Carlo Cottarelli Director, Fiscal Affairs Department October 2011.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 Relative GDP per capita 2000 PPPs, OECD = countries. Estimates for Source: OECD National Accounts.
Advertisements

Chapter Sixteen: Deficits and Debt. Deficits and National Debt.
The European Union THE EUROPEAN UNION How do individuals, businesses and economies benefit from using the Euro?
1 Fiscal Policies for Sustainable Economic Growth: Challenges for Slovenia Gerd Schwartz Deputy Director, Fiscal Affairs Department, IMF Conference on.
EU Enlargement EU Enlargement. FYR Enlargement: from 6 to 27  1973: United Kingdom, Ireland, Denmark  : Greece, Spain, Portugal  1995: Sweden,
Economic Experience and Crisis in the Euro Zone Carlos Hurtado* The Restructuring and Resolution of External Sovereign Debt World Bank. Annual Law, Justice.
60% Gross Domestic Product 40% EU signed Maastricht Treaty, under which EDP was defined in article 104. According to the treaty, fiscal surveillance.
1 A Strategy for Fiscal Adjustment When the Recovery Takes Hold Paolo Mauro November 17, 2009 Bangkok.
Pension Reform and Labor Market Policies In Central Europe Elaine Fultz Senior Specialist in Social Security International Labor Organization Budapest.
ECO 358 International Economics Professor Malamud BEH – 3294 Fax: 895 – Website:
ECO 358 International Economics Professor Malamud BEH – 3294 Fax: 895 – – Website:
“Today, there are three kinds of people: the have's, the have-not's, and the have-not- paid-for-what-they-have's.“ Earl Wilson.
Macroeconomics Basics.
1 Transparent and Credible Strategies to Achieve Medium-Term Fiscal Sustainability Carlo Cottarelli XXII Regional Fiscal Policy Seminar, ECLAC, Santiago.
Long-run Pension System Reforms in Europe and Central Asia Anita M. Schwarz Lead Economist Human Development Department Europe and Central Asia Region.
INBU 4200: International Financial Management Professor Michael Palmer Leeds School of Business Fall Semester, 2010.
Economics 434 Financial Markets Professor Burton University of Virginia Fall 2011.
 20- Claude Debussy; composer, early 20 th century  50- Antoine de St.-Exupéry; author, early-mid 20 th century.
Critiques of Capitalism Week 5. Growth as a religion Is a larger real GDP always preferable to a smaller real GDP?
Macroeconomic Policy in the Eurozone: Are There Alternatives to Slow Growth and High Unemployment? Mark Weisbrot, Co-Director Center for Economic and Policy.
Pension systems during the financial and economic crisis Edward Whitehouse Social Policy division, OECD.
European Long-Term Growth and the Euro Crisis Uri Dadush New York University, Stern School of Business October 8,
Fiscal Policy, Deficits, and Debt
16 out of 27 member states Known as euro zones 2 nd largest traded currency after the dollar The name euro was officially adopted on 16 December 1995.
Austerity in the Eurozone: It’s Not Working Mark Weisbrot Center for Economic and Policy Research
The Israeli Economy International Perspective February 2013 Ministry of Finance A comparison of recent economic developments in Israel and the developed.
The Global Economic Environment
The Quest for Lasting Financial Stability Centre International d'Etudes Monétaires et Bancaires José Viñals Financial Counsellor International Monetary.
Restricted 1 The Future of Public Debt: Prospects and Implications Stephen Cecchetti * Economic Adviser and Head Monetary and Economic Department Bank.
Public finances and monetary policy First Deputy Governor Svante Öberg SACO 26 April 2010.
1 Sovereign Credit Risk: Changing Fundamentals Fixed Income Forum March 25, 2010 Manmohan S. Kumar Assistant Director Fiscal Affairs Department International.
The Future of the Global Economy Augusto López-Claros, Ph.D. International Environment Forum Brighton, United Kingdom December 18, 2010.
GREECE IS CHANGING 2010 – 2012 April Fiscal consolidation  Primary budget deficit decreased from €24.1 bn in 2009 to €10.7 bn in 2010 to €4.7 bn.
OECD Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development Organisation and Content Overview.
Carlo Cottarelli Director, Fiscal Affairs Department September 2011.
1. GDP Growth of Eurozone Double-dip recession 2015Q1Q2Q3Q4 Year average Growth rate of GDP 0.4% 0.5% 1.4% 2.
1 Public Pension Reform and Fiscal Consolidation Carlo Cottarelli Director Fiscal Affairs Department May 20, 2010 Paris.
The 10-Step Road Map To Prosperity 1.Trade Policy 2.Fiscal Burden 3.Government Intervention 4.Monetary Policy 5.Capital Flows and Foreign Investment.
“Measuring the Information Economy” WITSA Public Policy Meeting hosted by BIAC 24 October 2002.
Capitalist. Main Points In a capitalist or free-market country, people can own their own businesses and property. People can also buy services for private.
The Global Economic Environment The Coming Boom Wealthy Industrial Countries Developing Countries East Asia South Asia Latin America
UEMS ORL TREASURY REPORT October 2012 M. de la Mota, F. Marchal.
Doing Business in Europe Bay Area CITD Seminar Series Tuesday, September 21st, 2004 Kemarra Inc. - Key Marketing Resources & Associates San Francisco USA.
South East Europe in an Environment of Volatile Capital Flows Sarajevo, June 5 and 6, 2014 Michael Faulend
International Comparison of Health Care Gene Chang.
To relocate or not to relocate Hans Martens Chief Executive European Policy Centre.
 Used by 17 of 27 countries  Used for all payments starting in 2002  Should be used by all countries once they join THE EURO.
The European Union 1 THE EUROPEAN UNION Lesson 2 Where in the world is the European Union?
The United States The Economy. What is GDP ? Gross Domestic Product (GDP): The total market (or dollar) value of all final goods and services produced.
THE BIG PICTURE: Global Industry Status and Prospects Europe Iker Goikoetxea Managing Director Kursaal Congress Centre and Auditorium.
The Euro Area Crisis: Origins, Prospects and Implications for the World Economy and Global Governance Domenico Lombardi UNLV, April 3, 2013.
Fiscal Policy, Deficits, and Debt 30 McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2012 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Inflation Report May Demand Chart 2.1 World trade (a) Sources: CPB Netherlands Bureau for Economic Policy Analysis and OECD. (a) Volume measure.
European Union Established in accordance with Masstricht Treaty (1993) 27 countries –Motto: Unity in Diversity Four Freedoms –People –Goods –Services.
Latest developments in the global outlook, and the situation in Greece 18 February 2015 Alvaro Pereira Director, Country Studies Council.
Economic Cooperation by Rojda Icboyun, Jasmin Reinhardt, Adrian Welter, Spela Dimic, Sandi Denzic Group 1 Heimschule Lender Sasbach, International.
6. Ráðstefnan um rannsóknir á íslensku þjóðfélagi Háskólanum á Akureyri, 20. – 21. apríl 2012 The Nordic Countries in an International Comparison Helga.
September 16, 2009 World Economic and Market Developments Olivier Blanchard Economic Counsellor Research Department.
Overview. Table A Key risks to the UK financial system.
Part A: Global environment
Monetary Policy and Fiscal Soundness
Introduction. Monika Queisser Head of Social Policy Division
How Canada Compares Internationally
EUROS Identification Austria - Belgium - Cyprus - Estonia - Finland - France - Germany - Greece - Ireland - Italy - Latvia Lithuania - Luxembourg - Malta.
Global Financial Crisis: Implications for Future Business Education
EU: First- & Second-Generation Immigrants
Sovereign debt and multiple equilibria
Where in the world is the European Union?
2006 Rank Adjusted for Purchasing Power
Presentation transcript:

Carlo Cottarelli Director, Fiscal Affairs Department October 2011

2 Fiscal Monitor, September 2011

3 1. The state of the public finances before the 2008 crisis 2. The effect of the crisis on the fiscal accounts 3. The risks arising from the current situation 4. Policy conclusions Overview

4 1. The state of the public finances before the 2008 crisis

General Government Gross Debt in G-7 Economies, (In percent of GDP)

General Government Gross Debt in Selected Advanced Economies, (In percent of GDP)

General Government Gross Debt in Emerging Economies, (In percent of GDP)

8 2. The effect of the crisis on the fiscal accounts

9 Change in General Government Debt and Deficit: Advanced Economies Change in debt with respect to Change in deficit with respect to 2007

10 Change in General Government Debt and Deficit: Advanced Economies Change in debt with respect to Change in deficit with respect to 2007 Canada France Germany Greece Italy Japan Portugal Spain United Kingdom United States

Portugal 11 Change in General Government Debt and Deficit: Advanced Economies Change in debt with respect to 2007 Canada France Germany Greece Italy Japan Spain United Kingdom United States 2009 Change in deficit with respect to 2007

Change in General Government Debt and Deficit: Advanced Economies Change in debt with respect to 2007 France Germany Greece Italy Portugal Spain United Kingdom United States 2010 Canada Japan 12 Change in deficit with respect to 2007

13 Change in General Government Debt and Deficit: Advanced Economies Change in debt with respect to 2007 France Canada Greece Italy Japan Portugal United Kingdom United States Germany Change in deficit with respect to 2007 Spain

14 Change in General Government Debt and Deficit: Advanced Economies Change in debt with respect to 2007 Japan United States Canada France Germany GreeceItaly Portugal Spain United Kingdom Change in deficit with respect to 2007

15 Change in General Government Debt and Deficit: Advanced Economies Change in debt with respect to 2007 Japan United States Canada France Germany GreeceItaly Portugal Spain United Kingdom Change in deficit with respect to 2007

16 Change in General Government Debt and Deficit: Emerging Economies Change in deficit with respect to 2007 Change in debt with respect to

17 Change in General Government Debt and Deficit: Emerging Economies Brazil China India Mexico Russia Average Advanced Change in deficit with respect to 2007 Change in debt with respect to

18 Change in General Government Debt and Deficit: Emerging Economies Brazil China India Mexico Russia Average Advanced Change in deficit with respect to 2007 Change in debt with respect to

19 Change in General Government Debt and Deficit: Emerging Economies Brazil China India Mexico Russia Average Advanced Change in deficit with respect to 2007 Change in debt with respect to

20 Change in General Government Debt and Deficit: Emerging Economies Brazil China India Mexico Russia Average Advanced Change in deficit with respect to 2007 Change in debt with respect to

21 Change in General Government Debt and Deficit: Emerging Economies Brazil India Mexico Russia Average Advanced Change in deficit with respect to 2007 Change in debt with respect to

22 G-20 Advanced Economies: Increase in General Government Debt, 2008–15 (Total increase: 38.6 percentage points of GDP)

23 Illustrative Scenarios for Primary Balance Adjustment and Debt, General Government Gross Debt-to-GDP Ratio Overall Balance Primary Balance Cyclically Adjusted Primary Balance

24 Cyclically Adjusted Primary Balance that Needs to Be Maintained in 2020–30 to Achieve Debt Target by 2030 (In percent of GDP)

25 3. The risks arising from the current situation

26 General Government Deficit vs. Debt in Euro Area Countries, 2011 Austria Belgium Cyprus Estonia Finland France Greece Ireland Italy Luxembourg Malta Netherlands Portugal Slovak Republic SloveniaSpain Germany Gross Debt (percent of GDP) 2011 Deficit (percent of GDP)

General Government Deficit vs. Debt in Euro Area Countries, 2007

28 General Government Deficit vs. Debt in Euro Area Countries, 2011 Austria Belgium Cyprus Estonia Finland France Greece Ireland Italy Luxembourg Malta Netherlands Portugal Slovak Republic SloveniaSpain Germany Japan United States Gross Debt (percent of GDP) 2011 Deficit (percent of GDP)

29 1. Past and future fiscal trends Why Euro Area Countries Are Different from US and Japan?

30 General Government Deficit vs. Debt in Euro Area Countries, 2011 Austria Belgium Cyprus Estonia Finland France Greece Ireland Italy Luxembourg Malta Netherlands Portugal Slovak Republic SloveniaSpain Germany Japan United States Gross Debt (percent of GDP) 2011 Deficit (percent of GDP)

2011 General Government Deficit, in percent of GDP

32 Change in the Deficit in the Euro Area, US and Japan Percent of GDP change, Fall 2009 FM Current FM

33 Fiscal Outlook: Increase in General Government Debt during Spain Belgium France (Change in percent of GDP) Germany Italy October 2009 Sept 2011 October 2009 Sept 2011 October 2009 Sept 2011 October 2009 Sept 2011 October 2009 Sept 2011 United States Japan October 2009 Sept 2011 October 2009 Sept Increase in debt, Increase in debt, Increase in debt, Increase in debt, Increase in debt, Increase in debt, Increase in debt,

34 1. Past and future fiscal trends 2. Long-term pressures on spending for health care and pensions Why Euro Area Countries Are Different from US and Japan?

35 NPV of Pension and Health care Spending Change 2010–50 (Change in percent of GDP)

36 NPV of Pension and Health care Spending Change 2010–50 vs. Yield Spreads

37 1. Past and future fiscal trends 2. Long-term pressures on spending for health care and pensions 3. Banks 4. Growth Why Euro Area Countries Are Different from US and Japan?

38 Sovereign Bond Yield Spreads and Projected Real GDP Growth

39 Sovereign Bond Yield Spreads and Real GDP Growth

40 High Public Debt is Bad for Growth Rogoff and Reinhart: “This Time is Different: Eight Centuries of Financial Folly” (2009) Kumar and Woo: “Public Debt and Growth” (2010) Steven Cecchetti: “The Real Effects of Debt” (2011)

41 Advanced Economies: Debt Above 80 percent of GDP AUSAUT BEL CAN CZE DEN DEU ESP FIN FRA GBR GRC ICE IRE ISR ITA JPN NED NZL PRT SLK SLV USA %

42 Advanced Economies: Debt Above 80 percent of GDP AUSAUT BEL CAN CZE DEN DEU ESP FIN FRA GBR GRC ICE IRE ISR ITA JPN NED NZL PRT SLK SLV USA %81% 2011

43 1. Past and future fiscal trends 2. Long-term pressures on spending for health care and pensions 3. Banks 4. Growth 5. Sources of financing Why Euro Area Countries Are Different from US and Japan?

44 Sources of Financing: Holders of Public Debt Japan Central Government Bonds United States Treasury Securities Ireland Central Government Bonds Portugal General Government Debt Spain Central Government Securities Greece Central Government Marketable Debt Italy General Government Securities Belgium Gross Government Debt France Central Government Securities Private Residents Central Bank Private Non-residents Official Non-residents Note: For Ireland, France, Italy, Portugal, Greece and Spain: Private non-resident, includes ECB.

45 United States: Ownership of Treasury Securities Private Non-residents Central Bank Official Non-residentsChina

46 Private Non-residents Holders of Debt vs. Yield Spreads

47 4. Policy conclusions

48 1. United States and Japan need a clear plan 2. Europe needs: 1. Adjustment in fiscal fundamentals 2. Reforms to boost potential growth 3. Banking 4. Financing for countries that are adjusting Policy Conclusions

49 General Government Deficit vs. Debt in Euro Area Countries, Spain Malta Gross Debt (percent of GDP) Austria Belgium Cyprus Estonia Finland France Greece Ireland Italy Luxembourg Netherlands Portugal Slovak Republic Slovenia Spain Germany Deficit (percent of GDP)

50 General Government Deficit vs. Debt in Euro Area Countries,

51 Initial debt ratio at 100% Increase the growth rate for 10 years by 1 p.p. Spending constant in per capita terms, assuming a 40% tax ratio Would lower public debt by 29% of GDP The Role of Growth Lowering Debt Ratios Debt in Percent of GDP Year Role of Growth in Debt Reduction 29% Difference Baseline With growth increased by 1 percentage points

Thank You!