Pasquale Di Bari (Max Planck, Munich) COSMO 06, Tahoe Lake, September 25-29, 2006 Flavor effects in leptogenesis Reference paper: S. Blanchet, PDB hep/ph.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Can we experimentally test seesaw and leptogenesis? Hitoshi Murayama (IPMU Tokyo & Berkeley) Melbourne Neutrino WS, Jun 4, 2008 With Matt Buckley.
Advertisements

TeV scale Universal seesaw, vacuum stability and Heavy Higgs at the LHC Yongchao Zhang ( 张永超 ) Center for High-Energy Physics, Peking University w/ Rabi.
Resonant Leptogenesis In S4 Model Nguyen Thanh Phong Cantho University In cooperation with Prof. CSKim, SKKang and Dr. YHAhn (work in progress)
Flavor Violation in SUSY SEESAW models 8th International Workshop on Tau-Lepton Physics Tau04 Junji Hisano (ICRR, U of Tokyo)
The classically conformal B-L extended standard model Yuta Orikasa Satoshi Iso(KEK,SOKENDAI) Nobuchika Okada(University of Alabama) Phys.Lett.B676(2009)81.
Neutrinoless double beta decay and Lepton Flavor Violation Or, in other words, how the study of LFV can help us to decide what mechanism is responsible.
1 Flavor effects on leptogenesis Steve Blanchet Max-Planck-Institut für Physik, Munich September 15, 2006 Neutrino Oscillation Workshop Conca Specchiulla,
Neutrino Mass Seesaw at the Weak Scale, the Baryon Asymmetry, and the LHC Z. Chacko University of Maryland, College Park S. Blanchet, R.N. Mohapatra.
Pasquale Di Bari (INFN, Padova) Melbourne Neutrino Theory Workshop, 2-4 June 2008 New Aspects ofLeptogenesis Neutrino Mass Bounds (work in collaboration.
Higgs Quadruplet for Type III Seesaw and Implications for → e and −e Conversion Ren Bo Coauther : Koji Tsumura, Xiao - Gang He arXiv:
PPC 2010, July, 2010 Interconnections among Baryo/Leptogenesis models Pasquale Di Bari TexPoint fonts used in EMF. Read the TexPoint manual before.
Fourth Generation Leptons Linda Carpenter UC Irvine Dec 2010.
June 18, 2004Mitsuru Kakizaki1 Democratic (s)fermions and lepton flavor violation Mitsuru Kakizaki (ICRR, University of Tokyo) June 18, 2004 We propose.
May 25, 2004Kakizaki, Mitsuru1 Flavor structure in supersymmetric models Kakizaki, Mitsuru (ICRR, University of Tokyo) May 25, 2004 We proposed a new alignment.
Oct. 25, 2004Mitsuru Kakizaki1 Flavor structure in supersymmetric models Mitsuru Kakizaki (ICRR, University of Tokyo) Oct. 25, Ochanomizu University.
B. Dutta Texas A&M University Phys.Rev.Lett.100:181801,2008; arXiv: ; To appear Grand Unified Models, Proton Decay and Phase of Collaborator: Yukihiro.
Probing Majorana Neutrinos in Rare Meson Decays Claudio Dib UTFSM I.S. & B.K. Fest, UTFSM, May 2010 G. Cvetic, C.D., S.K. Kang, C.S. Kim, PRD 82, ,
Particle Physics and Cosmology
March 2005 Theme Group 2 Perspectives on Grand Unification in View of Neutrino Mass R. N. Mohapatra University of Maryland.
CUSTODIAL SYMMETRY IN THE STANDARD MODEL AND BEYOND V. Pleitez Instituto de Física Teórica/UNESP Modern Trends in Field Theory João Pessoa ─ Setembro 2006.
Pasquale Di Bari (Max Planck, Munich) ‘The path to neutrino mass’, Aarhus, 3-6 September, 2007 Recent developments in Leptogenesis.
Model building: “The simplest neutrino mass matrix” see Harrison and Scott: Phys. Lett. B594, 324 (2004), hep-ph/ , Phys. Lett. B557, 76 (2003).
1 Electroweak Baryogenesis and LC Yasuhiro Okada (KEK) 8 th ACFA LC workshop July 12, 2005, Daegu, Korea.
Nov.9, 2006, SNULeptogenesis & Triplet Seesaw1 Leptogenesis and Triplet Seesaw Eung Jin Chun KIAS TexPoint fonts used in EMF. Read the TexPoint manual.
Wednesday, Apr. 23, 2003PHYS 5326, Spring 2003 Jae Yu 1 PHYS 5326 – Lecture #24 Wednesday, Apr. 23, 2003 Dr. Jae Yu Issues with SM picture Introduction.
International workshop on dark matter, dark energy and matter- antimatter asymmetry National Tsing Hua University ( 國立清華大學 ) 20–21 November 2009 Electromagnetic.
Shaving Type-I Seesaw Mechanism with Occam's Razor
Let us allow now the second heavy RH neutrino to be close to the lightest one,. How does the overall picture change? There are two crucial points to understand:
Pasquale Di Bari (INFN, Padova) Dark Matter from Heavy Right-Handed Neutrino Mixing (see A.Anisimov, PDB, arXiv: [hep-ph] ) NuHoRIzons 09 Harish-Chandra.
Sterile Neutrino Oscillations and CP-Violation Implications for MiniBooNE NuFact’07 Okayama, Japan Georgia Karagiorgi, Columbia University August 10, 2007.
Right-handed sneutrino as cold dark matter of the universe Takehiko Asaka (EPFL  Niigata University) Refs: with Ishiwata and Moroi Phys.Rev.D73:061301,2006.
1 Lepton Electric Dipole Moments in Supersymmetric Type II Seesaw Model Toru Goto, Takayuki Kubo and Yasuhiro Okada, “Lepton electric dipole moments in.
Anarchy, Neutrinoless double beta decay and Leptogenesis Xiaochuan Lu and Hitoshi Murayama NuFact 2013, Aug 22nd UC Berkeley.
1 Pasquale Di Bari (Max Planck, Munich) Università di Milano, February 8, 2007 Can neutrinos help to solve the puzzles of modern cosmology ?
Family Symmetry Solution to the SUSY Flavour and CP Problems Plan of talk: I.Family Symmetry II.Solving SUSY Flavour and CP Problems Work with and Michal.
1 Neutrino Phenomenology Boris Kayser Scottish Summer School August 11,
Ohio State DUSEL Theory Workshop Stuart Raby Underground Detectors Investigating Grand Unification Brookhaven National Lab October 16, 2008.
Neutrino mass and DM direct detection Daijiro Suematsu (Kanazawa Univ.) Erice Sept., 2013 Based on the collaboration with S.Kashiwase PRD86 (2012)
Impact of Neutrino Oscillation Measurements on Theory Hitoshi Murayama NuFact 03 June 10, 2003.
21 Sept The MSM -- Neutrino Masses and Dark matter -- Takehiko Asaka (Tohoku University) TA, S.Blanchet, M.Shaposhnikov [hep-ph/ ] TA, M.Shaposhnikov.
Yukawa and scalar interactions induced by scalar relevant for neutrino masss generation are: Since is assumed to be an exact symmetry of the model has.
Geometric -Mass Hierarchy & Leptogenesis Zhi-zhong Xing (IHEP, Beijing)  A Conjecture + An Ansatz  Seesaw + Leptogenesis  -Mixing + Baryogenesis Z.Z.X.,
1 Prospect after discoveries of Higgs/SUSY Yasuhiro Okada (KEK) “Discoveries of Higgs and Supersymmetry to Pioneer Particle Physics in the 21 st Century”
Duality in Left-Right Symmetric Seesaw Mechanism Michele Frigerio Service de Physique Théorique, CEA/Saclay Rencontres de Physique des Particules March.
SUSY GUT Predictions for Neutrino Oscillation Mu-Chun Chen Brookhaven National Laboratory DUSEL Workshop, January 4-7, 2005 University of Colorado at Boulder.
Cosmological matter-antimatter asymmetry & possible CP violation in neutrino oscillations Zhi-zhong Xing (IHEP) International UHE Tau Neutrino Workshop.
EDMs in the SUSY GUTs Junji Hisano (ICRR, Univ. of Tokyo) NuFact04 6th International Workshop on Neutrino Factories and Superbeams, Osaka University, Japan.
季向东 (Xiangdong Ji) Shanghai JiaoTong University /University of Maryland.
Issues in Leptogenesis1 Eung Jin Chun Korea Institute of Advanced Study, Seoul APCTP, Yonsei, Sep. 15, 2007.
THE CONNECTION BETWEEN NEUTRINO EXPERIMENTS AND LEPTOGENESIS Alicia Broncano Berrocal MPI.
4 ½ Problems from Modern Cosmology 4 ½ Problems from Modern Cosmology Pasquale Di Bari MAX PLANCK PROJECT REVIEW 2005 and a few solutions !
Neutrino physics: The future Gabriela Barenboim TAU04.
Double beta decay and Leptogenesis International workshop on double beta decay searches Oct SNU Sin Kyu Kang (Seoul National University of.
1-2 Mass Degeneration in the Leptonic Sector Hiroyuki ISHIDA (Tohoku University) Collaboration with : Takeshi ARAKI (MISC) Ref ; T. Araki and H.I. arXiv.
Fourth Generation Leptons Linda Carpenter April 2011.
and what we unsuccessfully tried to explain (so far)
Leptogenesis beyond the limit of hierarchical heavy neutrino masses
Classically conformal B-L extended Standard Model
Leptogenesis Parameterized by Lepton Mass Matrices
TeV-Scale Leptogenesis and the LHC
The Physics of Neutrinos
Neutrino Mass Seesaw, Baryogenesis and LHC
Matter vs. Antimatter The Question of Symmetry
On neutrinoless double beta decay in the nMSM
Baryogenesis at Electroweak scale
New aspects of leptogenesis
CEPC-Physics Workshop
Double beta decay and Leptogenesis
TeV Leptogenesis in the Minimal Seesaw Model
Rome Samanta, University of Southampton
Presentation transcript:

Pasquale Di Bari (Max Planck, Munich) COSMO 06, Tahoe Lake, September 25-29, 2006 Flavor effects in leptogenesis Reference paper: S. Blanchet, PDB hep/ph

Outline From the see-saw mechanism to leptogenesis The traditional picture Beyond the traditional picture Flavor effects General implications on leptogenesis bounds Role of Majorana phases  testing leptogenesis at low energies ?  testing leptogenesis at low energies ?Conclusions

From the see-saw mechanism to … From the see-saw mechanism to … already Compared to any other baryogenesis model, leptogenesis relies on a piece of new physics that has been already observed: neutrino masses neutrino massesneutrino massesneutrino masses and on the simplest way to explain them: and on the simplest way to explain them: the see-saw mechanism Adding to the SM (3) RH neutrinos with Yukawa couplings h and a Majorana mass M, a usual Dirac mass m D = v * h is also generated after SSB. For M >> m D : 3 light LH neutrinos: 3 light LH neutrinos: 3 heavy RH neutrinos: N 1, N 2, N 3 3 heavy RH neutrinos: N 1, N 2, N 3,

CP asymmetry If  i ≠ 0 a lepton asymmetry is generated from N i decays and partly converted into a baryon asymmetry by sphaleron processes if T reh  100 GeV ! efficiency factors ´ # of N i decaying out-of-equilibrium (Kuzmin,Rubakov,Shaposhnikov, ’85) M, m D, m are complex matrices  natural source of CP violation (Fukugita,Yanagida ’86) … leptogenesis

Kinetic Equations ``decay parameters´´ CP violation in decays Wash-out term from inverse decays Strong wash-out when K i  3 Weak wash-out when K i  3

flavor composition of leptons is neglected hierarchical heavy neutrino spectrum asymmetry generated from lightest RH neutrino decays (N 1 -dominated scenario) The traditional picture

N 1 - dominated scenario

Dependence on the initial conditions m 1  m sol M 1  GeV Neutrino mixing data favor the strong wash-out regime !

Neutrino mass bounds m 1 =0  M 1

beyond the hierarchical limit N 2 -dominated scenario flavor effects Beyond the traditional picture

(Barbieri et a l. ’01; Endo et al. ’04; Pilaftsis,Underwood ’05; Nardi,Roulet’06;Abada et al.’06;Blanchet,PDB’06) Flavor composition: Does it play any role ? However for lower temperatures the charged lepton Yukawa couplings, are strong enough to break the coherent evolution of the and of the, that are then projected on a flavor basis: ‘flavor’ is measured and comes into play ! Flavor effects It is then necessary to track the asymmetries separately in each flavor:

How flavor effects modify leptogenesis? The kinetic equations then become : First type of effect: inverse decays wash-out in each flavor is suppressed by the projectors: Second type of effect: additional contribution to the individual CP asymmetries: Same as before! (Nardi et al., 06) Interestingly one has that this additional contribution depends on U !

NiNi L NO FLAVOR NjNj Φ Φ LeLe LµLµ LτLτ

NiNi WITH FLAVOR NjNj Φ Φ LeLe LµLµ LτLτ

General implications on the bounds Upper bound on the individual CP asymmetries (Abada, et al., 06) : Notice that it does not decrease when the active neutrino mass scale increases  This can potentially remove the upper bound on neutrino masses Possible general scenarios: –Alignment case (Nardi et al., 05) –Democratic (semi-democratic) case (Blanchet, PDB, 06) –One-flavor dominance (Blanchet, PDB, 06) and potentially big effect!

Lower bound on M 1 The lowest bounds independent of the initial conditions (at K 1 =K * ) don’t change! (Blanchet, PDB ‘06) 3x10 9 alignment democratic semi- democratic But for a fixed K 1, there is a relaxation of the lower bounds of a factor 2 (semi-democratic) or 3 (democratic), but it can be much larger in the case of one flavor dominance.

A relevant specific case  Semi-democratic case Let us consider: For m 1 =0 (fully hierarchical light neutrinos)  Since the projectors and flavored asymmetries depend on U  one has to plug the information from neutrino mixing experiments Flavor effects represent just a correction in this case !

The role of Majorana phases However allowing for a non-vanishing m 1 the effects become much larger especially when Majorana phases are turned on ! m 1 =m atm  0.05 eV  1 = 0  1 = - 

Leptogenesis testable at low energies ? Let us now further impose  real setting Im(  13 )=0 traditional unflavored case M 1 min The lower bound gets more stringent but still successful leptogenesis is possible just with CP violation from ‘low energy’ phases that can be tested in  0 decay (Majorana phases) and neutrino mixing (Dirac phase) Moreover considering the degenerate limit these lower bounds can be relaxed ! (Blanchet,PDB 06)

Conclusions Leptogenesis is fastly developing in last years becoming more and more quantitative; The most interesting recent achievement is represented by an account of flavor effects; They typically reduce the range of the strong wash- out regime without relaxing the lower bounds on M 1 and on T reh (for this one needs to consider a degenerate heavy neutrino spectrum) but removing the upper bound on neutrino masses that holds in the unflavored case; Very interestingly they make possible to have successful leptogenesis just from low energy phases testable in neutrino experiments:  0 decay experiments (Majorana phases) and neutrino mixing experiments (Dirac phase)

Neutrino masses: m 1 < m 2 < m 3

WEAK WASH-OUT z´ M 1 / T zdzd K 1 ´ t U (T=M 1 )/   STRONG WASH-OUT

Beyond the hierarchical limit Assume: partial hierarchy: M 3 >> M 2, M 1 heavy N 3 : M 3 >> GeV 3 Effects play simultaneously a role for  2  1 : (Pilalftsis ’97, Hambye et al ’03, Blanchet,PDB ‘06)

For  The lower bound on M 1 disappears and is replaced by a lower bound on M 2. The lower bound on T reh remains (PDB’05) N 2 -dominated scenario See-saw orthogonal matrix: