Newall: Philosophy of Mind I.Mind and body are the same (monism) a)Physicalism: physical objects or processes (e.g., neural firings) are “tokens” (examples)

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Philosophical Issues in Neuroscience Dr. Kelley Kline FSU.
Advertisements

Metaphysics Part II. Thought Experiment: Physical & Mental Properties A1. 2 more objects: quarters, books, grass… A2. 2 more physical descriptors: green,
John Coleman DACE LWP How to reach Functionalism in 4 choices (and 639 words) Pack your baggage – mine includes Pack your baggage – mine includes.
What Are the Metaphysical Issues?  Metaphysics: questions about the nature of reality  Nature of ultimate reality permanence and change appearance and.
Chapter 10: What am I?.
A Language Circuit  Wernicke’s areas and Broca’s areas are part of a connected circuit for receiving and producing language.  Wernicke predicted conduction.
The Mind-Body Relation Dualism: human beings are composed of a material body and an immaterial mind which are distinct from each other (Descartes) Problems:
The Mind-Body Relation: Ancient Western Views Materialism: all things (including minds/souls & mental events) are bodies in motion Democritus (fl. 450.
October 13, 2009Introduction to Cognitive Science Lecture 11: Philosophical Questions 1 Philosophical Questions Philosophy, the “love of wisdom,” is an.
Section 2.5 The Whole is Greater Than the Sum of Its Parts
20 th Century Views on Mind and Body Logical Behaviorism (Gilbert Ryle): “mind” refers simply to a way of speaking about behaviors ( ) Mind-Brain.
The Mind-Body Relation Dualism: human beings are composed of a material body and an immaterial mind which are distinct from each other (Descartes) Problem:
Mind, Body and Philosophy
The Mind-Body Duality Source: Robert H. Wozniak
More 20 th Century Theories of Mind Eliminative Materialism: we should replace terms like “thought” with purely material expressions Paul Churchland (1942.
Chapter 2 The Mind-Body Problem
Philosophy of Mind Matthew Soteriou. Physicalism The physicalist answer to the question of the relation between the mental and the physical: The mental.
The metaphysics of mind: an overview Michael Lacewing
The Egocentric Predicament (pg 194); term coined by Ralph Perry  Egocentric: the Individual self is at the center of all our experience.  Predicament:
Chapter Two The Philosophical Approach: Enduring Questions.
© Michael Lacewing Dualism and the Mind-Body Identity Theory Michael Lacewing
The Mind-Body Problem. Some Theories of Mind Dualism –Substance Dualism: mind and body are differerent substances. Mind is unextended and not subject.
The Mind-Body Debate. Mind-Brain Debate What is the relationship between mind and brain?
© Michael Lacewing Functionalism and the Mind- Body Problem Michael Lacewing
© Michael Lacewing The Mind-Body Identity Theory Michael Lacewing
Christopher Ullman, Professor-- Christian Life College1 LIFE’S ULTIMATE QUESTIONS by Ronald Nash Chapter 18: Human Nature: The Mind-Body Problem and Survival.
Why does your view of human Nature Matter?
Descartes’ Meditations. I exist (as a thinking thing) God exists C & D perceptions are accurate Math Geom. Phys obj’s exist Descartes’ Meditations Mind.
Substance dualism and mental causation Michael Lacewing
The Mind-Body Problem. Monism  Materialism : Everything is Physical  Idealism : Everything is Mental.
The Mind-Body Relation: Ancient Western Views ä Materialism: all things (including minds/souls & mental events) are bodies in motion Democritus (fl. 450.
How do you know you have a mind? How do you know the person next to you has a mind? What is a mind? psychlotron.org.uk.
Dualism: epiphenomenalism
Chapter 2 The Mind-Body Problem McGraw-Hill © 2013 McGraw-Hill Companies. All Rights Reserved.
BODY, MIND AND SOUL WHAT THE EXAMINERS SAY WE NEED TO STUDY (a) Distinctions between body and soul in the thinking of Plato, John Hick and Richard Dawkins.
Philosophy of Mind The Mind/Body Problem. Overview  The Mind/Body Problem  Some Possible Solutions Dualist Solutions Monist Solutions.
Metaphysics…an Introduction Some Guiding Questions: What is Reality? What is a personal identity? Is there a Supreme Being? What is the meaning of life?
Metaphysics The study of the basic structures of reality.
Human Nature 2.3 The Mind-Body Problem: How Do Mind and Body Relate?
For Friday Read chapter 27 Program 5 due. Program 5 Any questions?
Owen Flanagan James B. Duke Professor of Philosophy Professor of Psychology and Neuroscience Co-Director Center for Comparative Philosophy Duke University.
© Michael Lacewing Substance and Property Dualism Michael Lacewing
Learning objective: To understand what is meant by epiphenomenalism and issues with it. epiphenomenalist dualism Causal redundancy.
By: Keanu, Michael and Miller Time.  In the philosophy of mind, dualism is the theory that the mental and the physical—or mind and body or mind and brain—are,
Anomalous monism Michael Lacewing uk.
Philosophy of Mind Panpsychism: All is mind/conscousness.
Philosophy of Mind: Theories of self / personal identity: REVISION Body & Soul - what makes you you?
Eight problems Descartes and his immediate successors were concerned with 1. The Mind-Body Problem 2. The Problem of Other Minds 3. The Problem of Skepticism.
DUALISM: CAUSAL INTERACTIONISM Philosophy of Mind.
The Mind And Body Problem Mr. DeZilva.  Humans are characterised by the body (physical) and the mind (consciousness) These are the fundamental properties.
Substance and Property Dualism Quick task: Fill in the gaps activity Quick task: Fill in the gaps activity ?v=sT41wRA67PA.
METAPHYSICS The study of the nature of reality. POPEYE STUDIES DESCARTES.
Mind body problem What is the relationship between mental states and the physical world? Zoltán Dienes, Philosophy of Psychology René Descartes ( )
Recap on your whiteboards
The study of the basic structures of reality
Substance and Property Dualism
Which of these do you agree with?
Minds and Bodies.
The Search for Ultimate Reality and the Mind/Body Problem
What is the relationship between body and soul.
Life After Death: The Soul (Aristotle)
Recap Questions What is interactionism?
PHL 203 Theories of Reality
Think, pair, Share Is this the same person?.
The Mind Body Problem Our minds seem to be non-physical and different from our bodies. Our bodies seem to be something different from our minds. Are they.
The study of the nature of reality
Michael Lacewing Physicalism Michael Lacewing
What is good / bad about this answer?
The Mind Body Problem Our minds seem to be non-physical and different from our bodies. Our bodies seem to be something different from our minds. Are they.
Presentation transcript:

Newall: Philosophy of Mind I.Mind and body are the same (monism) a)Physicalism: physical objects or processes (e.g., neural firings) are “tokens” (examples) of “types” of things (minds or mental events) i.Reductive physicalism: minds/mental events are reducible to physical objects/events ii.Non-reductive physicalism: minds/mental events “supervene on” physical objects and events: that is, they depend on, but are not reducible to, physical objects and processes

More Monistic Theories of Mind b)Mind-Brain (Identity) Theory: mental states are simply brain states Objection: brain states and introspective qualia (experiences) have different characteristics c)Functionalism: mental states are associations or linkages of sensory stimuli and behaviors d)Eliminative Materialism: we should replace terms like “thought” with materialist expressions e)Idealism: physical objects/processes are really only mental events or objects of mind

Dualistic Theories of Mind a)Predicate Dualism: the mental and physical are said to be different kinds of things b)Property Dualism: the mental and physical are different characteristics of things c)Substance Dualism: the mental and physical are simply different kinds of real things The major problem with dualism (viz., interaction) concerns how the physical and mental can affect or relate to one another

Attempted Solutions to the Challenge of Dualistic Interactionism Epiphenomenalism: bodies can influence minds, but minds cannot influence bodies Objections: why can’t minds influence bodies? Why have the mental at all? Occasionalism: God’s intervention accounts for the interaction Parallelism: apparent interaction is due to a pre-established harmony between the physical and mental N. Malebranche G. W. Leibniz