Think Big, Really Big The Engineering view of the world is never very interesting, scalable or sustainable  manipulates nature Physicists view the world as a system, assess its overall capacity and limitations  partners with nature

An Issued Challenge  Goal: Provide resources for a global population that will quadruple in 100 years  Done: 1900 – 2000  Consequences: Depends on your point of view about progress versus quality of life versus human condition

Some Consequences Rapid mining/depletion of accessible high energy content medium (like, oil, dude) Rapid mining/depletion of accessible high energy content medium (like, oil, dude) Serious worldwide inequities in resource distribution and wealth Serious worldwide inequities in resource distribution and wealth Two world wars and some other minor skirmishes, invasions, annexations,etc Two world wars and some other minor skirmishes, invasions, annexations,etc Robbing our great grandchildren of a possible future Robbing our great grandchildren of a possible future

Who Can We Blame Aristotle (Father of all white guys …) Aristotle (Father of all white guys …) Nixon (why not) Nixon (why not) The Enemy (we seem to require one) The Enemy (we seem to require one) Your Parents Your Parents Anyone you like (absolution) Anyone you like (absolution) The Business as Usual Attitude The Business as Usual Attitude Our Genes Our Genes

Business As Usual Scenario Population stabilizes to billion by the year 2100 (possible to do) Population stabilizes to billion by the year 2100 (possible to do) Total world energy use from 2000 to 2100 is 4000 Terra Watt Years (Current US use is about 1.5 TW years) Total world energy use from 2000 to 2100 is 4000 Terra Watt Years (Current US use is about 1.5 TW years) Holy crap, Batman is the sky falling? Holy crap, Batman is the sky falling?

Ultimately Recoverable Resource Conventional Oil/Gas Unconventional Oil Coal Methane Clathrates Oil Shale Uranium Ore Geothermal Steam - conventional 1000 TWy (1/4 need) ,000 30,000 2,000 4,000

Other Possibilities Breeder Reactors Hot Dry Rock Sunlight Wind Energy Global Biomass Fusion 2,000,000 TWy 1,000,000 9,000, ,000 10,000 Essentially unlimited

There is no Real Energy Barrier or Limit And other extragalactic Civilizations have surely solved this problem. On Earth, we have a bunch of other likely problems

We may be running out of … Cheap Oil Livable Environment/Fresh Water Tolerance for inequity (its about time …) Money for better options Time for a transition out of the fossil fuel economy into something else Leadership to do what is required

Hydrogen Production  Your research indicated we need 4 trillion KWHs per year for Hydrogen production  This equals 10 billion KWHs per day or in round numbers 1 billion KWHs per hour.  Figure of Merit is then 1 million MW of power needed for Hydrogen production  Is this a lot?

One Million Megawatts 1000 Nuclear Reactors 1000 Gas Fired Plants Well if your going to build that crap, just connect it to the grid, you idiot Okay, then what about remote energy generation where grid connection is difficult

1 TW Production Schemes  Harvest some Megaplumes Megaplumes  Build 100, MW Wind Turbines off the Aleutian Island Chain (note total wind resource here is about 50 TW) Aleutian Island ChainAleutian Island Chain  Place one 100 MW turbine every 200 meters in the Gulf Stream which is equivalent to a 200 km/hr wind

More Production Schemes  Distributed OTEC islands – circular platforms of radius 1 km can produce 1000 MW. (Russia wants to build floating nuclear power plants; Boeing wants floating equatorial launch platforms)  Note: 1 TW of PV power requires PV arrays (200 miles x 200 miles) in North Africa Desert

Bottom lines Large Scale hydrogen production schemes are possible using way out of the box large scale renewable energy systems where grid connection is unlikely Large Scale hydrogen production schemes are possible using way out of the box large scale renewable energy systems where grid connection is unlikely Solar Power is not a direct player in this scheme; CSP unlikely to work on this scale Solar Power is not a direct player in this scheme; CSP unlikely to work on this scale Many technical difficulties lie ahead which we will discuss, but similar technical barriers were overcome in the last century! Many technical difficulties lie ahead which we will discuss, but similar technical barriers were overcome in the last century! Reminder, we have walked on the Moon Reminder, we have walked on the Moon

Impulsive Discussion Now Impulsive Discussion Now Are humans intrinsically competitive or cooperative? Are humans intrinsically competitive or cooperative? Which mode facilitates sustainability? Which mode facilitates sustainability?