LRN2006/1 © Chris Hicks, Tom McGovern & Colin Herron University of Newcastle upon Tyne An evaluation of the implementation of Lean Manufacturing by the.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
MMM341/1 © Dr. C.Hicks, MMM Engineering University of Newcastle upon Tyne Supply Chain Management.
Advertisements

Services SP Pro Your Success is our Goal! Lean Manufacturing.
HR SCORECARD Presented By ADEEL TARIQ MOBASHIR ALI.
OCD Internal and Education and Training Purposes Only A New Approach for You to Create Broader, Long-term Customer Engagements CL12092.
Superior Industries International 4 th Quarter 2008 Results Earnings Conference Call February 26, 2009.
Reasons for Evaluating Training Companies are investing millions of dollars in training programs to help gain a competitive advantage. To justify the costs.
The North East Economy: A great place to invest. Overview of North East LEP Area.
Benefits and Challenges of University - Industry Interactions: A Critical Perspective Jeremy Howells, Ronnie Ramlogan and Shu-Li Cheng Manchester Institute.
ICMR/1 © Colin Herron & Chris Hicks University of Newcastle upon Tyne Improving the competitiveness of the North East companies by implementing lean manufacturing.
Process Industries Benchmarking Professor Munir Ahmad School of Science and Engineering Teesside University NEPIC Presentation.
Total Productive Maintenance (TPM)
© Colin Herron & Chris Hicks University of Newcastle upon Tyne The application of lean manufacturing as a repositioning strategy. Colin Herron, One NorthEast.
Scottish Urban Regeneration Forum – Perth, 7 th November 2006 Tom Warburton Head of Regeneration, One NorthEast.
Click to edit Master title style 1 European Regions For Innovative Productivity (ERIP) Final Conference – Introduction 23 rd and 24 th November 2011.
Roger Urwin, Chief Executive Officer National Grid Group plc EEI Conference 18 February 2002.
ENBIS/1 © Chris Hicks University of Newcastle upon Tyne Stochastic simulation studies of dispatching rules for production scheduling in the capital goods.
Chamber of Commerce is a form of business network, a kind of organization to further and facilitate the business interests Local businesses are the members.
Cost Management. learning objectives cost/volume/profit (CVP) relationships and break-even analysis break-even chart – low fixed costs, high variable.
Chapter 6 Measuring Indicators
MBA/MIS Class #3 September 2, 2008 IT Business Value Financial Justification 1.
Tokyo Conference May 2007 UNITED NATIONS INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT ORGANIZATION FDI: Source of Sustainable Growth Africa Foreign Investors.
Ratio Analysis.
Business Consulting Services © Copyright IBM Corporation 2003 Global Human Capital Survey 2003 – Summary.
Area of Study 1: Large-Scale Organisations in Context
NE Process Industry Productivity Benchmark th March 2010.
Improving the Performance of Acquired and Merged Operating Units BackgroundBackground The client is a unit of a parent company recognized worldwide as.
Foundations Consulting “Supporting Your Growth” The Balanced Scorecard & KPI’s “You can’t improve what you don’t measure” (Kaplan & Norton) CustomersFinancials.
PRESENTATION TO INDIANA UNIVERSITY SEPTEMBER 18, 2001 Indiana University Kelly School of Business.
Education, Training and Establishment Survival William Collier, Francis Green & Young-Bae Kim.
Interactive Training Skills: Evaluation Study Executive Summary Presentation Service Merchandise Company Date: Wednesday, April 6, 2011 CONFIDENTIAL Consultants:
Generic Skills Survey 2003 DRIVERS OF SKILLS NEEDS.
Results of pilot benchmark study Anfried Sauerborn/René Colin EAQG Metrics WGtApril 2008.
The Balanced Score Card
Audit of Innovation in the BMW Region An Evaluation of a Regional Knowledge Economy Gerry Finn, Director.
Manufacturing Advisory Service South-West Jon Hurrell.
© 2009 Pearson Prentice Hall. All rights reserved. Quality Cost.
Business Location A2 Business Studies. Aims and Objectives Aim: Understand the quantitative and qualitative location factors Objectives: Explain quantitative.
5S and Visual We consider 5S and Visual Controls to be the foundation of Lean Manufacturing systems. 5S and Visual Controls are workplace organizational.
1 © The Delos Partnership 2004 Performance Measures Linking to the corporate goals.
Internal Auditing Effectiveness
Gulay Litchfield For CQI-TECH PLC
D2N2 LEP Skills for a Productive Workforce Transport and Logistics University of Derby Enterprise Centre 20 July 2015.
Chapter 3: Evaluation of performance Area of Study 1: Large-Scale Organisations in Context.
Performance Measurement. 2 Performance measures recently introduced or being considered for introduction Balanced Scorecard Approach Economic Value Added.
Main Function of SCM (Part I)
Activity Based Costing Nancy R. Mangold Professor, Department of Accounting California State University, East Bay.
A PROJECT REPORT On Total Quality Management in Manufacturing Organization In partial fulfillment o f the requirement for the award of the degree IN [
Supply Chain Progress towards Aeronautical Community Excellence An efficient Supply Chain to meet new global challenges An efficient.
A2 External Influences Government policies affecting business.
Top lean six sigma consulting strategies for businesses Lean Six Sigma Manufacturing Consulting By: Group50.com.
Choosing Lean Manufacturing Presented to you by : Vrunda Consultancy Service, Ahmedabad.
Lean for Micros Pilot Review Robert Hernan January 2016.
Calculation Summary Card Calculating Shopper Numbers Calculating an amount as a % = The value of the amount you want to know as a % The total number X.
Case Study Pizza GOGO Limited Rainham Essex U.K. BY-CHANDRESH TRIPATHI.
Senior Management Team Away Day Session 1: HMS Business Update Presentation by Paul Worthington Managing Director Friday 19th and Saturday 20th October.
Supply Chain Optimisation of HydraPowar Dynamics Limited Prasanta Kumar Dey and William Ho Operations and Information Management Group.
Regional Economic Strategy (RES) Leading the Way and Action Plan Gillian Roll, One NorthEast NERIP Measuring the Economy Seminar 20 th November 2006.
The nature of operations
Human Resources - Performance
Dd/mm/yyyyy Ref/Title.
AGM
4.3 Increasing efficiency and productivity
Consulting environment Keystone overview Small firm versus big firm
Graduation Project (II): Operations Improvement at Mhanna Factory
EVALUATION OF BUSINESS TRANSFORMATION
ACC 560 HELP Education for Service-- acc560help.com.
Top Strategies for Asset Performance Management (APM)
Integrating and Controlling the Retail Strategy
Lean Production Methods
The PEAR Friday 2 November 2012.
Presentation transcript:

LRN2006/1 © Chris Hicks, Tom McGovern & Colin Herron University of Newcastle upon Tyne An evaluation of the implementation of Lean Manufacturing by the North East Productivity Alliance Chris Hicks and Tom McGovern, University of Newcastle upon Tyne Business School Colin Herron, One NorthEast

LRN2006/2 © Chris Hicks, Tom McGovern & Colin Herron University of Newcastle upon Tyne Productivity (GVA per job) vs. Participation (jobs per population of working age) Regional policy seeks to increase productivity and participation

LRN2006/3 © Chris Hicks, Tom McGovern & Colin Herron University of Newcastle upon Tyne Lower than average manufacturing sector performance NE sectoral performance, sector growth and regional significance UK manufacturing has relatively low GVA growth NE has high reliance on manufacturing Increasing manufacturing productivity is a regional priority

LRN2006/4 © Chris Hicks, Tom McGovern & Colin Herron University of Newcastle upon Tyne North East Productivity Alliance (NEPA) The aim is to increase productivity by transferring Lean Manufacturing from the automotive industry to other sectors. Methodology based upon Nissan/Industry Forum supplier development initiatives. This paper reports on 30 interventions at 15 companies.

LRN2006/5 © Chris Hicks, Tom McGovern & Colin Herron University of Newcastle upon Tyne Industry Forum model Hands-on training using ‘Common Toolkit’ comprising –The Building Blocks 5C/5S, Standardised Work and Visual Management, and 7 Wastes –Supporting tools, data analysis, problem solving, set up improvement and line balance Trainees receive NVQ in Business Improvement Techniques on successful completion of training.

LRN2006/6 © Chris Hicks, Tom McGovern & Colin Herron University of Newcastle upon Tyne Diagnostic Tools NEPA sponsored the development of a three stage diagnostic tool to select participating companies: –Productivity Needs Analysis, general information (sector, size, turnover), DTI 7 measures (floor space utilisation, value added per operator, stock turn ratio, OEE, not right first time, schedule achievement and operator productivity) and other measures. –Manufacturing Needs Analysis, records information on manufacturing processes and framework for selecting Lean tools. –Training Needs Analysis Tool applied by independent consultants before and during Lean interventions.

LRN2006/7 © Chris Hicks, Tom McGovern & Colin Herron University of Newcastle upon Tyne PNA Metrics Turnover gives a measure of overall activity Stock turn ratio indicates how effectively inventory is utilised GVA per direct employee, absenteeism and staff turnover relate to the effective use of labour The breakdown of labour into indirect, direct and temporary indicates the significance of manufacturing. Breakdown of costs helps identify labour intensive companies that are particularly vulnerable to competition from low cost economies.

LRN2006/8 © Chris Hicks, Tom McGovern & Colin Herron University of Newcastle upon Tyne PNA Metrics OEE and floor space utilisation relate to the effective use of plant and buildings Delivery schedule achievement and not right first time are measures of customer satisfaction.

LRN2006/9 © Chris Hicks, Tom McGovern & Colin Herron University of Newcastle upon Tyne MetricIncreasedUnchangedDecreasedNo data Turnover £M10032 Profit/loss £M00015 Profit margin %00015 Order success rate %12012 Stock turn ratio7143 Productivity / direct employee 8016 GVA / direct employee9024 Absenteeism %5352 Staff turnover %7332 Direct employees5082

LRN2006/10 © Chris Hicks, Tom McGovern & Colin Herron University of Newcastle upon Tyne MetricIncreasedNo changeDecreasedNo data Indirect employees8061 Temporary labour5352 Total employees30111 Direct labour %30111 Temporary labour %5352 Turnover / employee £ Material content %7512 Labour content %2364

LRN2006/11 © Chris Hicks, Tom McGovern & Colin Herron University of Newcastle upon Tyne MetricIncreasedNo changeDecreasedNo data Overhead content%2445 Turnover / floor space £/M Delivery schedule achievement % 4533 Not right first time %3534

LRN2006/12 © Chris Hicks, Tom McGovern & Colin Herron University of Newcastle upon Tyne Summary of results 10 of the companies had increased turnover (2.5-35%) Stock turn ratio improved in 7 cases – 4 showed dramatic improvements of 18, 23, 92 and 100% 8 companies improved productivity (105% in the best case) Number of employees reduced in 11 companies and increased in 3 companies Turnover per employee increased in 11 companies, 7 companies with less employees increased turnover.

LRN2006/13 © Chris Hicks, Tom McGovern & Colin Herron University of Newcastle upon Tyne Conclusions (1) There were some dramatic improvements in performance, but some companies had not been particularly successful. Some of the companies with implementation difficulties have started to address barriers, but the benefits have yet to be realised. Many of the measures lag actual improvements. There is substantial anecdotal evidence that the impact has been more positive than the quantitative data suggests. A further study of 50 companies with improved data collection methods will provide more insight.

LRN2006/14 © Chris Hicks, Tom McGovern & Colin Herron University of Newcastle upon Tyne Conclusions (2) Manufacturing productivity particularly important in the North East. Total savings to date are £4.36 million with an average saving per intervention of £149,000. With the Industry Forum evaluation method, which ignores the highest an lowest cases the average saving was £106,000 Total returns were eight times the cost. NEPA supported lean manufacturing are an effective way of addressing regional productivity problems.