University of Minnesota Content is not king Andrew Odlyzko Digital Technology Center University of Minnesota

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Owning a Wi-Fi TV TM Owning a Wi-Fi TV TM Channel.
Advertisements

Introduction to e-Business. History of WWW Late 1960s, ARPA (Advanced Research Project Agency) of Dept of Defense sponsored some of MIT graduate student.
Can You Identify the most Challenging Issue in todays Business Scenario ?
Presented by: Your Name Your Phone Number Your Website Address How Your Local Business Can ATTRACT and KEEP Customers Through Mobile Marketing.
© 2009 IBM Corporation1 Telco, media, entertainment and consumer electronics companies face an overlapping set of challenges and opportunities Companies.
AOVG Andrew Odlyzko Content versus connectivity and the future of 3G
Going Places Safely Essential Question:
UNIT 6.1 Advertising Media
What is Communication?.
HOW WE KEEP IN TOUCH by Eric Michaels.
Radio, Television & Media Convergence ( brought to you by… The Web! ) April 2010.
AOVG Andrew Odlyzko Traffic Growth and Network Spending: What’s Ahead?
1 Internet economics, Internet evolution, and misleading networking myths Andrew Odlyzko Digital Technology Center University of Minnesota
1 False dogmas and real incentives on the Internet Andrew Odlyzko Digital Technology Center University of Minnesota
Do We Really Need Denise Huang. Agenda ITV: What’s new Industry overview Consumers’ attitudes and usage patterns What are the demands? Challenges from.
1 Internet evolution and misleading networking myths Andrew Odlyzko School of Mathematics and Digital Technology Center University of Minnesota
1 The delusions of net neutrality Andrew Odlyzko School of Mathematics and Digital Technology Center University of Minnesota
Broadband Andrew Odlyzko The Many Paradoxes of Broadband
Computers As A One Stop Entity TelevisionTelevision Radio/MusicRadio/Music ShoppingShopping MoviesMovies Communicati onCommunicati on.
University of Minnesota Content versus connectivity and the persistent mirage of real-time streaming multimedia Andrew Odlyzko Digital Technology Center.
University of Minnesota Next Generation Network, Next Generation Services, and Misleading Telecom Myths Andrew Odlyzko Digital Technology Center University.
Surveillance camera in terms of business. Index *surveillance systems * Types of control systems * Elements of control systems * Types of monitoring camera.
Introduction to Information Technology: Your Digital World © 2013 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.Using Information Technology, 10e©
Project: Role of mobile phones in our life Cadet Ilin Vlad 6A Cadet Corps 5 Teacher Ibragimova Goulnara.
Direct and Online Marketing Objective: Discussing the latest developments in the communication technologies and their use and impacts in tourism and hospitality.
& Instant Messenger Communication of the Future Jonathan Smith MIS.
Types of Advertising Mrs. Wilson Ryle High School.
Unit 6 - Promotion.  There are many forms of advertising to fit all kinds of budgets.  A large company such as Procter & Gamble typically spends 25.
Happy Monday! Agenda: The Chosen Presentations part 2 Padlet – Technology Chat.
The Internet Present By Tianyi Xiao ID : C  The Internet is a global system of interconnected computer networks that use the standard Internet.
UNIT 6.1 Advertising Media
Vocabulary Link International companies These people are talking about their companies. Read what they say. Notice the words in blue. Lesson B Big business.
Social Media Facilitated by: Caroline Egan Carmichael Centre for Voluntary Groups.
Entertainment Distribution ENTERTAINMENT Written by: M. Reed Georgia CTAE Resource Network 2010.
Digital Marketing
Communication Timeline
FUTURE OF TV? 2006 Future of Television Forum NYU Stern School of Business John Rose November 14 th, 2006.
Telecommunication technology Then and Now. But First… What is telecommunication Technology? Telecommunication is the transmission of messages over a country.
State of Social Media: 2011 Mary Madden, Senior Research Specialist Presented to: U.S. State Department's Bureau of Educational and Cultural Affairs National.
Presented by: Your Name Your Phone Number Your Website Address How Mobile Apps Can Help You Connect With Local Consumers.
+ History of Computers By: Evan Alderman + What will we be talking about today? Slide 3 & 4: Early computers Slide 5: ARPA Slide 6 & 7: ARPANET & the.
M7 U1 Living with technology Welcome to the unit.
 NEED  Food  Water  Clothes/shoes  Homes  Phones  Gas for cars  WANT  Accessories  Junk food we don’t need (eating out)  Online shopping.
XP Practical PC, 3e Chapter 7 1 Connecting to the Internet.
Media Literacy. Media in our lives Growing up… How many TVs were in your house? How many computers? How many family members had a cell phone?
The Media Chapter 10 Candidate Centered Campaigns.
Sales & Marketing Session 3
What is Data Communication? Data communication is the process of collecting and distributing data(text, voice, graphics, video, etc) electrically from.
By: D’Kihya Cooper.  The first messages are sent.
Fostering Faith in a Digital Age: challenge and opportunity Terri Martinson Elton.
The Internet and Converging Media Journalism Principles and Practices.
Chapter 4 Concepts of Mass Communication. Introduction of Mass Communication The term ‘mass communication’ may be considered as a 20th century development.
Journalism online The World Wide Web, the past, the present, the future.
Match these words to the letters in the picture.. screen, monitor, keyboard, mouse, microphone, speakers, system unit.
Overview Present the past, present & future of VoIP. Focus: –Technology –Cultural Factors –Economic Factors –Regulatory Factors.
Communities Unit 1 Review Which is where an important event happened? 1.Government 2.Landform 3.Library 4.Historic site
Copyright © 2016 – Curt Hill The Digital World Understanding the challenges of this world.
The Future of Mobile Marketing Lee Mueller University of Montana Integrated Online Marketing 420.
The way we communicate has changed over time. The Internet has changed many aspects of our lives, including the way we communicate with each other, how.
Great Moments in Communication Created by: Savannah York.
Advertising – Definitions and Techniques. What is Advertising?  The act or practice of calling public attention to one's product, service, need, etc.
SPK – 4 Golomazov Artem in my life. Hello! My name is Artem and I’d like to tell you about Information Technology by using Information Technology! It.
Unit 9 Technology Reading LIFE ON THE GO. Pre-reading Have you ever used a cellphone? Do any of your classmates have cellphone? How is the way we live.
Electronic mail News File transfer protocol Chat Instant messaging Online services Online shopping.
A Parent’s Guide to Child Safety on the Internet.
Understanding Customer Needs. Why understand customers? Because they are all different.
Means of comunication Alex Uvarov Form 8-A.
Aggregated Research. Mobile Services Usage per Age Group, US Source: Pew Research Center's Internet & American Life Project, April 2010 Key findings 57%
Make sentences with your strips of paper  Mobile phones are portable devices which let us contact others wherether they and we are. TThe Internet is.
Presentation transcript:

University of Minnesota Content is not king Andrew Odlyzko Digital Technology Center University of Minnesota

University of Minnesota Main points:  Long historical tradition of overemphasis on content  Connectivity has traditionally been valued much more than content  Social connectivity very important but neglected Note: Content (defined as material prepared by professionals for wide distributions) is big and important, it is just not as big or as important as connectivity.

University of Minnesota Big challenges, lack of solutions:

University of Minnesota Common wisdom vs. reality:

University of Minnesota New threat or ancient underappreciated truth?

University of Minnesota Rejection of WAP (content) and eager acceptance of SMS (connectivity) should not have been a surprise: it fits the dominant historical pattern

University of Minnesota What would the Internet be without “content?'' It would be a valueless collection of silent machines with gray screens. It would be the electronic equivalent of a marine desert - lovely elements, nice colors, no life. It would be nothing. E. Bronfman, Jr., May 2000 Example of common but ludicrous overvaluation of content

University of Minnesota Value of bits: Cable TV$ Wired Phone Mobile Phone SMS Price/MB

University of Minnesota Selected sectors of U.S. economy telephone$199.3$ % U.S. Postal Service advertising motion pictures movie theaters video tape rentals broadcast industries television broadcasting radio broadcasting newspapers magazines consumer spending on “content” annual Industryrevenuesrevenuesgrowth (billions)(billions)rate

University of Minnesota Revenues of U.S. cable TV and cell phone industries cable TVcellular year(millions)(millions) 1987$11,563$ ,0796, ,78425, ≈50,000 Radio moved from point-to-point connectivity to content broadcasting, but now is moving back

University of Minnesota Typical usage pattern of communication services:  first govenment  then business  then social

University of Minnesota Dominant types of communication: business and social, not content, in the past as well as today Thirty years ago you left the city of Assur. You have never made a deposit since, and we have not recovered one shekel of silver from you, but we have never made you feel bad about this. Our tablets have been going to you with caravan after caravan, but no report from you has ever come here. circa 2000 B.C. A fine thing you did! You didn't take me with you to the city! If you don't want to take me with you to Alexandria, I won't write you a letter, I won't talk to you, I won't say Hello to you even.... A fine thing you did, all right. Big gifts you sent me - chicken feed! They played a trick on me there, the 12th, the day you sailed. Send for me, I beg you. If you don't, I won't eat, I won't drink. There! circa 200 A.D.

University of Minnesota For the first 30 years of the telephone, promoters struggled to identify the killer application that would promote its wide adoption by home owners and businesses. At first the telephone was promoted as a replacement for the telegraph, allowing businesses to send messages more easily and without an operator. Telephone promoters in the early years touted the telephone as new service to broadcast news, concerts, church services, weather reports, etc. Industry journals publicized inventive uses of the telephone such as sales by telephone, consulting with doctors, ordering groceries over the telephone, listening to school lectures and even long distance Christian Science healing! The concept that someone would buy the telephone to chat was simply inconceivable at that time. C. Fischer, America Calling Historically common pattern: government and business decision-makers emphasize content, users prefer connectivity

University of Minnesota The popularity of was not foreseen by the ARPANET's planners. Roberts had not included electronic mail in the original blueprint for the network. In fact, in 1967 he had called the ability to send messages between users “not an important motivation for a network of scientific computers”.... Why then was the popularity of such a surprise? One answer is that it represented a radical shift in the ARPANET's identity and purpose. The rationale for building the network had focused on providing access to computers rather than to people. J. Abbate, Inventing the Internet The Internet succeeded by accident. , its “killer app,” was not among the original design criteria:

University of Minnesota Example of attitude that the phone industry had to overcome before it could grow as large as it did: The unlimited use of the telephone leads to a vast amount of unnecessary occupation of the wires, and to much borrowing of telephones by parties who are not subscribers. Thus the telephone system is so encumbered with calls which are unnecessary, and largely illegitimate, that the service is greatly impaired, and subscribers, to whom prompt connection is essential, become dissatisfied. Bell company announcement, 1880s

University of Minnesota Many disappointing “content” ventures:  Phone company information services  Videotext experiments (including AT&T venture with Knight Ridder)  Minitel  AOL (started out as game network), Prodigy, … Inside stories of the Knight Ridder and Prodigy cases: demand for connectivity in unexpected settings

University of Minnesota Quantitative measures:  Sarnoff’s Law: Value of content distribution network grows like n  Metcalfe’s Law: Value of connectivity network grows like n 2  Odlyzko & Tilly: Metcalfe’s Law wrong, value of general connectivity network grows like n*log(n) n*log(n) grows faster than n, but difference is sufficiently slow to enable the “content is king” dogma to persist n = number of participants

University of Minnesota Quantitative measures (cont’d):  Odlyzko-Tilly n*log(n) “law”  general observations supporting the “content is not king” thesis  Chris Anderson’s “long tails” thesis all consistent with, and supported by, Zipf’s Law (1/n valuation of n-th most valuable item)

University of Minnesota Conclusions:  Content is valuable  Content not as valuable as connectivity  Social connectivity should be promoted

University of Minnesota Further data, discussions, and speculations in papers and presentation decks at: