CONTROVERSIES AND ETHICS OF ANIMAL TESTING: EMERGING ISSUES AND NEW CHALLENGES By Prof. Dr. P. V. S. KISHORE, Ph.D., FNAVS, FIAVA Professor & Head Department.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

July 2002 EU Conference on 3Rs Animal Experimentation - a controversial issue.

Advertisements

Introduction to Ethics Lecture 20 Cohen & The Case for the Use of Animals in Biomedical Research By David Kelsey.

Moral  the person’s individual set of values Ethics  consensus of a social system Both try to define what is good and what is bad CUDOS (Robert Merton.

Animal Welfare: belief that animals should be treated humanely. This includes proper housing, nutrition, disease prevention and treatment, responsible.

Effective animal welfare education changes children’s hearts and minds Jasmijn de Boo Education and Training Coordinator World Society for the Protection.

1 Welcome To Rural Sociology 2225 “Science, Technology and Society” Mary Grigsby Associate Professor of Rural Sociology Division of Applied Social Sciences.

Animal Liberation Movement. Historical/Social Context Animal Experimentation Animal Experimentation Animal testing is when scientists, students or commercial.

The work of ethical review committees in Germany and the United Kingdom - from the point of view of animal welfare Ursula G. Sauer, Germany For: Royal.

Ethics in Research Stangor Chapter 3.

Animal Testing Lauren Draper. Animal Testing  History  Animal Welfare Act 1999  Pros  Cons  Current NZ issue: Psychoactive Substances Act (aka party.

The use of animals Constraints on the use of animals Arguments for and against their use in psychological research Practical Moral & ethical

What are the Issues with Animal Research Bill Greer IACUC Administration The Office for Research Protections.

Animal Testing Previously we looked at the use of animals in spaceflight to further our understanding of the space environment. The use of animals in.

The ethical issues in experimental animal researches

Clinical Trials of Traditional Herbal Medicines In India Y.K.Gupta Professor & Head, Department of Pharmacology, All India Institute of Medical Sciences,

 Not the same as Animal Welfare  Should not be used as if it means the same as animal welfare.  Media may wrongly use the two terms interchangeably.

Biomedical research methods. What are biomedical research methods? An integrated approach using chemical, mathematical and computer simulations, in vitro.

‘C’ Grade –gain further knowledge of pros & cons of animal testing ‘B’ Grade –understand how to structure answers to questions in section ‘C’ ‘A’ Grade.

Ethical Treatment of Lab Animals

Objective 1.4. Objective 1.3 offer a considered and balanced review that includes a range of arguments, factors or hypotheses; opinions or conclusions.

Chapter One History and Purpose of Laboratory Animal Science and Animal Care Programs.

1 Psychology 2020 Unit 1 cont’d Ethics. 2 Evolution of ethics Historic Studies Tuskegee Syphilis Study ( ) Milgram’s Obedience Study (1960s)

Psychology 291 – Lab 4 Ethics October 9, 2012

The importance & relevance of animals in research, and their welfare Third OIE Global Conference on Animal Welfare. Kuala Lumpur, Malayasia 6 th November.

Chapter Eleven: Animal Rights and Environmental Ethics

Legal Responses to Scientific & Technological Development.

The Human-Animal Bond Veterinary Medical Applications.

We have reviewed this material in accordance with U.S. Copyright Law and have tried to maximize your ability to use, share, and adapt it. The citation.

Animal Experimentation & Value Judgments AP Psychology Ms. Desgrosellier

A symposium presented by the IUPS Ethics Committee 37 th Congress IUPS Birmingham UK July 2013.

1 Conducting Psychology Experiments & Ethics of Experimentation.

“What’s Ethics Got To Do With It” Presentation to the Canberra Evaluation Forum Gary Kent Head Governance Australian Institute of Health and Welfare.

MEDICAL ETHICS ETHICS PROJECT. MEDICAL ETHICS MEDICAL ETHICS STUDIES PRINCIPLES OF RIGHT AND WRONG FOUR PRINCIPLES OF MEDICAL ETHICS AUTONOMY JUSTICE.

Animals in Lab By Paul Choi 06/10/09.

Biomedical Research. What is Biomedical Research Biomedical research is the area of science devoted to the study of the processes of life; prevention.

Introduction to Ethics Lecture 20 Cohen & The Case for the Use of Animals in Biomedical Research By David Kelsey.

Psychology 291 – Lab 4 Ethics September 29 - October 2, 2013.

General Experimental Design 2015 Mouse 101 Course Linda G. Byrd, Ph.D. Geneticist Laboratory of Metabolism September 21, 2015.

Unit 3 – Health psychology: substance misuse The use of animals in drug research.

Ethics Review Committee | 28 th -30 th June 2009, Chengdu 1 |1 | The purpose and process of formal ethical review International Workshop of Ethics Review.

ANIMAL RESEARCH VS. ANIMAL RIGHTS.  Animals have always played an important role in the lives of humans  Animals provide basic needs like food, clothing,

"Perspectives of former International Pain Policy Fellows" Prof. Snežana Bošnjak, MD, PhD Institute for Oncology and Radiology of Serbia (IORS) Belgrade,

Ethical Issues and Non-human Animals Likely Question: Discuss ethical issues in the use of nonhuman animals in psychology psychlotron.org.uk.

Animal Rights and Welfare. Animal Rights Animal rights, also referred to as animal liberation, is the idea that the most basic interests of animals should.

Experimenting on Animals Harold Herzog – two arguments used by animal rights activists The utilitarian argument – equality Peter Singer - the capability.

Webquest modified by Sarah Bauhs from N/UMN/AnimalRights/uh1.aspx.

SOC Animal Experimentation James G. Anderson, Ph.D. Purdue University.

Relations Between Human and Nonhuman Animals

Animal Testing: Good, Bad or Ugly?

Science Symposium, 26 May 2014, New Delhi, India Dr Gerald Renner Director Technical Regulatory Affairs Cosmetics Europe EU scenario on alternatives in.

Human and Animal Research 1. What issues does this raise? 2.

Session 5: 3Rs statement VICH5 Conference, October 2015, Tokyo 1.

Do we have the right to perform experiments on animals? Barbara Malinowska Department of Experimental Physiology and Pathophysiology Medical University.

ANIMAL RESEARCH VS. ANIMAL RIGHTS

Sucul Hayvan deneyleri

Chapter 3: Ethical guidelines for psychological research.

Chapter 3 Ethics in Research

Animal Experimentation

Responsible Conduct of Animal Research

Branches of Ethics.

What is cruelty to animals? What is the main argument?

Ethics in Research.

Biotechnology with a conscience

Use a ruler to underline your title

Animal Rights vs. Animal Welfare

Animal Rights Versus Animal Welfare

University of Windsor Animal User Training Program

Ethics of the Use of Animals in Scientific Research: Legislation

Animal Research vs. Animal Rights

Presentation transcript:

CONTROVERSIES AND ETHICS OF ANIMAL TESTING: EMERGING ISSUES AND NEW CHALLENGES By Prof. Dr. P. V. S. KISHORE, Ph.D., FNAVS, FIAVA Professor & Head Department of Veterinary Anatomy SV Veterinary University, INDIA

ANIMAL TESTING HIGHLY CONTROVERSIAL ISSUE UNIQUE TO MODERN SCIENCE FAVOUR ACADEMICIANS RESEARCHERS CONTROVERSIES 2KISHORE AGAINST ANIMAL RIGHTS ACTIVISTS ETHICS

ACADEMICIANS & RESEARCHERS SCIENTIFIC BREAKTHROUGHS ANTIBIOTICS, DRUGS, VACCINES MEDICAL PROCEDURES, TOXICOLOGY XENO TRANSPANTATION OF ORGANS SAVED HUMAN LIVES 3KISHORE

ANIMAL RIGHTS ACTIVISTS REPEATED PROTESTS DECISION MAKING ABILITY AVOID / MINIMIZE EXPERIMENTATION CONSEQUENTIALIST JUSTIFICATION (comparing the moral consequences of an experiment DOING or NOT DOING) 4KISHORE

. CONTROVERSIES. ETHICS. EMERGING ISSUES. NEW CHALLENGES

CONTROVERSIES PAIN, SUFFERING, DISCOMFORT PAIN RELIEVER MAY INTERACT WITH DRUG IRRATIONAL ABUSE UNNECESSARY REPLICATIONS INDISCRIMINATE NUMBER 6KISHORE

ETHICS MORAL STATUS - (HUMANS = ANIMALS) SPECIESISM (like racism) (inflicting pain on human/animal is equally wrong) ETHICAL SELF-EXAMINATION (self-analysis of one's own personal and scientific motives) ETHICAL REVIEWS & AUDIT 7KISHORE

EMERGING ISSUES METABOLIC TESTS TOXICITY TESTS EFFICACY TESTS CARCINOGENIC TESTS LD 50 TOXICITY TEST BANNED 8KISHORE

EMERGING ISSUES PREVENTION OF CRUELTY TO ANIMALS ACT, 1960 WILDLIFE PROTECTION ACT, 1972 UGC GUIDELINES 2011 DISCONTINUATION OF DISSECTION AND EXPERIMENTS ON LIVE ANIMALS IN A PHASED MANNER MOEF GUIDELINES 2012 NGO’S - PFA, PETA, SPCA etc 9KISHORE

NEW CHALLENGES ALTERNATE MODES FOR DISSECTION AND EXPERIMENTATION DIGITAL / PLASTINATED SPECIMENS DEVELOPMENT OF ALTERNATIVES TO USE OF ANIMALS IN PG EDUCATION 10KISHORE

4 R’s RUSSELL & BURCH REDUCTION REFINEMENT REPLACEMENT REHABILITATION 11KISHORE

ALTERNATIVES CDs, COMPUTER SIMULATIONS, MANNEKIN / MODEL, INVITRO METHODS AUTOPSY, EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDIES, TISSUE CULTURES, IN SILICO TESTS COMPUTERS ARE UNABLE TO MODEL ALL INTERACTIONS MAKING ANIMAL RESEARCH NECESSARY IN MANY AREAS 12KISHORE

REMEDIES ONLY MEDICINAL PURPOSES NO COSMETICS TESTING JUSTIFIED CIRCUMSTANCES UNNECESSORY SACRIFICE BEST EXPERIMENTAL DESIGNS EUTHANASIA 13KISHORE

COSMETICS TESTING BANNED IN EUROPE LEAPING BUNNY LOGO OTHER AREAS LEATHER Vs JUTE BAGS NON VEG / VEG / VEAGEN 14KISHORE

? FOCUSSED CRITICAL THINKING IS AND WILL BE AN ONGOING PROCESS CHANGING ATTITUDES OF PEOPLE MORAL STRESS - EUTHANASIA CLEAR ALL ETHICAL DILEMMAS BROADER PERSPECTIVE HOLISTIC APPROACH 15KISHORE

? SCIENTIFIC BASIS ENFORCEMENT OF LAWS, REGULATIONS STRICT ANIMAL ETHICS COMMITTEES NON SCIENTIFIC SOCIAL MEMBER TRANSPARENCY 16KISHORE

CONCLUSION NECESSARY EVIL INDISPENSIBLE & INEVITABLE HELPFUL FOR FURTHERING MEDICAL SCIENCE 17KISHORE

? ? ? INITIALLY ON HUMANS HUMAN RIGHTS ACTIVISTS ANIMALS ANIMAL RIGHTS ACTIVISTS HUMANS AGAIN (WITH CONSENT) ? ? ? ? 18KISHORE

19KISHORE