FIAS June 25-27, 2008. Collaboration: Phys.Rev. C 74 (2006) 025206 Phys.Rev. C 77 (2008) 065210.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Stefano Piano, FINUDA Collaboration – da ne Frascati, 7 th – 11 th June 2004 Examining bounds states with FINUDA FINUDA COLLABORATION Stefano Piano.
Advertisements

Kaonic nuclear clusters with ALICE E. Fragiacomo INFN Trieste Convegno Nazionale sulla Fisica di ALICE Vietri sul Mare – 30 maggio 2006.
1.Introduction 2.Exotic properties of K nuclei 3.To go forward (Future plan) 4.Summary Dense K nuclei - To go forward - KEK Nuclear KEK, ’06.Aug.3.
Deeply Bound Pionic States in Sn at RIBF N. Ikeno (Nara Women’s Univ. M1) J. Yamagata-Sekihara (IFIC, Valencia Univ.) H. Nagahiro (Nara Women’s Univ.)
Degree of polarization of  produced in quasielastic charge current neutrino-nucleus scattering Krzysztof M. Graczyk Jaroslaw Nowak Institute of Theoretical.
Two- and three-body resonances in the system N.V. Shevchenko Nuclear Physics Institute, Ř e ž, Czech Republic.
Kˉ- 4 He, Kˉ- 3 He interactions at low energies Vera Grishina (INR RAS, Moscow, Russia) University of Bonn, Germany August 31 – September 5, 2009.
Confirmation for a kaon-bound state K - pp observed in antiproton- 4 He annihilation at rest G. Bendiscioli 1, T. Bressani 2, A Fontana 1, L. Lavezzi 1,
Evidence for Narrow D s  0 and D s   0 states Jianchun Wang 05/09/03 Directly involved: Dave Cinabro Selina Li Sheldon Stone Jon Urheim Jianchun Wang.
P. Kienle, IX International Conference on Hypernuclear and Strange Particle Physics, October 2006 Antikaonic Matter At DAΦNE: Experiments with Unraveling.
1. Àngels Ramos Recent Progress in Many-Body Theories 14 Barcelona, July 16-20, 2007.
Excitation of the Roper Resonance in Single- and Double-Pion Production in NN collisions Roper‘s resonance Roper‘s resonance a resonance without seeing.
Motivations Results on Σ(1385) with FOPI detector Results on Λp correlation Conclusions / Outlook Towards strange multi-baryonic clusters, measurement.
K- bound states? A theoretical view V. Magas, A. Ramos (University of Barcelona) E. Oset (University of Valencia) H. Toki (RCNP,Osaka University) International.
1 Studies of K - -nuclear states with FINUDA Alessandra Filippi I.N.F.N. Torino - Italy HYP2006 Conference – Mainz October 11, 2006.
Lecture 10: Inelastic Scattering from the Proton 7/10/2003
Open-charm mesons in hot and dense matter L. Tolos 1, A. Ramos 2 and T. M. 3 1 FIAS (University of Frankfurt) 2 Universitat de Barcelona 3 Virginia Tech.
Sevil Salur for STAR Collaboration, Yale University WHAT IS A PENTAQUARK? STAR at RHIC, BNL measures charged particles via Time Projection Chamber. Due.
The search for deeply bound kaonic nuclear states at J-PARC Toshihiko Hiraiwa Kyoto University On behalf of the J-PARC E15 collaboration.
D 0 Measurement in Cu+Cu Collisions at √s=200GeV at STAR using the Silicon Inner Tracker (SVT+SSD) Sarah LaPointe Wayne State University For the STAR Collaboration.
Study of hadron properties in cold nuclear matter with HADES Pavel Tlustý, Nuclear Physics Institute, Řež, Czech Republic for the HADES Collaboration ,
 4 He(e,e'p)X, April 13 and April 14, 2011, 16 hours Measured P miss at to 1.0 GeV/c, x b = 1.24, Q 2 = 2 (GeV/c) 2 Extension of SRC 2 body data.
1 Formation spectra of  -mesic nuclei by (  +,p) reaction at J-PARC and chiral symmetry for baryons Hideko Nagahiro (RCNP) Collaborators : Daisuke Jido.
Omega meson in nucleus, experimental study K. Ozawa (Univ. of Tokyo)
Extending the Bertini Cascade Model to Kaons Dennis H. Wright (SLAC) Monte Carlo April 2005.
Chiral condensate in nuclear matter beyond linear density using chiral Ward identity S.Goda (Kyoto Univ.) D.Jido ( YITP ) 12th International Workshop on.
1 Reaction Mechanisms with low energy RIBs: limits and perspectives Alessia Di Pietro INFN-Laboratori Nazionali del Sud.
Cross section of elementally process [5] The  -ray spectroscopy of light hypernuclei at J-PARC (E13) K. Shirotori for the Hyperball-J collaboration Department.
N* Production in α-p and p-p Scattering (Study of the Breathing Mode of the Nucleon) Investigation of the Scalar Structure of baryons (related to strong.
Application of coupled-channel Complex Scaling Method to Λ(1405) 1.Introduction Recent status of theoretical study of K - pp 2.Application of ccCSM to.
Dott. Antonio Botrugno Ph.D. course UNIVERSITY OF LECCE (ITALY) DEPARTMENT OF PHYSICS.
Few Body-18Santos, Brazil August 25, Meson Exchange Currents in Pion Double Charge Exchange Reaction Roman Ya. Kezerashvili NY City College of Technology.
Víctor M. Castillo-Vallejo 1,2, Virendra Gupta 1, Julián Félix 2 1 Cinvestav-IPN, Unidad Mérida 2 Instituto de Física, Universidad de Guanajuato 2 Instituto.
C. Oppedisano for the ALICE Collaboration. 5 Jun 2012 C. Oppedisano 2/10 Centrality in p-A interactions can be defined through the number of collisions.
1 On extraction of the total photoabsorption cross section on the neutron from data on the deuteron  Motivation: GRAAL experiment (proton, deuteron) 
Interactions of low-energy anti-kaons with lightest nuclei Vera Grishina (INR RAS, Moscow) Moscow, September 17-20, 2009 XII International Seminar on Electromagnetic.
Total photoabsorption on quasi free nucleons at 600 – 1500 MeV N.Rudnev, A.Ignatov, A.Lapik, A.Mushkarenkov, V.Nedorezov, A.Turinge for the GRAAL collaboratiion.
Extended Brueckner-Hartree-Fock theory in many body system - Importance of pion in nuclei - Hiroshi Toki (RCNP, KEK) In collaboration.
Aye Aye Min, Khin Swe Myint, J. Esmaili & Yoshinori AKAISHI August 23, 2011 By Theoretical Investigation for Production of Double-  Hypernuclei from Stopped.
Nucleon Decay Search in the Detector on the Earth’s Surface. Background Estimation. J.Stepaniak Institute for Nuclear Studies Warsaw, Poland FLARE Workshop.
NEW TRENDS IN HIGH-ENERGY PHYSICS (experiment, phenomenology, theory) Alushta, Crimea, Ukraine, September 23-29, 2013 Effects of the next-to-leading order.
Yudai Ichikawa (Kyoto University/JAEA) 2013/07/26 RCNP 研究究会「核子・ハイペロン多体系におけるクラスター現 象」 1 J-PARC における d(π +, K + ) 反応を 用いた K 中間子原子核の探索.
Neutrino cross sections in few hundred MeV energy region Jan T. Sobczyk Institute of Theoretical Physics, University of Wrocław (in collaboration with.
In collaboration with : V.K. Magas, E. Oset, R. Molina, L. Tolós, J. Yamagata-Sekihara, S. Hirenzaki A. Ramos University of Barcelona (JPS+SPHERE meeting,
NSTAR2011, Jefferson Lab, USA May 17-20, 2011 Mitglied der Helmholtz-Gemeinschaft Tamer Tolba for the WASA-at-COSY collaboration Institut für Kernphysik.
Pion-Induced Fission- A Review Zafar Yasin Pakistan Institute of Engineering and Applied Sciences (PIEAS) Islamabad, Pakistan.
Exotic Atoms and Exotic 05,RIKEN 16 Feb. ’05 S. Hirenzaki (Nara Women’s Univ.)
Simultaneous photo-production measurement of the  and  mesons on the nucleons at the range 680 – 1500 MeV N.Rudnev, V.Nedorezov, A.Turinge for the GRAAL.
Structure of light Λ hypernuclei Emiko Hiyama (RIKEN)
Search for neutron-rich hypernuclei in FINUDA: preliminary results presented by M. Palomba 1 for the FINUDA Collaboration 1 INFN and Dipartimento di Fisica,
1 Recent Results on J/  Decays Shuangshi FANG Representing BES Collaboration Institute of High Energy Physics, CAS International Conference on QCD and.
1  - mesic nuclei and baryon chiral symmetry in medium Hideko Nagahiro (Nara Women’s Univ.) collaborators: Daisuke Jido (Tech. Univ. Muenchen) Satoru.
Department of Physics, Sungkyunkwan University C. Y. Ryu, C. H. Hyun, and S. W. Hong Application of the Quark-meson coupling model to dense nuclear matter.
Few-body approach for structure of light kaonic nuclei Shota Ohnishi (Hokkaido Univ.) In collaboration with Tsubasa Hoshino (Hokkaido Univ.) Wataru Horiuchi.
Search for direct evidence of tensor interaction in nuclei = high momentum component in nuclei = TERASHIMA Satoru 寺嶋 知 Depart. of Nuclear Science and Technology,
Few-Body Models of Light Nuclei The 8th APCTP-BLTP JINR Joint Workshop June 29 – July 4, 2014, Jeju, Korea S. N. Ershov.
DWIA calculation of 3 He (In-flight K -, n) reaction RIKEN, Advanced Meson Science Lab. Takahisa Koike KEK 研究会「現代の原子核物理-多様化し進化する原子核の描像」、 2006 年 8 月 3 日.
Current theoretical topics on K - pp quasi-bound state Sajjad MARRI and Toshimitsu YAMAZAKI  Theoretical interpretation of J-PARC E15 and E27 results.
Search for a nuclear kaon bound state K - pp at the J-PARC K1.8 beam line. Dep. of physics, Kyoto University / JAEA Y. Ichikawa for E27 Collaboration Korea-Japan.
V. Nuclear Reactions Topics to be covered include:
The role of isospin symmetry in medium-mass N ~ Z nuclei
Kaon Absorption from Kaonic Atoms and
Short Range NN Correlations (from Inclusive Cross Sections)
Baryonium a common ground for atomic and high energy physics
Observation of the DsJ(2463)Dspo & Confirmation of the DsJ(2317)Dspo
Study of the kaonic nuclear clusters at DAΦNE: the AMADEUS experiment
Deeply Bound Mesonic States -Case of Kaon-
In-medium properties of the omega meson from a measurement of
On a Search for -Mesic Nuclei at MAMI-C
XIV International Conference
Presentation transcript:

FIAS June 25-27, 2008

Collaboration: Phys.Rev. C 74 (2006) Phys.Rev. C 77 (2008)

- Critical review of some claims of observed deeply bound antikaon states in nuclei - Present a conventional explanation of the data - Attempt to extract new physics from the data, even if experiment has been done for reasons which are not supported a posteriori Goals

K N interaction Since the pioneering work of Kaiser, Siegel and Weise [NP A594 (1995) 325] many other chiral coupled channel models have been developed: Oset, Ramos, NP A635 (1998) 99 Oller, Meissner, PL B500 (2001) 263 Lutz, Kolomeitsev, NP A700 (2002) 193 Garcia-Recio et al., PR D67 (2003) Lutz, Kolomeitsev, NP A700 (2002) 193 Borasoy, Nissler, Weise, PRL 94 (2005) ; EPJ A25 (2005) 79 Oller, Prades, Verbeni, PRL 95 (2005) J. A.Oller, EPJ A28 (2006) 63 Borasoy, Meissner, Nissler, PR C74 (2006) more channels, next-to-leading order, Born terms beyond WT (s- channel, u-channel), fits including new data

A moderate attraction of about -40 MeV at  0 is obtained Ramos, Oset, NP A671 (2000) 481 Tolós, Ramos, Oset, PR C74 (2006) Similar results for optical potentials: Schaffner-Bielich, Koch, Effenberber, NP A669 (00) 153 Cieply, Friedman, Gal, Mares, NP A696 (2001) 173

If true -- New era in nuclear physics Critical review can be found in Oset, Toki, Phys.Rev.C74 (06) Ramos,Magas,Oset,Toki,Nucl.Phys.A804 (08) 219

The KEK proton missing mass experiment: T. Suzuki et al., Phys. Lett. B597, 263 (2004) S 0 is a tribaryon with S = -1 and T = 1 If interpreted as a [K - pnn] bound system…  B K = 197 MeV New experiment with a more precise measurement: only a broad bump remains Sato et al., PL B659 (2008) 107

A conventional explanation K - absorption by two nucleons leaving the other nucleons as spectators Oset, Toki, Phys. Rev. C74, (2006) do not absorbe energy nor momentum from the probe Fermi motion + mometum conservation explain the peak width Ramos, Magas, Oset, Toki, Nucl. Phys. A804 (08) 219

Oset-Toki’s prediction: Oset, Toki, Phys. Rev. C74, (2006) Such a peak should be seen in other light or medium nuclei, and it should be narrower and weaker as the nuclear size increases

The FINUDA proton missing mass experiment: M. Agnello et al, Nucl. Phys. A775 (2006) 35 This view is consistent with the observation by the FINUDA collaboration of a peak in the proton missing mass spectrum at ~ 500 MeV/c (from K - absorbed in 6 Li) A study of the angular correlations (p and  - are emitted back-to-back) allow them to conclude that the reaction: in 6 Li is the most favorable one to explain their signal 6 Li 4 He

FINUDA experiment M. Agnello et al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 94, (2005) But here both emitted particles are detected!  the invariant mass of the  p pair is measured, M  p The same elementary reaction as in KEK: K - p p   p (select p  > 300 MeV/c to eliminate K - N   Nuclei:

Interpreted by the FINUDA experiment as a (K - pp) bound state FINUDA results Transition to the g.s. of daughter nucleus

Conventional explanation K - absorption by two nucleons leaving the other nucleons as spectators

A conventional explanation: Final State Interactions (FSI) of the primary  and p (produced after K- absorption) as they cross the daughter nucleus! Discarded by FINUDA on the basis of back-to-back correlations Conventional explanation

Our calculations Monte Carlo simulation of K - absorption by pp and pn pairs in nuclei The K - is absorbed mainly from the lowest atomic orbit for which the energy shift has been measured

S. Hirenzaki, Y. Okumura, H. Toki, E. Oset and A. Ramos, Phys. Rev. C61, (2000) K- wave function

Our calculations Monte Carlo simulation of K - absorption by pp and pn pairs in nuclei The K - is absorbed mainly from the lowest atomic orbit for which the energy shift has been measured Primary  and N are emitted accordingly to PS: The K - is absorbed by two nucleons with momenta randomly chosen within the local Fermi sea:

Nuclear density profile and overlap K-pN   N process The K− absorption width from pN pairs in a nucleus is given in first approximation by is the in-medium decay width for the process

Our calculations Monte Carlo simulation of K - absorption by pp and pn pairs in nuclei The K - is absorbed mainly from the lowest atomic orbit for which the energy shift has been measured Primary  and N are emitted according to PS: The K - is absorbed by two nucleons with momenta randomly chosen within the local Fermi sea: Further collisions of  and N as they cross the nucleus according to a probability per unit length  with   ~2  N /3

Our calculations Monte Carlo simulation of K - absorption by pp and pn pairs in nuclei The K - is absorbed mainly from the lowest atomic orbit for which the energy shift has been measured Primary  and N are emitted according to PS: The K - is absorbed by two nucleons with momenta randomly chosen within the local Fermi sea: Further collisions of  and N as they cross the nucleus according to a probability per unit length  with   ~2  N /3 Finally, the invariant  p mass is reconstructed from the final events, experimental cuts are applied

Transition to the g.s. of daughter nucleus for the light nuclei First (narrow) peak: Our model is not really suitable to reproduce this peak Nucleons move in mean field Thomas-Fermi potenti al: - , such that the maximum ΛN invariant mass allowed by our model = only for the holes  =15-16 MeV (Li), 9.6 MeV (V) we made a rough estimate of 10% of all events

Quasi-elastic peak (QEP) after K - absorption A peak is generated in our Monte Carlo simulations: the primary  and p (produced after K - absorption) undergo quasi-elastic collisions with the nucleus exciting it to the continuum This is the analogue of the quasi-elastic peaks observed in nuclear inclusive reactions using a variety of different probes: (e,e’), (p,p’), (  ’),… (The QEP comes mostly from one collision of the particles exciting the nucleus to the continuum)  The QEP accounts for the second peak of the FINUDA experiment! Second (wider) peak:

Allowing up to three collisions Results: Compare to FINUDA data Back-to-back

Angular correlations Results: Our Estimate: 10 %

Mixture of the light targets

What have we learned?

Results:

What have we learned? We can study the FSI for different nuclei

FINUDA experiment M. Agnello et al. Phys. Lett. B654 (2007) 80-86

FINUDA results No peak – because it is smeared out by the FSI M. Agnello et al. Phys. Lett. B654 (2007) 80-86

Interpreted by the FINUDA experiment as a (K - pp) bound state Evolution of the FINUDA ideas Transition to the g.s. of daughter nucleus

Evolution of the FINUDA ideas Now they learned that FSI is important for large nuclei

We suggest a conventional explanation: K - absorption by three nucleons leaving the other nucleons as spectators

We suggest a conventional explanation: K - absorption by three nucleons leaving the other nucleons as spectators p p p n n n K  n p

p p p n n n K  n p Our model

Results: Good agreement with the data!

Results:

What have we learned?

Conclusion We have shown that there are (so far?) no experimental evidences of deeply bound K - state in nuclei All “signals” of deeply bound state can be explained in conventional scheme: K - absorption by two or three nucleons leaving the others as spectators + Final State Interaction for heavy nuclei However, the FINUDA data allows to study in details the two and three nucleon K - absorption mechanisms

K in a nuclear medium: The presence of the  (1405) resonance makes the in-medium KN interaction to be very sensitive to the particular details of the many-body treatment.  we’d better do a good job! (SELF-CONSISTENCY) Pauli blocking free (repulsive) medium (attractive) Self-consistent kaon dressing pion and kaon dressing K K K K K K    Weise, Koch Ramos,Oset Lutz

We give a conventional explanation: Final State Interactions (FSI) of the primary  and p (produced after K- absorption) as they cross the daughter nucleus! FINUDA results C(p,p’) H(p,p’) 12 2

K-pN   N process Fermi sea  const, And finally where

 p   p p FSI of the primary  N where kernel describes further propagation of  and N as they cross the nucleus according to a probability per unit length  with   ~2  N /3

Transition to the g.s. of daughter nucleus How much strength should we expect? Formation probability (FP) x Survival probability (P S ) In light nuclei: FP ~ | | 2 = 0.1–0.5, P S ~ 0.6 (Li), 0.4 (C)  In heavier nuclei: FP increases, but P S decreases: ~0.26 (Al), 0.18 (V)  also below 30% First (narrow) peak: Our estimate: 7 Li (pp) -1  5 H

Can the peak be due to other processes? followed by This peaks around 2170 MeV (where there is indeed a small third peak in the experiment) and has a smaller strength than A) B) followed by  located in the region of the QEP and all events back-to-back, but strength is small, ~ 10-30% of events