Stellarator magnets L. Bromberg J.H. Schultz MIT Plasma Science and Fusion Center ARIES meeting March 8-9, 2004.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The HiLumi LHC Design Study (a sub-system of HL-LHC) is co-funded by the European Commission within the Framework Programme 7 Capacities Specific Programme,
Advertisements

Zian Zhu Superconducting Solenoid Magnet BESIII Workshop Zian Zhu Beijing, Oct.13,2001.
EuCARD-HFM ESAC review of the high field dipole design, 20/01/2011, Maria Durante, 1/40 EuCARD-HFM ESAC Review of the high field dipole design Fabrication.
AT Pilot Plant EM and Structural Studies P. Titus.
Study on supporting structures of magnets and blankets for a heliotron-type fusion reactors Study on supporting structures of magnets and blankets for.
September 15-16, 2005/ARR 1 Status of ARIES-CS Power Core and Divertor Design and Structural Analysis A. René Raffray University of California, San Diego.
1 Configuration Development for HIF Final Focus Superconducting Quadrupole Array HIF Final Focus Meeting July 2, 2002 Tom Brown Chang Jun Phil Heitzenroeder.
Physics and Technology Trade-Offs in Optimizing Compact Stellarators as Power Plants Farrokh Najmabadi and the ARIES Team UC San Diego 21 st IEEE Symposium.
Tracker Solenoid Module Design Update Steve VirostekStephanie Yang Mike GreenWing Lau Lawrence Berkeley National LabOxford Physics MICE Collaboration Meeting.
Preliminary Analysis of the Target System Magnets 1.Version with a 6-T copper magnet insert 2.Version with a 6-T high-temperature superconductor insert.
LPK Recent Progress in Configuration Development for Compact Stellarator Reactors L. P. Ku Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory Aries E-Meeting,
NCSX, MHH2, and HSR Reactor Assessment Results J. F. Lyon, ORNL ARIES Meeting March 8-9, 2004.
Magnet System Definition L. Bromberg P. Titus MIT Plasma Science and Fusion Center ARIES meeting November 4-5, 2004.
Status of the Power Core Configuration Based on Modular Maintenance Presented by X.R. Wang Contributors: S. Malang, A.R. Raffray and the ARIES Team ARIES.
Overview of ARIES Compact Stellarator Study Farrokh Najmabadi and the ARIES Team UC San Diego US/Japan Workshop on Power Plant Studies & Related Advanced.
Status of the Coil Structure Design and Magnetic-Structural Analysis Presented by X.R. Wang Contributors: UCSD: S. Malang, A.R. Raffray PPPL: H.M. Fan.
Status of Coil Structural Design and Magnetic-Structural Analysis Presented by X.R. Wang Contributors: ORNL: D. Williamson UCSD: S. Malang, A.R. Raffray.
ARIES-Stellerator studies Magnet issues L. Bromberg P. Titus MIT Plasma Science and Fusion Center Cambridge MA May 7, 2003.
Superconducting Solenoids for COMET KEK Cryogenics Center, Osaka Univ. Kuno-san’s Team, J-PARC MLF Muon Group.
Progress on Engineering and Costing Algorithms for ARIES Systems Code Zoran Dragojlovic, Rene Raffray, Chuck Kessel and Leslie Bromberg ARIES Project Meeting.
Overview of the ARIES-CS Compact Stellarator Power Plant Study Farrokh Najmabadi and the ARIES Team UC San Diego Japan-US Workshop on Fusion Power Plants.
ARIES IFE Final Focusing Magnets L. Bromberg Magnet Technology group at MIT MIT Plasma Science and Fusion Center ARIES Meeting UCSD April 23, 2002.
December 3-4, 2003/ARR 1 Maintenance Studies for 3-Field Period and 2-Field Period Configurations Presented by A. R. Raffray Major Contributors: X. Wang.
HTS Magnets for ARIES-AT L. Bromberg J.H. Schultz MIT Plasma Science and Fusion Center ARIES Meeting March 20, 2000.
UCN Phase 2 Design Status September 10, Design Components Bulk Shielding Target Crypt Cryogenic Insert Target Insert UCN Port Beam Window Cooling.
ARIES CS Magnet definition L. Bromberg MIT Plasma Science and Fusion Center USCD November 18, 2005.
Stellarator magnet conductors L. Bromberg J. Schultz MIT Plasma Science and Fusion Center Cambridge MA Aries Meeting, Georgia Tech September 3, 2003.
Magnet Options for Modular Stellarator Power Plants Leslie Bromberg J.H. Schultz ARIES team MIT Plasma Science and Fusion Center Cambridge MA US/Japan.
Magnet considerations for ARIES IFE L. Bromberg With contributions from J.H. Schultz MIT Plasma Science and Fusion Center ARIES Meeting Madison, WI September.
Review of the mechanical design of the final focusing region of the HIF Point Design T. Brown ARIES Project Meeting January 8, 2003.
Magnet considerations for ARIES IFE HTS/LTS algorithms and design options L. Bromberg With contributions from J.H. Schultz MIT Plasma Science and Fusion.
Aug 29, 2006S. Kahn T HTS Solenoid1 A Proposal for a 50 T HTS Solenoid Steve Kahn Muons Inc. August 29, 2006.
Magnet costs L. Bromberg J.H. Schultz ARIES Meeting & Review PPPL, October
BASIC CONSIDERATIONS IN DESIGN  The aim of the design is to completely obtain the dimensions of all the parts of the machine to furnish the data to the.
Superconducting Large Bore Sextupole for ILC
1 A Joint Proposal for US-Japan Cooperation Program Proposal to JSPS US-Japan collaboration fund R&D of superconducting magnet technology for high intensity.
Possible HTS wire implementation Amalia Ballarino Care HHH Working Meeting LHC beam-beam effects and beam-beam interaction CERN, 28 th August 2008.
Magnets for muon collider ring and interaction regions V.V. Kashikhin, FNAL December 03, 2009.
NSTX Center Stack Upgrade Workshop Requirements & Design Point C Neumeyer Jan 22, 2009.
Superconducting R&D – Now Strand and Cable R&D FERMILAB Magnet Systems Department – Now SC Materials Department (TD) HTS Insert Coil Test in External Solenoid.
KDEMO Structural Analysis P. Titus June ! KDEMO coil axisymmetric analysis pfcb 21 1, 1.52,0.70,.9,1.3,8,10 !CS1 2, 1.52,2.10,.9,1.3,8,10 !CS2.
ARIES AT Project Meeting - Princeton, NJ 18 Sept 00 1 ARIES-AT Toroidal Field (TF) and Poloidal Field (PF) Coils Tom Brown, Fred Dahlgren, Phil Heitzenroeder.
SuperB Meeting, May 2008 Status of the magnetic design of the first quadrupole (QD0) for the SuperB interaction region S. Bettoni on behalf of the whole.
KEK Hiroshi Yamaoka Task list for Magnet/Iron yoke Solenoid magnet Iron yoke Experimental hall and other facilities May 11, ’05.
UCRL-PRES Magnet Design Considerations & Efficiency Advantages of Magnetic Diversion Concept W. Meier & N. Martovetsky LLNL HAPL Program Meeting.
Magnet for ARIES-CS Magnet protection Cooling of magnet structure L. Bromberg J.H. Schultz MIT Plasma Science and Fusion Center ARIES meeting UCSD January.
GROUP C – Case study no.4 Dr. Nadezda BAGRETS (Karlsruhe Institute of Technology) Dr. Andrea CORNACCHINI (CERN EN Dept.) Mr. Miguel FERNANDES (CERN BE.
5 K Shield Study of STF Cryomodule Norihito Ohuchi, Norio Higashi KEK Xu QingJin IHEP 2008/3/3-61Sendai-GDE-Meeting.
56 MHz SRF Cavity Thermal Analysis and Vacuum Chamber Strength C. Pai
CERN Accelerator School Superconductivity for Accelerators Case study 3 Paolo Ferracin ( ) European Organization for Nuclear Research.
16 T Dipole Design Options: Input Parameters and Evaluation Criteria F. Toral - CIEMAT CIEMAT-VC, Sept. 4th, 2015.
Stellarator magnet options. Electrical/winding issues Elegant solution for ARIES-AT does not extrapolate well for ARIES-CS –High Temperature Superconductor.
1 Modular Coil Winding Keystoning Issues NCSX Technical Meeting May 29, 2003 What is the current baseline winding? What is the problem? What are the variables.
CLIC Stabilisation Day’08 18 th March 2008 Thomas Zickler AT/MCS/MNC/tz 1 CLIC Quadrupoles Th. Zickler CERN.
Nonlinear Analyses of Modular Coils and Shell structure for Coil Cool-down and EM Loads Part 1 – Results of Shell Structure and Modular Coils H.M. Fan.
NCSX NCSX TF Coil Conductor FDR 5/17/05 1 Michael Kalish NCSX TF Conductor.
CEA DSM Irfu - J-M Rey - EUCARD WP 7 Meeting - GRENOBLE 22/03/ HTS insert preliminary design and solenoid prototypes Mélanie Bruchon, Sandrine Cazaux,
Pier Paolo Granieri, TE-CRG Collimation Upgrade Specification Meeting #35 21 st March, 2014.
KEK-CEA Superconducting Magnet Co-operation Program The FJPPL workshop LAPP, Annecy-Le-Vieux (France), June LHC-3 Superconducting Magnets.
Magnetics Program Highlights VLT Conference Call September 13, 2000 presented by J.V. Minervini MIT Plasma Science and Fusion Center.
Thermal screen of the cryostat Presented by Evgeny Koshurnikov, GSI, Darmstadt September 8, 2015 Joint Institute for Nuclear Research (Dubna)
Compact Stellarators as Reactors J. F. Lyon, ORNL NCSX PAC meeting June 4, 1999.
SPS High Energy LSS5 Thermal contact & cooling aspects
16 T dipole in common coil configuration: mechanical design
Update on PANDA solenoid design
Task 6: Short period helical superconducting undulator
EuCARD2 WP 10.2 HTS Conductor
The superconducting solenoids for the Super Charm-Tau Factory detector
Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics,
S. Bettoni on behalf of the whole team
Presentation transcript:

Stellarator magnets L. Bromberg J.H. Schultz MIT Plasma Science and Fusion Center ARIES meeting March 8-9, 2004

Organization of talk Magnet design with dual temperature superconductor –MgB 2 and NbTi Costing algorithm Future work

Medium Temperature Superconductor

Preliminary design MgB 2 Needed for determination of radiation effects on magnet due to B in the SC

Algorithm for low Tc coil

Manufacturing Inserted from the plasma side into large structures. If wound. substantial amount of strain capability required for assembly –Nb 2 Sn requires low strain –MgB 2 has similar low strain capability –(both require react and wind) Stuck with either NbTi (at low temperature at high field) or high temperature superconductor.

Multiple temperature operation? By using either MgB2 or BSSCO, it is possible to grade the magnet for cost reduction –Use NbTi at 4 K for the low temperature region –The low field region is further removed from the plasma as is better shielded.

Method for performing dual temperature - Option 1 Radiation captured at the higher temperature Need to transfer loads through low temperature region (one insulation region required)

Method for performing dual temperature - Option 2 Substantially decreased thermal loads Need to transfer outward loads from high temperature region through low temperature region before getting to structure (if bucking): two insulation regions.

Dual temperature Impact mainly on cost. Tradeoff: –Much cheaper superconductor if using dual temperature –But More complicated arrangement Need for 4 K refrigerator Final design will investigate both

Design/Costing algorithms Prepared simple spread sheet model for designing coils and costing Coil designs (conductor) –Simple coil (one type of conductor) and coils with multiple types of conductors Coil structure Coil cost Spread sheet transferred to Jim Lyon

Using design by J. Lyon (presented in Dec. meeting) Coil aspect ratio small –There may be sufficient space between coils without having to change the winding pack shape

Coil structure Assumes that all space between coils is filled with structure –Regions for access ports need to be reinforced elsewhere –Conservative assumption –Subtraction of relatively large numbers for estimating the volume –Good for system code. Will be improved once design space is narrowed down.

Calculation of external structure Using simple beam theory (good for system analysis) –A = B 0 2 R 0 2 /2  0 –S 1 = A (R 2 ln(R 2 /R 1 ) - R 2 +R 1 )/(R 1 (R 2 -R 1 )) –S 2 = A (R 2 - R 1 - R 1 ln(R 2 /R 1 ))/(R 2 (R 2 -R 1 )) – t 1 = S 1 /  m ; t 2 = S 2 /  m –R 3 = (S 1 R S 2 R 2 2 )/(A ln(R 2 /R 1 )) –a = 3/8 S 2 R 2 (R 2 -R 3 )/  b / R 3 ) –R 2 : outer external structure radius –R 1 : inner external structure radius

Design criteria for external support Use SS-316 because of the large amounts of materials required could have substantial cost penalty Cross section of support determined by bending –Maximum stress by lowest of 1.5 x greater of (2/3  y or 1/3  u ) –Use around 800 MPa (for SS-316) SS-316: (1400 MPa yield, 1800 MPa ultimate)

Bucking cylinder and total structure cost Large structure with tight tolerances. –$50/kg may be an underestimate –Can we use rapid prototyping methods for manufacturing of these large structures?

Total coil costing Cost of magnet dominated by winding assembly Cost of BSCCO would be larger than that of Nb 3 Sn

Magnet design Very aggressive IFE magnet design ran into a lot of resistance (from the reviewers of Fusion Eng Design article) I propose that the baseline be wound magnet –BSCCO and NbTi, if cost warrants –Else, just BSCCO Use aggressive design as option

Work to be done System design tools have been developed Detailed calculations need to be performed for a design point, in order to assure the appropriateness of the algorithms –Calculate stresses using actual currents and geometries Structural considerations Deformations and strains of the structure and superconductor –Superconductor characteristics –Power supplies –Cryogenic loads and cooling Need one design point to calculate some details –NCSX (??) –HSR

Resources Can PPPL provide assistance with the calculations of the loads? –Stresses? P. Titus has been performing calculations for NCSX, but only earthquake analysis