An Introduction to Alternative and Complementary Medicine NUTR 547 – Nutrition Update David L. Gee, PhD Summer 2006
Allopathic Medicine : A system of medicine that embraces all methods of proven value in the treatment of disease. Conventional medicine, Western Medicine Complementary and Alternaitive Medicine a group of diverse medical and health care systems, practices, and products that are not presently considered to be part of conventional medicine. (NCCAM, 2006) Definitions
Alternative medicine: : used in place of conventional medicine using special diet to treat cancer instead of chemotherapy, surgery, etc... Complementary medicine : used together with conventional medicine using aroma therapy to relieve discomfort following surgery Integrative medicine : combines mainstream and CAM therapies for which there is some high-quality scientific evidence of safety and effectiveness. Definitions
A glimpse of CAM in American history. Bible Christian Evangelist ( ) Promoted homeopathic medicine and the belief of “natural living” “Dyspepsia” caused by diets too concentrated…break up diet by putting back the bran Meat excited vile tempers and habits…drove men to sexual excesses Cold baths, exercise, fresh air, cold food Sylvester Graham Inventor of the Graham Cracker
A glimpse of CAM in American history. Adventist Sister Ellen White Upon advice from the Lord, built the Western Health Reform Institute in Battle Creek, MI. Employed a medical physician Daily enemas, vegetarianism, whole grain advocate Henry Ford, John D. Rockefeller, Harvey Firestone became patients Developed wheat flake cereal Dr. John Harvey Kellogg Younger brother, William Kellogg, develops the corn flake cereal, leaves brother and established his own company (WK Kellogg company) in 1906
A glimpse of CAM in American history. In 1891, a well-to-do real estate salesman and blanket manufacturer was a patient at the Battle Creek Sanitarium Spent his fortune at Battle Creek trying to recover his health. Asked Kellogg if he could promote a new coffee cereal; was denied. Left Battle Creek, became a Christian Scientist, started his own sanitarium and cereal company (with some of Kellogg’s formulations!) Cereal coffee- Postum could cure “coffee neuralgia” and “cofee heart” Broken bits of sheets of baked wheat: Grape Nuts His name: C.W. Post
The Use of CAM in the US Report by NCCAM & NCHS 36% of Americans use CAM
Who uses CAM the most? Women more than men people with higher education people who have been hospitalized in past year former smokers (more than current or never smoked)
Types of CAM defined by NCCAM, 2006 Mind-Body Medicine techniques designed to enhance the mind's capacity to affect bodily function and symptoms meditation, mental healing Energy Medicine therapies affecting “body energy fields” (qi gong, healing touch, Reiki) or unconventional use of electro-magnetic fieldsusing Manipulative and Body-based Practices chiropractic or osteopathic manipulation or massage therapy Biologically based products herbs and other dietary supplements
Mind-body medicine used most (if including prayer) Biologically based practices used most if prayer excluded
Spending on CAM Eisenberg DM, Davis RB, Ettner SL, et al. Trends in alternative medicine use in the United States, : results of a follow-up national survey. JAMA. 1998;280(18): $36-$47 billion in 1997 $12-$20 billion out of pocket more than spent out of pocket for hospitalizations half of what was spent out of pocket for physician services $5 billion spent on herbal supplements
So why study CAM ? Many Americans utilize CAM Money Alternative vs Complementary Medicine CAM interactions with Allopathic medicine drug interactions nutrient interactions Most commonly used type of CAM are dietary supplements/herbs