In Macromolecular Crystallography Use of anomalous signal in phasing

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Intensities Learning Outcomes By the end of this section you should: understand the factors that contribute to diffraction know and be able to use the.
Advertisements

Phasing Goal is to calculate phases using isomorphous and anomalous differences from PCMBS and GdCl3 derivatives --MIRAS. How many phasing triangles will.
Protein x-ray crystallography
CCP4 workshop Argonne, June 2011 Strategy of diffraction data collection (at synchrotrons) Zbigniew Dauter MCL-NCI & ANL-BIO.
Introduction to protein x-ray crystallography. Electromagnetic waves E- electromagnetic field strength A- amplitude  - angular velocity - frequency.
Methods: X-ray Crystallography
Overview of the Phase Problem
Determination of Protein Structure. Methods for Determining Structures X-ray crystallography – uses an X-ray diffraction pattern and electron density.
X-Ray Crystallography
Bob Sweet Bill Furey Considerations in Collection of Anomalous Data.
Experimental Phasing stuff. Centric reflections |F P | |F PH | FHFH Isomorphous replacement F P + F H = F PH FPFP F PH FHFH.
A Brief Description of the Crystallographic Experiment
Twinning in protein crystals NCI, Macromolecular Crystallography Laboratory, Synchrotron Radiation Research ANL Title Zbigniew Dauter.
Narrow transitions induced by broad band pulses  |g> |f> Loss of spectral resolution.
X-ray Crystallography Kalyan Das. Electromagnetic Spectrum to 10 nm 400 to 700 nm to nm 10 to 400 nm 700 to 10 4 nm X-ray radiation.
Experimental Phasing Andrew Howard ACA Summer School 22 July 2005.
Anomalous Scattering: Theory and Practice Andrew Howard ACA Summer School 29 July 2005 Andrew Howard ACA Summer School 29 July 2005.
19 Feb 2008 Biology 555: Crystallographic Phasing II p. 1 of 38 ProteinDataCrystalStructurePhases Overview of the Phase Problem John Rose ACA Summer School.
Automated protein structure solution for weak SAD data Pavol Skubak and Navraj Pannu Automated protein structure solution for weak SAD data Pavol Skubak.
The goal of Data Reduction From a series of diffraction images (films), obtain a file containing the intensity ( I ) and standard deviation (  ( I ))
Direct Methods By Fan Hai-fu, Institute of Physics, Beijing Direct Methods By Fan Hai-fu, Institute of Physics, Beijing
Overview of the Phase Problem
Phasing based on anomalous diffraction Zbigniew Dauter.
Radiation-damage- induced phasing with anomalous scattering Peter Zwart Physical biosciences division Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratories Not long.
Protein Structure Determination Part 2 -- X-ray Crystallography.
The phase problem in protein crystallography. The phase problem in protein crystallography.
Introduction to Macromolecular X-ray Crystallography Biochem 300 Borden Lacy Print and online resources: Introduction to Macromolecular X-ray Crystallography,
Progress report on Crank: Experimental phasing Biophysical Structural Chemistry Leiden University, The Netherlands.
Data Collection and Reflection Sphere - Data completeness - Rsym Structure factors and Phase Problems - Structure factor - Fourier transform - Electron.
Patterson Space and Heavy Atom Isomorphous Replacement
The ‘phase problem’ in X-ray crystallography What is ‘the problem’? How can we overcome ‘the problem’?
H.F. Fan & Y.X. Gu Beijing National Laboratory for Condensed Matter Physics Institute of Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences P.R. China H.F. Fan & Y.X.
SAD phasing by OASIS-2004 SAD phasing by OASIS-2004.
Chem Patterson Methods In 1935, Patterson showed that the unknown phase information in the equation for electron density:  (xyz) = 1/V ∑ h ∑ k.
Chem Structure Factors Until now, we have only typically considered reflections arising from planes in a hypothetical lattice containing one atom.
Lesson 22 SIR2011 Patterson Theory DIRDIF Patty Solve your structures.
Phasing Today’s goal is to calculate phases (  p ) for proteinase K using PCMBS and EuCl 3 (MIRAS method). What experimental data do we need? 1) from.
1. Diffraction intensity 2. Patterson map Lecture
THE PHASE PROBLEM Electron Density
Macromolecular Crystallography and Structural Genomics – Recent Trends Prof. D. Velmurugan Department of Crystallography and Biophysics University of Madras.
1 UV-Vis Absorption Spectroscopy Lecture Measurement of Transmittance and Absorbance: The power of the beam transmitted by the analyte solution.
Page 1 X-ray crystallography: "molecular photography" Object Irradiate Scattering lens Combination Image Need wavelengths smaller than or on the order.
Methods in Chemistry III – Part 1 Modul M.Che.1101 WS 2010/11 – 8 Modern Methods of Inorganic Chemistry Mi 10:15-12:00, Hörsaal II George Sheldrick
Pattersons The “third space” of crystallography. The “phase problem”
Atomic structure model
X-ray crystallography – an overview (based on Bernie Brown’s talk, Dept. of Chemistry, WFU) Protein is crystallized (sometimes low-gravity atmosphere is.
Anomalous Differences Bijvoet differences (hkl) vs (-h-k-l) Dispersive Differences 1 (hkl) vs 2 (hkl) From merged (hkl)’s.
Electron Density Structure factor amplitude defined as: F unit cell (S) = ∫ r  (r) · exp (2  i r · S) dr Using the inverse Fourier Transform  (r) =
Electromagnetism Around 1800 classical physics knew: - 1/r 2 Force law of attraction between positive & negative charges. - v ×B Force law for a moving.
Absolute Configuration Types of space groups Non-centrosymmetric Determining Absolute Configuration.
Before Beginning – Must copy over the p4p file – Enter../xl.p4p. – Enter../xl.hkl. – Do ls to see the files are there – Since the.p4p file has been created.
Interpreting difference Patterson Maps in Lab this week! Calculate an isomorphous difference Patterson Map (native-heavy atom) for each derivative data.
X-ray Crystallography Kalyan Das. Electromagnetic Spectrum to 10 nM 400 to 700 nM to nM 10 to 400 nM 700 to 10 4 nM X-ray was discovered.
Methods in Chemistry III – Part 1 Modul M.Che.1101 WS 2010/11 – 9 Modern Methods of Inorganic Chemistry Mi 10:15-12:00, Hörsaal II George Sheldrick
Phasing in Macromolecular Crystallography
H.F. Fan 1, Y.X. Gu 1, F. Jiang 1,2 & B.D. Sha 3 1 Institute of Physics, CAS, Beijing, China 2 Tsinghua University, Beijing, China 3 University of Alabama.
Fourier transform from r to k: Ã(k) =  A(r) e  i k r d 3 r Inverse FT from k to r: A(k) = (2  )  3  Ã(k) e +i k r d 3 k X-rays scatter off the charge.
Today: compute the experimental electron density map of proteinase K Fourier synthesis  (xyz)=  |F hkl | cos2  (hx+ky+lz -  hkl ) hkl.
Lecture 3 Patterson functions. Patterson functions The Patterson function is the auto-correlation function of the electron density ρ(x) of the structure.
Crystal Structure and Crystallography of Materials Chapter 13: Diffraction Lecture No. 1.
Amyloid Precursor Protein (APP)
OASIS-2004 A direct-method program for
Model Building and Refinement for CHEM 645
Phasing Today’s goal is to calculate phases (ap) for proteinase K using MIRAS method (PCMBS and GdCl3). What experimental data do we need? 1) from native.
Protein Structure Determination
Chapter 35-Diffraction Chapter 35 opener. Parallel coherent light from a laser, which acts as nearly a point source, illuminates these shears. Instead.
Nobel Laureates of X Ray Crystallography
Experimental phasing in Crank2 Pavol Skubak and Navraj Pannu Biophysical Structural Chemistry, Leiden University, The Netherlands
r(xyz)=S |Fhkl| cos2p(hx+ky+lz -ahkl)
By Fan Hai-fu, Institute of Physics, Beijing
Presentation transcript:

In Macromolecular Crystallography Use of anomalous signal in phasing Title ACA Summer School In Macromolecular Crystallography Chicago, July 2006 Use of anomalous signal in phasing Zbigniew Dauter

Normal (elastic) scattering Anomalous (resonant) scattering changes with q , not with l Anomalous (resonant) scattering not dependent on q , changes with l

Structure factor equation for normal scattering Fh = Sj fj exp(2pih.r) = |Fh|exp(ij) for anomalous scattering f = fo + f’ + if” f” is proportional to absorption and fluorescence f’ and f” related by Kramer-Kronig transformation f’(E) = 2/p ò ___________ dE’ E’.f”(E’) (E2 – E’2)

Black – ideal f” curve by CROSSEC (for isolated atom) fSe Black – ideal f” curve by CROSSEC (for isolated atom) Blue – experimental f” curve with white line (affected by environment)

Excitation spectrum of Hg (calculated theoretically)

Structure factor – vector sum of contributions of individual atoms Fh = Sj fj exp(2pih.rj) = |Fhkl|exp(ij) B factors (ADP’s) omitted for simplicity

Fh = Sj fj exp(2pih.rj) + Sj fj exp(2pih.rj) P H f1b Fh = Sj fj exp(2pih.rj) + Sj fj exp(2pih.rj) P H

Fh = Sj fj exp(2pih.rj) + Sj (fj +fj+ifj)exp(2pih.rj) f1c Fh = Sj fj exp(2pih.rj) + Sj (fj +fj+ifj)exp(2pih.rj) N A o / // i.exp(ij) = = i.[cos(j) + i.sin(j)] = i.cos(j) - sin(j) = i.sin(j+90o) + cos(j+90o) = exp[i(j +90o)]

FA is perpendicular to FA if all anomalous scatterers f1d FT = FN + FA + FA + iFA / // FA is perpendicular to FA if all anomalous scatterers are of the same kind //

/ // FT = FN + FA + FA + iFA imaginary term iFA breaks Friedel’s law f1e FT = FN + FA + FA + iFA / // // imaginary term iFA breaks Friedel’s law |FT| = |FT| jT = - jT + - + - /

f1f F represented by its complex conjugate *F -

more realistic proportions f1g more realistic proportions Bijvoet ratio <D F>/<F> ~ 3 – 6% for Se for S can be 0.6% (B.C. Wang) <D F>/<F> = (2.NA/NT)1/2 . f”/6.7

sad2

Glucose isomerase: 1 Mn in 388 aa sad2a Glucose isomerase: 1 Mn in 388 aa

DFanom is available from experiment DFanom = 2 FA” sin(jT – jA) sad2b DFanom is available from experiment DFanom = 2 FA” sin(jT – jA) FA” = FA . f”/fo therefore FA ~ DFanom if DFanom is large and DFanom can be used to locate anomalous scatterers instead of FA - using Patterson synthesis - using direct methods

Harker sections of anomalous diffr. Patterson Sav3 anom. Patt. Subtilisin in P212121 , l = 1.54 Å Harker sections of anomalous diffr. Patterson Three calcium sites (f”Ca = 0.70)

anomalous diffraction sad1 Single-wavelength anomalous diffraction SAD phase ambiguity

with experimental errors sad3 with experimental errors

sad4

sad5 Idea of B.C.Wang (1985)

SAD Fourier maps proper wrong overlap solvent flattening SAD maps SAD Fourier maps proper wrong overlap solvent flattening

Partial structure (Sim) contribution sad6 Partial structure (Sim) contribution

sad6a Ferredoxin – 2 Fe4S4 in 55 aa

sad7

mad1

First SAD result – crambin Hendrickson & Teeter, 1981 6 S among 46 amino acids l=1.54 Å, f”(S)=0.56, <DF>/<F>=1.4%

Rice, Earnest & Brünger (2000) re-solved 7 SeMAD structures with SAD and recommended collecting first complete peak data set, and then other MAD wavelengths data, as a sort of insurance policy 1.5-wavelength approach (2002) collecting peak data and rapid phasing, if successful, postponement of next l (now it may be < 1-wavelength)

David Blow, Methods Enzymol. 374, 3-22 (2003) “How Bijvoet made the difference ?” (written probably in 2001) . . . The future of SAD It seems likely, however, that the various improvements to analyze MAD data more correctly are fading into insignificance. The MAD technique is losing ground to SAD.

2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 SAD/(SAD+MAD) structures deposited in PDB PDB statistics SAD/(SAD+MAD) structures deposited in PDB 11% 22% 32% 45% 55% 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005

Proteinase K 279 amino acids, 1 Ca + 10 S f”(S) = 0.23e, f”(Ca) = 0.35e Proteinase K Beamline SER-CAT 22-ID Unit-cell parameters (Å) a=67.55, c=106.88 Space group P43212 Wavelength (Å) 0.98 Distance (mm) 150 Number of images 660 Oscillation (°)/exposure time (s) 0.5 / 2 Transmission 10% Resolution (Å) 50-1.27 (1.32-1.27) Number of unique reflections 63537 Completeness (%) 96.4 (92.7) Overall I/σI 106.1 (31.5) Redundancy 27.1 (26.3) Rmerge (%) 3.3 (13.0)

Anomalous difference Fourier Results of SHELXD Rank Position Height 1 Prot. K SHELXD Results of SHELXD Rank Position Height 1 Ca 1.0000 2 Cys73 0.5105 3 Met111 0.4967 4 Met225 0.4571 5 Met55 0.4560 6 Cys178 0.4417 7 Met238 0.4341 8 Cys123 0.3938 9 Cys249 0.3862 10 Met154 0.3861 11 Cys34 0.3696 12 0.1400

Experimental map after SHELXE Prot. K SHELXE Experimental map after SHELXE Mean phase error 27.5o

Effect of data redundancy Prot. K redundancy Effect of data redundancy Dataset Label Peak Height (σ) Number of sites SHELXD Ca <10S> SO42- 045 25.77 10.48 5.47 - 060 29.07 11.68 6.22 090 35.71 13.95 6.23 120 39.51 15.59 6.54 3 150 43.59 17.20 6.96 8 180 46.81 18.64 7.30 11 210 48.93 19.27 7.44 240 52.17 20.51 7.62 270 54.56 21.24 7.87 300 56.37 21.79 7.80 330 58.13 22.29 8.19

Indicators of anomalous signal - Bijvoet amplitude or intensity ratio - Ranom - c2 difference if Friedels merged - list of outliers - measurability - anomalous signal to noise ratio - correlation between data sets - relation between signal in acentrics and centrics

Bijvoet ratio and Ranom GI Bijvoet ratio Bijvoet ratio and Ranom <DF± >/<F> = (2 NA/NP)1/2 . (fA” /6.7) Ranom = S (F+ - F-) / S (F+ + F-)/2 Four data sets from glucose isomerase 1 Mn in 375 a.a.

Merging c2 difference crystal soaked in Ta6Br12 cluster compound Chi2 and Rmerge Merging c2 difference crystal soaked in Ta6Br12 cluster compound blue – c2 red - Rmerge when Friedels independent orange – c2 green - Rmerge equivalent

List of outliers If redundancy if high enough, clearly shows anomalous differences

Signal to noise ratio (DF±)/s(F) for proteinase K requires proper estimation of s’s (which is not trivial) signal is meaningful, if this ratio is > 1.3

Correlation between data sets corr (DF1±, DF2±) F1 and F2 may be at different MAD l or merged partial SAD data If higher than 25 - 30% - meaningful (advocated by George Sheldrick for SHELXD resolution cutoff)

No indicator is fully satisfactory these indicators of anomalous signal do not tell if the signal is sufficient for structure solution e.g. difficulties with Cu-thionein (Vito Calderone) 8 Cu in ~53 a.a. (12 Cys), P4332 eventually solved from extremely redundant data

only one satisfactory indicator of anomalous signal exists: Conclusion only one satisfactory indicator of anomalous signal exists: successful structure solution nowadays the structure can be solved in few minutes, when the crystal is still at the beam line