Rate Appeal Group of Districts in Austin area appealed City of Austin Wholesale Water and Wastewater Rates that became effective February 1, 2013 appeal.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Ventura County Mobile Home Park Rent Review Board Hearing February 26, 2014 Proposed Amendments to Mobile Home Park Rent Control Ordinance Project No.
Advertisements

1 May 9, 2014 Nancy S. McNayr, AICP McNayr Paque, LLC Oklahoma Municipal League Oklahoma Municipal League Planning Commissioner Workshop Practical Advice.
County Home Rule in Iowa New County Officers School January 19, 2005 David Vestal General Counsel ISAC (515)
2012 Utility Update TCEQ Water Utilities Program Todd Galiga Environmental Law Division Office of Legal Services.
Limited Self-Governance Act Limited Self-Governance Act Act No , “The Alabama Limited Self-Governance Act,” became law on May 26, 2005 Is not.
NARUC/NIGERIA REGULATORY PARTNERSHIP Peer Review Presented by Elijah Abinah Assistant Director Public Utilities Division Arizona Corporation Commission.
Limited Self-Governance Act
Randy J. Cox.  Montana Supreme Court  District and Justice Courts  “such other courts as may be provided by law” Article VII of the Montana Constitution.
The Federal Court System. Lower Federal Courts The Constitution allows for Congress to establish a network of lower federal courts as well. These courts.
LOCAL REGULATION AND CLIMATE CHANGE QUICK TELECONFERENCE American Bar Association Section of Environment, Energy, and Resources Climate Change, Sustainable.
Blueprint of a Bid Protest. …well, more of a thumbnail of a bid protest.
Legislative Changes to the County Employees Retirement Law of 1937 (AB 340 and AB 197) Presented by: Contra Costa County Employees’ Retirement Association.
Net Metering and Interconnection Stakeholder Discussion Net Metering and Interconnection Stakeholder Meeting September 21, 2012 Discussion of.
The New Mediation Regulation October 16, 2012 Commissioner Derrick L. Williams.
1 LAFCO FEES The Statutory and Legal Framework 2010 Annual CALAFCO Meeting Hilton Hotel, Palm Springs Scott Browne.
Who Should Pay for Costly Water and Sewer Infrastructure? The Legal Considerations TRWA / TWCA Water Law Seminar January 24 – 25, 2013 Austin, Texas Leonard.
Unit Eight The Judicial Branch.
FEDERAL COURTS AND KANSAS STATE COURTS By: Alisha Talsma All information obtained from Clack, G. (Ed.).(2004).Outline of the American Legal System(5 th.
Charter Government Overview Kurt Spitzer June 2, 2008.
Legislation, Regulation, Guidelines
The Judicial Branch. The Original Plan The idea of the judicial branch came from the Virginia Plan. The idea of the judicial branch came from the Virginia.
Sharing Low-Income Customer Information Water & Energy Utilities LIOB Meeting - January 2009 Seaneen M Wilson Division of Water & Audits.
Water and Wastewater Certification 1 Water & Wastewater Reference Manual.
© 2011 South-Western | Cengage Learning GOALS LESSON 1.1 LAW, JUSTICE, AND ETHICS Recognize the difference between law and justice Apply ethics to personal.
Government.
The Judicial Branch The Federal Courts and the Supreme Court.
Texas Judicial System Consists of : Courts Judges Law enforcement agencies Serves the purposes of: Supporting a system for the trial and punishment of.
Customer Service Enforcement After AB 2987 John Risk Communications Support Group, Inc. (c) 2006 John Risk Communications Support Group, Inc. (c) 2006.
State and Federal Court Systems Law Enforcement I.
Becky Hovarter MS APHN RNBC Health Director/Officer Shawano-Menominee Counties Health Department October 2012.
IRSDA Conference What Do the Amendments to Indiana Code Section Mean to You? Kristina Kern Wheeler, General Counsel Ja-Deen L. Johnson, Consumer.
Powers of the Federal Courts Introduction –What is the purpose of the Court system? To balance the power of the other two branches. –Who is Chief Justice.
The Trinity of American Government Declaration of Independence –A document that is used to separate a country from another country. EXAMPLE: Texas from.
Background Claremont residents and officials have voiced concerns over the water rate increases imposed by the Golden State Water Company (GSWC). On average,
2010 Florida Building Code: I nterpretation P rocess O verview.
Chapter 28-2: Texas Judicial Branch and Courts Systems
Consolidation Commission Training Session Board of County Commissioners Chambers April 6, 2005.
Local Powers for Land Use Regulation. Local Land Use Powers Land use regulation is considered a residual power –In most circumstances, that is… –Power.
October 6, 2015San Antonio, Texas 2015 Attorneys Section Meeting IFTA DISPUTE RESOLUTION PROCESS Lonette L. Turner, CEO IFTA, Inc.
ANNEXATION. WHY ANNEXATION CITIES PAY FOR A WIDE ARRAY OF SERVICES AND FACILITIES THAT BENEFIT ENTIRE REGIONS AND THE ENTIRE STATE. MOST STATES RECOGNIZE.
Stoney-Brook Development Corporation v. Town of Fremont No SUPREME COURT OF NEW HAMPSHIRE 124 N.H. 583; 474 A.2d 561; 1984 N.H. LEXIS 348 March.
© 2015 Denton Fracing Ban Litigation and House Bill 40 Greg Mathews Bill Kroger Jason Newman November 11, 2015.
Repeal and Replace the Boundary Adjustment Act with the Urban Reserve Act.
1 Senate Bill 790 San Diego Energy District Foundation Carlos Velasquez CCA Regulatory Analyst California Public Utilities Commission June 21, 2012.
S.B Municipality Fees. S.B – Environment Budget Reconciliation Bill Enacted during the 2011 regular legislative session and becomes effective.
Chapter 28-2: Texas Courts Systems Guided Notes. Texas Judicial System A. Consists of : 1)Courts 2)Judges 3)Law enforcement agencies B. Serves the purposes.
History, Structure and Function of the American Legal System 1 Court Systems and Practices.
Stacy L. Miller Attorney at Law. This session will cover appeals from Juvenile Court to Circuit Court and what is required of the Clerks of each court.
Wastewater Treatment and Disposal Upgrade Nampa Wastewater Advisory Group Meeting #10 October 9, 2012.
Chapter 18 The Judicial Branch: The Federal Court System.
Juvenile Legislative Update 2013 Confidential Records and Protected Disclosures.
FIRE PROTECTION CONTRACTS Workshop on Senate Bill 239 (Hertzberg) July 21, 2016 Nevada LAFCo – Presented by P. Scott Browne, Counsel.
Missouri Constitution!!!
Discussion of the Differences Public Works Law and Bid Law
ND League of Cities Sept. 17, 2016
Administrative Agencies
Municipal Code Amendment Suspension of Utility Services for Violation of Specified Code Sections of the Pasadena Municipal Code City Council May 15,
Judicial Branch Interpret the Laws.
Complainant's rights within the competition proceedings Access to file
CCN Decertification and Compensation Potential Solutions
The Structure, Function, and Powers of the Judicial Branch
Public Service Commission of West Virginia
The Judicial System Structure.
TRWA/TWCA Water Law Seminar Waves of Change January 11–12, 2017
Legislation, Regulation, Guidelines
CHALLENGES TO VOTER REGISTRATION APPLICATIONS AND REGISTERED VOTERS
Existing Law: Sanctuary Cities Banned In South Carolina
United States Legal System
Texas Judicial System Consists of : Courts Judges
Florida Courts Scavenger Hunt
Presentation transcript:

Rate Appeal Group of Districts in Austin area appealed City of Austin Wholesale Water and Wastewater Rates that became effective February 1, 2013 appeal filed April 12, 2013 (water) and December 12, 2013 (wastewater)

Petitioners North Austin MUD No. 1 North town MUD Wells Branch MUD Travis County WCID No. 10 (water only)

Hearing Process Discovery lasted for months 10's of thousands of pages of documents reviewed February days

The Law Appealed under of the Texas Water Code Enacted as a result of appeal of Austin Wholesale rates in the late 1980's

The Law Intended to require direct de novo review of Austin’s wholesale rates (b) "Notwithstanding the provisions of any resolution, ordinance, or agreement, a district may appeal the rates imposed by the municipality by filing a petition with the utility commission. The utility commission shall hear the appeal de novo and the municipality shall have the burden of proof to establish that the rates are just and reasonable. The utility commission shall fix the rates to be charged by the municipality and the municipality may not increase such rates without the approval of the utility commission."

The Law Intended to avoid the public interest test However, Austin still claims that public interest test should apply

Beneficiaries of Any district required to obtain water or wastewater service from the consenting city in its consent agreement (a) "This section applies to rates charged by a municipality for water or sewer service to a district created pursuant to Article XVI, Section 59, of the Texas Constitution, or to the residents of such district, which district is located within the corporate limits or the extraterritorial jurisdiction of the municipality and the resolution, ordinance, or agreement of the municipality consenting to the creation of the district requires the district to purchase water or sewer service from the municipality."

Arguments Austin claims: – followed correct process and allowed interested parties to participate and have input – costs are related to utility service

Arguments Petitioners claims: – Austin’s rates not just and reasonable – costs unrelated to provision of utility service millions of dollars in transfers out of utility fund to fund a variety of other Austin departments and services – costs not supported by evidence in the record

Judges' Rulings so far applies Interim rate relief is available Austin has burden of proving up its rates

Status Interim Rates (2012 rates) currently in effect Closing Briefs have been filed Reply briefs have been filed Awaiting proposal for decision (PFD)

Appeal Expect the non-prevailing party to appeal Additional days at PUC District court process could take years

Parallel Court Proceeding Austin claims PUC has no authority to set interim rates Briefing by Petitioners and State agencies due this month Hearing set for September

Legislature No efforts to repeal during 2015 Session Vigilance in protecting rights required during future sessions

The Future Monitor Future Austin Rate Increase Continue Public Relations Efforts to bring awareness to the community about Austin’s use of Electric and Water/Wastewater Funds for non-utility purposes Monitor any legislative efforts regarding appeal of wholesale rates

Bill and Ted’s Excellent Adventure John J. Carlton The Carlton Law Firm, PLLC 2705 Bee Cave Road Suite 200 Austin, Texas (512)