Human Rights Based Spatial Planning in Cambodia. Learning from the past and identifying new win- win spatial solutions in Phnom Penh.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The Vienna Declaration and its Implications
Advertisements

GREENING TROPICAL URBAN ENVIRONMENTS: utilising social housing policies, Caribbean raw materials, and smart technologies to build healthy and safe communities.
Day: Wednesday 9 th November Session: 9.00am am Speaker: Stig Enemark Topic:The Land Management Paradigm.
2.2.2 Formalizing Property Right and Tenure Security 1 FORMALIZING PROPETY RIGHTS AND TENURE SECURITY UPA Package 2, Module 2.
HOUSING FOR SUSTAINABLE CITIES: COMMITMENTS AND PARTNERSHIP OPPORTUNITIES Regional Conference on Housing Policy towards Sustainable Housing Development.
Public-Private Partnerships in the Global Perspective: Outstanding Methods, Constraints and Challenges A Comparative Study of Partnerships between Public.
Slum Situation Analysis
1. 2 UN-HABITAT Current Status & Strategy for the Future.
China’s Land System Reform; What Comes after the Third Plenum? John W. Bruce 16 th Annual World Bank Conference on Land and Poverty March 23 – 27, 2015,
Japanese Experiences in Urbanization & Urban Planning System in Japan JICA Expert Kenichi WAKAMATSU 23 Aug.2001 Jakarta.
3.2.5 On-Site Land Tenure Improvement in the Philippines: The Case of Slum Upgrading Program in Quezon City, Philippines 1 UPA Package 3, Module ON-SITE.
International consulting by internationally renown experts Christine Walker Founding Member Cadastec Property Lawyer, Registrar Real Property.
6.4 Durable solutions for IDPs and returnees in post-conflict Iraq Iraq: Commitment and involvement of government and a broad range of actors in a complex.
Community Land Information Program (CLIP) SHACK DWELLERS FEDERATION OF NAMIBIA (SDFN) / NAMIBIA HOUSING ACTION GROUP (NHAG) Networking Event Count me in,
Shelter Training 08b – Belgium, 16 th –18 th November, 2008 based on content developed by p This session identifies the six transitional reconstruction.
Expert Meeting on Land Administration Systems- Priorities in The Third World University of Melbourne 9 –11 November 2005 Ian Lloyd Director Land Equity.
Country Experience In Improving Governance of Tenure of Land, Turkey.
Managing land issues for sustainable local development: Notes for a policy research and action agenda in Latin America Malcolm D. Childress Sr. Land Administration.
BY BENJAMIN BRADLOW SHACK/SLUM DWELLERS INTERNATIONAL (SDI) KNOWING YOUR CITY PROVIDING ACCESS TO URBAN LAND AND INFRASTRUCTURE THROUGH GRASSROOTS DATA.
Confidential # v1 Issues in Real Estate Transactions Involving Affordable Rental Housing For Urban Re-Development Stephanie M. M. Smith 500.
Citi REO Strategy & Community Relations September 15, 2009.
Key Recommendations of the High Level Task Force on Affordable Housing for All Presentation to the Ministry of Housing and Urban Poverty Alleviation December.
Agricultural employment trends in Latin America and new requirements for statistics Fourth International Conference on Agricultural Statistics (ICAS-4)
S ocial T enure D omain M odel A Pro-Poor Land Information System.
Land Administration in Africa Searching for Land Tenure Security May 22 to 25, 2006 Alternatives to Titling Geoffrey K. Payne Principal Geofftrey Payne.
July 2010 by EMORN PRASITTISOOK. T H A I L A N D Total area 513,115 Sq.km. (51.3 Million ha) 76 Provinces Population 64 million Estimate of Land Type.
Draft Law on Industrial Parks. Definition of Industrial Park Territory on which economic activity, including industrial production, services provision,
‘Doing more with less’ – enhancing resilience in eThekewini Municipality Coleen Vogel REVAMP Wits.
Premier Accra Airport Hotel, Accra Ghana,
Crossing the river by feeling the stones, Experimenting with changing rural land use rights in Chengdu Meine Pieter van Dijk & Laura Kamsma Erasmus and.
Manufactured Home Parks -An Overview-. Minnesota law (§ 327C) defines a manufactured home park as a site with 2+ occupied manufactured homes excluding.
The Lake The People Some 4,200 Boeung Kak families live in nine villages around the lake before 2007.
SYNOPTIC REFLECTION ON URBAN LAND ADMINISTRATION ISSUES IN ETHIOPIA Abuye Aneley Alemu Decision Makers Meeting On Good Administartion of Lands Polytechnic.
UNCLASSIFIED 1 MPAT TEMPEST EXPRESS-14 Staff Planning Workshop Scenario Overview 6 March 2008.
UNECE WPLA Workshop Athens, December, 2012 Informal Settlements (Azerbaijan) Dr. Elshad KHANALIBAYLI State Committee on Property Issues Republic.
12 June 2008WPLA1 The UNECE Working Party on Land Administration (WPLA) Tasks of the Real Estate Market Advisory Group (REM) Milan, 12 th June 2008 Peter.
Efforts to Achieve the MDG Cities Alliance Consultative Group Meeting Poverty Alleviation: Action Programme 2015 Collaboration with other donors within.
University of Lagos, Lagos, Nigeria
LAND POLICY AND LAND ADMINISTRATION Mark Marquardt Best Practices for Land Tenure and Natural Resource Governance in Africa October 2012.
CR TOOLKIT WORKSHOP MANAGEMENT TOOLKIT - RESETTLEMENT PLANNING Ref – ICMM CD TOOLKIT # 18 - Trainer: Martin Paining Date: 28 th of November, 2013.
Housing as a Process, Not a Product
LAC Land Agenda: Secure property rights, access and spatial development Land Policies for Growth and Poverty Reduction (Deininger 2003)—importance of secure.
Land Administration Åse Christensen Polytechnic of Namibia, Namibia Land Administration Course Land Administration, Bachelor Semester 5, February 2015.
An Evaluation Of The Resettlement Program In The Philippines: The Case Of Towerville Resettlement Project A Country Report On New Town Development And.
BY JACK MAKAU SHACK/SLUM DWELLERS INTERNATIONAL (SDI) KNOWING YOUR CITY The evolution of the urban discourse in Kenya and how grassroots data collection.
Changes to come: JNNURM II Rajiv Awas Yojana (RAY)
Funded by Scaling up Urban Disaster Risk Reduction in Cambodia by: People in Need.
POLICY PLANNING OPERATIONAL IN SENEGAL: CASE OF UPGRADING SLUMS Mrs Lamdya Emilie MANGA Deputy Chairman Ministry of Urban Renewal, Housing and living environment.
PERU: STATE OF THE HOUSING INDUSTRY IHA Secretariat.
Sustainable Development In Practice: Sanitation & Urban Upgrading Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam Le Dieu Anh, PCHCMC - Benoit Legrand, BTC ECOSOC - 2 July 2008.
Slums, resettlement, and tenure in JNNURM & RAY. History of Slum Policies The Tamil Nadu Slum Clearance Act was passed in 1971, and was the first and.
Experiences of JNNURM in Chennai and Lessons for RAY & JNNURM II Slides prepared by TRANSPARENT CHENNAI for workshop on slum policies held on July 21,
Armenia Action B th – 23 rd March 2012 Mrs Vibeke Skov Møller Address Register The Danish experience.
Background: The Tamil Nadu Slum Clearance Act, 1971 The first and only piece of legislation for slum clearance, and to establish the Slum Clearance Board.
Cities & Adaptations Ajaz Ahmed. Climate Change A global problem and serious threat Risk to socioeconomic systems – exposure Solution – Mitigation & adaptation.
Afghanistan Independent Land Authority متعهد به رشد اجتماعی و اقتصادی Committed to Social & Economic Growth Land-NPP: A Tool to Implement.
COMMUNITY DRIVEN CLIMATE CHANGE MITIGATION AND ADAPTATION STRATEGIES PRESENTED BY KHADIJA KINGI AND TIM NDEZI TANZANIA FEDERATION OF THE URBAN POOR AND.
«An assessment of the socio-economic benefits of the Hellenic National Cadaster» Panos Lolonis, Ph.D. Member of the Scientific Council NATIONAL CADASTRE.
PERU: STATE OF THE HOUSING INDUSTRY
LAR in aspect of the cadastral managing – capacity building
Housing on North Pender Island
MONENI URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT
What is a Comprehensive Plan? A Regional Comprehensive Plan… is the official and legal strategy guiding the growth, development, redevelopment and.
STREET LED APPROACH IN SLUM UPGRADATION
In-situ Slum Rehabiliation
Shelter and reconstruction options
INGONYAMA TRUST BOARD’S ANNUAL PERFORMANCE PLAN
Expected Impact and Results
PRESENTATION TO: THE PORTFOLIO COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC WORKS
Presentation transcript:

Human Rights Based Spatial Planning in Cambodia. Learning from the past and identifying new win- win spatial solutions in Phnom Penh.

The population of Phnom Penh grows at 4% per annum (the highest urban growth in the region). 78% of the population still live in the rural areas In 1975 the city was depopulated by Khmer Rouge forces and all the cadastral information lost While we need to recognize that the city’s infrastructure in the central districts of Phnom Penh improved, at the same time, urban poor were relocated from Phnom Penh In 2003 the Phnom Penh Municipality launched a program for poverty reduction with 4 urban poor communities selected for “land sharing” (500 slums upgrades in 5 years). Phnom Penh urban development

In 2003, 4 locations in the city’s prime areas were selected for “land sharing” piloting in Phnom Penh: Day Krohom (1465), Borei Kheila (1776), Railway A (70) and B (255) communities By 2008, only 1261 original residents’ families in Borei Kheila received flats (with 154 excluded from the process). Families from 3 other sites had to accept compensations offered by the companies and relocation outside of the city. It resulted in a huge wave of mistrust among urban poor towards any initiatives of the Phnom Penh Municipality Land Sharing in Phnom Penh

Number of NGOs emerged in Phnom Penh as a result of urban growth and growing concerns over the evictions and effective urban poverty reduction The typical response would include: mapping and enumeration of the urban poor settlements, community organizing, legal land surveys of the settlements, small scale upgrades, community events and in some cases drafts of the onsite re-development plans The municipal authorities expressed willingness to engage in the “troubled” cases and try to resolve the land disputes such as Borei Kheila and Baoung Kak Lake. However, the final deals were not finalized up till now. The HRBSP project of PIN and STT presents a more comprehensive process for on- site development Urban NGOs response

It uses the good practice tools developed in the past: mapping, enumeration, community organizing …but instead of general land tenure status analysis it looks at the individual possession rights, analysis of official legal documents which become the basis for architectural and urban re-development plans which is later developed with local authorities and communities under threat of eviction to find satisfactory solutions for all parties It engages private sector real estate companies in land valuation and financial and economic feasibility studies to ensure the re-development plan is financially, legally and economically sound yet preserve the land, housing and property rights of the urban poor dwellers How?

Members of the communities gain land/ property titles; improved living environment and valuable assets over time Local authorities gain political incentive demonstrating they are genuinely interested in working for the people and thanks to their initiative important part of the city is revitalized; land value increases Private sector gains well located parcels of land for commercial development which is not contested by local communities What is there to win?

Chrang Chamres target area is populated by 1295 households mainly Cham Muslim families It is located along road no. 5 and Tonle Sap river and frequently affected by flooding Out of 1295 only 25% families reside fully in the “white zone”, which is not considered a state public land The project team has developed an acceptable architectural plan for the community members which will be presented to PPM for revision and approval Case of Chrang Chamres

RESULTS OF LAND PRICE SURVEY IN Q BY VTRUST GROUP LAND PRICE REPORT 2014 BY VTRUST REALTY (ACTUAL TRANSACTIONS) Location Asking PriceOn main streetOn sub-street AverageMinMaxAverageMinMaxAverageMinMax Chrang Chamres I

Case of Chrang Chamres- How much does it cost? Total number of m 2a Total cost of construction Cost of construction (m 2 ) Estimated value of the adjacent land transferred to the developer Adjusted total cost of construction Adjusted cost of construction (m 2 ) transferred to the households USD 228 USD USD (12000 m 2 x 360 USD) USD USD

1. Do nothing leave it as it is- It is too complicated 2. Do the same PPP model as in Thailand in 70’ and 80’’ but with a third party responsible for monitoring, facilitation of the process and liaisioning between the parties involved The investor would use the adjacent land (1.2 ha) for commercial development 15 year mortgages would be offered to the target families 3. or establish a legal entity which applies for a communal land title representing ALL families and manages the construction themselves. It will be definitely cheaper and a better deal …but can we get 1300 families to agree to form a trust? And manage such complex project? How to implement it?