New Estimates of the Index of Economic Well- Being for Canada Lars Osberg - Dalhousie University Andrew Sharpe - Center for the Study of Living Standards.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 Alternative measures of well-being Joint work by ECO/ELSA/STD.
Advertisements

Changes in measurement of savings: Perspectives from a consumer (of NA data) Alain de Serres* OECD Florian Pelgrin * Bank of Canada * Personal views, not.
The Well-being of Nations Chapter 1 Emerging Social and Economic Concerns.
Isn’t it Well Being That We Want to Improve? - The Metric of Evaluation Lars Osberg - Department of Economics, Dalhousie University - Institute for Social.
SESSION 11: MACROECONOMIC INDICATORS: GDP, CPI, AND THE UNEMPLOYMENT RATE Talking Points Macroeconomic Indicators: GDP, CPI, and the Unemployment Rate.
Assessing “Success” in Anti-Poverty Policy Lars Osberg Dalhousie University October 1, 2004.
The Evolution of Poverty Measurement - with special reference to Canada Lars Osberg Economics Department, Dalhousie University Workshop on Low Income,
Accounting for Wealth in the Measurement of Household Income Edward N. Wolff New York University, NBER, and Levy Economics Institute Ajit Zacharias The.
International trends in poverty: how rates mislead but intensity and labour supply matter Lars Osberg - Department of Economics, Dalhousie University.
Global Poverty Defining, Measuring and Analyzing Trends.
Community Happiness Index Gwendolyn Hallsmith, Director Department of Planning and Community Development City of Montpelier.
G. Madonia Department of International Business and Economics, University of Greenwich, Old Royal Naval College, Park Row, Greenwich, London SE10 9LS.
Measuring the State of the Economy
Has Economic Well-being improved in Western Nations? Lars Osberg Department of Economics, Dalhousie University Halifax, Nova Scotia Presentation at Wuhan.
Labor Market Trends in North America – Has Economic Well-being improved ? Lars Osberg Department of Economics, Dalhousie University Halifax, Nova Scotia.
The “Housing First” Approach to Ending Homelessness Housing First 101 November 16, 2004.
Fiscal Policy Distortionary Taxes. The Data Information on Government Budgets is typically available from Treasury/Finance Ministry. –IMF Government Finance.
Reinert/Windows on the World Economy, 2005 Development Concepts CHAPTER 19.
A Review of Conceptual Foundations write by Peter Kaufamann, Sigrid Stangl, Katarzyna Zawalińska, Jerzy Michalek Presented by Mariana Gálová.
Measuring GDP and Economic Growth
What is Economic Growth? How do we know when we are better off?
Chapter 5: Family Income, Wealth, INCOME DISTRIBUTION & POVERTY BY : DR. ZURONI MD. JUSOH Department of Resource Management & Consumer Studies.
Measuring the Aggregate Economy
Constructing the Welfare Aggregate Part 2: Adjusting for Differences Across Individuals Bosnia and Herzegovina Poverty Analysis Workshop September 17-21,
Learning Objectives Know what GDP measures – and what it doesn’t Know the difference between real and nominal GDP Know why aggregate.
Social protection policy and programmes: a review of experiences, lessons and best practices November 2013, FAO, Rome Promoting Social and Economic.
An Index of Labour Market Well-being for Canada and the United States Lars Osberg Economics Department, Dalhousie University Andrew Sharpe & Jeremy Smith.
Chapter 24 – Measuring Domestic Output and National Income
Poverty Ms. C. Rughoobur Africa Statistics Day 18 November 2013.
Measuring a Nation’s Income
1 Gross Domestic Product Economics for Today by Irvin Tucker, 6 th edition ©2009 South-Western College Publishing.
DFID: STATISTICS TRAINING DAY LONDON, NOVEMBER 11, 2013 JONATHAN HAUGHTON Measuring.
ECON 3508 Human Development: Concepts and Measurement A. R. M. Ritter September 2007.
The Role of Assets and their Distribution in the Estimation of Economic Well-Being Presentation at the 4 th OECD World Forum on Measuring Well-being for.
Poverty measurement: experience of the Republic of Moldova UNECE, Measuring poverty, 4 May 2015.
Income Assistance Programs and the Labour Market - Relevant Canadian Experiences & Worker Well Being Lars Osberg Economics Department, Dalhousie University.
Backgrounds of Research (1) : Public attention to Income Gap
7 McGraw-Hill/IrwinCopyright © 2012 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. Measuring Domestic Output and National Income.
A Quarter Century of Economic Inequality in Canada: Lars Osberg Economics Department Dalhousie University Dec. 14, 2007.
MGMT 510 – Macroeconomics for Managers Presented By: Prof. Dr. Serhan Çiftçioğlu.
Copyright © 2008 Pearson Addison-Wesley. All rights reserved. Chapter 26 Long-Run Economic Growth.
Principles of Macroeconomics Lecture 1 INTRODUCTION TO MACROECONOMICS & MEASURING ECONOMIC ACTIVITY.
Issues with Representing the Welfare of Agents U(x) is fundamentally Unobservable, proxies are needed, here we deal with some of the issues.
Has Economic Well-being improved in Canada and the United States? Lars Osberg Department of Economics, Dalhousie University Halifax, Nova Scotia Andrew.
Time, Money and Inequality in International Perspective Lars Osberg -Dalhousie University -I.S.E.R. U of Essex.
“Where’s the Beef?” Living Standards and Inflation Victories in Canada Lars Osberg Economics Department Dalhousie University Twenty Years of.
The Most Important Graph in the World: US Life Cycle Deficits, Gretchen Donehower UC Berkeley Department of Demography September 27, 2006.
Demand for Local Public Services: The Median Voter and Other Approaches.
SESSION 8: MACROECONOMIC INDICATORS: GDP, CPI, AND THE UNEMPLOYMENT RATE Talking Points Macroeconomic Indicators: GDP, CPI, and the Unemployment Rate 1.
Constructing the Welfare Aggregate Part 2: Adjusting for Differences Across Individuals Salman Zaidi Washington DC, January 19th,
MACRO E conomics Unit 3: Measuring Growth using GDP “The stock market and economy are two different things..” -- Milton Friedman “The annual labour of.
Measuring Domestic Output, National Income, and the Price Level CH 7 *
Chapter 15: Distribution May 20, Pareto optimality Economics defines efficiency as the Pareto optimal allocation of resources by the market  Assumption?
Measuring Economic Growth-GDP
Introduction to the UK Economy. What are the key objectives of macroeconomic policy? Price Stability (CPI Inflation of 2%) Growth of Real GDP (National.
MEASURING NATIONAL OUTPUT AND NATIONAL INCOME. GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT (GDP) versus GROSS NATIONAL PRODUCT (GNP) 1.GDP It is the market value for all final.
Issues in the Use of Equivalence Scales - comments Lars Osberg Economics Department, Dalhousie University Workshop on Low Income, Poverty and Deprivation.
Chapter 25: The Difference Between Short-Run and Long-Run Macroeconomics Copyright © 2014 Pearson Canada Inc.
Living standard indicators. Living standard material, cultural, social and moral utitity values which have inhabitants in the time and space utility values.
A cost-benefit analysis for the economic growth in China two concepts: growth and development two concepts: growth and development harmonious society 和.
How do we know when we are better off?.  Satisfy our wants and needs  We do this through purchasing goods and services  Goods and services gives us.
How do we know when we are better off?.  Satisfy our wants and needs  We do this through purchasing goods and services  Goods and services gives us.
National-Income Accounting
4 GDP & National income accounting
Measuring Economic Growth-GDP
Lifecycle Deficit (Consumption & Labor Income)
GDP and beyond Robin Lynch
Measuring National Output and National Income
GDP and beyond Robin Lynch
Presentation transcript:

New Estimates of the Index of Economic Well- Being for Canada Lars Osberg - Dalhousie University Andrew Sharpe - Center for the Study of Living Standards Canadian Economics Association May 27, 2006

"Are you better off today than you were four years ago?" 1980 Ronald Reagan actual increase in per capita disposable income in USA = 8.8% Audiences answered “NO!” – WHY ? Widespread dissatisfaction with GDP as a measure of Economic Well-Being BUT: Alternative measures also aggregate to a single index, burying value judgments

Is the nation “better off” ? As voters or bureaucrats, individuals do make decisions re: collectivity Vote index I = α 1 (own utility) + α 2 (society’s well-being) Economic Well-Being is multi-dimensional Index should respect heterogeneity Values / Preferences of Analysts Life Circumstances of Population Objective of Index construction: to assist democratic discourse & summative subjective judgments

Outline of Paper Index of Economic Well Being Consumption flows Sustainability / Accumulation of Productive Resources Distribution: inequality & poverty Economic Security Present new estimates of trends in the index for Canada and provinces Compare to GDP per capita trends Discuss methodological changes Linear Scaling Economic Security from Risk of Unemployment

Dimensions of Economic Well Being ConceptPresent Representative Agent / “Typical Citizen” Average Flow of Current Income Per Capita GDP or “Adjusted” Average Income Flow Issues: Market transactions only, heterogeneity, stocks

Dimensions of Economic Well Being ConceptPresent Representative Agent / “Typical Citizen” Average Flow of Current Income Diversity of Population Experiences Distribution of Current Income - Poverty and Inequality Social Welfare Function literature SWF = f ( µ, σ )

Dimensions of Economic Well Being ConceptPresentFuture Representative Agent / “Typical Citizen” Average Flow of Effective Current Consumption Aggregate Accumulation of Productive Stocks (broadly defined) Issues:Average Income does not reveal savings rate - assets include environment, Human Capital, R&D, etc. Aggregate Savings – not automatically optimal, sustainable –preferences for social saving differ among individuals

Dimensions of Economic Well Being ConceptPresentFuture Representative Agent Average Flow of Effective Current Consumption Aggregate Accumulation of Productive Stocks Diversity of Population Experiences Distribution of Current Income: - Poverty and Inequality Insecurity of Future Income

Values matter – and differ ECONOMIC WELL-BEING= α 1 [ CONSUMPTION ] + α 2 [ STOCKS OF WEALTH ] + α 3 [ EQUALITY ] + α 4 [ ECONOMIC SECURITY ] DIFFERENT VALUES WILL IMPLY DIFFERENT WEIGHTS Useful to know whether (& how much) aggregate trend depends on weighting α = 0 is a (strong) value choice

Why an Additively Separable Social Welfare Function ? Key theoretical assumptions: Constant relative risk/inequality aversion Imperfect Insurance & Capital Markets Additively Separable Lifetime Utility Risk Averse Representative Agent choosing from behind Veil of Ignorance ? Communication is key to actual usage Sensitivity to alternative weightings easy

Methodology Variables now scaled linearly Consistent with other indices (e.g. HDI) Solves “Directionality Problem” (Max – value)/(Max – Min) OR (Value – Min)/(Max-Min) Problems: Reporting trends as % change or % points Scaling removes base – sensitive to comparison group “Base Case” assigns equal weight to all dimensions Excel data sheet available for experimentation

Average Consumption Flows $ Marketed real consumption per capita from SNA Adjustments value of increased longevity of life / consumption reduced economies of scale in household consumption Unpaid work generalist replacement wage Government cost “Regrettable Necessities” Commuting, costs of crime & divorce, household pollution abatement spending

Accumulation, Sustainability and Intergenerational Bequest $ Physical capital stock Plant & Equipment + Residential Research and Development – as capital stock Value of natural resource stocks price + quantity change Stocks of human capital cost education) Net change in foreign indebtedness Net Change in state of environment & national heritage (cost of CO 2 emissions ) NOTE: Real productive assets only

Distribution Same average income if all get $500 or if ½ get $999 & ½ get $1 – but well-being differs How to summarize “Distribution”? Simplicity desirable if index to be used Poverty & Inequality differ, but both matter Inequality - Gini coefficient After-tax & transfer household income Equivalence scale = Poverty - Sen-Shorrocks-Thon measure Rate (Poverty Line = ½ Median) Average poverty gap ratio Intensity = rate x gap

Economic Security. [25] “Everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health and well being of himself and of his family, including food, clothing, housing and medical care and necessary social services, and the right to security in the event of unemployment, sickness, disability, widowhood, old age or other lack of livelihood in circumstances beyond his control.” Universal Declaration of Human Rights - United Nations: 1948 “Named Risks” – conditional probability of financial loss approach

“Economic Security” Risk of loss due to unemployment Risk of Unemployment + E(financial loss|unemployment) Financial Risk of Illness Unreimbursed private medical expenses as share of disposable income Risk of single parent poverty Divorce rate x poverty rate x poverty gap of single parents Risk of poverty in old age chance x depth of elderly (>65) poverty Security risks weighted by relevant population size

Security from Unemployment Original method – financial loss implied by compound probability =P(U)*P(B|U)*(E(B/W) Assumes components matter equally Decline UI/EI coverage has big impact on trends New literature on self-reported happiness Di Tella, MacCulloch, Oswald (2003) “The Macro Economics of Happiness” RESTAT Ordered Probit life satisfaction – n= 271,224 Recover Implicit weights on Unemployment Rate and Unemployment Benefits This paper: Unemployment rate = 4x UIBen =.8*(scaled Unemp) +.2*(scaled P(B|U)*(E(B/W))

Conclusion growth rate 1981 – 2005 GDP per capita = 1.68 % Index of Economic Well-being = 1.30 % Average Consumption flows & Wealth Stocks grew Equality & Security declined Equality & Security Focus of Welfare State Crucial to personal well-being