07-06-2005Thredbo 9 1 PUBLIC TRANSPORT PERFORMANCE, ORGANISATION AND MANAGEMENT DECISIONS Álvaro Costa / Teresa Stanislau.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Benefit-estimation for mobility management by stat. data Walter Bien ECOMM-2008 (London, June-2008) 1 Quick & Simple – a new approach for benefit-estimation.
Advertisements

Porto / Portugal 41,3 Km² inhabitants Citizens
What is the capital of the UK? London What is the capital of France? Paris.
Facility Planning: Capacity. Capacity Planning Interrelated facility planning decisions: 1.Number of facilities and general type 2.Capacity 3.Locations.
The international perspective: problems and opportunities 29 February 2012 Brussels, Belgium Presented by Mr John Gilbert President Eurolines Organisation.
Study Project The Countries and Capitals of the European Union.
Ministry of Public Works, Transport and Communications Cabinet of the State Secretary for Transportation The Organisation and Financing of Local Public.
Part-financed by the European Union WP 4 implementation cases: Estonia BalticClimate, 1st transnational seminar Gävle, June 11-12, 2009.
1 Deep impact for High Impact Agencies? Assessing the role of bureaucratic encounters in evaluations of government Steven Van de Walle Public Management.
Thredbo 9 – Lisbon 2005 Some thoughts on service quality measurement The SCTP case study Álvaro Costa, Sofia Pinto, Jorge Freire de Sousa.
European Capital Cities Quiz. What is the capital of France? a) Berlin b) Bern c) Madrid d) Paris.
Developing and Implementing Workforce Plans A2 Business Studies.
National trends in passenger transport regarding the choice of transport mode Grant Agreement number: Project Acronym: USEmobility Project title:
Mike Brown – Managing Director London Underground & London Rail Maximizing rail capacity in London.
‘The integrated organising authority as the driving force behind public transport’ The STIF: the organising authority for transport and mobility in Paris.
This project is implemented through the CENTRAL EUROPE Programme co-financed by the ERDF. CENTRAL EUROPE Annual event – 23./ ,
Rail and the West Midlands Economy EMTA Conference Birmingham, 11/11/11 Peter Sargant Head of Rail Development, Centro.
Global Research and Consulting European Investment Briefing Presented by: Michael Haddock, Director, EMEA Research & Consulting 05/10/2010.
Lesson 3: Monitoring and Indicator Macerata, 23 nd October Alessandro Valenza, Director, t33 srl.
Social Measurement in third sector organisations, social accounting and sustainability: The case of leisure trusts Dr Jane Gibbon Newcastle University.
Map of Europe.
FINANCING OF PUBLIC TRANSPORT INFRASTRUCTURE IN EUROPE Maria-Pilar Machancoses Regeneration & Planning Manager Centro.
© International Road Transport Union (IRU) 2004 Page 1 The TØI Study “Taxi Regulation in Europe” Marc Billiet Head Passenger Transport IRU.
EMTA Strategy & Working program Lyon meeting October2006.
EUROCITIES Knowledge Society Forum - TeleCities Cities Role in the Knowledge Society Herkalion 5 – 6 May 2006 Chris Newby Forum Chair and Councillor Liverpool.
A comparison using the EMTA Barometer 2004 data This work has been realized on the basis of EMTA Barometer 2004 data recently published. Its objectives.
Budapest Transport Closely Held Corporation (BKV) Changes in the public transport in Budapest over the past 15 years Andrea Bagoly, 22 June, 2007 „We make.
Project Cycle Management for International Development Cooperation Indicators Teacher Pietro Celotti Università degli Studi di Macerata 16 December 2011.
CHAPTER 12 Descriptive, Program Evaluation, and Advanced Methods.
10th October, 2013 Public transport employees’ ticket privileges Tamás Dombi ZTM Warsaw.
Political Map of Europe Western European Countries.
Torino, April 17th-18th, 2008 Laura Delgado EMTA BAROMETER OF PUBLIC TRANSPORT IN EUROPEAN METROPOLITAN AREAS 2008 (Data 2006) Agenda.
EMTA General Meeting , Turin Tamas Dombi, ZTM Warsaw1 Actual Problems of the Public Transport in Warsaw Metropolitan Area.
Conclusion from part 1 The EU constitutes a group of developed countries. 500 million inhabitants who possess considerable buying power and who on the.
France Start Card Who has ……. Germany Paris Who has …… I Have ……
EMTA General Meeting – London October 9° 2014 SURVEY ON THE INTERCHANGE RATE Results of the questionnaire circulated among EMTA Members.
EMTA Questionnaire on Governance and Mobility Plans EMTA General meeting April 2009 Valencia.
EMTA General Meeting Prague May 2012 Round table on PSO Regulation 1370/2007 “Two years after enforcement, where are we? How efficient is the regulation?
Chapter 6.  OM, previously known as productions management is the management of resources to achieve efficient output of goods or services.  It involves.
Paris Lisbon Madrid Reykjavik Dublin London Oslo Stockholm Helsinki Berlin Warsaw Athens Vatican City (Rome) Kiev.
Social cost benefit analysis of Delhi Metro
SKM Warsaw – a communal train Piotr Izdebski ZTM Transport and Economic Growth – An International Perspective Birmingham, 11th November 2011.
Resource allocation and portfolio efficiency analysis Antti Toppila Systems Analysis Laboratory Aalto University School of Science and Technology P.O.
Someone needed here to point out where Europe is….
Regional Policy Towards indicators of proximity to services in Europe's major cities Enhancing the analytical use of the GMES Urban Atlas in combination.
COMPETITIVE EUROPEAN CITIES: WHERE DOES THE UK STAND? Professor Michael Parkinson European Institute for Urban Affairs The Art of City Making Conference.
Click to edit Master text styles Who we are and what we can offer you Sunhotels Group & Incentive Department.
WIS DOT MCLARY MANAGEMENT PERFORMANCE MEASUREMENT.
FREE PUBLIC TRANSPORT Hasselt from the beginning to the end Summer School Tallinn 22 – 24 August 2013 Marc Verachtert, General Manager.
Shona Frame Construction Dispute Resolution Partner CMS Cameron McKenna LLP.
#HASH BROWNS: F&B SOCIAL MEDIA AND IP RIGHTS Tom Scourfield Chair Consumer Products Sector Group and UK Head of
Leanness Score of Value Stream Maps 1. ANES WEDARING DHARMA ( ) 2. EKA NOVANTARA ( ) 3. RENAN LINTANG PRAKOSO ( )
Free Public Transport in Tallinn – a step toward green capital INTERMODES Brussels, By Allan Alaküla, Head of Tallinn EU Office Rue du Luxembourg.
What can we learn from Benchmarking? Bård Uthus BKK Nett AS
Someone needed here to point out where Europe is…
All Roads Lead to Rome Km 923 Km 489 Km 0 Km 989 Km 518 Km 898 Km 811
KOHALIKU OMAVALITSUSE ARENGU VAJADUSED ja VÕIMALUSED (PEALINNA KOHT KOHALIKUS OMAVALITSUSES) DEVELOPMENT NEEDS and OPPORTUNITIES of LOCAL SELF-GOVERNMENT.
Countries and Capitals of Western Europe
Member States of the EU Austria
بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم.
The European Union (EU for short)
The Urban Audit follow-up
NO2 Measurement Method proposed by Japan 9 ~ 10 December 2010.
Urban passenger mobility   Jari Kauppila Economiste | Chef de l’unite statistiques Eurostat Workshop on Passenger Mobility Luxembourg, 17 June 2014.
Supply chain management
Regional Operational Programme under Objective 1 of Cohesion Policy case of Pomorskie Region in Poland Stanislaw Bienias on behalf of Pomorskie Region.
WEST EUROPE MAP REVIEW.
The City Summit & The Urban Audit
Citizens' Dialogues The New Deal for Consumers
Someone needed here to point out where Europe is…
Presentation transcript:

Thredbo 9 1 PUBLIC TRANSPORT PERFORMANCE, ORGANISATION AND MANAGEMENT DECISIONS Álvaro Costa / Teresa Stanislau

Thredbo 9 2 Urban Public Transport System Organisation Modal Services (Lisbon, Porto, Budapest, Luxembourg, Nicosia, Tallinn,…) Authority and Operator (Amsterdam, Barcelona, Brussels, Lyon, Munich, Warsaw,…) Authority and Multiple Operators (Berlin, Dublin, London, Prague, Stockholm,…) Deregulation (Birmingham, Manchester)

Thredbo 9 3 Management Decisions and Performance Management Decision Performance D1D2D3 Decision Making Models Usual Procedure

Thredbo 9 4 Management Decisions and Performance Proposed Procedure Decision Making Models + Past Analysis Analysis of the impact of management decision in performance (DEA technique) Management Decision Performance D1D2 D3

Thredbo 9 5 Case Study - STCP Porto Metropolitan Area Portugal Map in Porto Map in Councils14 Area (km 2 ) Inhabitants

Thredbo 9 6 Serviços de Transportes Colectivos (1946) Sociedade de Transportes Colectivos do Porto, S. A. (1994) Operates in 6 councils of Porto Metropolitan Area 81 bus lines + 2 tram lines 18 bus lines+ 2 tram lines integrated fare system (June 2005) Case Study - STCP STCP

Thredbo 9 7 Case Study - STCP DEA - Efficiency/Effectiveness Matrix STCP – Public Service Maximize the outputs to be obtained from available resources DEA Time series Efficiency/Effectiveness Matrix Performance evaluation and resource allocation of public transport operator

Thredbo 9 8 Case Study - STCP Inputs and Outputs Efficiency Effectiveness Input Staff (31 Dez.) Vehicles Output Vehicles.km Passengers Data in STCP’s Reports and Accounts since 1946

Thredbo 9 9 Case Study - STCP Results

Thredbo 9 10 Case Study - STCP Results

Thredbo 9 11 Only major marks can be distinguished: - Council management (50’s) - Social benefits to workers (60’s) - Political Events (70’s) - Single Agent (80’s) - Operational Leasing (90’s) Case Study - STCP Results

Thredbo 9 12 Data precision and availability conditioned the results. There are significant lags between management decisions and their effects It’s not possible to evaluate the effect of every management decisions, only major decisions can be spotted. Case Study - STCP First Conclusions

Thredbo 9 13 Case Study - STCP DEA and Other Indicators Short Term Capital Effectiveness Labour Effectiveness Ratio DEA Effectiveness

Thredbo 9 14 Case Study - STCP DEA and Other Indicators Capital Productivity Ratio Labour Productivity Ratio DEA Efficiency

Thredbo 9 15 Case Study - STCP DEA and Other Indicators Production Effectiveness Another type of indicator which gives other type of information relating both outputs considered in this case study. Production resources efficiency or effectiveness can not be evaluated with this ratio. Gives us information about production effectiveness relating passengers served and Vkm produced. Relates demand and offer

Thredbo 9 16 Conclusions Construction of an EEM can give a general view about the operator performance in terms of aggregate measures. Analyzing an operator’s EEM together with its management history is useful for identifying effects of certain decisions in terms of company performance. There’s a variable lag between a decision and its reflex on the performance.

Thredbo 9 17 Conclusions Considering production resources efficiency it’s equivalent to analyse capital productivity ratio and labour productivity ratio together. Production resources effectiveness is equivalent to short term capital effectiveness together with labour effectiveness ratio. It can not be proved that using EEM to evaluate public transport operators performance is more trustful than using all performance indicators together, but it is easy to use and gives a fast view on general performance of the company.