / IN2P3 Quark Matter 2008 Jaipur, 2008, February 6.
INTRINSIC AND EXTRINSIC P T EFFECTS ON J/  SHADOWING This work, on behalf of E. G. Ferreiro F. Fleuret J.-P. Lansberg A. Rakotozafindrabe Work in progress…
SQM 2008 Beijing, China L. Bravina (University of Oslo), A. Capella, E.G. Ferreiro,A.B.Kaidalov, K. Tywoniuk, E.Zabrodin.
1 Part 1: Free the quarks! Part 2: Measuring dimuons in heavy-ion collisions Part 3: “The dog that didn’t bark” and other scenes from the particle zoo;
Charmonium production in pA collisions: results and perspectives R.Shahoyan, IST Lisbon Motivation Production models and absorption parametrizations Last.
Energy Scan of Hadron (  0 ) Suppression and Flow in Au+Au Collisions at PHENIX Norbert Novitzky for PHENIX collaboration University of Jyväskylä, Finland.
Olena Linnyk Charm dynamics from transport calculations Symposium and 10th CBM Collaboration Meeting September 25 – 28, 2007.
J/ψ production and elliptic flow in relativistic heavy-ion collisions Taesoo Song (Texas A&M Univ., USA) Reference : T. Song, C. M. Ko, S. H. Lee and J.
Latest Charmonium Results from the PHENIX Experiment at RHIC Alexandre Lebedev (Iowa State University) For the PHENIX Collaboration Lake Louise Winter.
An experiment to measure  c suppression at the CERN SPS CHIC: Charm in Heavy Ion Collisions F. Fleuret 1, F. Arleo 2, E. G. Ferreiro 3, P.-B. Gossiaux.
J/  Suppression and Collision Dynamics in Heavy Ion Collisions Mike Bennett Los Alamos National Laboratory.
Nuclear matter effects in charmonium production in proton-nucleus collisions‏ Hermine K. Wöhri LIP – Lisbon, Portugal QWG 2008, Nara, Japan, December 2008.
Round Table Workshop on NICA Physics Dubna,September 9-12,20091 J/Ψ Production in Heavy Ion Collisions J/Ψ Production in Heavy Ion Collisions Pengfei ZHUANG.
J/ψ production in PHENIX Raphaël Granier de Cassagnac LLR – École polytechnique / IN2P3 For the PHENIX collaboration Hot Quarks 2006 Villasinius, Sardinia,
Loïc Grandchamp Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory “Probing QCD with High Energy Nuclear Collisions” Hirschegg, Jan ’05 with H. van Hees, S.
Francesco Noferini Bologna University Erice, Italy 31 st August 2006 Two-particle correlations: from RHIC to LHC.
Robert Pak (BNL) 2012 RHIC & AGS Annual Users' Meeting 0 Energy Ro Robert Pak for PHENIX Collaboration.
Quark Matter ’05 Budapest Aug 3-9, 2005 Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN - TH J/  suppression.
1 J/, Charm and intermediate mass dimuons in Indium-Indium collisions Hiroaki Ohnishi, RIKEN/JAPAN For the NA60 collaboration XXXV International Symposium.
C H I C Charm in Heavy Ion SPS 1.J/  – Suppression in A+A 2.CHIC – Physics motivations 3.CHIC – Experimental aspects 1F. Fleuret - LLR.
OPEN HEAVY FLAVORS 1. Heavy Flavor 2 Heavy quarks produced in the early stages of the collisions (high Q2)  effective probe of the high-density medium.
Olena Linnyk Charmonium in heavy ion collisions 16 July 2007.
Charm measurements at SPS to RHIC Y. Akiba (KEK) March 14, 2003 Strangeness in Quark Matter 2003.
PHENIX results on J/  production in Au+Au and Cu+Cu collisions at  S NN =200 GeV Hugo Pereira Da Costa CEA Saclay, for the PHENIX collaboration Quark.
Dilepton production and the onset of deconfinement International Workshop “Critical Point and Onset of Deconfinement” Firenze, July E. Scomparin.
News from quarkonia Rencontres QGP Etretat 16/9/2014 Elena G. Ferreiro Universidad de Santiago de Compostela Spain.
Charmonia in Heavy Ion Collisions should we go back to SPS ? – charmonia in A+A : the current (simplified) picture – – back to SPS : the CHIC picture–
Diagnosing energy loss: PHENIX results on high-p T hadron spectra Baldo Sahlmüller, University of Münster for the PHENIX collaboration.
Quarkonium suppression from SPS to RHIC Raphaël Granier de Cassagnac LLR – École polytechnique / IN2P3 Hard Probes 2006 Asilomar, California, June 13 th.
1/21 Carlos Lourenço, 4 th International Workshop on Heavy Quarkonium, June 27– Recent results from the CERN SPS on quarkonium production in p-nucleus.
Saturation physics with an ALICE-like detector at FHC Some numbers and ideas – a discussion-starter Marco van Leeuwen, Nikhef.
Ming X. Liu Moriond04 3/28-4/ Open Charm and Charmonium Production at RHIC Ming X. Liu Los Alamos National Laboratory (PHENIX Collaboration) - p+p.
Helen Caines Yale University Strasbourg - May 2006 Strangeness and entropy.
Heavy Flavor Measurements at RHIC&LHC W. Xie (Purdue University, West Lafayette) W. Xie (Purdue University, West Lafayette) Open Heavy Flavor Workshop.
1 Joint meeting IPNO-LAL LUA9-AFTER Orsay, Novembre 2013 Roberta Arnaldi INFN Torino (Italy)
Heavy quarks and charmonium at RHIC and LHC within a partonic transport model Jan Uphoff with O. Fochler, Z. Xu and C. Greiner XLIX International Winter.
ALICE and the Little Bang
Motivation for Studying Heavy Quarks
Heavy ions at RHIC The J/Y adventure
Charmed hadron signals of partonic medium
Charmonium dynamics in heavy ion collisions
Charmonium dissociation and recombination at RHIC and LHC
1 nb 1 pb Mmm (GeV) Christensen et al., Phys. Rev. D8 (73) 2016
Presentation transcript:

Charmonia production at the SPS energies Marie-Pierre COMETS IPN Orsay, FRANCE SQM2006, UCLA, Los Angeles, USA, March 26-31, 2006

Goal: study anomalous J/ ψ suppression in AA collisions as predicted by Matsui and Satz in case of QGP formation Need of a reference: normal absorption in pA Outline:  J/ ψ and ψ ’ production pA results at SPS - Comparison with E866 and Hera b experiments AA results p T results  Conclusion and open questions

J/ ψ and ψ ’ normal nuclear absorption NA50 pA at 450 GeV Glauber fit to J/ ψ and ψ ’ absolute cross-sections lead to: ψ ’ presents a larger absorption than J/ ψ.

NA50 pA (450 GeV) In our kinematical domain, charmonium formation time small enough to distinguish the 2 states. J/ ψ and ψ ’ normal nuclear absorption x F = x 1 – x 2 (p) (A)

J/ ψ and ψ ’ normal nuclear absorption Drell-Yan cross section per nucleon-nucleon collision for 2.9 < M  < 4.5 GeV Fit  (Drell-Yan) with a power law  =  0 · A  ->  Drell-Yan =  Compatible with 1. In  and σ abs :  Shadowing (antishadowing)  Nuclear absorption  Absorption by comovers -> negligible  …… DY scales with the number of NN collisions -> reference for J/ ψ and ψ ’ NA50 pA at 400 GeV

A=208 Q 2 = 2.25, 5.39,14.7,39.9, 108, and GeV 2 For DY: At SPS x F ≈0, M DY ≈3 GeV -> x 2 ≈0.11  shadowing valence quark ≈ antishadowing antiquark  no nuclear absorption =>  DY ≈1 J/ ψ and ψ ’ normal nuclear absorption: discussion on 

42 GeV 38 GeV 29 GeV J/ ψ and ψ ’ normal nuclear absorption: discussion on 

J/ ψ and ψ ’ normal nuclear absorption: discussion on  If ONLY shadowing in  : σ pA = A  σ pp = A R A σ pp Open charm:  no nuclear absorption  antishadowing ~18% ->  open charm ≈ 1.03 E866 Δ  due ONLY to shadowing variation between x F ≈0 (R A ≈1.2 x 2 ≈0.09) and x F ≈1 (R A ≈0.85 x 2 ≈0.007) ≈ 0.06 << 0.25 (measured) Lack of x 2 scaling not surprising.

-> other explanations: F. Arléo et al.: scenario with octet state-nucleon collisions at large x F (Phys. Rev. C61(2000)054906) D. Kharzeev and K. Tuchin: in the CGC framework, J/ ψ production is suppressed at large x F due to saturation of gluons in the nuclear wave function. At smaller x F, nuclear absorption plays a significant role; because of formation time effects, it suppresses the J/ ψ prod. at SPS stronger than at Fermilab. (hep-ph/ ) J/ ψ and ψ ’ normal nuclear absorption: discussion on 

J/ ψ - NA50 Glauber fit of all pA data at 450 and 400 GeV, and pp and pd NA51 -> σ J/ ψ abs =4.18 ± 0.35 mb J/ ψ and ψ ’ normal nuclear absorption

J/ ψ /DY: from pp to PbPb Average path length L traversed by the cc pair in nuclear matter: appropriate to visualize nuclear absorption in different systems.  Peripheral PbPb data points, AND all SU data points compatible with normal nuclear absorption.  PbPb: departure from normal nuclear absorption at mid-centrality

J/ ψ suppression versus p T Ratio to the most peripheral bin (1) J/ ψ suppression is mainly at low p T and increases with centrality For p T >3.5 GeV/c, weak centrality dependence of J/ ψ suppression R i = N ψ,i (p T )/N DY,i / N ψ,1 (p T )/N DY,1 PbPb 158 GeV/c NA50

of J/ ψ versus centrality increases linearly with L Attributed to parton multiple scattering in the initial state, even in PbPb? Phenomenological description (L) = pp +  gN L with pp varying with energy and a common slope  gN = ± GeV 2 /c 2 /fm

of J/ ψ versus centrality NA50 Saturation of versus E T observed for central PbPb collisions.  S. Gavin and R. Vogt: if broadening due only to parton rescattering -> saturation  J.P. Blaizot and J.Y. Ollitrault: in a plasma model (scenario in which ALL the J/ ψ are suppressed whatever their p T over a certain energy density) -> saturation  D. kharzeev et al. predict an increase followed by a decrease within a plasma model Is p T a « good » variable?

Ψ ’/DY: from pp to pPb Ψ ’ - NA50 Fit of all pA data at 450 and 400 GeV -> σ ψ ’ abs = 7.6 ±1.1 mb  2 regimes: one for proton and one different for ion- induced reactions  Similar centrality dependence for SU and PbPb

J/ ψ suppression in InIn collisions Anomalous suppression present in lighter nuclear systems? Variable driving the suppression? NA60 experiment: InIn collisions at 158 GeV/c Anomalous suppression present in InIn. Onset in the range 80 < N part < 100. Saturation at large N part.

J/ ψ suppression in InIn collisions The SU, PbPb and InIn data points do not overlap in the L variable, while the suppression patterns are in fair agreement in the N part variable.

J/ ψ suppression in InIn collisions None of the models seems to properly reproduce the observed pattern. J/ ψ absorption by comovers – Capella and Ferreiro (Eur. Phys. J. C42(2005)419) J/ ψ dissociation and regeneration in QGP and hadronic phases – Grandchamp,Rapp,Brown (J. Phys. G30(2004)S1355)  c suppression in a percolation model Digal, Fortunato, Satz (Eur. Phys. J. C32(2004)547)

Conclusions and open questions AT SPS energies: J/ ψ normal nuclear absorption -> NA60 - pA at 158 GeV nuclear absorption at 158 GeV  c nuclear dependence (First upsilon results in pA – NA50) ANOMALOUS J/ ψ suppression in PbPb and InIn at √s = 17.8 GeV Pt ? What at higher energies? -> RHIC (√s = 200 GeV): next talk -> LHC (√s = 5.5 TeV): to come

Upsilon production in pA collisions NA50 pA at 450 GeV