K. MakishimaCooling Flow, 31 May 2003 The ASCA View on Cooling Flows and its Implications K. Max Makishima (U. Tokyo /RIKEN) in collaboration with Yasusi.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
arvard.edu/phot o/2007/m51/. Confronting Stellar Feedback Simulations with Observations of Hot Gas in Elliptical Galaxies Q. Daniel Wang,
Advertisements

X-ray Astronomy with High Spectral Resolution: Astro-E2 / ISAS Y. Tanaka.
Front X-ray Studies of Galaxies and Galaxy Systems Jesper Rasmussen Ph.D. Defence Astronomical Observatory, Univ. of Copenhagen 17th March 2004.
X-Ray Measurements of the Mass of M87 D. Fabricant, M. Lecar, and P. Gorenstein Astrophysical Journal, 241: , 15 October 1980 Image:
Strange Galactic Supernova Remnants G (the Tornado) & G in X-rays Anant Tanna Physics IV 2007 Supervisor: Prof. Bryan Gaensler.
RX J alias Vela Jr. The Remnant of the Nearest Historical Supernova : Impacting on the Present Day Climate? Bernd Aschenbach Vaterstetten, Germany.
Clusters & Super Clusters Large Scale Structure Chapter 22.
HI Gas as Function of Environment When and where do galaxies stop accreting cool gas? How do they loose the cool gas? When do they stop forming stars?
The Radio/X-ray Interaction in Abell 2029 Tracy Clarke (Univ. of Virginia) Collaborators: Craig Sarazin (UVa), Elizabeth Blanton (UVa)
Hard X-ray Emission and IC in Coma and Abell 3667 from Suzaku and XMM-Newton Craig Sarazin University of Virginia A3667 XIS images and radio contours Coma.
Radio halos and relics in galaxy clusters. NGC315: giant (~ 1.3 Mpc) radio galaxy with odd radio lobe (Mack 1996; Mack et al. 1998). precessing jets (Bridle.
Ben Maughan (CfA)Chandra Fellows Symposium 2006 The cluster scaling relations observed by Chandra C. Jones, W. Forman, L. Van Speybroeck.
July 7-11, 2008 Radio Galaxies in the Chandra Era 1 Hard X-ray study of lobes of radio galaxy Fornax A Naoki Isobe (RIKEN/Suzaku Help Desk) Makoto Tashiro,
HOT TIMES FOR COOLING FLOWS Mateusz Ruszkowski. Cooling flow cluster Non-cooling flow cluster gas radiates X-rays & loses pressure support against gravity.
Prospects and Problems of Using Galaxy Clusters for Precision Cosmology Jack Burns Center for Astrophysics and Space Astronomy University of Colorado,
I. Balestra, P.T., S. Ettori, P. Rosati, S. Borgani, V. Mainieri, M. Viola, C. Norman Galaxies and Structures through Cosmic Times - Venice, March 2006.
Particles and Fields in Lobes of Radio Galaxies Naoki Isobe (NASDA, MAXI Mission) Makoto Tashiro (Saitama Univ.) Kazuo Makishima (Univ. of Tokyo) Hidehiro.
Centaurus A Kraft, Hardcastle, Croston, Worrall, Birkinshaw, Nulsen, Forman, Murray, Goodger, Sivakoff,Evans, Sarazin, Harris, Gilfanov, Jones X-ray composite.
1 Origin of Variability of X-ray and γ-ray Spectra on Daily Scale Radovan Milinčić Astrophysics 711 May 3 rd 2005.
3C 186 A Luminous Quasar in the Center of a Strong Cooling Core Cluster at z>1 Aneta Siemiginowska CfA Tom Aldcroft (CfA) Steve Allen (Stanford) Jill Bechtold.
Magnetic Jets and Lobes in Cosmological MHD Hui Li Los Alamos National Laboratory NSF/DOE Center for Magnetic Self-Organization (CMSO) Collaborators: H.
X-Ray Group Scaling Relations: Insights for Galaxy Formation Romeel Davé (Arizona) Neal Katz (UMass) David Weinberg (Ohio State) (work in progress)
Extended Radio Sources in Clusters of Galaxies Elizabeth Blanton University of Virginia.
Cosmological MHD Hui Li Collaborators: S. Li, M. Nakamura, S. Diehl, B. Oshea, P. Kronberg, S. Colgate (LANL) H. Xu, M. Norman (UCSD), R. Cen (Princeton)
Galaxy Clusters Perseus Cluster in X-rays. Why study clusters? Clusters are the largest virialized objects in the Universe. Cosmology: tail of density.
Chandra Observations of Radio Sources in Clusters: Impact on the ICM and Tracers of High-z Systems Elizabeth Blanton University of Virginia Collaborators:
Estimate* the Total Mechanical Feedback Energy in Massive Clusters Bill Mathews & Fulai Guo University of California, Santa Cruz *~ ±15-20% version 2.
An X-ray Study of the Bright Supernova Remnant G with XMM-Newton SNRs and PWNe in the Chandra Era Boston, MA – July 8 th, 2009 Daniel Castro,
MODELING INTRACLUSTER MEDIUM AND DARK MATTER IN GALAXY CLUSTERS Elena Rasia Dipartimento di Astronomia Università di Padova Padova, April 9th, 2002.
SEARCHING FOR COOLING FLOWS… Silvia Caffi IASF/CNR Sez. Milano.
(MNRAS 327, 610, 2001 & 347, 1234, 2004) David Churches, Mike Edmunds, Alistair Nelson - Physics & Astronomy, Cardiff University - Physics & Astronomy,
Galaxy Evolution in the Virgo Cluster Bernd Vollmer CDS, Observatoire de Strasbourg, France In collaboration with: P. Amram, C. Balkowski, R. Beck, A.
Scientific objectives for XEUS: Galaxies Groups and Clusters at z~2 Study of the Evolution of clusters in the mass range kT > 2 keV up to z=2. Dynamics,
Santiago Chile (5-9 Dec 2005) 1 “Groups of Galaxies in the nearby Universe” ESO 2005 workshop X-ray Properties of a Mass- Selected Group Catalog P. Mazzotta.
The Environments of Galaxies: from Kiloparsecs to Megaparsecs August 2004 Cool Cores in Galaxy Groups Ewan O’Sullivan Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics.
Suzaku, XMM-Newton and Chandra Observations of the Central Region of M 31 Hiromitsu Takahashi (Hiroshima University, Japan) M. Kokubun, K. Makishima, A.
Summary(3) -- Dynamics in the universe -- T. Ohashi (Tokyo Metropolitan U) 1.Instrumentation for dynamics 2.Cluster hard X-rays 3.X-ray cavities 4.Dark.
Suzaku Study of X-ray Emission from the Molecular Clouds in the Galactic Center M. Nobukawa, S. G. Ryu, S. Nakashima, T. G. Tsuru, K. Koyama (Kyoto Univ.),
Extended X-ray Emissions from the Radio Galaxies Centaurus B and Fornax A Makoto Tashiro 1, Naoki Isobe 2, Masaya Suzuki 1 Kouichi Ito 1, Keiichi Abe 1,
Hot gas in galaxy pairs Olga Melnyk. It is known that the dark matter is concentrated in individual haloes of galaxies and is located in the volume of.
MASS AND ENTROPY PROFILES OF X-RAY BRIGHT RELAXED GROUPS FABIO GASTALDELLO UC IRVINE & BOLOGNA D. BUOTE P. HUMPHREY L. ZAPPACOSTA J. BULLOCK W. MATHEWS.
The chemical enrichment of clusters of galaxies Jelle S. Kaastra Collaborators: Norbert Werner, Jelle de Plaa, Aurora Simionescu, Yan Grange.
GH2005 Gas Dynamics in Clusters III Craig Sarazin Dept. of Astronomy University of Virginia A85 Chandra (X-ray) Cluster Merger Simulation.
AY202a Galaxies & Dynamics Lecture 17: Galaxy Groups & Clusters continued.
3 Temperature profiles The shape of the temperatures profiles (some examples are shown in Fig.2) resemble the one obtained for hotter, more massive clusters.
GH2005 Gas Dynamics in Clusters II Craig Sarazin Dept. of Astronomy University of Virginia A85 Chandra (X-ray) Cluster Merger Simulation.
GH2005 Gas Dynamics in Clusters
Main-Cluster XIS0XIS1XIS3 Weighted mean Chandra Figure 2 : XIS spectra of the main-cluster XIS keV Main-Cluster Sub-Cluster Search for Bulk Motion.
On the evolution of Cool Core Clusters Joana Santos (INAF-Trieste) Piero Rosati (ESO), Paolo Tozzi (INAF-Trieste), Hans Boehringer (MPE), Stefano Ettori.
CLUSTERS OF GALAXIES The Physics of the IGM: Cooling Flows.
X-ray Astronomy School 2002 Clusters of Galaxies (and some Cosmology) Scientific and Data Analysis Issues Keith Arnaud NASA/GSFC and UMCP.
The Generation of Magnetic Fields and X-ray Observations Yutaka Fujita National Astronomical Observatory, Japan → Osaka University, Japan.
C. Y. Hui & W. Becker X-Ray Studies of the Central Compact Objects in Puppis-A & RX J Max Planck Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics, Giessenbachstrasse.
ISM X-ray Astrophysics Randall K. Smith Chandra X-ray Center.
Energy Balance in Clusters of Galaxies Patrick M. Motl & Jack O. Burns Center for Astrophysics and Space Astronomy University of Colorado at Boulder X-ray.
RGS observations of cool gas in cluster cores Jeremy Sanders Institute of Astronomy University of Cambridge A.C. Fabian, J. Peterson, S.W. Allen, R.G.
Metal abundance evolution in distant galaxy clusters observed by XMM-Newton Alessandro Baldi Astronomy Dept. - University of Bologna INAF - OABO In collaboration.
T. Ohashi (Tokyo Metropolitan University)
Recent Progress in Understanding X-ray Emission From Early-type Galaxies: The Hot Gas Component Jimmy A. Irwin University of Michigan X-rays From Nearby.
CLUSTERS OF GALAXIES IGM, and Scaling Laws. Emission Processes of Clusters of Galaxies in the X-ray Band.
Probing the Dynamics of Galaxy-Gas Interactions in Groups and Clusters with Chandra and XMM-Newton Marie Machacek Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory.
KASI Galaxy Evolution Journal Club A Massive Protocluster of Galaxies at a Redshift of z ~ P. L. Capak et al. 2011, Nature, in press (arXive: )
High Energy Astrophysics in the Next Decade International Workshop on NeXT and Future Missions Tokyo Metropolitan University June 21-23, 2006.
Bremsstrahlung from CLUSTERS OF GALAXIES. Clusters of Galaxies: a short overview.
GOAL: To understand the physics of active region decay, and the Quiet Sun network APPROACH: Use physics-based numerical models to simulate the dynamic.
The prolate shape of the Galactic halo Amina Helmi Kapteyn Astronomical Institute.
Ni ABUNDANCE IN THE CORE OF THE PERSEUS CLUSTER: AN ANSWER TO THE SIGNIFICANCE OF RESONANT SCATTERING AND SNIa ENRICHMENT Fabio Gastaldello (CNR-IASF,
Metallicity in intra-cluster medium of clusters and groups of galaxies
Jesper Rasmussen (Univ. of Birmingham)
Type Ia and II supernovae contributions
Presentation transcript:

K. MakishimaCooling Flow, 31 May 2003 The ASCA View on Cooling Flows and its Implications K. Max Makishima (U. Tokyo /RIKEN) in collaboration with Yasusi Ikebe, Yasusi Fukazawa, Kyoko Matsushita, Haiguan Xu, Takayuki Tamura, Isao Takahashi, and Madoka Kawaharada Makishima et al. PASJ, 53, 401 (2001) 1. ASCA and the Gas Imaging Spectrometer 2. Summary of the ASCA Results 3. Physics in the “post-CF” Era 4. The Prospect for ASTRO-E2

K. MakishimaCooling Flow, 31 May ASCA and the GIS Ohashi et al. PASJ 48, 157 (1996) Makishima et al. PASJ 48, 171 (1996) Energy (keV) 0.1 1e-2 1e-3 1e-4 cts/sec/cm 2 /keV Blanck sky (CXB+NXB) Sunlit earth (solar X-ray+ NXB) Mg Si S Ar Night earth (NXB) Cu GIS background spectra 45 arcmin Fornax Cluster with the GIS

K. MakishimaCooling Flow, 31 May EM cool /EM hot Hot component temperature (keV) A2199 A1795 A2147 A119 A496 3A0335 A3558 A1060 Hydra-A A2634 A2063 A4059 A400 MKW3s Virgo Cen AWM7 A539 AWM4 A262 2a. The central cool emission is exclusively associated with cD galaxies cD clusters (B-M I, I-II, or II) non-cD clusters (B-M II or III) 2. Summary of the ASCA Results Consistent with previous knowledge From 2T fits

K. MakishimaCooling Flow, 31 May b: The cool ICM phase is metal-enriched -According to the CF scenario, a metal-rich portion would cool and disappear quickly -- a contradiction. -The chemical abundance of ICM differs between the central and outer regions (Fukazawa et al. MNRAS 313, 21, 2000) -The cool component appear to be associated with the cD galaxy, rather than with cooling portion of the ICM.

K. MakishimaCooling Flow, 31 May 2003 CF rate with ASCA (M 0 /yr) A1795 Hydra-A A2199 A496 3A0335 MKW3s Centaurus Virgo AWM7 A262 CF rate before ASCA (M 0 /yr) - Hot emission from the cluster core was mistaken for the cool emission. - The central potential “dimple” was not properly considered Ikebe et al. (1997) - Xu et al. (1998) - Ikebe et al. (1999) - Makishima et al (2001) Reconfirmed with Chandra and XMM-Newton 2c. The CF rate was previously overestimated A good example will be given by the next speaker

K. MakishimaCooling Flow, 31 May 2003 Projected radius (arcmin) 101 ASCA GIS keV 101 ASCA GIS 3-10 keV Beta model (convolved) 100 kpc The central excess surface brightness is nearly color- independent (A1795; Xu et al. ApJ 500,738, 1998). 2d. The centrally peaked surface brightness is due to central potential deepening Surface brightness (a.u.) 1-beta fits (95 clusters) 2-beta fits (26 clusters) Core radius (Mpc) Number 60 kpc 220 kpc The ICM profile involve two spatial scales (ROSAT+ASCA; Ota et al. ApJL 567, L23, 2002).

K. MakishimaCooling Flow, 31 May e. The central cool component traces the central potential deepening Ikebe astroph/ ASCA A1795 EPIC-MOS EPIC-PN Temperature (keV) Projected radius (arcmin) T cool ~ T hot / 2, with a common radial temperature profile (Ikebe astro-ph/ ; Allen et al. MNRAS 328, L37, 2001) Temperature (keV) Log L X (erg/s) Cool component obeys the same L x -T relation as the entire cluster sample Most detailed 2T analysis: Ikebe et al. ApJ 525, 58 (1999) T cool may simply reflect the central potential depth

An isothermal hot ICM fills the entire potential well. A two-phase region is produced within the central potential dimple, by an admixture of metal-rich cool plasma. A hierarchical potential is formed by the cluster and the cD galaxy. 2f. The ASCA view of a cD cluster -- “Double-beta” and “2T” (Ikebe et al. ApJ, 525, 58,1999)

K. MakishimaCooling Flow, 31 May b. Simple-minded considerations 3a. Conclusion from Makishima et al. (2001) Through the ASCA study, we have arrived at a novel view on central regions of galaxy clusters. It describes the region around a cD galaxy as a site of significant and active evolution, where plenty of heavy elements are produced, a self-gravitating core develops, the stellar component condensates to the center, and the liberated energy is deposited onto the X-ray emitting plasmas. The scenario makes a sharp contrast to the previous view which emphasized the role of radiative plasma cooling. Novel X-ray information to be available with Chandra, XMM-Newton, and hopefully the rebuilt ASTRO-E will be utilized for further examination of our scenario. Through the ASCA study, we have arrived at a novel view on central regions of galaxy clusters. It describes the region around a cD galaxy as a site of significant and active evolution, where plenty of heavy elements are produced, a self-gravitating core develops, the stellar component condensates to the center, and the liberated energy is deposited onto the X-ray emitting plasmas. The scenario makes a sharp contrast to the previous view which emphasized the role of radiative plasma cooling. Novel X-ray information to be available with Chandra, XMM-Newton, and hopefully the rebuilt ASTRO-E will be utilized for further examination of our scenario. 3. Physics in the “Post-CF” Era

K. MakishimaCooling Flow, 31 May b. A simple idea (Makishima 1994) - ICM, DM, and galaxies have ~ the same specific energy. - Since alaxies have much lower specific entropy than ICM, the free energy will be transferred from galaxies to ICM. - Galaxies will lose energy and fall to the cluster center. High z Low z Evolution?

K. MakishimaCooling Flow, 31 May c. Supporting evidence - In angular extent, stars < DM < ICM -- Energy of the galaxies was transferred to the ICM. - Evidence for gradual galaxy mergers in the cluster center -- Dynamical energy of galaxies was extracted, and was deposited on the ICM. --> Poster #17. “The Dark Group Candidate, RXJ ” by Kawaharada et al. - The central decrease in Iron- Mass-to-Light -Ratio (IMLR) -- Galaxies gradually fell to the center while ejecting metals IMLR Centaurus e-3 1e-4 A1060 3D radius (kpc) Radial IMLR profiles - The O-profile is flatter than the Fe-profile -- Early SNe II occurred over an extended region, while subsequent SNe Ia occurred closer to the center.

K. MakishimaCooling Flow, 31 May d. Numerical estimates - The expected galaxy-to-ICM energy transfer rate ; -dE/dt ~ N  R i 2 n m p v 3 (Sazazin 1988, p.152) ~ 2x10 44 (N /300) (R i /10kpc) 2 (n/10 -3 ) (v/500 kms -1 ) 3 erg/s (N=galaxy number; R i = interaction radius; n=ICM density; v=galaxy velocity dispersion) - The intra-cluster magnetic fields are easily “pushed away” by moving galaxies that are good electrical conductors. This makes R i ~ DM halo of each galaxy. - The available total dynamical energy in galaxies; E ~ 5x10 62 (M gal /10 14 M 0 ) (v/500 kms -1 ) 2 ergs E/(dE/dt) ~ 80 Gyr

K. MakishimaCooling Flow, 31 May 2003 Reconnection sites Hot phase Cool phase Magnetic field lines Galaxy motion/rotation - Ordered magnetic fields separate the hot and cool phases. - Galaxies’ kinetic energy -- > MHD turbulence -- > reconnection -- > plasma heating & particle acceleration - The loop-like structure stabilizes the heating/cooling. 3c. A speculative view -- the “cD corona”

4. The Prospect for ASTRO-E2 The first improved version of the M-5 rocket has been launched successfully on 2003 May 9, putting “Sample-Return” mission into an interplanetary orbit. We are re-building the Hard X-ray Detector (HXD). The recovery mission ASTRO-E2 will be launched in The XRS (D       measures the expected ICM turbulence. -The HXD ( keV) searches for particle acceleration. -The XIS (CCD camera) studies the ICM heating process.

K. MakishimaCooling Flow, 31 May 2003 Conclusion - - Using ASCA, we have pointed out for the first time that the CF hypothesis needs a significant revision. - - The view has been reinforced by XMM- Newton and Chandra. - - We propose that the dynamical energy in the galaxy motion is dissipated onto the ICM. - - ASTRO-E2 will open the new era of such post-CF physics.

K. MakishimaCooling Flow, 31 May 2003