4. Modeling 3D-periodic systems Cut-off radii, charges groups Ewald summation Growth units, bonds, attachment energy Predicting crystal structures.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Simulazione di Biomolecole: metodi e applicazioni giorgio colombo
Advertisements

How to setup the initial conditions for a Molecular Dynamic Simulation
Simulated Annealing Premchand Akella. Agenda Motivation The algorithm Its applications Examples Conclusion.
Bare Surface Tension and Surface Fluctuations of Clusters with Long–Range Interaction D.I. Zhukhovitskii Joint Institute for High Temperatures, RAS.
CHE Inorganic, Physical & Solid State Chemistry Advanced Quantum Chemistry: lecture 4 Rob Jackson LJ1.16,
Ion Solvation Thermodynamics from Simulation with a Polarizable Force Field Gaurav Chopra 07 February 2005 CS 379 A Alan GrossfeildPengyu Ren Jay W. Ponder.
Applications and integration with experimental data Checking your results Validating your results Structure determination from powder data calculations.
Structure Outline Solve Structure Refine Structure and add all atoms
Instructor: Mircea Nicolescu Lecture 13 CS 485 / 685 Computer Vision.
Computing Protein Structures from Electron Density Maps: The Missing Loop Problem I. Lotan, H. van den Bedem, A. Beacon and J.C. Latombe.
The Calculation of Enthalpy and Entropy Differences??? (Housekeeping Details for the Calculation of Free Energy Differences) first edition: p
Molecular Modeling of Crystal Structures molecules surfaces crystals.
Two Examples of Docking Algorithms With thanks to Maria Teresa Gil Lucientes.
2. Modeling of small systems Building the model What is the optimal conformation of a molecule? What is the relative energy of a given conformation? What.
MAE 552 – Heuristic Optimization Lecture 6 February 6, 2002.
3. Crystals What defines a crystal? Atoms, lattice points, symmetry, space groups Diffraction B-factors R-factors Resolution Refinement Modeling!
Algorithm for Fast MC Simulation of Proteins Itay Lotan Fabian Schwarzer Dan Halperin Jean-Claude Latombe.
PREDICCIÓN DE ESTRUCTURAS DE CRISTALES CON MOLÉCULAS FLEXIBES EN SU CELDA V. Bazterra, M. B. Ferraro, J. C. Facelli Departamento de Física Facultad de.
Joo Chul Yoon with Prof. Scott T. Dunham Electrical Engineering University of Washington Molecular Dynamics Simulations.
Optimization of thermal processes2007/2008 Optimization of thermal processes Maciej Marek Czestochowa University of Technology Institute of Thermal Machinery.
Bioinf. Data Analysis & Tools Molecular Simulations & Sampling Techniques117 Jan 2006 Bioinformatics Data Analysis & Tools Molecular simulations & sampling.
Molecular Modeling Part I Molecular Mechanics and Conformational Analysis ORG I Lab William Kelly.
Monte-Carlo simulations of the structure of complex liquids with various interaction potentials Alja ž Godec Advisers: prof. dr. Janko Jamnik and doc.
Monte Carlo Simulation of Interacting Electron Models by a New Determinant Approach Mucheng Zhang (Under the direction of Robert W. Robinson and Heinz-Bernd.
1 Physical Chemistry III Molecular Simulations Piti Treesukol Chemistry Department Faculty of Liberal Arts and Science Kasetsart University :
Algorithms and Software for Large-Scale Simulation of Reactive Systems _______________________________ Ananth Grama Coordinated Systems Lab Purdue University.
Materials Process Design and Control Laboratory ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF WEIGHTED MANY- BODY EXPANSIONS USING AB-INITIO CALCULATIONS FOR PREDICTING STABLE.
The Nuts and Bolts of First-Principles Simulation Durham, 6th-13th December : DFT Plane Wave Pseudopotential versus Other Approaches CASTEP Developers’
Free energies and phase transitions. Condition for phase coexistence in a one-component system:
Conformational Sampling
1 CE 530 Molecular Simulation Lecture 17 Beyond Atoms: Simulating Molecules David A. Kofke Department of Chemical Engineering SUNY Buffalo
Chapter 25 Electric Potential Electrical Potential and Potential Difference When a test charge is placed in an electric field, it experiences a.
Integrated Coordinated Science End of Year Review.
Optimization in Engineering Design Georgia Institute of Technology Systems Realization Laboratory Mixed Integer Problems Most optimization algorithms deal.
Ionic Conductors: Characterisation of Defect Structure Lecture 15 Total scattering analysis Dr. I. Abrahams Queen Mary University of London Lectures co-financed.
Simulated Annealing.
For a new configuration of the same volume V and number of molecules N, displace a randomly selected atom to a point chosen with uniform probability inside.
Markov Chain Monte Carlo and Gibbs Sampling Vasileios Hatzivassiloglou University of Texas at Dallas.
Plan Last lab will be handed out on 11/22. No more labs/home works after Thanksgiving. 11/29 lab session will be changed to lecture. In-class final (1hour):
Potential energy surface, Force field & Molecular Mechanics 3N (or 3N-6 or 3N-5) Dimension PES for N-atom system x E’ =  k i (l i  l 0,i ) +  k i ’
Molecular simulation methods Ab-initio methods (Few approximations but slow) DFT CPMD Electron and nuclei treated explicitly. Classical atomistic methods.
Advanced methods of molecular dynamics 1.Monte Carlo methods 2.Free energy calculations 3.Ab initio molecular dynamics 4.Quantum molecular dynamics 5.Trajectory.
MODELING MATTER AT NANOSCALES 3. Empirical classical PES and typical procedures of optimization Classical potentials.
Molecular Crystals. Molecular Crystals: Consist of repeating arrays of molecules and/or ions.
Intermolecular Forces. Forces that hold solids and liquids together may be ionic or covalent bonding or they may involve a weaker interaction called intermolecular.
Chapter2. Some Thermodynamics Aspects of Intermolecular Forces Chapter2. Some Thermodynamics Aspects of Intermolecular Forces 한국과학기술원 화학과 계면화학 제 1 조 김동진.
Thermal Surface Fluctuations of Clusters with Long-Range Interaction D.I. Zhukhovitskii Joint Institute for High Temperatures, RAS.
Molecular Modelling - Lecture 2 Techniques for Conformational Sampling Uses CHARMM force field Written in C++
Selecting Diverse Sets of Compounds C371 Fall 2004.
Quantum Mechanics/ Molecular Mechanics (QM/MM) Todd J. Martinez.
Intermolecular Interactions
Interacting Molecules in a Dense Fluid
An Introduction to Monte Carlo Methods in Statistical Physics Kristen A. Fichthorn The Pennsylvania State University University Park, PA
1 Statistical Mechanics and Multi- Scale Simulation Methods ChBE Prof. C. Heath Turner Lecture 20 Some materials adapted from Prof. Keith E. Gubbins:
Molecular dynamics (4) Treatment of long-range interactions Computing properties from simulation results.
1 Molecular Simulations Macroscopic EOS (vdW, PR) Little molecular detail Empirical parameters (  ) Seeking understanding of complex systems Surfactants.
--Experimental determinations of radial distribution functions --Potential of Mean Force 1.
1 Information Content Tristan L’Ecuyer. 2 Degrees of Freedom Using the expression for the state vector that minimizes the cost function it is relatively.
CS-ROSETTA Yang Shen et al. Presented by Jonathan Jou.
The Nuts and Bolts of First-Principles Simulation Durham, 6th-13th December : Testing Testing. Basic procedure to “validate” calculations CASTEP.
Symmetry in crystals. Infinitely repeating lattices.
Computational Physics (Lecture 11) PHY4061. Variation quantum Monte Carlo the approximate solution of the Hamiltonian Time Independent many-body Schrodinger’s.
A New Potential Energy Surface for N 2 O-He, and PIMC Simulations Probing Infrared Spectra and Superfluidity How precise need the PES and simulations be?
Chapter 2 Molecular Mechanics
Maria Okuniewski Nuclear Engineering Dept.
Virtual Screening.
Algorithms and Software for Large-Scale Simulation of Reactive Systems
Molecular simulation methods
Algorithms and Software for Large-Scale Simulation of Reactive Systems
Conformational Search
Presentation transcript:

4. Modeling 3D-periodic systems Cut-off radii, charges groups Ewald summation Growth units, bonds, attachment energy Predicting crystal structures

Modeling 3D-periodic systems Modeling just the asymmetric unit should be sufficient, but…. the number of VdW/Coulomb interactions becomes infinitely large! solutions: * cut-off + Contributions from VdW/Coulomb get smaller at larger distance, and will finally converge. - Systematic error in E VdW - Does E coul really converge? - Discontinuity at R c periodicity -- handling long-range interactions

Modeling 3D-periodic systems periodicity -- handling long-range interactions * cut-off * ‘smooth’ cut-off + No discontinuity at R c - Artifacts at R c, due to large forces (F=  E/  R) E= q i x q j 4  0  r ij E approx = E x C(r ij ) C(r ij ) r ij 1 0

Modeling 3D-periodic systems periodicity -- handling long-range interactions * cut-off * ‘smooth’ cut-off * cut-off with charge groups Electrostatic energy can strongly depend on the chosen cut-off or atomic position. Z tot ….

Modeling 3D-periodic systems periodicity -- handling long-range interactions * cut-off * ‘smooth’ cut-off * cut-off with charge groups + Avoids discontinuity at R c - Need to define charge groups Electrostatic energy can strongly depend on the chosen cut-off or atomic position. Solution: consider neutral groups instead of individual atoms/ions.

Modeling 3D-periodic systems periodicity -- handling long-range interactions * cut-off * ‘smooth’ cut-off * cut-off with charge groups * Ewald summation Mathematical trick which makes use of the periodicity of the system: * part of the system treated ‘normally’ (in direct space) * part of the system treated via it’s Fourier transform (in reciprocal space) Combines good accuracy with efficiency. Can be implemented in 3 and 2 (and 1) dimensions, corresponding to an infinite crystal or an infinite slice

Growth units, bonds and attachment energy Growth units: basic building blocks in crystal growth. Organic crystals  usually molecules as growth units. Example: benzene

Growth units ; slices Morphology from E attachment : growth rate ~ interaction energy between slice and bulk crystal

Growth units, bonds and attachment energy surface crystal bulk solution/vapour/melt Crystal growth occurs via the incorporation of growth units. This process is directed by the interactions between growth units, bonds.

Growth units ; bonds Bond strength: the sum of all interactions between growth units 12 x 12 x 2=288 interactions, summed into one bond; molecule treated as rigid body

Predicting crystal structures * what is the 3D structure of a given crystalline material? * which other crystal packings might be possible? * what will be the structure if we change some functional group(s)? Crystal structure prediction: - generate many hypothetical structures - determine which ones are reasonable (ranking) - remove similar/duplicate structures from your results

Predicting crystal structures Step 1: generating trial crystal packings - use space-group statistics on organic solids for efficiency * non-chiral systems * any value for Z’ * top-17 covers 90%

Predicting crystal structures Generating trial crystal packings in a MC-like way O b a c 0. Select the proper molecular conformation(s) 1. Choose cell angles (max. 3) and orientation of cell contents. 2. Set position of the molecule(s) in the asym. unit. 3. Apply symmetry, and ‘shrink to fit’ starting from long cell axes. 4. Calculate E MM 5. Accept new packing if: e (-  E/kt) > r (  E=E new - E old ; r= random number, 0  r  1) 6. Vary cell/orientational angles, and GOTO 2 … and at the same time, vary T. Asymmetric unit generated from space-group symmetry

Predicting crystal structures Generating trial crystal packings: MC and T Accept new structure if: e (-  E/kt) > r  E  e (-  E/kt)   E: E new - E old 0.69kt Always accepted Maybe accepted

Predicting crystal structures Generating trial crystal packings: varying T during MC “Simulated Annealing” (SA) Temp  Time  1 1: increase T until almost every ‘move’ gets accepted, so every configuration can be reached. 2: slowly cool down, to drive the system to low-energy regions. 2

Predicting crystal structures Crystal structure prediction: - generate many hypothetical structures - determine which ones are reasonable (ranking) Relative MM energy as ranking criterion  optimize all hypothetical structures, using e.g. a MM energy function. Degrees of freedom: * cell parameters (up to 6) * all atomic coordinates in the asymmetric unit

Predicting crystal structures Thermodynamically: structure(s) with lowest G can be found  relative MM energy as approximation.

Crystal structure prediction results

Crystal structure prediction clustering Reduce computation time via a representative subset of all structures. Remove identical structures. SamplingClusteringRankingClustering 5000 structures 500 structures 50 structures Clustering works by comparing descriptors for different items (i.c. structures) in the set, and quantifying their difference. Descriptors for crystals: space group; cell parameters; density; atomic coordinates; orientation of dipoles in the cell; …..

Crystal structure prediction descriptors: Radial Distribution Functions

C O H  C--C C--H C--O O--O O--H H--H

Crystal structure prediction descriptors: Radial Distribution Functions RDF based on: atoms element force field type weight factors via: partial charge (c.f. Egon Willighagen) number of electrons (~powder diffraction pattern) ….

Crystal structure prediction - accuracy Accuracy from e.g. calculated  E’s between observed polymorphs. Polymorph pair  E ACPRET BAFLID BRESTO CIYRIL ESTRON ESTRON GASFAH LABHAX MHNPRY PROGST ZZZNUK =2.0 kcal/mol

Our ‘toolkit’ for polymorph prediction Database searching [guess at initial model; spgr statistics] Conformational search [good starting structures] Monte Carlo; simulated annealing [sampling] clustering [speed up] energy minimization [ranking] combination with experiments XRPD ssNMR IR phase diagrams