We have tested the accuracy of borehole temperature profiles in tracking surface air temperatures on short timescales (< 20 y) by direct comparison of.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
2008 Subsurface 3D Modeling: An Application to Waterfront Project Planning and Site Evaluation Andrew S. Thomas Moffatt & Nichol 600 University St, Ste.
Advertisements

Weather and Climate.
The Effect of Observing Environment on Temperature in North China Plain Area Jianxia Guo 1, Xin Li 2 1. Meteorological Observation Center of CMA, Beijing,
Feasibility of data assimilation using documented weather record for reconstruction of historical climate Kei Yoshimura and Kinya Toride AORI, Univ Tokyo.
A Multidisciplinary Analysis of Climate Change: Testing Borehole Paleoclimatology W. Gosnold, J. Majorowicz, S. Wood University of North Dakota Grand Forks,
Fig. 9. The ground-surface temperature history (GSTH) can be calculated from the T-Z profile using a non-linear Bayesian formulation based on the method.
Climate and Climate Change 17 January How and Why Does Climate Change? Climate changes over a broad range of time scales – Years, decades, centuries,
Section 3: Types of Maps Preview Objectives Topographic Maps
Architectural Design Mapping Mechanics: An introduction to topography by the use of contour lines UNT in partnership with TEA. Copyright ©. All rights.
Section 3: Types of Maps Objectives
Determination of Solar Cycle and Natural Climate Variation using both Surface Air/Soil Temperature and Thermal Diffusion Model Xiquan Dong (Atmospheric.
Group 1 Mobile, Alabama Alana Smith Meredith Karr Charles Edwards Chris Swaim Lindsay Ash.
Discussion Session Lisha M. Roubert University of Wisconsin-Madison Department of Atmospheric & Oceanic Sciences.
Geothermal Energy is the Ethical Energy Source for the Future Will Gosnold Dept. of Geology and Geological Engineering Donald Poochigian Dept. of Philosophy.
The Post-Glacial Warming Signal in Heat Flow IUGG Perugia, It, 6/7/2007 Will Gosnold and Jacek Majorowicz University of North Dakota Grand Forks, ND USA.
T21C-1981 Estimating Earth's Heat Flux Will Gosnold, Department of Geology and Geological Engineering University of North Dakota
Life: levels of organization – organism (individuals): any form of life – population: a group of interacting individuals of same species – community: populations.
Climatic changes in the last 200 years (Ch. 17 & 18) 1. Is it warming? --climate proxy info (recap) -- info from historical & instrumental records 2. What.
Xin Kong, Lizzie Noyes, Gary Corlett, John Remedios, Simon Good and David Llewellyn-Jones Earth Observation Science, Space Research Centre, University.
Annual air temperatures from the US HCN for the north central United States show a high degree of interannual variability and overall trends of warming.
Linking Borehole Temperatures to Air Temperatures Will Gosnold, Xiquan Dong, Shannon Heinle, Jacek Majorowicz, Julie Popham, Rachel Robinson, Brad Rundquist,
Integrated Approach for Assessing the Characteristic of Groundwater Recharge in Basin Scale Hsin-Fu Yeh*, Cheng-Haw Lee, Kuo-Chin Hsu Department of Resources.
Different types of maps and how to read them.
MSc Remote Sensing Supported by NERC Broad ranging course, concentrating on use of Earth observation for environmental analysis, mapping, image processing.
Canada’s Climate February 20,  Often defined as average weather, when weather means the current state of the atmosphere  Because of Canada’s size,
LST Validation and Analysis Simon J. Hook et al.
Topography & Topographic Maps 8th Grade Science.
Climate Change Global Warming Greenhouse Effect
Results from the Radiation, Snow Characteristics and Albedo at Summit (RASCALS) campaign Aku Riihelä, Panu Lahtinen Finnish Meteorological Institute Teemu.
Introduction Jacek Majorowicz 1,2, Walter Skinner 3, William Gosnold 2 and Jan Safanda 4 1 Northern Geothermal, 105 Carlson Close, Edmonton, Alberta, T6R.
Section 12.3 Gathering Weather Data
Assessing Climate Changes in Arctic Sweden and Repercussions on Sami Reindeer Husbandry and Culture: Using a MODIS Image Time Series and Key Informant.
Earth System Sciences, LLC Suggested Analyses of WRAP Drilling Rig Databases Doug Blewitt, CCM 1.
Possibly from logging upstream? The Use of Dendrochronology to Date Pinus strobus Stumps and Examine the Influence of Climate on Radial Tree Growth Douglas.
Active Microwave and LIDAR. Three models for remote sensing 1. Passive-Reflective: Sensors that rely on EM energy emitted by the sun to illuminate the.
Objectives –climatology –climate –normal Vocabulary –tropics –temperate zone –polar zone Recognize limits associated with the use of normals. Explain.
Understanding Glacier Characteristics in Rocky Mountains Using Remote Sensing Yang Qing.
Canada’s Physical Geography Climate and Weather Part I Unit 2 Chapter 2.
GLOBAL POSITINING SYSTEM WORKING,ERRORS AND CORRECTION USING DGPS Department Of Electronics and Communication Engineering.
Objective Data  The outlined square marks the area of the study arranged in most cases in a coarse 24X24 grid.  Data from the NASA Langley Research Center.
Models of the Earth Chapter 3. Ch03\80017.html.
Gravity surveys Annie, Sue, Betsy. Regional location Bango Road canal bank V-line canal bank Reno Highway Carson Highway.
Ice Cover in New York City Drinking Water Reservoirs: Modeling Simulations and Observations NIHAR R. SAMAL, Institute for Sustainable Cities, City University.
Assessing the Phenological Suitability of Global Landsat Data Sets for Forest Change Analysis The Global Land Cover Facility What does.
AGU2012-GC31A963: Model Estimates of Pan-Arctic Lake and Wetland Methane Emissions X.Chen 1, T.J.Bohn 1, M. Glagolev 2, S.Maksyutov 3, and D. P. Lettenmaier.
BOT / GEOG / GEOL 4111 / Field data collection Visiting and characterizing representative sites Used for classification (training data), information.
CE 401 Climate Change Science and Engineering evolution of climate change since the industrial revolution 9 February 2012
Global Terrestrial Network for Permafrost Contributions to cryospheric and climate monitoring Sharon Smith Geological Survey of Canada Kananaskis, March.
Using Borehole Temperature Profiles to Reconstruct and Test Surface Temperature Scenarios Over the Last Millennium David S. Chapman 1, Michael G. Davis.
Assessing the Influence of Decadal Climate Variability and Climate Change on Snowpacks in the Pacific Northwest JISAO/SMA Climate Impacts Group and the.
Climate What is Climate? average weather conditions over a period of many years.
Inverse Barometer correction comparison for Envisat mission between Corrections based on JRA-55 and ERA-Interim atmospheric reanalyses The JRA-55 correction.
Geography The science of studying Earth as the home of humans. Geography is divided into two main branches: the human geography and the physical geography.
Copyright © Texas Education Agency, All rights reserved. Architectural Design Mapping Mechanics: An introduction to topography by the use of contour.
The Derivation of Snow-Cover "Normals" Over the Canadian Prairies from Passive Microwave Satellite Imagery Joseph M. Piwowar Laura E. Chasmer Waterloo.
The Geographer’s Tools (Chapter 1, Lesson 1, pp.11-25) (Chapter 1, Lesson 1, pp.11-25)
Types of Maps Cartography is the science of mapmaking. For thousands of years, people have used maps to define borders and to find places. What is a.
Weather and Climate Weather Temporary behavior of atmosphere (what’s going on at any certain time) Temperature is one of the basic elements of weather.
Understanding Social Studies Concepts Chapter 1 Section 1.
The Basics of Geography Chapters 1 — 4
Weather Forecasting.
Optimizing climate data for use in climate-forest health studies
Raad A. Kattan(1). , Abdurrahman Farsat Heeto. (2) , Hussein H
Impacts of Climate Change: Tropical Storm Intensity
Mapping Cont..
The 5 Themes of Geography
“Studying Geography" GEOGRAPHY Understanding Social Studies Concepts
Larry Braile, Purdue University
Getting from here to there: protecting and promoting ecosystem services during the conversion of forests to fields in New England Alexandra Contosta1,
Presentation transcript:

We have tested the accuracy of borehole temperature profiles in tracking surface air temperatures on short timescales (< 20 y) by direct comparison of multiple borehole logs and the meteorological record from nearby climate stations. We have conducted similar tests on long timescales (~100 y) by comparing synthetic borehole T-z profiles generated from climate data with measured T-z profiles. In both tests, we found that the borehole temperature profiles accurately record the surface air temperature record. Examples the long-term tests in which borehole sites show warming trends that parallel the meteorological record are shown below in the Figures 1 & 2. However, when we examined the global set of borehole data used for climate reconstructions, we found large scatter in the data with some borehole sites showing cooling where the meteorological record indicates warming. We suspected that because the data were not screened initially for terrain and cultural effects, a screening for these factors might yield a better data set. Subsequent examination of the locales of the 130 sites in US segment of the global borehole data set by remote sensing, topo maps, and Google Earth indicates that at least 33 sites may have terrain effect disturbances to the T-z profiles. We have used remote sensing and thermal modeling of some of the sites to determine if corrections can be applied to the data. Synthetic T-z profiles generated from USHCN annual temperature data match observed T-z profiles in the mid-continent of North America. Figure 1Figure 2 Significant scatter in the global borehole T-z profiles (Fig. 3) is largely a function of data location by latitude, but some may be due to terrain and cultural disturbances that were not screened out of the data. Inversion of some of the data from the mid-continent of North America (Fig. 4), a region in which the data were screened, generates a relatively scattered, although consistent, set of results. Some early analyses of composite borehole T-z inversions with no screening for terrain effects yielded “spaghetti” plots as simulated in Fig. 5. Figure 4 Figure 3 Figure 5 The types of terrain effects on surface temperature that disturb the T-z profile we can discern from air photos, satellite imagery, topo maps, and historical records include: change in land cover, proximity to water bodies, and topography. Figure 7 Figure 6 Figure 8 The time-transient effects of borehole proximity to the edge of a clearing in the case of clearing of old growth forest circa (Fig. 6) and regrowth of forest (Fig. 7) can be modeled. However, too much is unknown about the amount and timing of surface temperature change to permit precise corrections to borehole T-z profiles. Figure 8 shows the effects of changes in land cover on subsurface temperature at two sites in Nebraska and one in Vermont. The Fremont, NE site converted from overgrowth with 1.5 m tall weeds to a heavily grazed pasture between 1981 and The Wayne, NE site experienced increasing tree shading during the same period. The Vermont site experienced cooling between 1965 and 1992, but the air temperature record shows warming. The T-z profile labeled Model shows the theoretical effect the air temperature should have had on the 1965 T-z profile in Surface temperature changes at the sites cannot be documented precisely enough to permit corrections to the borehole T-zs. Comparison of T-z profiles and subsurface isotherms affected by proximity to a water body. The models are based on a site in Canada (Image 1). Fig. 9 shows the lake effect without climate change. Fig. 10 shows the effect of 2ºC warming and Fig. 11 shows the effect of 2ºC cooling. An appropriate profile from the model for no climate change could be used to correct the observed T-z profile. Figure 9Figure 10 Figure 11 Image 1 Image 2 Conclusions: Topographic corrections to T-z profiles can be modeled relatively accurately and are the most likely candidates for use in improving the borehole database. In all other situations, the amount and timing of surface temperature changes is insufficiently known to permit precise corrections. Alternatively, a careful screening of the data and exclusion of potentially disturbed sites could improve the overall results. Modeled T-z profiles (Fig. 13) and isotherms (Fig. 14) across a valley in Utah (Image 2). The site is one of the US sites in the borehole database and has an obvious disturbance to the T-z profile. This research is supported by National Science Foundation Award ATM GC51A-0449 Resolving Terrain Effects in Borehole Temperature Profiles Will Gosnold and Shannon Heinle, Department of Geology and Geological Engineering, Grand Forks, ND