Is the cost worth the risk? Why are we blowing such a large amount of money on such a small amount of land? Saving a lot of land might do little for wildlife,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Employment and inflation. Inflation Money is like everything else: the more there is of it the less value it has So if there is a lot of money in an economic.
Advertisements

12/19/05 Finance Committee Framing Statements & Conclusions.
8 2008, Jeffrey Dorfman The Economics of Growth, Sprawl and Land Use Decisions Jeffrey H. Dorfman The University of Georgia.
Southern California Association of Governments Where Will Our Children Live? Darin Chidsey Member Relations Officer Growth, Change and Rising Prices.
The Rising Price of a College Education Sandy Baum Michael McPherson Skidmore College & The Spencer Foundation The College Board The College Board College.
Conducted by: William M. Rohe Spencer Cowan Daniel Rodriguez Conducted for: The North Carolina Association of Community Development Corporations in cooperation.
Farmland Preservation is essential to our Polk County lifestyle.
HCP Implementation in Pima County, Arizona Julia Fonseca Pima County Office of Sustainability and Conservation Photo by Aaron Flesch.
Ranching in SE AZ and the Sonoran Desert Conservation Plan Compromise - Consensus - Balance.
Green Infrastructure Planning for working landscapes, natural resources and other open spaces.
Free Market Environmentalism
An edible vegetable oil From the fruit of oil palm trees The most widely used vegetable oil.
Managing Your Investments Chapter 11 Notes Money Management Got the Safety Net, Now What…? Once you’ve got a bit of emergency cash stashed away in some.
Who is ProvPlan? Mission to promote the economic and social well-being of the city, its people, and its neighborhoods. 501(c)3 non-profit created in 1992.
James Pappas, Housing Policy and Preservation Associate California Housing Partnership SCANPH Webinar 03/17/2014.
Savings Tools Take Charge of Your Finances Family Economics & Financial Education.
Budgeting and Financial Planning. Budgets Budget: A plan for how a person, family, or organization will raise and spend money. Why do you think it is.
Taxes And Spending “In this world, nothing is certain but death and taxes” -Benjamin Franklin.
Taxes © 2013 Created by Sally Camden ~ The Reflective Educator ~
Chapter 7 The Government Sector. Introduction: The Growing Economic Role of Government Most of the growth over the past seven decades was due to the Depression.
Objectives Describe three values that people consider when making decisions about the environment. Describe the four steps in a simple environmental decision-making.
Chapter 4 Study Guide.
Taxes. What are Taxes? Taxes are payments people are required to pay to local, state and national governments. Taxes are used to pay for services provided.
 Saving is income not spent.  Saving also includes reducing spending, such as recurring costs.  Savings can include a relatively low-risk investment.
Chapter 13SectionMain Menu Unemployment What are the different types of unemployment? How are unemployment rates determined? What is full employment?
Types of Unemployment Frictional Unemployment
Commonwealth Housing Task Force Draft – For Final Review Confidential – Not for Distribution Zoning Overlay Districts & State Financing Recommendations.
BUDGET CRISIS OR REVENUE FIGHT? JUNE 29, Income inequality is growing quickly The 1% are living in a VERY different world from the rest of us AVERAGE.
UNIT C ECONOMIC FOUNDATIONS AND FINANCING 5.02 Explain the relationship between economic measurements and economic growth.
There are two types of seat in the room: 35 Consumers 14 Insurers Sit one person to each seat. If you are comfortable doing a lot.
Types of Unemployment Frictional Unemployment
Chapter 13SectionMain Menu Unemployment What are the different types of unemployment? How are unemployment rates determined? What is full employment?
All Real estate is Local Market Trends Delaware’s diversity  According to the United States Census Bureau, as of 2005 Sussex County’s population.
The Community Preservation Act Hadley – April 14, 2004 The Community Preservation Coalition What is the CPA and how does it work? What does the CPA mean.
The Secrets of Saving Get Ready to Take Charge of Your Finances.
Richard Y. Nelson Jr. Director Montgomery County Department of Housing and Community Affairs Wednesday, May 9th.
Prepared by Stewardship America, Inc. For the Polk County Farm Bureau.
Financial Values Categories G1 © Family Economics & Financial Education – December 2005 – Enhancement Tools – Financial Values – Slide 2 Funded.
Financial Values Categories G1 Concern for Others Help your family and friends, Support causes you believe in Make the world a better place for.
Income Tax- is a tax on income the money an individual or business earns. The 16 th amendment in 1913 gave our government the power to collect such a tax.
Downtown by Robert Liston. Urban Problems Overpopulation Power Money Planning Renewal Projects Pollution.
Tools of Environmental ScienceSection 3 Classroom Catalyst.
Alternative Growth Futures Studio University of Colorado at Denver Sponsors: Custer Heritage Committee San Isabel Foundation Sonoran Institute.
SACO, formerly known as Pepperellborough named in In 1805 dropped the old name in favor of the ancient Native American name of SACO. QUICK FACTS:
Tools of Environmental ScienceSection 3 Section 3: Making Informed Decisions Preview Bellringer Objectives Values and the Environment An Environmental.
The Community Preservation Act in Sutton – May 27, 2004.
The Community Preservation Act in Kingston. Open Space Historic Preservation Affordable Housing Allows communities to establish a dedicated fund for:
A Foundation of St. Johns County’s Economy and Land Base: Agriculture and Natural Resources.
LEARN ABOUT THE PROCESSES OF SAVING AND INVESTING YOUR MONEY AND SOUND FINANCIAL PLANING Savings and Investment Planning.
Unit 1: What is economics all ABOUT? Chapters 1-6.
Jefferson City Revenue Forecast Staff Analysis. Accuracy in Estimates Important to Make Best Use of Tax Payer Money.
 Scientific research is an essential first step in solving environmental problems.  However, before research can begin, an examination of values is.
Renting Vs. Buying a Home. Scenario A renter starts out paying $800 per month with annual increases of 5%. A homeowner purchases a home for $110,000 and.
Redefining the housing sector December 2011 Kathy Hanson Head of Learning.
The Housing Market ‘Reset’ and its Implications for Housing Policy Alan Mallach Non-resident Senior Fellow The Brookings Institution.
The Community Preservation Act. Open Space Historic Preservation Affordable Housing Allows communities to establish a dedicated fund for: The Community.
Urban Sprawl Warm Up p. 47 Urban Rural Create a 4 square positive
General Election 2010 What the Parties Say - Money.
Children and older people do not typically pay taxes. These groups cost governments money for education and health care.
Housing Deciding between Renting and Owning a House.
State and Local Public Finance Professor Yinger Spring 2016 LECTURE 3 VOTING.
Savings Tools Take Charge of Your Finances Family Economics & Financial Education.
Shelby Ragan English /8/12. How can the Florida Panthers' habitat be preserved while still appeasing the advocates of urbanization in the area?
U.S. Housing Annual Home Sales New Existing New Existing
Home Mortgage Disclosure Act Lending Patterns (HMDA): Cuyahoga County
State and Local Public Finance Professor Yinger Spring 2017
Community Preservation Coalition
State and Local Public Finance Professor Yinger Spring 2017
Bellringer.
Bellringer.
Presentation transcript:

Is the cost worth the risk? Why are we blowing such a large amount of money on such a small amount of land? Saving a lot of land might do little for wildlife, while saving a little money might have wide benefits elsewhere. Saving a lot of land might do little for wildlife, while saving a little money might have wide benefits elsewhere.

Is the cost worth the risk? Buying land is just the start... Buying land is just the start... But there are other hidden, recurring costs of habitat protection, the price tag depends on how much land the public buys : But there are other hidden, recurring costs of habitat protection, the price tag depends on how much land the public buys : managing the land managing the land monitoring its plants monitoring its plants monitoring its animals monitoring its animals

Is the cost worth the risk? Even vacant land will have to be maintained, secured or kept up. Even vacant land will have to be maintained, secured or kept up. And in the end, ambitious plans to protect open spaces, and the plants and animals living there, might not even work. And in the end, ambitious plans to protect open spaces, and the plants and animals living there, might not even work.

Pushing people It costs money to withdraw open land from development, and Tucson is not a rich town - earning less than $9 for each $10 made by households nationwide. It costs money to withdraw open land from development, and Tucson is not a rich town - earning less than $9 for each $10 made by households nationwide. Preserving land also pushes people to places they wouldn't otherwise choose to live, putting affordable housing at risk. Preserving land also pushes people to places they wouldn't otherwise choose to live, putting affordable housing at risk.

Pushing people Only the rich have the means to live amidst nature preserves, while others find their options for housing grow more compact and more urban. Only the rich have the means to live amidst nature preserves, while others find their options for housing grow more compact and more urban. The SDCP will only benefit owners of large land parcels that will be part of county purchases. The SDCP will only benefit owners of large land parcels that will be part of county purchases. Those wealthy landowners also benefit from increased property values because of proximity to officially protected parcels. Those wealthy landowners also benefit from increased property values because of proximity to officially protected parcels. These land restrictions might also reduce access to public lands. These land restrictions might also reduce access to public lands.

The Cost Pima County is one of the fastest growing areas in the Nation. Pima County is one of the fastest growing areas in the Nation. In 10 years ( ), the population in Pima County grew 26.5% In 10 years ( ), the population in Pima County grew 26.5% The SDCP limits this growth which limits The SDCP limits this growth which limits Economic development and growth Economic development and growth County revenue County revenue Cultural growth Cultural growth Tucson can remain stagnant, or we can aspire to be a better community! Tucson can remain stagnant, or we can aspire to be a better community!

The Cost Desert protection might cost up to one billion dollars!! Desert protection might cost up to one billion dollars!! $ 11 million for the Tortolitas $ 11 million for the Tortolitas $ 5 million for Avra Valley $ 5 million for Avra Valley $ 10 million for land surrounding Davis-Monthan $ 10 million for land surrounding Davis-Monthan These millions are just for purchasing the dead land and do not include protection and management costs These millions are just for purchasing the dead land and do not include protection and management costs

The Cost Desert protection, as with all public spending, takes a heavier toll on people in Pima County: Desert protection, as with all public spending, takes a heavier toll on people in Pima County: Median family income here is $44,446, according to the 2000 census, or about 88 percent of the national average. It has remained there since Median family income here is $44,446, according to the 2000 census, or about 88 percent of the national average. It has remained there since Pima County also has the highest property tax rate of Arizona's 15 counties. Pima County also has the highest property tax rate of Arizona's 15 counties. The plan could hurt homeowners who already pay the state's highest property tax rate. The plan could hurt homeowners who already pay the state's highest property tax rate.

Independent Research In the highly charged political atmosphere surrounding the far-reaching Sonoran Desert Conservation Plan, it would be valuable to have an independent group research other communities that have implemented large-scale land-use plans. In the highly charged political atmosphere surrounding the far-reaching Sonoran Desert Conservation Plan, it would be valuable to have an independent group research other communities that have implemented large-scale land-use plans. The following are results of a report conducted by the Morrison Institute, an independent research group... The following are results of a report conducted by the Morrison Institute, an independent research group...

Independent Research Business leaders are divided on whether the conservation plan will actually allow developers to know where they may develop. Business leaders are divided on whether the conservation plan will actually allow developers to know where they may develop. Most business people believe the amount of affordable housing will be reduced. Most business people believe the amount of affordable housing will be reduced.

Independent Research Thus, the issue should not be dismissed as a self-serving, pro-development argument. Thus, the issue should not be dismissed as a self-serving, pro-development argument. If left unchecked, housing price increases will do significant harm. Many families won't be able to buy homes! If left unchecked, housing price increases will do significant harm. Many families won't be able to buy homes!

References U.S. Census Bureau.. Feb U.S. Census Bureau.. Feb Davis, Tony. “A lofty goal: save the desert.” Arizona Daily Star. Dec. 15, Davis, Tony. “A lofty goal: save the desert.” Arizona Daily Star. Dec. 15, “Costs and benefits.” Arizona Daily Star. April 12, “Costs and benefits.” Arizona Daily Star. April 12, Cavanaugh, Patrick. “Land plan raises controversy in NW.” Explorer.. Sep 7, Cavanaugh, Patrick. “Land plan raises controversy in NW.” Explorer.. Sep 7, 2005.